Welcome to Smashboards, the world's largest Super Smash Brothers community! Over 250,000 Smash Bros. fans from around the world have come to discuss these great games in over 19 million posts!
You are currently viewing our boards as a visitor. Click here to sign up right now and start on your path in the Smash community!
z25 is effectively dead as long as the hunter is alive. We could lynch him, but that could lead us into a situation where the hunter's shot decides the game. Since the hunter could do something a little too clever and throw the game on their own, I think we're fine where we are. I may be slightly biased in this assessment since I really, really don't want to get vigged and somehow lose this very town-sided game.
Pythag is too damn good at this game.
I feel you, I was just being playful.
My Ex read is just like a tone read, just general feels, plus I guess they were off the UP Waggon on D1. I don't have anything really solid I can put in either the town or scum columns for them, but I guess the best way to explain it is they don't feel like they're struggling to survive as the last mafia.
Read This page
When Raxxel Posts his reads, UP comes in to defend himself :
How do you not consider a vote during the deadline end of a phase targeting? I'd agree if it were for pressure, but this was when we had to start thinking of a suitable person to lynch d1.
Pythag
, you asked why I would vote for Kary over Wiisp. I mainly found their posts from day 1 and 2 to be aggressive without substance. Their day 1 content especially did little. They start by asking for reads, not to evaluate the people they're asking, but in order to get a sense of direction while they catch up. This reads like somebody trying to play the game easy and ride the wave, which also matches their posts whining about drivel, as if they wish to make things more readable. They don't seem to want to put effort into actually reading each individual. Other small things like their vote on UP with no explanation attached, their approach to Funnier vs. ExLight where they outright announce their apathy to the outcome in terms of who dies, and their call for the hunter to claim are what make me uneasy about this slot.Pretty sure if we don't lynch scum toDAy we have to tomorrow, so z25 gets put on the block.
Ok that's fine.Anyway,
If you want my next lynch, it wouldn't be Wiisp, it would be ExLight. Their excessive use of emotional appeal absolutely offsets me.
if you flip town we are forced to lynch Z25 during D4 if the bomb doesn't go off during N3
yea I kinda hate how he kept giving me townpants
Raxxel
okay, I'll stop leading you around.
Yeah but don't forget that I started this line of questioning in 2706 which, you will notice, is before 2737.
Lack of activity, while it can be considered NAI, is often more attached to scum than it is town, at least from my experience. Keep in mind, my only other game as town had both werewolves get by with saying little to nothing. You're also kind of simplifying my points about them a bit. It's more the lack of substance to what they post, as well as them seeming disinterested in town's interests in general.
Why are you not responding to the post that gives my reasoning to vote for UP? While a reach (which is what made me scumread Z) is definitely on the scummier side of things, being reactive and defensive upon being called out is worse imo. It shows a larger focus in staying alive than solving. That's what knocked UP down for me. Z was my strongest scumread, but this was early game where hardly anyone had much to work with yet, so my impressions between the two shifted between then and when I had decided to vote UP.
Why didn't you vote for z25 Day 1?
You had him between null and scum for most of the Day.
Before you voted, he waggons were tied at 3-3 between Poyzin and z25.
You yourself said that you didn't understand the Poyzin waggon.
And, I've given you a chance toDay to explain how you ended up voting for Poyzin.
To me, it looks pretty obvious. You had to avoid voting for z25 because he's your partner.
This is the votecount, and your vote comes at the top of the following page.
The man quit. I think I just didn't feel like it was relevant to say alone, so I brought it up when saying scum reads because it was on my mind.
Maybe I could believe your reasoning if there was any shred of evidence that you thought this way at the time.
Funnier's entrance was more remarkable to me since it reminded me of Rajam in Jungle Mafia. It got more of a reaction on the spot from me than Lore as a result, even if I found Lore's focus on how one player types to be more anti-town, so I think I more impulsively made a remark on him.
I've made my reads already tbh. The lynch list is Kary > Ex >>>> Wiisp >>> Ran.
Yes, because I disagreed with your rationale. I disagreed with your argument about how they thought out-loud (and honestly, even after the flip, reading back I disagree with it even more so because in the post you quoted UP was stating an observation and read), and I disagreed with your attack on UP over how they asked about who should be wagon'd, then because the post you quoted contradicted your accusation of him just trying to piggyback others, and now because you did the same thing in your entrance.
I mean
It doesn't really matter what I argue at this point because I have a feeling you're gonna be dying pretty soon here. If you want to spend your last hours debating the little details with me then we can do that, but I don't think it will help your case.
Agreed. Solving the game is the most important and fun part of mafia for me, so analysis is definitely where I'm strongest. But the things you've mentioned, like being proactive, are definitely things I'm just gonna have to pick up through more experience.
maaaaaaan why do people gotta assume I'm dumb.
I tend to agree. If I'm dying I'd much rather spend what I have left doing what I enjoy in mafia. Only problem is that since the last page or so has been about me, there isn't much for me to analyze.
Wiisp
Who would you believe scum is killing tonight?
ranmaru
