bubbaking
Smash Hero
I wasn't actually talking about you. I was talking about the ones you refer to who "are more familiar with the Marth matchup" but might have trouble with Roy. I can see what you're saying. For me, the biggest difference between the two (that favors Roy) is how they recover. Roy's upB seems to have a much more protective hitbox and its KB is more appreciable. I know Roy is lighter, falls faster, and gains much less vertical distance with his recovery, but the horizontal distance gained can surprise someone, especially since it can be varied, and I find it a lot harder to deal with Roy's recovery when he's actually in a position to recover.