Official Smash Ultimate Discussion

[Deleted member]

I remember PolarPanda saying some other stuff about how some Nintendo partners were saying Geno or something like that, but I can’t find the quote. Anybody mind helping me out there?

 

[Ignoritus]

Crono is still more widely recognized by a certain age group though... while geno is only recognized by a fraction of that same age group...

You'd be amazed. Chrono Trigger is a cult classic yeah, but it's still a relatively niche name. Geno was obscure yes, but you'd be amazed how many gaming fans know him nowadays just because of all the Smash Bros buzz surrounding him. In a general audience there's definitely a strong argument to be had for Crono, but when the target audience is Smash Bros players Geno has the edge over him easily. If Nintendo were specifically going to go for a niche "fan-favorite" character from Square Enix, Geno is definitely the right answer.

Spoiler

I'm not used to being able to talk about Geno as being a more logical or recognizable pick than another character.

 

[Cyn]

wait why? why can't it appear under all of my posts?

It is done to prevent page clutter and to avoid page load lag.

 

[Cosmic77]

Uhhh... that’s just not true lol Hitagi has definitely gotten things correct xd that’s a big assumption

Like what?

As of now, I haven't seen Hitagi do anything that convinces me he isn't just leeching off of Verge and spitting out whatever characters are mentioned by "inside sources" without seeing if it checks out with what other people have heard. All I have to go off of is, "So you know how I said we're getting Katalina and a first-party swordfighter? Yeah, that was all incorrect information. Sorry 'bout that," and that's not a strong first impression.

 

[PsySmasher]

no i think that it is cool that we got all of the vets back. it's kinda like a family reunion. plus, now we can see snake cloud and pichu and Krool in one game. i personally think its very hard to complain about that.

I'm not saying the prospect of "Everyone is Here" was a bad one.
The fact that we have all of the cut characters back is amazing (I'm personally looking forward to Wolf, Snake, Pichu, and Pokemon Trainer).
However, that did come with a cost: much fewer unique newcomers and ALMOST no new stages beyond the typical versions of BF, Big BF, and FD.
The newcomers they choose were VERY hit or miss with me. Echo fighters did help, but it didn't fix the problem for me.
The fact they brought back ALMOST ever stage is fantastic, but I don't like that it cost us all but 4 new stages.
So while I am happy with what we got, it's far from my perfect scenario.

 

[Nekoo]

Okay, I know this isn't the Chrom thread, but this is an important matter.
We need to talk about this.

nerf k rool up b

also nerf chrom hitboxes LMAO pic.twitter.com/jf3HHlUvVo

— james (@Rivers3k) November 28, 2018

Yeah...Did you see?

T H I S

Spoiler

HOLY MOLY THAT RANGE AND F-SMASH HITBOX

 

[Dyllybirdy]

Please try and ignore this post, to the best of your ability.

 

[praline]

Okay, I know this isn't the Chrom thread, but this is an important matter.
We need to talk about this.

nerf k rool up b

also nerf chrom hitboxes LMAO pic.twitter.com/jf3HHlUvVo

— james (@Rivers3k) November 28, 2018

Yeah...Did you see?

T H I S

Spoiler

View attachment 180459

HOLY MOLY THAT RANGE AND F-SMASH HITBOX

And here people were saying Chrom sucked?

 

[Deleted member]

Okay, I know this isn't the Chrom thread, but this is an important matter.
We need to talk about this.

nerf k rool up b

also nerf chrom hitboxes LMAO pic.twitter.com/jf3HHlUvVo

— james (@Rivers3k) November 28, 2018

Yeah...Did you see?

T H I S

Spoiler

View attachment 180459

HOLY MOLY THAT RANGE AND F-SMASH HITBOX

When I said Chrom was jank I didn’t mean like this.

 

[Kuon]

You'd be amazed. Chrono Trigger is a cult classic yeah, but it's still a relatively niche name. Geno was obscure yes, but you'd be amazed how many gaming fans know him nowadays just because of all the Smash Bros buzz surrounding him. In a general audience there's definitely a strong argument to be had for Crono, but when the target audience is Smash Bros players Geno has the edge over him easily. If Nintendo were specifically going to go for a niche "fan-favorite" character from Square Enix, Geno is definitely the right answer.

Spoiler

I'm not used to being able to talk about Geno as being a more logical or recognizable pick than another character.

I had never heard of Geno until just a few months ago, and I've known about SMRPG since the mid-2000s

 

[Cosmic77]

Okay, I know this isn't the Chrom thread, but this is an important matter.
We need to talk about this.

nerf k rool up b

also nerf chrom hitboxes LMAO pic.twitter.com/jf3HHlUvVo

— james (@Rivers3k) November 28, 2018

Yeah...Did you see?

