SmashBoards Roster Evolution (11-1, break)

[GreenReaperGod]

What about cuts?

 

[SunnyDust]

Added Rosalina, Samurai Goroh, Greninja, Mach Rider and Wonder Red. I now have a total of 28 series.
Yes, I put Rosalina instead of Toad and Greninja instead of Jigglypuff. Looks like I won't survive this round.

 

[Smasher 101]

Additions:
Toad: Wanted Mario at five at this point. Chose him due to how long he's been in the series.
Jigglypuff: Wanted Pokemon at five as well. Also finishes off the Brawl vets besides third parties and the other two Trainer Pokemon. (I also just realized that I should have put her in the middle of the Pokes but I'll fix that next round if I make it)
Chrom: Wanted a third Fire Emblem character.
Chibi-Robo: Going to try to keep adding at least one new series per round.
Lip: Had back in like Round 3 but dropped her in favor of Andy. Decided it was finally time to add her for good.

Honorable mentions: Rosalina, Bowser Jr., Greninja, Meowth, Roy, Saki.

Total Series: 27 (Mario, Donkey Kong, Yoshi, Wario, The Legend of Zelda, Metroid, Kirby, Star Fox, Pokemon, F-Zero, Mother, Fire Emblem, Kid Icarus, Pikmin, Animal Crossing, Punch-Out!!, Wii Fit, Ice Climber, Game & Watch, R.O.B., Golden Sun, Xenoblade, Wars, The Legendary Starfy, Chibi-Robo, Mach Rider, Panel de Pon)

 

[The Light Music Club]

View attachment 13178

Added Rosalina, Samurai Goroh, Greninja, Mach Rider and Wonder Red. I now have a total of 28 series.
Yes, I put Rosalina instead of Toad and Greninja instead of Jigglypuff. Looks like I won't survive this round.

Don't worry Greninja and Jiggly are both bad choices imo. Meowth is the next most memorable in the series. Jiggly was only popular in the anime. But Meowth, Pikachu, and Charizard are the only Kanto pokes that are still in the anime (I think).

 

[GreenReaperGod]

well whatever, I have one cut

Cut: Toad (see below)
Added: Captain Toad (having two different Toad character wouldn't work, even considering that Captain Toad and Toad are most likely the same person), Dillon, Andy, Starfy, Lucario, and Bandana Dee

 

[The Light Music Club]

well whatever, I have one cut

Cut: Toad (see below)
Added: Captain Toad (having two different Toad character wouldn't work, even considering that Captain Toad and Toad are most likely the same person), Dillon, Andy, Starfy, Lucario, and Bandana Dee

Since when has having two of the same people been a problem? Sheik and ZSS......

 

[GreenReaperGod]

Since when has having two of the same people been a problem? Sheik and ZSS......

I'm not saying it from that point of view but more along the lines of being unlikely (at at least this stage in the game). Toad hasn't even made it into Smash yet as a character and having 2 Toad characters on a 50 character roster is just silly.

 

[SunnyDust]

Don't worry Greninja and Jiggly are both bad choices imo. Meowth is the next most memorable in the series. Jiggly was only popular in the anime. But Meowth, Pikachu, and Charizard are the only Kanto pokes that are still in the anime (I think).

Charizard is not in the anime anymore... Anyway, the reason why I chose Greninja over the others is because I don't want to overrepresent the first generation.
Plus, Meowth has lost a lot of his popularity over time.

 

[pupNapoleon]

I will be merging Greninja into P. Trainer, reformating Red to have Charizard, Greninja, and Sceptile.
Fusing Sheik into Zelda as well (and adding ZSS back into Samus). This frees two extra slots.

My added seven:
-Andy, as it is time for him. The wars series is huge.
- Robin (Fire Emblem), as Fire Emblem is very massive, it needs another. Seeing as there isn't really a way to properly represent others from this series (meaning, I have the two recurring lords, but I want a new one that is more variant, and could use .... not a sword, I believe she can learn magic too? Also, female option, and I've got a few avatar characters- Villager, WFT, Trainer)
- Duck Hunt Dog; another series, and also another animal. He would play as the character on screen, playing off the shots of the hunter in the fourth wall.
- Ray MK, because it is another Franchise, and I love him.
- Cooking Mama; wanted her for a long while, and she represents a huge franchise, female, and new demographic for smash.
-Toon Link, since Zelda now needs a fourth, and Paper Mario ade room for him (as did ZSS; Link should not be the only dual person of the same person)
-Jigglypuff (Amazing plans with this coming soon, but so many changes this round, I must just satiate her supporters before I make her even better).

