• Welcome to Smashboards, the world's largest Super Smash Brothers community! Over 250,000 Smash Bros. fans from around the world have come to discuss these great games in over 19 million posts!

    You are currently viewing our boards as a visitor. Click here to sign up right now and start on your path in the Smash community!

Sunrise, Sunset - Isaac for Smash Ultimate #GoldenSunday

isaac3000

Smash Journeyman
Joined
Jul 14, 2014
Messages
217
Location
Germany
When Isaac gets confirmed and I have the game, first I will try to unlock him of course, after that, before I start playing as him I will click on him over and over again just to listen to the announcer crying out loud: ISAAC! I will not be able to believe my ears... I can't wait for this!
 

True Blue Warrior

Smash Hero
Joined
Oct 4, 2013
Messages
9,727
Location
United Kingdom
NNID
TrueBlueSM
3DS FC
2036-7619-4276
Hey guys. Isaac's one of my picks so I decided to make a discord for all isaac fans to communicate and speculate about smash. Maybe we'll even watch future directs in there!

https://discord.gg/mC72fnQ
I've added you.
  1. _Sheik
  2. 1/128
  3. 9Blades
  4. ☆Jisatsu☆
  5. *Verrix*
  6. ?!?!?!
  7. Accursed
  8. Adeptmune
  9. Agk0001
  10. AgatioGanon
  11. Aguki90
  12. airConditioner
  13. aldelaro5
  14. alguidrag
  15. Altais
  16. Amberloo
  17. Amtoj
  18. AncientArk
  19. andimidna
  20. Androobie
  21. Aeon Lupin
  22. Apollyon
  23. Aqua Rock X
  24. AquaDork1
  25. AquaSol
  26. Arcadenik
  27. Arsenal234,
  28. Arteen
  29. Asian_Charizard
  30. Astraltar
  31. Aureola
  32. Aurora Jenny
  33. AustarusIV
  34. AwesomeCauliflower68
  35. Awesomedude444
  36. Backgammon
  37. Baddies are back
  38. Balgorxz
  39. BandannaWaddleDee
  40. Bane84
  41. bassem6
  42. Bassoonist
  43. Billybae10K
  44. BillyBat
  45. Bingoshi
  46. Bkupa666
  47. Blackwolf666
  48. Blaziken
  49. Blue7113
  50. BluePikmin11
  51. BoltDragon
  52. BoN~
  53. Bowser-Daimao
  54. BravadoMan_13
  55. BridgesWithTurtles
  56. Browny
  57. Buddy002
  58. Bunny8093
  59. BUnit
  60. Burruni
  61. Calamitas
  62. Calane
  63. CactusBlah
  64. candyissweet
  65. Capita
  66. Cap'nChreest
  67. Captain Toad
  68. CardStealer1
  69. Cazzone,
  70. Chapter Serf
  71. CheckmateChuck
  72. CheeseBroJoe
  73. Cheezey Bites
  74. Chromfirmed
  75. Chrono.
  76. ChronoPenguin
  77. clearandsweet
  78. ClinkStryphart
  79. CliffJumper
  80. cocy965
  81. Cos.
  82. Coaltergeist
  83. Crap-Zapper
  84. CrossDispatcher
  85. cybersai
  86. Dalek_Kolt
  87. Darkdarkness
  88. Darkfur
  89. DatoSm
  90. Dendros
  91. Desert Croc
  92. Destroyer713
  93. Dezeray112
  94. Dhragen
  95. Diddy Kong
  96. Dihan
  97. Dimensionsword64
  98. DivinexRose
  99. DJ3DS
  100. DJBor
  101. D-Man9293
  102. DogManStar
  103. DoodleDuck97
  104. Doncalot
  105. DraginHikari
  106. Drakonis
  107. Dromader
  108. DukeNapoleon
  109. DustyPumpkin
  110. e105beta
  111. Eagle
  112. EclipseSmash
  113. EddyBearr
  114. ED Cantu
  115. Edlocke
  116. egaddmario
  117. ElPanandero
  118. El Syd
  119. EndlessChrom
  120. EndlessRain
  121. EnhaloTricks
  122. EricTheGamerman
  123. Essora
  124. ETFruitNinja