T H I S

Spoiler

View attachment 180459

HOLY MOLY THAT RANGE AND F-SMASH HITBOX

Chrom's recovery is in a garbage tier of its own, so maybe he needs this.

 

[Galaxyman]

what if smash ultimate only had 12 characters?
my roster would be
1 mario
2 luigi
3 kirby
4 link
5 zelda
6 ganon
7 pikachu
8 mewtwo/pkmn trainer
9 DK
10 Krool
11 DeDeDe
12 kirby

 

[Dukeofdeath5]

Okay, I know this isn't the Chrom thread, but this is an important matter.
We need to talk about this.

nerf k rool up b

also nerf chrom hitboxes LMAO pic.twitter.com/jf3HHlUvVo

— james (@Rivers3k) November 28, 2018

Yeah...Did you see?

T H I S

Spoiler

View attachment 180459

HOLY MOLY THAT RANGE AND F-SMASH HITBOX

Chrom Marth best Marth

 

[RyuhoFox]

I find it weird how Hitagi finds Geno so unlikely because Nintendo is prioritizing profit and recognizability, but doesn’t say anything about Crono, who is pretty much just as niche and unknown to general audiences.

Crono is the main character of one of the most well known and influential RPGs out there, as well as being in the literal title of the game. To call Crono Trigger niche is kind of insane.

 

[Idon]

I feel like this is going to be a controversial opinion...

While “everyone is here!” Is really truly super cool...
Am I the only one who would’ve preferred that they didn’t spend time on cut veterans and instead spent time developing more “new” newcomers?

Dixie, Elma, banjo, Geno, BWD and others(in my head) would’ve appealed to me much much more.

Nevertheless, I’m still super excited and I am happy that Pokémon trainer and Pichu are back

Absolutely not.
Honestly, I feel like Everyone Is Here sets up a really bad precedent for bringing back everything regardless of quality at the expense of newer content.

 

[lightdrago]

Chrom's recovery is in a garbage tier of its own, so maybe he needs this.

Unpopular opinion:

People exaggerate how bad Chrom’s recovery is. :v

 

[Deleted member]

what if smash ultimate only had 12 characters?
my roster would be
1 mario
2 luigi
3 kirby
4 link
5 zelda
6 ganon
7 pikachu
8 mewtwo/pkmn trainer
9 DK
10 Krool
12 kirby

Mario
Kirby
Pikachu
Link
Donkey Kong
Samus
Yoshi
Fox
Jigglypuff
Ness
Luigi
Captain Falcon

 

[Kuon]

what if smash ultimate only had 12 characters?
my roster would be
1 mario
2 luigi
3 kirby
4 link
5 zelda
6 ganon
7 pikachu
8 mewtwo/pkmn trainer
9 DK
10 Krool
11 DeDeDe
12 kirby

Is that your wish roster or is that the roster that seems the most accurate to you?

 

[ClaTheBae]

And here people were saying Chrom sucked?

his recovery sucks. losing a stock every time you're thrown off stage is a big deal.

 

[Untouch]

Okay, I know this isn't the Chrom thread, but this is an important matter.
We need to talk about this.

nerf k rool up b

also nerf chrom hitboxes LMAO pic.twitter.com/jf3HHlUvVo

— james (@Rivers3k) November 28, 2018

Yeah...Did you see?

T H I S

Spoiler

View attachment 180459

HOLY MOLY THAT RANGE AND F-SMASH HITBOX

I hope stuff like this isn't fixed.
Smash is better with jank like this, Smash 4 trying to sterilize everything like this made a lot of characters play so similar.

 

[Galaxyman]

Mario
Kirby
Pikachu
Link
Donkey Kong
Samus
Yoshi
Fox
Jigglypuff
Ness
Luigi
Captain Falcon

i see, taking the EASY way out huh?

 

[Ezclapper]

Like what?

As of now, I haven't seen Hitagi do anything that convinces me he isn't just leeching off of Verge and spitting out whatever characters are mentioned by "inside sources" without seeing if it checks out with what other people have heard. All I have to go off of is, "So you know how I said we're getting Katalina and a first-party swordfighter? Yeah, that was all incorrect information. Sorry 'bout that," and that's not a strong first impression.

So, you just think that verge started talking to hitagi for no reason? That’s what you are implying if you say he’s just piggybacking off what he says. I’m not saying hitagi is right, but verge can be just as wrong as him. The fact that verge and him discussed the SE character just shows that he’s definitely legit.

 

[Nekoo]

his recovery sucks. losing a stock every time you're thrown off stage is a big deal.