ONE of these may change, but I'm at about 90 percent, though I need to look at my roster and see if another franchise need be fleshed out. Any volunteers on making this roster? I will have the layout ready tomorrow and can PM it.

 

[The_Sheik]

I will be merging Greninja into P. Trainer, reformating Red to have Charizard, Greninja, and Sceptile.
Fusing Sheik into Zelda as well (and adding ZSS back into Samus). This frees two extra slots.

My added seven:
-Andy, as it is time for him. The wars series is huge.
- Robin (Fire Emblem), as Fire Emblem is very massive, it needs another. Seeing as there isn't really a way to properly represent others from this series (meaning, I have the two recurring lords, but I want a new one that is more variant, and could use .... not a sword, I believe she can learn magic too? Also, female option, and I've got a few avatar characters- Villager, WFT, Trainer)
- Duck Hunt Dog; another series, and also another animal. He would play as the character on screen, playing off the shots of the hunter in the fourth wall.
- Ray MK, because it is another Franchise, and I love him.
- Cooking Mama; wanted her for a long while, and she represents a huge franchise, female, and new demographic for smash.
-Toon Link, since Zelda now needs a fourth, and Paper Mario ade room for him (as did ZSS; Link should not be the only dual person of the same person)
-Jigglypuff (Amazing plans with this coming soon, but so many changes this round, I must just satiate her supporters before I make her even better).

ONE of these may change, but I'm at about 90 percent, though I need to look at my roster and see if another franchise need be fleshed out. Any volunteers on making this roster? I will have the layout ready tomorrow and can PM it.

I can do it for you. Oh, and you stole my Pokemon trainer idea.

 

[Angelglory]

Edited my roster, swapping Chrom for Lucas

Newcomers: Rosalina, Wolf, Lucas, Mach Rider, Dillon
New Series: Mach Rider, Dillon's Rolling Western
Total Series: 29​

 

[Tepig2000]

Yes, I put Rosalina instead of Toad and Greninja instead of Jigglypuff. Looks like I won't survive this round.

This is just why I won't vote for you. I prefer Rosalina and Greninja over Toad and Jigglypuff.

 

[andimidna]

This is just why I won't vote for you. I prefer Rosalina and Greninja over Toad and Jigglypuff.

Me too.

My roster should be here soon.

 

[SmasherMaster]

I added Zero Suit Samus, Falco, Lip, Captain Rainbow and Wonder Red.

Zero Suit Samus and Falco are the last Nintendo veterans.
I needed new series.
Lip is from Panel de Pon, which has good amount of games.
Captain Rainbow is a japanense game with minor Nintendo characters, such as Lip, Little Mac, Takamaru and Birdo.
Wonder Red is a new IP. Also, Wonderful 101 is owned by Nintendo, like how Pokemon or Fire Emblem are, except Platinum Games made it instead of a company owned by Nintendo.

Honorable mentions: Waddle Dee, Giovanni, Chibbi Robo, Andy

Series: 27 (Maro, Donkey Kong, Yoshi, Wario, Legend Of Zelda, Metroid, Ice Climbers, Gryomite, Kid Icarus, Punch Out, Nazo No Marusamu Jo, Panel de Pon, Kirby, Pikmin, Animal Crossing, Star Fox, F-Zero, Captain Rainbow, Pokemon, Fire Emblem, Mother, Game and Watch, Xenoblade, Golden Sun, Wonderful 101, Wii)

 

[andimidna]

Cuts:
Toad, because I LOVE Rosalina.
Skull Kid, because I felt worried that having 2 risky characters from main 3 series. So I added Toon Link to be a bit... safer.

Additions:
Rosalina
Toon Link
Jigglypuff
Wolf
Mach Rider
Dillon
Ray

 

[SmasherMaster]

I will be merging Greninja into P. Trainer, reformating Red to have Charizard, Greninja, and Sceptile.
Fusing Sheik into Zelda as well (and adding ZSS back into Samus). This frees two extra slots.

