Smash Bros. Mafia - OVER! Who lived happily ever after in the Subspace Emissary?

[Clownbot]

Vote ChibiCat

 

[Clownbot]

EBWOP:

Unvote, Vote ChibiCat

 

[Deleted member]

A replacement on Day 4 really? A modkill is much more appropriate tbh. Now we have to wait for Sephiroth to catch up on almost SIXTY pages of game before we can essentially "continue." It's not that I'm for a modkill per se, but this is going to make the game stall even more -_-

that doesn't make sense.
with this being a kind of inactive game he has all the time in the world catching up.
FoS: Chibi
for rather losing a townie to a modkill than having to work for it.

 

[Clownbot]

TPK, who do you think are the last two scum?

Spoiler

Please please please please please answer this question. I'm fed up with not getting answers which is just one of the reasons for me voting Chibi.

 

[Deleted member]

If you held a gun to my head and asked, I'd say Vrael and chibi/MK.
But as I said I'm really unsure. that's why I also listed 2 seconds.

 

[Sephiroths Masamune]

A replacement on Day 4 really? A modkill is much more appropriate tbh. Now we have to wait for Sephiroth to catch up on almost SIXTY pages of game before we can essentially "continue." It's not that I'm for a modkill per se, but this is going to make the game stall even more -_-

I'm on page 33 and I've been on SWF for only about 2 hours since the maintenance cut down my time. BTW I've come up with a few suspicions already.

FoS Vrael.

 

[Sephiroths Masamune]

EBWOP: FoS Vrael

 

[SwordsRbroken]

Chibicat(1): Clownbot
Vrael(2): Meta-kirby, Chibicat

Vrael & meta-kirby get a prod.

Deadline is extended to April 25 Noon.

 

[¯\_S.(ツ).L.I.D._/¯]

Why did I get a prod? I posted yesterday morning, less than 24 hours ago.

Sep, what's your reasoning on that? Spewing out random FoS's is a good way to look like scum.

 

[M.K]

I feel like Kirbyo is scum.
It's between Kirbyo, Vrael...and some other that pushed for a No Lynch, which I still feel is a pretty dumb move.

 

[Sephiroths Masamune]

Why did I get a prod? I posted yesterday morning, less than 24 hours ago.

Sep, what's your reasoning on that? Spewing out random FoS's is a good way to look like scum.

It's not random it's based on facts which I will post when I'm done reading the thread. It's just a FoS not a vote as you can see I'm on the fence with you. I will base my vote after I've read the entire thread so I won't make a faulty decision.

 

[Clownbot]

Deadline extension? Arghhhhhhhhhhhhhh.

MK, do you think Chibi is town now then?

 

[ChibiCat]

Page 33 already? I take back what I said lol, good stuff

 

[Clownbot]

Oh yeah, and I was the one who was pushing for a No Lynch.

I actually think Chibi is a pretty viable lynch now though.

 

[ChibiCat]

Can we at least extend it to be like 9pm or 11:59pm on the 25th? I'm sure a lot of people have things to do on Saturday (like I'm hosting a tourney), so activity won't be high then, so give us a good amount of Sunday to wrap up this day, especially with the new player. Noon is pretty early, esp considering thats 9am for west coast. I also wouldn't be opposed to Monday.

 

[¯\_S.(ツ).L.I.D._/¯]

I agree with Chibi. I'm pretty sure I won't be able to be on for the beginning of Saturday, but if we can extend it to the evening it would be great.

Sep, the fact that you FoS'ed before providing evidence is what got to me. Also, have you played Mafia before?

 

[ChibiCat]

He said he would post his facts when he's done reading in post 891

 

[¯\_S.(ツ).L.I.D._/¯]

Yes I know, that's the post I was responding to. Nevermind.

 

[Sephiroths Masamune]

I agree with Chibi. I'm pretty sure I won't be able to be on for the beginning of Saturday, but if we can extend it to the evening it would be great.

Sep, the fact that you FoS'ed before providing evidence is what got to me. Also, have you played Mafia before?

I am now officially caught up. No applause are needed. *jokes* But enough with the crap.

