- True, but just because one fights closer to Shulk doesn't mean the other is automatically less likely. If Sakurai feels like he could make something unique out of Rex, he'd still add him, regardless of whether or not his weapon is similar to an existing character.
Very true. However, it is certainly a point in Elma's favor to have a more distinct fighting style.
- That was almost a year after the Switch's release. Those comments came out a little late to influence who gets in Smash. On top of that, a port isn't even confirmed yet. For now, a XCX port is just an idea.
- Even if a sequel is being considered, that's gonna be way down the line. Back then, ideas for a possible sequel to XCX shouldn't have taken the focus away from XC2, a game that was already far in production.
Both extremely fair points. The main reason I bring those points up is that the planned continuation of the X series could be a reason for the director to recommend Elma before Rex, even if Sakurai was not given knowledge of that ahead of time.
- That's not really a solid reason to include a character. Besides, I could just as easily argue that a XCX character is unlikely because it's passed off as a different entity from other Xenoblade games.
Why not? We've had characters added to represent different aspects of a single series before, like Robin being added to represent magic in the Fire Emblem series and Toon Link being added to showcase the Toon branch of the Legend of Zelda. I posit that Elma would better represent the sci-fi side of the series and the variance of weapons in both games.
- ...Without trying to sound mean or dismissive towards the idea, adding a character simply because you want someone of a certain gender or color is bad way to look at things. I get that this isn't your primary reason for wanting her and that this would be more of a bonus of sorts, but this really shouldn't be how Sakurai chooses characters over others.
Again, I feel like this boils down to how a person looks at the situation. The argument is pretty even for both characters.
Of course, that isn't my primary reason, but given how many female characters were added in the previous game, I think it's fair to bring it up as a possible point in her favor. Sakurai does not choose characters exclusively to add someone of a certain gender or race, but I think it's fair to say he acknowledges that there's a demand for variety there.
And.. what about Rex?
I have said this before and this idea isn't far fetched
Rex can be similar to Pokemon Trainer, where he goes in not only with Pyra, but also other Blades with different weapons... Rex will have the Blade switch icon on his damage meter (Like Shulk has Monado art displayed on the Wii U version) , switching to Pyra and Mythra won't have cool down and his moveset won't, but he will only have his final Smash changed... whereas switching to other Blades not only result a cool down, but also change his moveset and specials entirely...
In XC2, you basically will have different types of Blades with different weapons... Katana, Knuckle Claws, Cannon, and Bitball... I think Rex can have Katana and Cannon Blades as other options (Since you can only bring 3 Blades)...
And they can add option where you can choose Rex only goes with either 1 Blade (Pyra/Mythra), or 2, or 3... again, just like in his original game. You can already change which Pokemon you go first in Brawl with Pokemon Trainer, so I don't think this is that much f a stretch...
The only problem is just how will Rex change his Blades....
So, Elma having two swords and guns, cool, but Rex also has the possibility of having more diversity as well in my opinion.
While this is a possibility, keep in mind that the reason Pokemon Trainer was cut was likely because of how much development time he took with his three movesets. If Rex does the same thing, then that's a lot of resources to put into a single character. I could see him switching blades for his specials and immediately switching back to Pyra, but that's less interesting than a moveset with a 100% unique type of weapon style.
Mind, I have played both games and have put 130 hours into XC2, so I'm not against Rex whatsoever. I enjoy him as a character and thought the game was fantastic. However, with how recent he is and with how easily Elma would be unique, I simply consider her more likely.
Not officially...ok? And whoa there, look, XCX is by far my most requested Wii U port.
Takahashi want XCX come to Wii U doesn't mean he will have the chance to do so, hope he does eventually.
Again mate.... no confirmation of XCX port or sequel as of yet...
This is a way too much an assumption...
My point is less that those are confirmed and more that the director has the game and the X branch of the series on his mind. That's significant in my eyes, since Sakurai tends to ask directors about their thoughts on characters.
Actually a fair point if I do say so myself, but the biggest feature of X is well... the skells. How will Skells be put in Smash without being OP? Maybe as her Final Smash will do the trick. Where she goes into the Skell and go cockpit mode, similar to Zero Suit Samus' Final Smash
I think you answered your own question, mate.
Please don't bring up skin color my friend at least when it comes to video games....
This has no benefit of explaining her possibility to be in Smash....
Still um... what about the Inklings? Maybe they will have palette swaps where they not only change their ink color but also their skin color.... but still... you know what I mean.
Again, I don't think it's the deciding factor, but I think it only has the potential to help the character, not hurt her.
And I'm nearly positive that's going to be an option for the Inklings. I mean, we have skin/hair color options in Mario Kart for the Inklings already, so I'd be surprised to not see that in Smash.
Moreover thoughts... I think core crystals from XC2 can also be a new assist item as well.
That'd be a dream come true. It's probably the best way to represent the blades in Smash, in my opinion.
I think we’re at a point where people expect more of an effort on that front. There are many people that care and I think it’s something that should be taken into account. But you’re right that’s not the main point of this discussion I just wanted to clarify that.
This is essentially my perspective.
Sorry for the long post.