I mean, apparently, literally everyone who's not K.Rool/Bayonetta/Inkling/Snake/Sonic/Ike got their recovery nerfed to oblivion.

Especially Diddy, sure he have monkey flip.
But jesus that UP-B range nerf was unecessary.

 

[Deleted member]

i see, taking the EASY way out huh?

Yes I am taking the easy way out thanks for noticing

 

[Idon]

Yeah OK, so KRool has this **** and Ganondorf isn't allowed to hover a bit?
Please.

 

[Blargg888]

Just got the news that Backslash snaps to ledge now.

Life is good.

 

[ClaTheBae]

I mean, apparently, literally everyone who's not K.Rool/Bayonetta/Inkling/Snake/Sonic/Ike got their recovery nerfed to oblivion.

Especially Diddy, sure he have monkey flip.
But jesus that UP-B range nerf was unecessary.

Yes but chrom is bad because he has one option to recover, and it has a lot of lag, and it doesn't go very far

also, snake is very easy to hit out of his up b

 

[prowler12]

what if smash ultimate only had 12 characters?
my roster would be
1 mario
2 luigi
3 kirby
4 link
5 zelda
6 ganon
7 pikachu
8 mewtwo/pkmn trainer
9 DK
10 Krool
11 DeDeDe
12 kirby

why is Kirby on there Twice.
My list would be

Spoiler: Long List

1. Marth
2. Roy
3.Ike
4.Robin
5.Corrin
6. Lucina
7.Chrom
8.Lyn
9.Black knight
10.Hector
11.Walhart
12.Duck hunt duo

 

[Opossum]

hey who is your least favorite character to play as and to fight in ultimate

Historically I've hated playing Sonic, Sheik, Diddy, and Pit/Dark Pit, so that'll probably stay the same in Ultimate.

 

[PsySmasher]

And here people were saying Chrom sucked?

Have you seen his recovery?
I mean I play a lot of characters w/ bad recovery and trust me it's really bad.

 

[Idon]

Just got the news that Backslash snaps to ledge now.

Life is good.

... but backslashing to recover in general sounds like a preeeeeetty bad idea.

 

[TheCJBrine]

Um, well, speaking of PolarPanda...

Now, I don't believe this at all, really, but I thought it may be of interest, to some...

I'd believe it; Panda also said the Mii Costume was compensation for fans, and that NoA didn't expect the backlash.

I also believe it because of how their ears were so deaf that they didn't realize people wanted K. Rool until the Ballot; apparently they didn't realize it about Isaac, though, and maybe Geno if he gets the same fate pls no.


edit: Also, Nintendo being surprised by the backlash may be good news. If Isaac fans keep pushing, maybe they'll include him in the next Smash, or even better, make Camelot develop a new Golden Sun game.

 

[Untouch]

K Rool's absurd recovery seems like it'll be easy to deal with, they just need to drastically reduce the knockback it deals.

 

[The DanMan051]

Like what?

As of now, I haven't seen Hitagi do anything that convinces me he isn't just leeching off of Verge and spitting out whatever characters are mentioned by "inside sources" without seeing if it checks out with what other people have heard. All I have to go off of is, "So you know how I said we're getting Katalina and a first-party swordfighter? Yeah, that was all incorrect information. Sorry 'bout that," and that's not a strong first impression.

He predicted the new Samurai Shodown game and details about and SNK Heroines' DLC.

Only things he's gotten right so far, and both have to do with SNK.

 

[Nekoo]

I hope stuff like this isn't fixed.
Smash is better with jank like this, Smash 4 trying to sterilize everything like this made a lot of characters play so similar.

Seems that Roy have the same things, being able to touch under platform alongside even Jab and F-tilt but Roy have a sourspot, so it wouldn't have done anything.
Seems like some jank leftover when they just took Roy and launched ChromCoatPaint.EXE and forgot to change it.

But you know what?

I love it, and hope it stays just like you said.

 

[Galaxyman]

why is Kirby on there Twice

o crap put bowser there instead...

 

[ClaTheBae]

Historically I've hated playing Sonic, Sheik, Diddy

ah a fellow hater of top 5 characters I see. Good taste comrade

 

[praline]

Have you seen his recovery?
I mean I play a lot of characters w/ bad recovery and trust me it's really bad.

Well it doesn’t matter if the recovery is bad if you never leave the stage.

 

[Nekoo]

Well it doesn’t matter if the recovery is bad if you never leave the stage.

Literally every Cloud main ever when Limitless.

 

[Idon]

Well it doesn’t matter if the recovery is bad if you never leave the stage.

Little Mac, how are you typing this with your boxing gloves on?