Smash Bros. Mafia - OVER! Who lived happily ever after in the Subspace Emissary?

[SwordsRbroken]

Don't turn this into an argument.

 

[M.K]

It's only one prod Paprika. Chill, I got one too.
Truly this game has stagnated. It's pretty hard to generate discussion. I know I promised those ChibiCat quotes, but failboard crashed as I started to compile them, so I lost all my info. X( I'll try to go back and look for specifics again later.

 

[Kirbyoshi]

Sigh. Crashboards is giving scum such good reasons to coast.

I'd like to see a case on Rockin if at all possible. He's been very protown this game imo.

 

[Clownbot]

I don't necessarily have a case on Rockin but I'm keeping my vote on him because he still has yet to reply to my request even though SWF is working fine now (and was at the time of Rockin's post complaining about it >_>).

Speaking of which, Swords, has a new deadline been decided yet since SWF is up and running alright now?

 

[ChibiCat]

Mkay, Crashboards seems to somewhat be over and I'm back from vacation and somewhat done moving, so I should be fine to post tonight when I read up on what I've missed.

 

[Kirbyoshi]

Crashboards did crash for a short time today, just to let everyone know.

 

[Kirbyoshi]

EBWOP:...who didn't already know that.

 

[SwordsRbroken]

Vote Count

Rockin(2): Clownbot, Junglefever
PaprikaKiller(2): Kirbyoshi, Rockin
Chibicat(1): Meta-kirby

With 9 alive it takes 5 to lynch!

Prodded vrael and Rockin.

Deadline is April 11 Noon EST.
​

 

[DtJ Jungle]

Soo, Rockin, what's up bruddah?

 

[Clownbot]

It'd be sort of nice if we could come to a majority decision on a lynch before too long.

Lynch candidates, everyone? I think Rockin or Chibi can go toDay.

 

[Kirbyoshi]

Awesome Clownbot, cuz I'm thinkin' PK or MK I have yet to see any valid arguments against either Rockin or ChibiCat.

 

[Clownbot]

What legitimate case is there on MK? 9_9

 

[Clownbot]

Also, what do you think about how SSBF acted about Chibi?

 

[ChibiCat]

Wow I forgot about this lol, lemme read back on the last few pages.

 

[Kirbyoshi]

Also, what do you think about how SSBF acted about Chibi?

Null.

The case on MK has been building almost all game long. Not gonna take the time to dig everything up now, as I'm about to head to bed, but there has been good suspicion being put on him throughout the game.

 

[ChibiCat]

Ouch, seems that this game has quieted down a bit.

Chibi, what do you think about MK's suspicion? Is it legit and if not then why? Why should we think you're town and who should be put before you as far as the lynchee goes?

I don't think much of it really. Smash Fan is a very new player here (isn't this his first game?) and his posting style really showed it. When I first read through it all and thought about it to myself, it sounded like he was just legit wondering where I was. Later on in the game he was a ***** more... uhh, aggressive I suppose against other players who were sort of lying low or just in general acting on what he thought was scum tells, but I'm thinking his change of pace was after my first couple huge posts with the point system since he wasn't looking so well iirc.

---

I'm still inclined to go for either Clownbot, Rockin, Bungle, or Vrael based on the vote count for the end of D2. This day has been sort of lacking (not to say I didn't contribute to it as much as I would not like to, not to mention the advent of crashboards :/) and I feel that I have to sort of fall back on logic here at this point. The curve ball of Smash Fan self hammering is so confusing I can't see it as a convoluted scum bus plot. While I'm not saying a scummy wasnt on his wagon for sure with how fast everything took place, chances are both aren't on there imo, and especially if we go for a lynch pool of people not on it compared to those on it, were increasing our chances of nailing scum by looking between 4 people instead of 5.

Vrael has me thinking after all the D1 shenanigans. I don't feel anything about about Rockin or Clownbot. Kind of neutral on Bungle, but the more I think about it I'm feelin a Vrael lynch.