My added seven:
-Andy, as it is time for him. The wars series is huge.
- Robin (Fire Emblem), as Fire Emblem is very massive, it needs another. Seeing as there isn't really a way to properly represent others from this series (meaning, I have the two recurring lords, but I want a new one that is more variant, and could use .... not a sword, I believe she can learn magic too? Also, female option, and I've got a few avatar characters- Villager, WFT, Trainer)
- Duck Hunt Dog; another series, and also another animal. He would play as the character on screen, playing off the shots of the hunter in the fourth wall.
- Ray MK, because it is another Franchise, and I love him.
- Cooking Mama; wanted her for a long while, and she represents a huge franchise, female, and new demographic for smash.
-Toon Link, since Zelda now needs a fourth, and Paper Mario ade room for him (as did ZSS; Link should not be the only dual person of the same person)
-Jigglypuff (Amazing plans with this coming soon, but so many changes this round, I must just satiate her supporters before I make her even better).

ONE of these may change, but I'm at about 90 percent, though I need to look at my roster and see if another franchise need be fleshed out. Any volunteers on making this roster? I will have the layout ready tomorrow and can PM it.

I suggest removing Cooking Mama, due to the fact that she is 3rd party.

 

[pupNapoleon]

I suggest removing Cooking Mama, due to the fact that she is 3rd party.

Whoa... is she? If so she will definitely be replaced.

Edit: yes, my first source was WRONG! So I will replace her with Lip.

7 (gw, takamaru, duck hunt, balloonfighter, lip, ic,lil mac)

9 (pikachu, p.trainer*, Lucario, Mewtwo, Jigglypuff, pit, paultena, shulk, isaac )

11 (mario, luigi, peach, bowser, paper mario, yoshi, wario, dk, diddy, k.rool, Dilon)

11(Link, Zelda/shiek, Ganondorf, Toon,Fox, Wolf, marth, ike, robin (girl) samus,/zss, ridley, )

7 (Kirby, Dedede, Meta, Nes, Prky,Olimar, villager girl)

5 (wft, ray mk, andy, captain falcon, mii)

**for pokemon trainer, the sixth/last image from dustination at the bottom of the page below (sceptile, charizard, greninja)
http://smashboards.com/threads/the-...on-8-0-available.336761/page-63#post-16687005

Posted in case any kind soul wants to put this together:
@ The_Sheik offered, but anyone else is welcome as I believe she is in school

 

[Tepig2000]

Whoa... is she? If so she will definitely be replaced.

Edit: yes, my first source was WRONG! So I will replace her with Lip.

7 (gw, takamaru, duck hunt, balloonfighter, lip, ic,lil mac)

9 (pikachu, p.trainer*, Lucario, Mewtwo, Jigglypuff, pit, paultena, shulk, isaac )

11 (mario, luigi, peach, bowser, paper mario, yoshi, wario, dk, diddy, k.rool, Dilon)

11(Link, Zelda/shiek, Ganondorf, Toon,Fox, Wolf, marth, ike, robin (girl) samus,/zss, ridley, )

7 (Kirby, Dedede, Meta, Nes, Prky,Olimar, villager girl)

5 (wft, ray mk, andy, captain falcon, mii)

**for pokemon trainer, the sixth/last image from dustination at the bottom of the page below (sceptile, charizard, greninja)
http://smashboards.com/threads/the-...on-8-0-available.336761/page-63#post-16687005

Posted in case any kind soul wants to put this together:
@ The_Sheik offered, but anyone else is welcome as I believe she is in school

I will make your roster soon. How did you know she is in school?

EDIT: Here it is. The trainer icon you wanted didn't work, sorry:

 

[pupNapoleon]

@ Tepig2000 Thanks man: and I don't know she is in school, I just saw her age when I messaged her, and assumed.

 

[BindingBlade]

Tingle Trances In - Tingle is the best fifth Zelda character that is not a carbon copy.
Nook Collects The Debt - I really wanted Nook in before, but it seems more justifiable now.
Waddle Dee Dances In - Obvious choice for another Kirby fighter.
Saki Saunters In - IDK, just felt him.
R.O.B Wheels On - Far past time for this Smash champion to debut!
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Close But No Cigar - The following character just couldn't do it for me this round: Porky, Toon Link, Prince Sabel, Dinosaur Squad, Alph

 

[Tepig2000]

@ Tepig2000 Thanks man: and I don't know she is in school, I just saw her age when I messaged her, and assumed.

