No Sakurai still has time constraints with DLC. The devs still have a schedule they need to keep and they can't just keep the team together forever. So he can't take as much time as he wants because
A) People would be left waiting a super long time for the character
B) Nintendo would care, and they aren't going to back a character taking longer unless it's going to make more money to make up for the lost time.
And yes Isaac could have been implemented, but he has a grand total of zero popularity outside of Golden Sun fans and the hardcore Smash players.
You act as though the only people who talk about Smash around here is hardcore Smash players. Isaac is wanted by much of the community, and, at least going by appearance, wouldn't garner that much of a different reaction from fans outside of it than Corrin or any other Fire Emblem character. Corrin had no popularity anywhere leading up to their reveal. So who cares where his fan base comes from? It's at least there.
I saw very little opposition to Ryu, and what I did see stemmed from a misquote of something Sakurai said about fighting game characters. And I saw even fewer people complain about his reveal, certainly not the extent we got with Cloud and Corrin.
Really? Well maybe it's just because I was involved in it, but therewas quite a bit. Maybe not here, but we really aren't allowed to have negative reactions around here without being dogpiled on anyway. A lot of people used the no traditional fighting game character, or no 3rd party company gets 2 reps thing to defend their point, but only a few didn't want him solely for those reasons alone. Either way, I still believe characters should be added based on popularity they had beforehand, not after. We aren't talking about how Sakurai should pick Smash 5's roster here, we're talking about how he picked a relatively un-talked about character, and decided to bypass about 50-or-so others just to make his dream a reality.
Never underestimate the power of memes, they turned
![Captain Falcon :4falcon: :4falcon:]()
into the legend he is today.
Captain Falcon may get a lot of meme attention now, but for years he was (along with Fox) the face of Smash Bros entirely. Roy's popularity seems to solely rely on "teh phire" and "R O Y B O Y S". Very few seem to care much for him outside of jokes.
You know I think this is where the problem lies. I don't give a **** about what's popular in the Smash community, because really we ain't ****. The vast majority of the people who play this game don't associate themselves with the game's community, let alone contribute to random popularity polls or post on forums. DLC, as well as all the other characters in this game, are made for EVERYONE who picks up a controller, and Cloud certainly is a character a lot of people wanted to play. What looks like a huge presence on something like SmashBoards like K. Rool might not matter at all to 80% of the people who play the game. You know what probably got Bayonetta voted highest? The people who visited the Smash Bros. website for whatever reason and saw that they could suggest a character to be added to Smash, and thought Bayonetta would be cool. Someone like Banjo or Isaac only matters to hardcore Nintendo fans, and those are not the majority of Smash players.
And that's the problem isn't it, the people who continue to support the game after all this time and make it part of their life get ignored, because a public poll let anyone who passively play/talk/involves themselves with the game the time of day to give their input. Many of which probably haven't even bought the damn thing.
I won't even talk about how I believe Bayonetta's numbers to be shady again; to effectively consider the opinions of a bunch of people that don't care all that much about the game over fans that follow it religiously is what subjects himself to criticism. We're the ones buying the DLC, that **** doesn't sell to everyone who bought a copy of the game. If you ask me, the ballot should've only been accessible after registering the game or some ****. Anything else, and you get a bunch of people who haven't played Smash Bros for 15 years/ people who played Smash at that party once deciding who does or doesn't make it in which I don't think makes a bit of sense.
Is some/many of the silent majority dedicated fans? Maybe maybe not, either we can't keep deferring to their opinions because in reality over 100,000 people backed Britney ****in Spears. The silent majority is full of idiots.
We did get
![Little Mac :4littlemac: :4littlemac:]()
though, whose reveal was essentially the equivalent of
![Roy :4feroy: :4feroy:]()
reveal for Japan, who was complaining about how this irrelevant character was taking a slot from one of THEIR big characters. People are always going to want their opinions valued more, that's the nature of life.
Look at pre-poll data for every Smash game that has some. Japan always gets a good chunk of the characters they asked for in the game, Roy's not the only one. Little Mac, on the other hand, seems like the only character that only had popularity in the states to make it in the game yet. I'm not going to get on him too much for that, it's regional bias sure, but it's unavoidable. He speaks their language, he traverses their boards, he hears their opinions, of course their will be
some bias there, but this much? I still wish he at least got someone to pay more attention to our opinions. I honestly think that the ballot was extra make-up for this as well. Notice how he didn't mention Japan's results for Bayonetta at the end. He needs to start taking all of our interests collectively, and not piece them together place by place.
I'm not talking about competitive viability, that means almost nothing. I'm talking about how fun a character is to play. Someone like Mewtwo was a ton of fun to play, just not competitively. Lets say that
![Wolf :wolf: :wolf:]()
was as fun to play as someone like
![Bowser :bowser2: :bowser2:]()
or
![Samus :samus2: :samus2:]()
was. Do you really think people would care about him as much? Ryu was chosen because his qualities made him a fun character. And there are a lot of people who would play as Ryu even if he wasn't as good as he is because they love the character, it's just that most of them aren't part of the Smash community.
My point with Ryu, is that he's blowing up because every other highlight reel has a Ryu or two in it, because he's so ****in' good. Without the exposure, he'd fade away, like WFT who had similar reactions upon their reveal. And I know, you don't think WFT had similar reactions, but I'm just saying what I saw. Smash fans will get hyped over anything once it gets revealed.
Also, many Mewtwo fans still hate how Mewtwo plays. We just put up with it because c'mon, it's
Mewtwo.
Wolf didn't get in the initial roster probably just because they didn't have time to fit everyone from Brawl in and the newcomers, and Wolf was one of the expendable Brawl newcomers (he was added in as an afterthought to begin with as well). He wasn't added as DLC because Lucas was chosen over him, and he couldn't match the popularity of Cloud or Bayonetta or the fighter potential of Ryu and wasn't a super special character from a new game like Corrin. As for why K. Rool wasn't picked... he isn't actually popular. It sucks to say it, considering the amount of people who are passionate for the character, and I'll be mad as hell if he isn't included in the next Smash game, but when taking all the millions of Smash players as a whole, the K. Rool fans make up a small percent. The polls really aren't a indicator of overall popularity. Think a moment for just how many more people visit the main Smash Bros site compared to something like Smashboards or the Smash subreddit, and then it starts to become clear that fan polls don't present a clear picture of what's popular. Wolf and K. Rool were nowhere near as universal as people made them out to be.
Wolf doesn't match the popularity of Cloud/Bayonetta etcc... Come on dude, you know better than that. I know he's not as important, but popularity is something he actually has even ouside of Smash. K.Rool too, although that may not last, because his bandwagoners are starting to get frustrated with not getting a hugely popular character and will most likely move on. Say what you want about their popularity inside or out of the Smash community, but you don't know who is and isn't popular just as much as I do, and up until the ballot neither did Sakurai. The info's just not there, our stupid polls are literally the only pulse on who people do and don't want, so if many say "K.Rool" you can't just assume they mean ****in' Cloud or Goku. I'm tired of hearing that our opinions are just few of many. Is it true? Sure, but until the ballot (which as I wrote earlier, I think is a joke anyway) it was the only ones he ever heard.
So yeah, OUR opinions are the ones he should've been listening to after all this time, not some mythical majority who most likely consists of kids who change their opinions every 5 seconds anyway (I used to be that kid). The fact that he ignored his DEDICATED fan base (which really, who else should you be really listening to anyway) is what subjects him to criticism, not supposed "insatiable fans" that just want to be angry.