To answer your question, no I haven't. But reading all the post in this thread within the past few days, I think I'm more than ready to play.

Now on to more serious business.

vote: fatchu

@Bunglefever: I really don't think Meta-Knight deserve an FoS at all. I see nothing that is worth trying to lynch him. While he has been relatively silent until yesterday, he has made some very good counterattack and criticism at me which I really do deserve.

I'll read from the end of the Ryker Vs. Vreal arguement to right now to see what I can find that can cause any suspicion. If I can't find anything, I'll just try to continue from there as much as possible.

Meta-Kirby, don't you think it's odd that he doesn't complain that you wanted to kill him? It sounds like you two are scum buddies.

If there is anything I don't want in this game, it's to be grouped with SSBF. TBH, not only do I really not like his way of posting, but I don't really think he's beneficial to town. That last thing towards Fatchu on D1 was incredibly harsh, and although it was TRUE, its not neccesary to be that harsh.
Plus, the fact that his EARLY Fatchu lynch attempt was like.....45,000 scum points,

I'm going to have to:

Unvote Vote: SSBF until you can prove to me why you tried to lynch Fatchu so early, and why you are dismissing others so quickly, saying things like "It's sad to say that ChibiCat won't be active for D2, oh well, MORE ACTIVITY PLEASE". I don't like that; activity police AND presumptuous? No thanks.

It looks like your trying to hard, and that you have too much of a loose end on your hands and you want to tie it up. This here, and the fact that you were too harsh on SSBF when he vote killed himself, seemed to me you again were trying to hard.

Meta-Kirby you are scum. Vote: Meta-Kirby

Based off of this, I don't like how friendly Clownbot has been to Meta-Kirby

making Clownbot my #3 suspect. FoS Clownbot

And finally as I make my final statement. We all know that SSBF was scum.

I've went back and read Day 2 as I promised.

So anyway, it looks like it's finally time to answer my own question I posted earlier.

There are three Mafia members running around, so there are three possible candidates. Right now, however, I can only find two who have leads of being scums. They are The Paprika Killer and Nicholas1024.

1. Nicholas1024

Whlie Nicholas has apoligized for his quick claim, he has so far failed to back up his excuses for them that was directed at Rockin and give reasons why he was basically parroting other people during Day 1.

2. The Paprika Killer

He is currently my top suspect in this case. He has made little significant posts in this game aside from pushing a case on me on Day 2, plus he sometimes shows questionable grammers. He's also basically been skimming the game until Day 2, giving an poor excuse that he basically lurks around until Day 2 or 3 due to lack of activity (Prehaps he's been in the wrong games?). Because of that, during those past game, he has been helping in decreasing activity in those previous games as well. Now I understand that we don't always get a lot of information on Day 1, but I have noticed this as an exception to the rules, so his excuse is especially invalid.

I'll be placing a Vote: The Paprika Killer for now. As for Nicholas, FomS (Fingers of Minor Susipicon): Nicholas1024

I think this proves that TPK is town. Based on the fact that SSBF was a horrible player and that we all know Nicholas1024 is also town. I do realize the fact that TPK could me scum and SSBF was just Voting on PTK just as Meta-Kirby did to SSBF earlier in the game. But as I stated before SSBF was a horrible player.

 

[Sephiroths Masamune]

EBWOP: under Now on to more serious business. vote fatchu was supposed to be in the quote of Vrael.

 

[M.K]

Oh my god, you can't be serious. xD You're basing your entire case on the fact that I was SO mean that it makes me his partner? I'm sorry, your case is not valid enough for me to retort properly. Do you forget all the "suspicioun" that SSBF had towards me as well? LOL this is Confirmation bias at it's best: looking solely for information that supports your point. I can pick and choose all the words I want as well.

Actually, I thought Kirbyo was scum so:

Unvote: Vote: Sephiroth's Masamune

ololololol You are trying WAY TOO HARD to frame the wrong person and it's kinda obvious.
Anyone who has problems with me can bring me to L-1 for a claim if you are just THAT desperate to get votes in. There is obviously a balance here that will easily be exposed if I flip town. Kirbyo was laying low because he was scum; sorry Seph, you just inherited a scum role and now you're just gonna target town 1 by 1.