Vote Vrael

 

[¯\_S.(ツ).L.I.D._/¯]

kirbyoshi, your last post says nothing about why MK should be lynched. you just said "oh he's been suspicious all game" (which isnt even really true) without evidence. i know you said youd dig up stuff later, but at least provide a basis for why hes suspicious.

 

[Deleted member]

Alright look, we have till April 6 to do something here. That's the deadline for D3

right now

vote: The Paprika Killer

I'm willing to lynch off The Paprika Killer. Clownbot is also an option. Maybe Bunglefever, but meh.

I feel he's fine in my book. I havn't seem him done anything scummy, and he has been fairly contributive in throughout the days.

Also, I'm debating on having Meta Kirby as another lynch option (over Bunglefever). Mainly for the grounds of how emotional he was towards SSBF. I know the AtE is bad in regards to using it as a case, but still...

These were the last two posts of rockin (he also made 2 comments on chrashboards which don't count towards the game), and he has basically given no reason whatsoever on why to lynch either of the people he mentioned and just put a vote on me for the heck of it. already told him but he isn't responding.

Rockin can go.

Vote: Rockin

 

[DtJ Jungle]

Chibo i missed all of day 2, in case you forgot, that's why my vote wasn't anywhere.

 

[M.K]

Unvote Vote Rockin

Chibi, I'm still suspicious of you. I don't really agree with the way you just brush off my claim (which I completely think is because nobody else has made mention or supported it, making it easier for you to avoid talking about it) but I do think what you said is true.
Paprika, I think you are town. I'm going to go ahead and agree with your stance. The fact that he considered me a lynch suspect for calling out SSBF on his failure of a quitstyle isn't even a legitamate case.

 

[Rockin]

Well, with smashboards behaving a bit (well, it was acting up in the morning time), I can start posting as well as telling up my reasons.

Post is coming soon. sorry for being inactive. It's slightly difficult to play when smashboards site keeps coming down.

 

[¯\_S.(ツ).L.I.D._/¯]

I'm still inclined to go for either Clownbot, Rockin, Bungle, or Vrael based on the vote count for the end of D2. This day has been sort of lacking (not to say I didn't contribute to it as much as I would not like to, not to mention the advent of crashboards :/) and I feel that I have to sort of fall back on logic here at this point. The curve ball of Smash Fan self hammering is so confusing I can't see it as a convoluted scum bus plot. While I'm not saying a scummy wasnt on his wagon for sure with how fast everything took place, chances are both aren't on there imo, and especially if we go for a lynch pool of people not on it compared to those on it, were increasing our chances of nailing scum by looking between 4 people instead of 5.

Vrael has me thinking after all the D1 shenanigans. I don't feel anything about about Rockin or Clownbot. Kind of neutral on Bungle, but the more I think about it I'm feelin a Vrael lynch.

Vote Vrael

Day 1 shenanigans? With Ryker? I was angry at him for posting "Vrael dead yet?" like 4 times, voting for me 8 posts in a row, and providing absolutely no reasoning for why I should be lynched.

I find it interesting that I was framed (presumably) by scum so that I would seem scummy when Ryker was NK'ed during N1, and that you are bringing that up now. Coincidence? I think not.

Vote: Chibicat

 

[Clownbot]

Vrael or Chibi, would you be willing to switch your vote to Rockin if the situation demanded it?

At this point it really looks either like him or a No Lynch and the deadline is getting very close.

 

[Rockin]

smashboards was acting a bit funny today, so I couldn't look like I wanted to.

I guess I could just post now and maybe TRY to do the other part tomorrow morning/afternoon before I go to work.

*ahem*

The thing is throughout D1, both Paprika and Meta-Kirby have done semi poorly. MK was mainly just around when Fatchu was getting pressured while Paprika was both fencesitting and wasn't contributing too much.

I'm sorry, I just find that this little discussion between Vrael and Ryker has gotten almost nowhere, and it's pretty impossible to chime in because they are so headstrong on their positions.