  125. ethanrodgers223
  126. Ezequileste
  127. Falgor
  128. Falkoopa
  129. False Sense
  130. FamiconDisk
  131. Felix_the_Slayer
  132. fenyx4
  133. ferioku
  134. Fire Rider
  135. Fire_Voyager
  136. FirstBlade
  137. Flareon
  138. Flik
  139. Flintike
  140. Flynn.Scifo
  141. fogbadge.
  142. foolssigma
  143. FrankAL
  144. FreddyOnDrugs
  145. Friesnchip
  146. Frosty Pops
  147. GalacticPetey
  148. Gameguy1996
  149. Gazorpazorpfield
  150. Geno Boost
  151. ghastmine
  152. Ghirahilda
  153. Gioka
  154. GladiusVortex
  155. GM_3826
  156. Golden Icarus
  157. GoodGrief741
  158. Gotann
  159. GraveEclipse567
  160. Hakerson
  161. heylodom
  162. Huanchi
  163. hwrdjacob
  164. iam8bit
  165. Icana
  166. iDazedX_x
  167. Inawordyes
  168. IntelliHeath1
  169. Invisible Shiny Bulbasaur
  170. isaac3000
  171. Isaac4SmashUltimate
  172. IsaacOrRiot
  173. Isaac: Venus Adept
  174. Istry555
  175. IvanQuote
  176. JaidynReiman
  177. Jak_spoon
  178. JamesDNaux
  179. James Tutumbero
  180. Jamurai
  181. JarBear
  182. JDogindy
  183. JesseMcCloud
  184. Johnknight1
  185. JohnnySparkxs
  186. Jupiter Ivan
  187. Jurae818
  188. Just a random scrub
  189. jweb22
  190. Kalomaze
  191. KCCHIEFS27
  192. KeniththeGatherer
  193. KeybladeSmasher
  194. KHJason95
  195. Kikaru
  196. Kind Dedede
  197. KingCloud
  198. KingShadow
  199. KiraYoshikage
  200. KirbyDragon
  201. Kirbyfan391
  202. Kisae
  203. Klimax
  204. KMDP
  205. KoalaNut
  206. Kokirikory
  207. Koori
  208. Kremling Man
  209. Kumatora
  210. KurouKamen
  211. Kycse
  212. Lady Palutena
  213. Lampy
  214. LaniusShrike
  215. lanky_gunner
  216. LasermasterA
  217. Leafeon523
  218. LeeYawshee
  219. Legendary Spirit Tamer
  220. legendofrob1
  221. LemmyKoopa
  222. lightdasher
  223. LightheartedBum
  224. Lightosia
  225. Linq
  226. Lisbon Mapping
  227. littl-myth
  228. Liverpool19
  229. Lone (Thirteenth)
  230. Lonodel
  231. Lord-Zero
  232. Lucanic
  233. Lucimar
  234. Ludjinnado
  235. lunarum
  236. Lukingordex
  237. Lurxy
  238. Lynn Eslie
  239. M23-X0
  240. MacSmitty
  241. MagiusNecros
  242. MAGMIS
  243. MainJPW
  244. Malcolm Belmont
  245. MaskO'Gears
  246. Master Rapier
  247. MasterMushroom
  248. Mav485
  249. McLapras
  250. Mega Bidoof
  251. Mendelsin
  252. MetalMario128
  253. Metocles
  254. Miifighters4Smash5
  255. Minato Arisato
  256. Mikegamer0608
  257. Mishudo
  258. Monkokaio
  259. MonopolyRubix
  260. MorbidAltruism
  261. Moydow
  262. MrGame&Rock
  263. MrMacBeth
  264. MrToxicVoltage
  265. Muirkat
  266. Mythzotick
  267. mynameisv
  268. MysticKnives
  269. N3ON
  270. Nauzgo
  271. Neo Zero
  272. NessAtc.
  273. Niala
  274. Nimbostratus
  275. Ninjakid41592
  276. Nintandy
  277. Nintendokusou
  278. NitrusVirus
  279. NonSpecificGuy
  280. NoOtherPersona
  281. NoR4U
  282. Nossnitro102
  283. Octillus
  284. Oddyesy
  285. OhMyBanana54
  286. Olo
  287. Oniric Spriter
  288. OptimisticStrifer
  289. Oracle_Summon
  290. Organization XIII
  291. osby
  292. otarolgam
  293. Oz37
  294. Pacack
  295. Papagenos
  296. ParanoidDrone
  297. Pcubed007
  298. Pennate
  299. Phaazoid
