Daily catch up.
My ability also only targets a specific alignment, fwiw.
Ok, interesting.
It came across as very natural. I don't really have an interest in attempting to verify that he has notes; that isn't really important to my assessment. I just don't feel this is the type of thing someone would bother including in their read unless they were actually doing it.
You’re missing my point, which is that you’re giving town points to someone for a remark that is very easy to fake because it can’t be verified. Your reason feels forced to me.
I can think of one or two examples from xkcd off the top of my head (Xivii, Stellaris, Town, for example; I feel like there was at least one Peaceful Whale game, possibly X-Men, Town, and maybe Crossover, Town as well). My memory is otherwise not as encyclopedic about those sort of details as I would like but I'm sure I could dredge up some more examples if my point isn't clear enough. I do not recall any instance in any game I have ever played of scum spontaneously claiming early in the game unless it was to save themselves from being yeeted. So... yes, I think Darkpit is likely Town due to his position in the claim order alone, and I believe that people farther down the claim order have a higher probability of being mafia.
I want to say Peaceful Whale claimed as town in Crossover and as mafia in another game I can’t remember but I think it was Refrigerator mafia, which is a game I haven’t started working on yet. My encyclopedic mafia memory is faltering after a year and a half (I have discussed this somewhere on this site recently) but I will think about it, I just don’t want to use the hours before deadline searching old games. So for right now I will concede that you currently have more supporting data than I do.
You could just look at my answer to Sabrar then.
I did that’s why I noted that Sabrar asked the same question.
I do feel that I am able to identify content that is fluff, yes. I know what scum hunting looks like.
And that you are being subjectively selective in your groupings.
I would rather just have you producing good content so I can evaluate you properly. There is no benefit to being cagey in a setup like this and every benefit in being as obvTown as possible, and I would expect that both you and Sabrar would have come to that realization on your own. You are misevaluating things that are transparently townie, likely because your point of view is not that of Town.
I’ve presented my analysis, and a summary of my analysis because you didn’t comprehend the original, and like I pointed out before, I feel you are downplaying my content because you don’t like where my analysis is leading me.
I am noting this for now and may go through it in detail later.
Interesting you scum read me for content that you don’t want to take the time to read carefully.
It's not specifically that she is not stating her reads. It's that she is not doing things to actively develop them. Her play is passive, uninspired. She isn't digging into people.
This from the person that had blocked my attempts to question somitomi. You mean I’m digging into people you don’t want me looking at.
Yeah, the role PM says "player of opposing alignment" but in paraphrasing the role I used the appropriate alignment instead, sue me. I also didn't mention that if I remove a spirit, they can't vote in Judgement Day, because it's irrelevant. I knew full well that roles are not tied to alignment [
#23], so coming up with a "townie power" makes little sense here. And at the risk of opening a bottle of wine, do I strike you as the scum player who proactively claims a made-up power before there's even consensus about a mass claim?
So, you are confirming I am correct in that you were not completely accurate in your role claim? I need to think about your revised claim.
Your question refers to what I have been pondering. I tried to question you on this earlier, when LaserGuy answered my question to you and attempted to justify why it wasn’t necessary for you to answer my question yourself.
yes, thank you very much for telling us a dog picture was fluff
Hey, not every dog picture is fluff! Fluffy maybe, but not necessarily fluff. I sometimes like to use the dog pics to denote agreement or skepticism and I thought it was obvious when I did this but maybe not.
and something about a taxi driver dosnt sit right with me which i already commented on
You keep bringing up that you are suspicious of FrozenFlame because of his role, and it has been pointed out many times that roles are NAI. I have already said that I am suspicious of you for this reason.
Also since I forgot to yesterday, I’m able to see who used an action on another player. Which has me curious as to how this works in a game with no night kill.
Interesting your perspective on this. There are other targeted actions in this game that aren't kills. I’ve already used one.
Can you honestly tell me you believe that this case comes from Town!bessie?
Can you honestly tell me that you think nitpicky focus is out of the range of someone that has been known to tunnel people based on their confirmation posts??
This is why I say we wait to vote fate. If they prove their role and their target has that Asterik we know they aren’t lying about their cookie role.
That doesn’t mean they can’t be scum, but I see no point in scum having this as a role. It be disrupting the balance if scum got a role that in most games would auto confirm them as town and get no questions asked.
Roles are NAI. Roles were determined, then alignments were randomly assigned to roles, like I keep reminding FateShirou. It’s in the OP and has been much discussed in thread.
That’s a bit of a convenient power. As early day one there isn’t going be many early votes in a shorter setup.
Granted like Fate, if these claims are true both could have been proven but have not. If Swiss wanted a town clear I don’t see why they wouldn’t just reset the first vote and prove themselves.
How would Swiss using his power clear him as town? He can reset the vote in the first half of the day it’s a power that does nothing substantial because we have two and a half days to revote.
I believe the intent of most (if not all) of the powers is that they don’t have a lot of effect on the game like FateShirou’s, putting an asterisk next to somitomi’s name doesn’t affect his vote in any way. And the powers that do something like the bus driver just swap vanillaish powers to other players. All powers are NAI.
This is true, however, was it no established that Swiss had not read or understood the rules when they said we should mass claim super early?
If true, that means they were not under the impression that the abilities meant nothing. Instead my original point would stand. They would think their claim and ability would be a clear for them. So why not do it?
Ok but powers are NAI so I still don’t see what you think using a power would clear.
Back in a bit.
