Spike's VGA's are not really that honourable. Why? Because Spike doesn't give a crap about Nintendo, frankly because they seem too childish. Did you know that last year, SMG won Best Wii Game, but wasn't even nominated for Game of the Year? IMO, SSBB should be nominated for Best Multiplayer Game, Best Soundtrack, and Game Of The Year. It's a masterpiece, but in the "mature" gaming world, it's fruity simple because it isn't "cool" like the PS3 or 360. It's funny, because 11 million more Wiis have been sold than 360, and more than double the amount of PS3's. I never even liked the COD series. Yes, Resident Evil 4 did win GotY in 2005, but that was most likely because it was ported to the PS2.
Conclusion: Spike care's about "cool" games, not good games.
Oh, one last thing. Guitar Hero: World Tour for Best Soundtrack? Gimme a break. The soundtrack in that game is nothing more than a bunch of random songs, just like Rock Band. Shameful. Just shameful.