  300. PhilosophicAnimal
  301. pholtos
  302. Pizza Robo
  303. P.Kat
  304. Plain Yogurt
  305. Playcube
  306. PlayfulMushroom
  307. POKEMANSPIKA
  308. Powerman293
  309. praline
  310. PSIguy89
  311. PSYNergy
  312. PrinceGal3n
  313. PWN3
  314. Pwnapplez
  315. QcSlayer
  316. Quetzal77
  317. R.O.B.
  318. Radical Beam
  319. Radori
  320. Raetah
  321. Raykz
  322. Raziek
  323. Red Dasher
  324. Red Ryu
  325. RegiGygas117
  326. Replica
  327. Retro gamer
  328. RhymeswithEmpty
  329. Roger Smith
  330. RosaPeach
  331. Royaru
  332. Royvolution Ream
  333. RumpletrellskiN
  334. Ryan
  335. Ryuji
  336. Ryuutakeshi
  337. Sabrewulf238
  338. Saer2k
  339. Sagittarius
  340. Salocin
  341. sandfall
  342. SanicJan
  343. Scatmansworld25
  344. Scoliosis Jones
  345. scoobymcsnack
  346. Seb9k+
  347. Secret Sexytime
  348. Seleir
  349. Seoxys
  350. sheik93
  351. Shin F.
  352. Shinhed-echi
  353. Shog
  354. Sidboylol
  355. Silo777
  356. SirCamp
  357. Skeleton o' Fun
  358. SkullKidKing
  359. Skyblade12
  360. Skyfox2000
  361. sman3975
  362. Smash_Handle69
  363. SmashBro99
  364. smashkirby
  365. SmashShadow
  366. smashtriforce77
  367. smileMasky
  368. SmilingMad
  369. SMX
  370. Solfiner
  371. someonetookjacob
  372. SonicLink125
  373. SonicSmasher
  374. SoraSaturn
  375. SorrowOfAcheron
  376. SoulofKhaos
  377. Soulsaint
  378. Spatman
  379. Spazzy_D
  380. Speedwagon
  381. spoilerowl
  382. Spootondorf
  383. Sqid
  384. SSBFan
  385. Staarih
  386. StaffofSmashing
  387. Strider_Bond00J
  388. StrikeBlade
  389. SuperBrawler
  390. Superfiremario
  391. SuperNintendoKid
  392. Supersmash77
  393. Superyoshiom
  394. Swampasaur
  395. Sykin
  396. Takasmash
  397. TBone06
  398. TCT~Phantom
  399. Techno1000
  400. TeenGirlSquad
  401. TehEpicRyuga
  402. TempestSurge
  403. Tetiro
  404. ThatShadowLink
  405. THE 6r
  406. The Curious Volnutt
  407. The One Who Wrote This
  408. Thekewlusername
  409. T-Hell
  410. TheRealHeroOfWinds
  411. TheSeanMan
  412. TheSpaceKing
  413. The Stoopid Unikorn
  414. TheTactician
  415. THE TemporaryFool
  416. thethirdkoopa
  417. TheZoologist
  418. ThirdDay
  419. ThoughtfulWanderer
  420. ThunderOverload
  421. TiaSilvia
  422. TimeSmash
  423. Tiymako
  424. ToothiestAura
  425. topspin1617
  426. Travix Man
  427. True Blue Warrior
  428. Turmalinium
  429. tveye
  430. UltimateWario
  431. Ultinarok
  432. User Name String
  433. Vann Accessible
  434. Vegito2727
  435. Venus of the Desert Bloom
  436. Vintage Creep
  437. Violenceman
  438. walph
  439. Warheart_666
  440. Wigglytuff ★
  441. winterofsilver
  442. Wintropy
  443. WhiteEaglePL
  444. Xelion
  445. Xenigma
  446. XenoWarriorX
  447. XeVioN
  448. Xiivi
  449. xLemmy_KoopaX
  450. xpnc
  451. XTremeGamer1234
  452. XxLtxX
  453. YellowLord
  454. Yoshi444
  455. YoshiandToad
  456. Young Horsetail
  457. Your Hero
  458. YwhaletailY
  459. Zabadoo
  460. zagman505
  461. zaiman12345
  462. Zandro
  463. ZanZero
  464. ZarroTsu
  465. ZeldaMaster
  466. ZelDan
  467. ZestyÑ
  468. zferolie
  469. Zulyar
  470. Zuppo
You know... I want both Rex & Pyra and Isaac to be a thing in Smash...