V_V

This post was made before the big Fatchu pressure, to which I then ask him if he couldn't contribute that way, then to go and find somewhere else to maybe question. There wasn't a post from him till the near beginning of the **** storm with Fatchu

bad reasoning is bad. even a child know you can't play the "but he did it too" card.
FoS: Fatchu.

and rocket said he had tests, which is btw one of the very few legit reasons for me to be okay with someone being absent.

Here's paprika semi fencesitting. Notice that he just put a FOS on fatchu...

Not quite liking how you only FoS Fatchu instead of voting him when you didn't have a vote on anyone else, Paprika Killer.

what is the problem with only placing an FoS?

You said that his posting was bad. You don't seem to find anyone else scummier. Do you just not think he's suspicious enough to warrant a real vote? If so, why? Is there anything on the other side of the argument you disagree with?

oh, like that. not really used to dropping a vote directly if someone does something moderately bad.

but yeah
Vote: Fatchu

...till someone had to put a bit of pressure.

I'm assuming Paprika did this so as to make sure he's on good terms with town, and not try anything risky like lead or make strong contribution, to which might blow up in his face. If you look a page or two back, he didn't even vote on me, nor FOSed me or Kirbyoshi, yet decides to vote as time seems near on me.

While also reading back, I'm not much up for lynching clownbot anymore, but my point still stands for both Paprika and MK.

Again, I'm sorry for being so inactive. x.x;;

 

[Deleted member]

It also might be true that I'm not used to throwing aound for the heck of it. before I came to SWF for mafia (aka on SmashNL), I only voted when I was pretty sure I wasn't gonna swap around anymore.

 

[SwordsRbroken]

Vote Count

Rockin(4): Clownbot, Junglefever, TPK, Meta-kirby
ThePaprikaKiller(2): Kirbyoshi, Rockin
Chibicat(1): Vrael
Vrael(1): Chibicat

With 9 alive it takes 5 to lynch!

Great activity guys, this game is finally picking up steam.

Deadline is April 11 Noon EST.
​

 

[¯\_S.(ツ).L.I.D._/¯]

Vrael or Chibi, would you be willing to switch your vote to Rockin if the situation demanded it?

At this point it really looks either like him or a No Lynch and the deadline is getting very close.

What do you mean by "if the situation demanded it?" Like if he was at L-1 or something? If there was a strong case against him, sure. He's looking pretty suspicious so I guess, but I dunno. We're not at that point yet.

 

[¯\_S.(ツ).L.I.D._/¯]

Oh wait, he is at L-1. **** I didn't realize how close to the deadline we are. Umm, I gotta look back through the game real quick and then I'll decide.

 

[¯\_S.(ツ).L.I.D._/¯]

It's kind of hard to make conclusions based on the fact that Rockin hasn't posted much for the past day.

But why is he bringing up D1 stuff? Seems desperate to me. This may be a big mistake, but Rockin has barely contributed at all and hasn't given me sufficient reasoning for why he should live.

Vote: Rockin

 

[Rockin]

It's kind of hard to make conclusions based on the fact that Rockin hasn't posted much for the past day.

But why is he bringing up D1 stuff? Seems desperate to me. This may be a big mistake, but Rockin has barely contributed at all and hasn't given me sufficient reasoning for why he should live.

Vote: Rockin

Oy, I said that smashboards was acting up a bit, and since I was a bit busy, I was only able to bring up a bit of D1 stuff that I noticed. I dunno how could I be 'desperate,' especially since I not only remained at those two who I believe is scum, but say I'll try to do the rest this morning/afternoon before I go to work.

but since I've been hammered, guess I'll claim.

I'm snake, the vig. I get to kill every night. That's right, every night.

N1, I tried to kill Kirbyoshi, because he was the most quiet D1, and I didn't like people who were quiet. For some odd reason though, he didn't die.

N2, I went after Nich cause that pre-claim still bothered me.

I still feel that Chibo and Clownbot are town to me.

That is all.