 

[Clownbot]

]Based off of this, I don't like how friendly Clownbot has been to Meta-Kirby

making Clownbot my #3 suspect. FoS Clownbot

Would you mind pointing me to where I've done this?

 

[Sephiroths Masamune]

Oh my god, you can't be serious. xD You're basing your entire case on the fact that I was SO mean that it makes me his partner? I'm sorry, your case is not valid enough for me to retort properly. Do you forget all the "suspicioun" that SSBF had towards me as well? LOL this is Confirmation bias at it's best: looking solely for information that supports your point. I can pick and choose all the words I want as well.

Actually, I thought Kirbyo was scum so:

Unvote: Vote: Sephiroth's Masamune

ololololol You are trying WAY TOO HARD to frame the wrong person and it's kinda obvious.
Anyone who has problems with me can bring me to L-1 for a claim if you are just THAT desperate to get votes in. There is obviously a balance here that will easily be exposed if I flip town. Kirbyo was laying low because he was scum; sorry Seph, you just inherited a scum role and now you're just gonna target town 1 by 1.

Hardly, why would I target town 1 by 1 if there is only 1 lynch = mafia win. although this is irrelevant.

You've just proven how guilty you are by posting in such of an aggressive manor, you also have change your vote just because I have voted for you, there is no reason or evidence other than that. Meta-Kirby I ask you for a better argument than that.

Would you mind pointing me to where I've done this?

They were subtle, and I've just read through an entire thread which makes me reluctant to reread posts without a search. Your not too much of a suspect, but your on the list.

 

[Clownbot]

Why is being aggressive a scumtell? Ryker was fairly aggressive during some of the time he was alive and was town.

 

[Sephiroths Masamune]

When a tiger is cornered that's when he becomes most ferocious. AKA when scum get cornered he shows his true colors. Although aggression doesn't necessarily mean your scum, it does make you seem so.

Meta-Kirby is over reacting and trying to hard. It's not like my word is law, you all have your freedom of choice. You can believe me or not.

 

[¯\_S.(ツ).L.I.D._/¯]

Sounds to me once the pressure was off you decided to jump on the closest wagon you could find, and left so you could stall for time while you could came up with a good enough reason to vote for Fatchu.

Umm no? I would have voted Fatchu had no one else voted for him. He didn't do anything to help the game, and at that point I felt like he needed to die.

Seems to be a poor excuse for not posting, and why didn't you post something about leaving town before hand? That would be important information the for the whole group. Maybe you were afraid that if you could type that you were leaving town they would give you crap about not posting your reason. Which you might not have had.

You're honestly bringing this up? I was at a Mock Trial tournament down in Springfield, IL. I find it hard to take you seriously if you're basing suspicion on that. My phone post pretty much summed up that I was out of town, I assumed people would realize that I wouldn't be able to post since I wasn't on my computer.

And furthermore Ryker died the next day. the day after he started to pressure you. On that day, the first thing you said was, "I was framed!" Which, could be a possibility because, Ryker was the most (in my opinion anyways) strongest town member. He knew how to apply pressure and who to lay it on. Although this could likely be all coincidence.

Point being?

You also push the hammer on another town member which is highly suspicious. It's more or less a copy of what SSBF did to Fatchu. Except this time, they were hammered.

SSBF hammered Fatchu out of nowhere. I was in a difficult situation. Rockin looked scummy to me, and I had an hour to decide whether or not to kill him. I screwed up, I know.

Overall, you're either basing suspicion on random things with bad evidence (regarding me and MK), or bringing up things that others have already said and have been resolved.

FoS: Masamume

 

[¯\_S.(ツ).L.I.D._/¯]

When a tiger is cornered that's when he becomes most ferocious. AKA when scum get cornered he shows his true colors. Although aggression doesn't necessarily mean your scum, it does make you seem so.

Meta was never put into a corner, he simply plays aggressively. You can't blame someone for their playstyle.