So that we can have an unholy fusion of these two jokes.
That innuendo.
 

Frosty Pops

Smash Journeyman
Joined
Aug 11, 2018
Messages
332
I don't know if this image has been posted here, but it's a pie chart of the remaining contenders of the Smash Poll Consolidation document. To say Issac is in a good position is an understatement, but I am curious on your guys opinions on some of the other placements.
https://docs.google.com/spreadsheet...pw5m-b4JHJ0_cGRKU15KYlTe1E/edit#gid=729442469
https://www.reddit.com/r/smashbros/...aracters_from_estimated_ballot_poll/?sort=new
I don't think paper Mario is very likely. and no Indie characters have made it in. so if shovel knight didn't make it I doubt shantae will. And if they do anything like the last smash game the more out there 3rd party character like banjo or rayman will most likely be DLC imo. Also captain toad is deconfirmed he is in a level, and dixie and shadow have decent chances of being echoes. If they are unique characters I would be surprised. Honestly Isaac and Geno and Bandana Dee look the most promising of all character present.
 

Arteen

Smash Lord
Joined
Oct 2, 2005
Messages
1,627
Location
Vault
When Isaac gets confirmed and I have the game, first I will try to unlock him of course, after that, before I start playing as him I will click on him over and over again just to listen to the announcer crying out loud: ISAAC! I will not be able to believe my ears... I can't wait for this!
I won't lie, I'll absolutely do this too.
 

Organization XIII

Smash Champion
Joined
Apr 10, 2015
Messages
2,083
Paper Mario could easily be turned into an Echo Fighter
No, that doesn't work on multiple levels. First Paper Mario and Mario share practically no moves and could not fight in the same way. This would be as bad K Rool being a Bowser clone. Sakurai could do it, just look at Ganondorf for a weird clone situation, but it would be incredibly lazy and a vast waste of potential. Next and the most obvious is Paper Mario wouldn't fit Mario's skeleton if anything he'd have to be a Game and Watch echo. That would kinda be closer to Paper Mario's actual movepool but still not a good solution.
Also, I did see your post about Paper Mario's skill set not translating to a fighting game space and aside from the mechanic where you press the attack button right before an attack for extra damage, most everything he has could be copy-pasted into Smash. Still I do agree that he's probably not joining the fray. Sad but I'm pretty sure Sakurai considers SMRPG the definitive Mario RPG.
 

JaidynReiman

Smash Hero
Joined
May 31, 2014
Messages
8,840
NNID
JaidynReiman
Can only expect Shantae in this. Would be a nice surprise but I'm content with waiting longer for more Smash news. We only have 8 days of August left. Then it's September (= Direct month!)
Smells like Shantae will dance on stage!
Even we in the Shantae forms don't believe it's a reveal.
I guarantee you guys there will be precisely a 100% chance of...

NO information about Smash Ultimate in a Nindies Direct. It doesn't even matter if a Nindie character does wind up in Smash (which I doubt). Smash Bros. is not an Indie game. The Nindies Direct is ONLY to show off Nindie games. Smash Bros. information won't get revealed in any other game-specific Direct either, like Pokemon. It will only get information in a general Nintendo Direct, or a Super Smash Bros. Direct. That's it.


The reason there's a new Nindies Direct now is because the last one was Nintendo UK. This is Nintendo America.
 

Metocles

Smash Journeyman
Joined
Apr 1, 2018
Messages
275
Location
Pennsylvania
I forgot 1.8 million votes were cast. Makes the 40k on that google doc seem pretty insignificant...
I thought I'd comment on this as it seems to be a high point of contention right now. Basically this is the source of everyone's nervousness, because they see the numbers and it says good things about Isaac, but they aren't sure about the data they're seeing. Just because you have 40k votes, which pales in comparison to the 1.8 million that we got, it doesn't mean we can't make some insights into the data here.

In fact, it's sometimes much worse to look at larger and larger sample sizes because the resources necessary to collect the data overflow your capability to sift through it. The smaller number doesn't actually matter that much if it's a representative sample. If you look in the tab, you see reporting from multiple polls taken from Smashboards, Reddit, Straw Poll, Tumblr and Poll Maker. Isaac really doesn't fall outside of the top 5. There's only one instance in the Tumblr poll where that's the case. Like I have commented on before, you really don't have to worry too much about unique voting polls for Isaac. These are basically 12 separate polls pooled together (For first party) and averaged out for characters. While Isaac is not #1 in even most of them, he still averaged a 2nd place and above Banjo.

The real question is, who was really voting in the character ballot? It's an interesting question. One can assume that it certainly includes the people that voted in these separate polls; effectively avid smash fans. Were there a lot of people voting that barely have contact with smash? Only told to vote by others? Play smash casually or very rarely? I get a sense that extrapolation would really not change a whole lot. Isaac may not have been #2 or #3, but would it fluctuate so wildly that he would end up out of the top ten? I think that's very unlikely.