Yeah, that's what I tought.

 

[andimidna]

I like that Pokemon Trainer idea.
Might be stealing that if I make it to the next round

 

[Gunla]

It is time for a little twist. You'll be voting as usual... but this time, the two players with the most votes will be eliminated. DOUBLE ELIMINATION! DOUBLE BANG FOR YOUR VOTE!
...As usual, vote for who you voted for and why in a post below.

Click Me to Vote!​

Spoiler: Contestants!

@ andimidna
@ Angelglory
@ BindingBlade
@ Chase
@ GreenReaperGod
@ SmasherMaster
@ The Light Music Club
@ The_Sheik
@ Smasher 101
@ SunnyDust
@ pupNapoleon
@kylexv
@ TheZombiePig

Spoiler: Rosters!

Chase:

GreenReaperGod:

Angelglory:

The Light Music Club:

SmasherMaster:

BindingBlade:

The_Sheik

andimidna

Smasher 101:

SunnyDust:

DukeNapoleon

kylexv

TheZombiePig

Double Elimination Begins Now!
You have until Friday Afternoon to vote!​

 

[Tepig2000]

Voted BindingBlade not necessarily because of Tingle, but because Tingle over Toon Link. Yeah, this is just bias.

 

[Chase]

Voted for GreenReaperGod because of Captain Toad (who has only appeared in 3 games) over regular Toad. Also because the other choices on his roster bore me.

EDIT: Also because 4 Kirby characters is too many at this point.

 

[The Light Music Club]

Bindingblade because I don't like quite a few of his characters. (Chrom, Tingle, Toad, Ray, Lucas, Solo ZSS, Solo Sheik) Also has four Kirby characters which I don't agree with.

 

[BindingBlade]

My votes are unexpected, to say the least. Rather have a clone than a major, original character? Sorry about that one.

 

[The Light Music Club]

My votes are unexpected, to say the least. Rather have a clone than a major, original character? Sorry about that one.

I just don't like Tingle but I like him more than toon. It's just that I prefer Skull Kid. You had some other characters I didn't like that's why.

 

[TheZombiePig]

Voted for BindingBlade.
Tom Nook seems odd if you ask me, and the roster appears to have the least diverse cast of characters, compared to the other rosters.

 

[andimidna]

Yikes... Tingle is my least favorite videogame character and I'm not so fond of Waddle Dee either...

I will be voting soon, but not now, I want to be sure...

 

[The Light Music Club]

With the double elim I was like 90% sure I was getting voted off. It's gone to like 45% sure, but last time I got my votes late in the round. Votes seem quite scattered this time around.

 

[GreenReaperGod]

Welp, looks like I'm a goner. I have a chance surviving if it wasn't double elimination but since it is, I'm screwed.

Y U NO LIKE CAPTAIN TOAD

 

[The Light Music Club]

Who voted for me and why?

 

[Chase]

Who voted for me and why?

I didn't, but it's most likely they voted for you because of Bowser Jr..

 

[SmasherMaster]

Voted for DukeNapeleon because of the lack of ROB.

 

[pupNapoleon]

Voted for DukeNapeleon because of the lack of ROB.

I'm not the only one without him..
I CANT BELIEVE I FORGOT HIM!

 

[Smasher 101]

Voted for BindingBlade because I think it's too early for Bandana Dee and Tom Nook.

 

[LoneKonWolf]

finally feels like there are no more safe rosters (though if the roster amount increases that will probably change)
so time to vote from bias,
mine came down to chase and zomebiepig for the exculsion of ike,
went with zombiepig because unlike chase he had three slots for fire emblem yet still no ike

 

[GreenReaperGod]

Who voted for me and why?

That was me and it was for Bowser Jr.

 

[The Light Music Club]

That was me and it was for Bowser Jr.

So I'm assuming for you the fifth mario rep is:
1.Toad
2. Paper Mario
3. Rosalina
4. Bowser Jr.

Or 2 and 3 swapped.