 

[Clownbot]

Chibi, what did you think of Kirby pre-replacement and what's your take on Sephiroth's stances?

Your latest posts really don't do much to progress the game. You seem like you're trying to look concerned by asking for deadline extensions and everything but it doesn't look like you're really trying yourself to stir up any discussion.

 

[Sephiroths Masamune]

Point being?

As stated before, (i don't remember exactly who). Killing the person that is most suspecting you than saying I was framed is a common tactic within mafia.

SSBF hammered Fatchu out of nowhere. I was in a difficult situation. Rockin looked scummy to me, and I had an hour to decide whether or not to kill him. I screwed up, I know.

Good point, you were under pressure but if you didn't think that said person was scum Don't vote! Instead of the mafia gaining one kill they get two!

Overall, you're either basing suspicion on random things with bad evidence (regarding me and MK), or bringing up things that others have already said and have been resolved.

FoS: Masamume

If what your saying is true why did I see not too long ago, the same points being brought up? These were the things that stuck out most to me, and reading the thread with updated information is probably the best way of doing it. I payed more attention to the posts from SSBF, because I had the information that he was scum. That is why I based my opinion of MK.

 

[Clownbot]

Rockin looked scummy to me

if you didn't think that said person was scum Don't vote!

Ahem .

 

[Sephiroths Masamune]

^doesn't change the difference that he hammered a townie.

 

[Clownbot]

So if you were in Vrael's situation you would have let the Day pass without a lynch? Even if you thought Rockin was being scummy? (yes, I know I was pushing for a No Lynch earlier toDay. Back then I didn't really feel like I had sufficient enough evidence for us to hit a scum but I'm confident in my thoughts now.)

 

[Sephiroths Masamune]

Yes and No, Yes if I thought that said person was scum. But no because I not once felt a scumy vibe coming from Rockin, nor did I even see a good reason for all of you voting him off, there was no cause. I say the whole thing was a lack in co-operation and discussion.

 

[Sephiroths Masamune]

Clownbot who do you think is scum?

 

[Sephiroths Masamune]

EBWOP: Also, do you agree with any/if all the information I have given?

 

[¯\_S.(ツ).L.I.D._/¯]

Yes and No, Yes if I thought that said person was scum. But no because I not once felt a scumy vibe coming from Rockin, nor did I even see a good reason for all of you voting him off, there was no cause. I say the whole thing was a lack in co-operation and discussion.

In my opinion, there was. So I voted.

Forget for a moment that you don't think Rockin was suspicious. If you did think he was suspicious, and you were in my situation, what would you have done?

Also, how many games have you played? I asked you this earlier and you didn't answer.

 

[¯\_S.(ツ).L.I.D._/¯]

Oh wait, you did answer. My baaaaaaaaaaaad.

Killing the person that is most suspecting you than saying I was framed is a common tactic within mafia.

Wait, so since you haven't played Mafia before, how would you know this? Making up stuff is also a good way to make yourself look like scum.

 

[Sephiroths Masamune]

As far as the Vrael wagon goes... I don't think Ryker really thought him suspicious at the end of the day. His Vrael wagon early in the day was to get us out of the RVS, and it did that quite well. However, one thing that I don't like about him is part of his response to the wagon.



I don't like the way he's throwing suspicion at everyone who's voting him. It reminds me way too much of what I did back in Ronike's test subject mafia. N1 I had killed the person most suspicious of me (I was basically the SK, it was my second game and first as anti-town), and when D2 came around, I successfully argued that mafia was trying to frame me and lynched one of the townies that had pushed a case on me at the beginning of the day.

This is where I get that info Vrael

 

[Sephiroths Masamune]

In my opinion, there was. So I voted.

Forget for a moment that you don't think Rockin was suspicious. If you did think he was suspicious, and you were in my situation, what would you have done?

Also, how many games have you played? I asked you this earlier and you didn't answer.

Ok I'll put your question into terms of now. As of right now I'd hammer MK if the dead line was approaching and there was no time for a claim. But, I would be reluctant to hammer you or clownbot because I'm only suspicious of you two.

 

[Deleted member]

giving an example doesn't make it common tactic.