Especially when you have the law of averages on your side. Lets say this was a decathlon; you have to do well in ten events to get first place. Paper Mario, man he's so good a throwing a javelin, but he can't run faster than your grandma in the 100meter dash. Magolor, that guy can throw the shot put and run short distance, but he really can't do the long jump. Isaac... well Isaac basically gets 3rd place every time, in every event. At the end of the day that's basically all you need in the decathlon. Isaac, as far as I've followed him in smash speculation, has been steady eddy in polls, popularity and fan desire. Sometimes it cools off, but it's pretty persistent, unlike many other characters who pop in and out of existence and try to make believe that they've always been that way. That's why the exit polling speaks to me, I really don't think it's far from the truth that Sakurai is seeing.

At the end of the day, yeah, some dudebros are gonna vote for Goku and Shrek on their only vote. That really doesn't amount to much, even if you add on top of that 5,000 more dudebros. With characters like K. Rool, Ridley and Isaac, there's a reason their popularity hasn't waned. A lot more people want them in Smash or back in video games in general than you think. Goku be damned to think otherwise.
 

Tetiro

Smash Ace
Joined
Aug 5, 2011
Messages
877
Location
United Kingdom
I guarantee you guys there will be precisely a 100% chance of...

NO information about Smash Ultimate in a Nindies Direct. It doesn't even matter if a Nindie character does wind up in Smash (which I doubt). Smash Bros. is not an Indie game. The Nindies Direct is ONLY to show off Nindie games. Smash Bros. information won't get revealed in any other game-specific Direct either, like Pokemon. It will only get information in a general Nintendo Direct, or a Super Smash Bros. Direct. That's it.


The reason there's a new Nindies Direct now is because the last one was Nintendo UK. This is Nintendo America.
Actually it was for Nintendo Europe. And definitely was not expecting anything this time. But rather pointing out what is likely to happen if at all.

I wouldn't get too hyped. After all it could be just like the last one with no bombshells. Just go in thinking "If there is a Smash person, it's Shantae"
 

Silo777

Smash Journeyman
Joined
Aug 10, 2018
Messages
256
My hype for Isaac at this point is through the roof, so I couldn't help myself to not make the rest of the video.

 

isaac3000

Smash Journeyman
Joined
Jul 14, 2014
Messages
217
Location
Germany
Oh too bad... would like to see Shantae, I like her series (especially Pirate's Curse, one of the ebst games I ever played!), well it is what it is...
 

Sabrewulf238

Smash Hero
Joined
Oct 17, 2007
Messages
5,164
Location
Ireland
I kind of hate how we're becoming so hopeful.

The more hopeful we get the more it'll hurt if Isaac doesn't get in. This doesn't feel good.
 

THE 6r

Smash Ace
Joined
Feb 4, 2015
Messages
898
Location
Fairfax,VA + Los Angeles, CA
NNID
6r$¢€£¥™©®
3DS FC
2981-7049-0538
Switch FC
SW-1195-6602-2525
I kind of hate how we're becoming so hopeful.

The more hopeful we get the more it'll hurt if Isaac doesn't get in. This doesn't feel good.
Sometimes we all just need to maintain hope to make it to the end.

We're almost there. I can feel it. We just need to wait just a little bit longer for our boy to be confirmed base or DLC. The stars are lining up for him this time more so then in the past. His inclusion would fit with the fan service nature of the game considering we got Inkling, Daisy, Ridley, Simon, Richter, Chrom, D. Samus, K. Rool, AND all of the vets. That's the sort of roster that if you suggested it during Smash 4 speculation would get you laughed out of the building for how amazingly unrealistic it sounds. But it's actually happening. I know it will hurt if by some off chance Isaac doesn't get in, but I would be genuinely shocked if the character supported by the largest and most active support thread on this website didn't make it to the dance.
 

Icana

Smash Apprentice
Joined
Mar 13, 2018
Messages
180
My hype for Isaac at this point is through the roof, so I couldn't help myself to not make the rest of the video.

Haha! If Isaac gets in, someone totally has to post this on Gamefaqs.

Also the ending of that vid was heart warming and soooo true.
 

True Blue Warrior

Smash Hero
Joined
Oct 4, 2013
Messages
9,727
Location
United Kingdom
NNID
TrueBlueSM
3DS FC
2036-7619-4276
His inclusion would fit with the fan service nature of the game considering we got Inkling, Daisy, Ridley, Simon, Richter, Chrom, D. Samus, K. Rool, AND all of the vets. That's the sort of roster that if you suggested it during Smash 4 speculation would get you laughed out of the building for how amazingly unrealistic it sounds
This is the type of reaction you'd get if you leaked the Smash roster we have right now 7 months ago.

"Every single character returning including Snake even though Konami sucks? Ridley, despite Sakurai stating he is impossible? K. Rool, Chrom and Dark Samus despite their lack of relevancy? No Rex? No Spring Man? Konami getting two newcomer characters despite being the worst company ever? This isn't the kind of roster Sakurai would ever make, it's a wish list made by a nostalgic fanboy. How fake."
 