 

[SwordsRbroken]

Vote Count

Rockin(5): Clownbot, Junglefever, TPK, Meta-kirby, Vrael
ThePaprikaKiller(2): Kirbyoshi, Rockin
Vrael(1): Chibicat

Everyone is suspicious of rockin. "You don't seem to care about what happens do you?" Rockin just sits there, saying nothing. Everyone starts to gang up on him until vrael finally comes and shouts, "GET THE TRAITOR!" Everyone starts attacking rockin until he dies. You see no purple stuff come off of him, so everyone comes to the conclusion that they just lynched someone on their side.

Rockin,(Snake, Town Vigilante)

, has been lynched!

Night 3 begins finally. You have 48 hours to send me your actions. ​

 

[SwordsRbroken]

Everyone wakes up and finds Junglefever, apparently burned to death by some sort of dark power.

Junglefever, Samus aran (Town Cop)

has been burnt to death during the night.

Deadline is April 22 Noon.

 

[DtJ Jungle]

super epic lamesauce

go town

 

[M.K]

Vote: Vrael

 

[M.K]

^--Explanation:

I don't like this "I've been FRAMED! DARN YOU EVERYONE!" mindset that you have going. You seem to want to remind everyone of how you were framed and how that was so, so wrong; however, in REALITY, nothing has proven your innocence, so I'm very much inclined to believe that you are scum.

 

[Deleted member]

Hm, good point. when reading back the message you were reffering to, chibicat indeed didn't even mention the "frame". I wanna see what Vrael has to say about this first though.

 

[Kirbyoshi]

Ugh, I don't get how Rockin was lynched at all. He did nothing scummy, NOTHING. Classic case of over-eager town being egged on by scum. Lemme analyze the Rockin wagon to see if I can pick anyone in particular out.

 

[ChibiCat]

This really isn't a good situation for us at this point with only 6 alive and only one scum out.

I agree with what Meta Kirby said about Vrael and thinking more into it, his entire being framed deal could really just be a big WIFOM maneuver to help protect him (which it has so far). Furthermore, I was really against the Rockin lynch and didn't see a reason for it, and Vrael went ahead and lynched him.

Vote: Vrael

 

[M.K]

This really isn't a good situation for us at this point with only 6 alive and only one scum out.

I agree with what Meta Kirby said about Vrael and thinking more into it, his entire being framed deal could really just be a big WIFOM maneuver to help protect him (which it has so far). Furthermore, I was really against the Rockin lynch and didn't see a reason for it, and Vrael went ahead and lynched him.

Vote: Vrael

ChibiCat (or anyone for that matter), can you tell me the negatives of a mass claiming? I know it sounds odd, but I feel that the game can only play out in a few different ways at this point.

If we assume that SSBF is correct and that there were 3 (now 2) Mafia Members running around, we have either:

4 Town and 2 Scum

----
Scenario 1: We lynch town today

That would leave us with:

2 Town and 2 Scum (after the lynch and night kill)
---
Scenario 2: We lynch Scum today

That would leave us with:

3 Town and 1 Scum (after the lynch and the night kill)
---
Scenario 3: We no-lynch today

That would leave us with:

3 Town and 2 Scum (after the lynch and night kill)
---

As you can see, the scenario really isn't TERRIBLE for us, as at least two of the set ups favor town. However, the one that doesn't favor town puts us in a sort of....odd predicament of lynch or lose.
So can you explain to me why a mass-claim would not ultimately benefit town at this point? I mean, sure, earlier in the game it would've caused too much controversy to be useful and beneficial to town; however, now we have more information, less possibilities, and less to lose.

The people still in this game are:

=Meta-Kirby
=ChibiCat
=Kirbyoshi
=The Paprika Killer
=Clownbot
=Vrael

I know that I am town, so I'm going to assume that 2 of the 5 of the rest of you are scum (at least).

Ultimately, this post is to suggest a mass claim. Please give thoughts, I want to hear them.

 

[Clownbot]

Wouldn't mind one. Don't particularly see it benefiting or harming town either way but if more people are in favor then that's fine with me.

Would also like to ask everyone how they'd feel about a No Lynch.