Teeb147

Smash Legend
Joined
Nov 15, 2007
Messages
10,624
Came back to check out this thread in the morning. Kind of mixed feelings, but nice to see people talking positively too, including about Shantae. :p

Besides that, I may keep popping out and in, I have trouble with certain ways around here. A few people don't think they're harsh, but to me they are, I mean that's how I feel. When I try to say that a point is debatable when I make a claim it's that I think it isn't perfect, but I feel like it's harsh when someone pushes a point against it as if what I said is wrong. i think we can all be wrong, and it's ok to speak our opinions, and take them as opinions, and there are nicer ways to handle people's thoughts,not just always going against what's thought to be not right.
I don't like debating that much, so call me sensitive, but I have trouble lasting more than a few posts on some of that stuff. I still get riled sometimes and in a few spots I might get aggro back, but that's not really me, that's at least partially answering back with how I felt.

Anyway, just felt like saying that before I withdraw from here at least for a little bit. Have fun.
 
Last edited:

Istry555

Smash Cadet
Joined
Aug 10, 2018
Messages
44
So, I'm slowly coming around to hope that Isaac will actually be in this time, but I'm still most worried about the limited slots thing. Like, he would 100% get in if they were adding a standard amount of newcomers but might miss his chance again because there are less newcomers than past games. I'm also kind of really annoyed at the Geno following; if he gets in over Isaac I'll be really pissed. I know Geno has his fans, but objectively Isaac is the more deserving character (more games, more recent, lead character, Nintendo owned). Geno getting in is almost 100% Sakurai bias, which, yes, he makes the game so good for him, but after all the Fire Emblem and Kid Icarus stuff last time, it's just left a bad taste in my mouth and would even more if it costs Isaac maybe his last chance for the series.

Also, was there a post about a new Isaac thread or something that you need permission to access? I thought I saw something last night but it was late and I was only skimming.
 
Last edited:

Tetiro

Smash Ace
Joined
Aug 5, 2011
Messages
877
Location
United Kingdom
So, I'm slowly coming around to hope that Isaac will actually be in this time, but I'm still most worried about the limited slots thing. Like, he would 100% get in if they were adding a standard amount of newcomers but might miss his chance again because there are less newcomers than past games. I'm also kind of really annoyed at the Geno following; if he gets in over Isaac I'll be really pissed. I know Geno has his fans, but objectively Isaac is the more deserving character (more games, more recent, lead character, Nintendo owned). Geno getting in is almost 100% Sakurai bias, which, yes, he makes the game so good for him, but after all the Fire Emblem and Kid Icarus stuff last time, it's just left a bad taste in my mouth and would even more if it costs Isaac maybe his last chance for the series.

Also, was there a post about a new Isaac thread or something that you need permission to access? I thought I saw something last night but it was late and I was only skimming.
Don't be pissed if Geno got in over Isaac. Be happy for them. The worst thing you can do is become a Hater as that will bring us down like what happened with Waluigi. That whole incident has likely damaged Waluigi's chances for the next Smash Bros.

If you want to improve Isaac's chances, make your voice known louder but without the tone that happened with Waluigi and the other haters out there. Showing Sakurai the raw passion of Golden Sun fans is what will get us Isaac in the end.

King K Rool had 10 years of inactivity and yet here he is alongside Ridley. It is clear Sakurai does not care how old a character is inactive provided the fans want it. So my advice is to keep supporting Isaac positively and strong
 

Frosty Pops

Smash Journeyman
Joined
Aug 11, 2018
Messages
332
I know that Shantae wasn't deconfirm yet, do you have a link to your evidence, I don't feel like reading every post one by one sadly, this thread is hard enough to follow already.

I might support Santae if Isaac make it in, I don't really know the character but I love seing new series in Smash. ;D

As for FF, shouldn't Square own the Music? Why can't they use not remix one?
I don't think she will make it being an indie character. But she would have a very interesting moveset from what I have played of her games. She uses a cannon, whip attacks with her hair, transforms into animals absorbs things into her lamp, all kinds of moveset potential.
 

TempestSurge

Smash Ace
Joined
Oct 20, 2014
Messages
832
I kind of hate how we're becoming so hopeful.

The more hopeful we get the more it'll hurt if Isaac doesn't get in. This doesn't feel good.
I think people are bcoming more hopeful because more things are lining into place that points to Isaac finally making the base roster this go around vs Smash 4's newcomer period. Before the ballot confirmation, Sakurai's tweet, and K. Rool's reveal there was plenty of realistic expectations and pessimism.

Isaac was already non existent in Smash 4, that's as rock bottom as it gets. Even if he were a no show this base game, there's DLC since it seems like Ultimate will be around for a long time. Only worst case scenario in my opinion is him returning as an assist trophy.
 

Fane

Smash Journeyman
Joined
Mar 20, 2018
Messages
355
Isaac definitely got a skyrocket in chances due to Sakurai confirming he chose newcomers based on the Ballot results.

I'm not saying he'll make it, but his chances are better than ever right now!

Never played Golden Sun and I'm not familiar with the character, but I'm excited for you fans of Isaac to finally get him in! :)
 

Tetiro

Smash Ace
Joined
Aug 5, 2011
Messages
877
Location
United Kingdom
I think people are bcoming more hopeful because more things are lining into place that points to Isaac finally making the base roster this go around vs Smash 4's newcomer period. Before the ballot confirmation, Sakurai's tweet, and K. Rool's reveal there was plenty of realistic expectations and pessimism.

Isaac was already non existent in Smash 4, that's as rock bottom as it gets. Even if he were a no show this base game, there's DLC since it seems like Ultimate will be around for a long time. Only worst case scenario in my opinion is him returning as an assist trophy.
Even then it is not the end.

They can still add Isaac and give Matthew/Felix his place as an Assist Trophy. Same move. Different character model and voice pack.
 

Frosty Pops

Smash Journeyman
Joined
Aug 11, 2018
Messages
332
Would a Rhythm Heaven rep count as a surprise to you? Because then it would still be a fan roster, as its popular in Japan. Otherwise what kind of surprises do you mean? I don't want another Wii Fit Trainer.

I wouldn't mind it at all if a Rhythm Heaven rep got in. They'd definitely be one of the more unique characters like Villager and I'm sure would be fun to play.
I am expecting a super retro, off the wall character to pop up that no one expects. Like ice climbers, Game and Watch, duck hunt dog...I can almost guarantee sakurai wants to throw in another one.
 

JaidynReiman

Smash Hero
Joined
May 31, 2014
Messages
8,840
NNID
JaidynReiman
I am expecting a super retro, off the wall character to pop up that no one expects. Like ice climbers, Game and Watch, duck hunt dog...I can almost guarantee sakurai wants to throw in another one.
If they do an off-the-wall character I'm still calling Lip. Sakurai's given Panel de Pon a lot of attention in the past and he redesigned the flowers this time when he usually never does that. There could be a dual purpose for that (such as them appearing on a Panel de Pon stage or something). I'm not expecting it, just if there IS an off-the-wall character, I'm betting on it being Lip.


But IMO, the #1 most likely newcomer right now is Isaac.


Don't be pissed if Geno got in over Isaac. Be happy for them.
I'm sorry but I can't do that. Geno has nothing going for him. He's a side character in a 20 year old Mario owned by a third-party company. I'll be happy for his fans if he gets in, but IMO Geno does not "deserve" it. Waluigi should be playable first. Hell, Fawful should be playable first. Just in terms of Mario.

In terms of Square Enix, so should Terra, Sora, and Crono. In terms of third-parties, there's Crash, Spyro, Banjo, etc.


Geno is a nothing character no matter how you slice it. Even among obscure Nintendo first-party characters, he's obscure because he's not a main character (but he's not first-party because Square Enix owns him).
 

XenoWarriorX

Smash Champion
Joined
Aug 11, 2018
Messages
2,278
I guarantee you guys there will be precisely a 100% chance of...

NO information about Smash Ultimate in a Nindies Direct. It doesn't even matter if a Nindie character does wind up in Smash (which I doubt). Smash Bros. is not an Indie game. The Nindies Direct is ONLY to show off Nindie games. Smash Bros. information won't get revealed in any other game-specific Direct either, like Pokemon. It will only get information in a general Nintendo Direct, or a Super Smash Bros. Direct. That's it.


The reason there's a new Nindies Direct now is because the last one was Nintendo UK. This is Nintendo America.
Yeah guys. Nintendo never overshadows the indie games with their own....

There is no Smash reveal.

I think people are bcoming more hopeful because more things are lining into place that points to Isaac finally making the base roster this go around vs Smash 4's newcomer period. Before the ballot confirmation, Sakurai's tweet, and K. Rool's reveal there was plenty of realistic expectations and pessimism.

Isaac was already non existent in Smash 4, that's as rock bottom as it gets. Even if he were a no show this base game, there's DLC since it seems like Ultimate will be around for a long time. Only worst case scenario in my opinion is him returning as an assist trophy.
The worst case scenario is him not returning at all.

But even with my stupid Theory, I'm still worried about his chances.
 

EarlTamm

Smash Hero
Joined
Jun 17, 2018
Messages
7,349
I'm sorry but I can't do that. Geno has nothing going for him. He's a side character in a 20 year old Mario owned by a third-party company. I'll be happy for his fans if he gets in, but IMO Geno does not "deserve" it. Waluigi should be playable first. Hell, Fawful should be playable first. Just in terms of Mario.

In terms of Square Enix, so should Terra, Sora, and Crono. In terms of third-parties, there's Crash, Spyro, Banjo, etc.


Geno is a nothing character no matter how you slice it. Even among obscure Nintendo first-party characters, he's obscure because he's not a main character (but he's not first-party because Square Enix owns him).
But characters aren't selected in Ultimate because they have some sacred right, they are getting in because they are popular and requested. It's influenced every newcomer to some degree, some more than other, but it's there. And as of now, Geno is petty much next in line alongside Issac for that old long requested characters now that Ridley and K.Rool are gone. It also helps that we know Sakurai thinks Geno is perfect for a Smash character, and he is the person who decides what characters are "deserving." If a character pleases the fans, than I feel the spot is well deserved then and there.
 
Last edited:

TempestSurge

Smash Ace
Joined
Oct 20, 2014
Messages
832
Yeah guys. Nintendo never overshadows the indie games with their own....

There is no Smash reveal.



The worst case scenario is him not returning at all.

But even with my stupid Theory, I'm still worried about his chances.
How so? I was of the mind if Isaac wasn't in base game then a DLC campaign would be started. There are popular characters who are assist trophies that still haven't managed to make the jump, so that's why I feel it's worst. But hey, that's just my opinion.
 
Last edited:

XenoWarriorX

Smash Champion
Joined
Aug 11, 2018
Messages
2,278
But characters aren't selected in Ultimate because they have some sacred right, they are getting in because they are popular and requested. It's influenced every newcomer to some degree, some more than other, but it's there. And as of now, Geno is petty much next in line alongside Issac for that old long requested characters now that Ridley and K.Rool are gone. It also helps that we know Sakurai thinks Geno is perfect for a Smash character, and he is the person who decides what characters are "deserving." If a character pleases the fans, than I feel the spot is well deserved then and there.
Funny, that even a few months ago, we were thinking that characters that were irrelevant like King K rool wouldn't get in. But why are we judging characters based on how deserving they are?

People can make the argument that Isaac isn't deserving because he's from Ann RPG that no one remembers today.

SMRPG hasn't been represented by anyone in so long, so I don't blame the fans for requesting for someone who isn't "relevant".
 

Nazyrus

Smash Champion
Joined
Aug 10, 2018
Messages
2,837
https://twitter.com/NintendoAmerica/status/1032613428907495425
Wait we are getting another indie game direct!? What the heck!?
Yeah it hasn't even been a week, holy hell… Well they did tease "more coming soon" at the end of that europe nindies direct so… I wouldn't be surprised if at the end of this nindies on the 28th they tease the REAL regular nintendo direct or, i don't know, early september? Since the 28th is literally almost the end of the month, to tease a regular Nintendo Direct for the first week of september doesn't seem off to me, specially since it's already crazy that we are getting two nindies direct within the same week. They just proved me with this that anything is possible, lol.

I guarantee you guys there will be precisely a 100% chance of...

NO information about Smash Ultimate in a Nindies Direct. It doesn't even matter if a Nindie character does wind up in Smash (which I doubt). Smash Bros. is not an Indie game. The Nindies Direct is ONLY to show off Nindie games. Smash Bros. information won't get revealed in any other game-specific Direct either, like Pokemon. It will only get information in a general Nintendo Direct, or a Super Smash Bros. Direct. That's it.


The reason there's a new Nindies Direct now is because the last one was Nintendo UK. This is Nintendo America.
I agree, I'm still hoping for something during gamescom, probably they are saving a singular trailer reveal for the 25th ? After all gamescom is a place of multiple announcements, but this is just me hoping for something that has 99% chances of not happening, yet 1% of happening so… I'm just hoping, either way I believe that we will have a regular direct on early september at this point. After 2 nindies direct within the same week, and a smash focused direct a few weeks ago, people who are hungry for a normal nintendo direct must be pissed off already and Nintendo knows it.
 

mynameisBlade

Smash Lord
Joined
Mar 15, 2010
Messages
1,071
Just wanted to let you all know that last night I had a dream of a double-package reveal. Isaac being one of the characters and the other shocked me, but was still exciting to see him. Agumon. :) I have a feeling at least one of these will come to fruition.
 
Top Bottom