Smash Bros. Mafia - OVER! Who lived happily ever after in the Subspace Emissary?

[ChibiCat]

@The Paprika Killer: Not really. The closest one to being suspicious is Meta-Kirby. Some of his posts are good, but there are a few that were relatively aggressive. But right now, I can't really find a lead that could prove his scumminess, so I'll wait for for information before saying otherwise.

@Meta-Kirby: Had it not been for Fatchu's interrupting the arguement with his poorly executed posts, it would have been a much longer timespan before the arguement would actually end. Vrael probably would still have some sort of grudge towards Ryker despite the arguement prematurely ending. To be able to get more information out of him, I suggest starting a bandwagon to get his attention:

Vote: Vrael

I don't like how you took the obvious route and were the first one to vote Vrael today. While the connection between Ryker and Vrael is obvious, I find it hard to believe Vrael would do something so obvious... I think.

Vrael - Sorry I forget, but what past games have you been in?

 

[ChibiCat]

After I saw that Ryker got killed, I immediately knew that I would have a few votes on me. It's not really surprising. It seems logical that Mafia would do that in an attempt to make me look more suspicious with the hopes that I'd be lynched. If I were Mafia, it's be what I would do.

I'm not feelin' this WIFOM here.

Is it a scum tell. *sigh* I don't know. That's what I hate about WIFOM! lol
I don't know what to make of it.

 

[ChibiCat]

I agree with Nick, Ryker v Vrael was more of an attempt at getting out of the RVS mroe than anything, imo. Ryker sort of seems like an obvious kill since he got us out of the RVS then stayed quiet, hinting towards trying to stay out of the spotlight but being useful early so people remember. Hmmm, more on this later

This is a good point, and if this is a case - no one would see Ryker as a thread except for people who were directly involved with it, which was pretty much just Vrael. So then we gotta decide, did Vrael kill him or did someone try to frame Vrael? *This is where Vrael's WIFOM comes into case, so do we buy it or not?

Since we know the one option of Vrael, who is the most likely option of scum to have framed him?

 

[ChibiCat]

@ChibiCat: I really do hope so because the last thing we need is for you to go through another inactive period like you did during the majority of Day 1.

SSBF, you are being very, very pushy with activity. Stop the activity policing. Where I am currently, it's 1:14 A.M., so I'm sure most of the game is sleeping. The game will pick up as new information is introduced in a steady (not forcibly exumed) pace.

I'm really not liking SSBF's outlook on the game either right now.

 

[Nicholas1024]

1. Nicholas1024

Whlie Nicholas has apoligized for his quick claim, he has so far failed to back up his excuses for them that was directed at Rockin and give reasons why he was basically parroting other people during Day 1.

I did respond to Rockin. Quit skimming please. Every game, someone accuses me of doing nothing but parroting, and every game it's a lie. Back up your statements or don't make them.

 

[Deleted member]

aw I wanted to see chibicat go for the quintuple post.

 

[Rockin]

I know, sorry I'm late. RL and whatnot.

@Rockin
Yes, I made a mistake on the whole quick-claim thing, and I'll be the first to admit that. However, is that really enough grounds for a lynch? I can understand why it would draw your attention or your vote, but you're not ready yet to push a lynch on me. Also, I didn't quite realize my error with the deadline at the time. It was only later, after I looked over the thread again that I realized my mistake.

You can say that you're sorry and all till you're blue in the face, but the fact that you didn't say your reason to Ryker (who was the first to directly get you on that) and say your reasons to me (a few hours after it was mention) makes it hardly believable.

I've went back and read Day 2 as I promised.

So anyway, it looks like it's finally time to answer my own question I posted earlier.

There are three Mafia members running around, so there are three possible candidates. Right now, however, I can only find two who have leads of being scums. They are The Paprika Killer and Nicholas1024.

1. Nicholas1024

Whlie Nicholas has apoligized for his quick claim, he has so far failed to back up his excuses for them that was directed at Rockin and give reasons why he was basically parroting other people during Day 1.

2. The Paprika Killer

He is currently my top suspect in this case. He has made little significant posts in this game aside from pushing a case on me on Day 2, plus he sometimes shows questionable grammers. He's also basically been skimming the game until Day 2, giving an poor excuse that he basically lurks around until Day 2 or 3 due to lack of activity (Prehaps he's been in the wrong games?). Because of that, during those past game, he has been helping in decreasing activity in those previous games as well. Now I understand that we don't always get a lot of information on Day 1, but I have noticed this as an exception to the rules, so his excuse is especially invalid.

I'll be placing a Vote: The Paprika Killer for now. As for Nicholas, FomS (Fingers of Minor Susipicon): Nicholas1024

Yo, you know something we don't SSBF?

also, what's with the FoSes here? Ya wasn't too scared of throwing around votes in D1, but some/half of ya seem intimidated on throwing a vote here. What's the matter, scared?

Ya need to man up and start throwing down votes, especially if ya really feel they're suspicious/scum.

 

[Nicholas1024]

You can say that you're sorry and all till you're blue in the face, but the fact that you didn't say your reason to Ryker (who was the first to directly get you on that) and say your reasons to me (a few hours after it was mention) makes it hardly believable.

Whatever, Rockin. Whatever.

Yo, you know something we don't SSBF?

also, what's with the FoSes here? Ya wasn't too scared of throwing around votes in D1, but some/half of ya seem intimidated on throwing a vote here. What's the matter, scared?

Ya need to man up and start throwing down votes, especially if ya really feel they're suspicious/scum.

I believe the correct phrase here is "You fail." SSBF voted IN THE VERY POST YOU QUOTED!

 

[ChibiCat]

In Smash Fan's defense there was a lot of talk earlier about there likely being 3 scummies (which I don't know why people would assume the set up at such an early point in the game), so it's likely that he could have gotten confused. I quoted some of these earlier posts very recently.

However, what makes me reluctant is the sureness of Smash Fan's claim of there being 3 scum people. If we lynch him and he does flip scum, then not only do we nail a scummy, we have info that there was 3 scum ppl (and now 2 remaining). Could be quite valuable to us tbh.

 

[Rockin]

Whatever, Rockin. Whatever.

Is that all you can really say?

I believe the correct phrase here is "You fail." SSBF voted IN THE VERY POST YOU QUOTED!

Was I talking about SSBF in that post? I believe I was talking to EVERYONE ELSE THAT HAS BEEN FOSing. (Like The Paprika Killer, for one)

>_>

However, what makes me reluctant is the sureness of Smash Fan's claim of there being 3 scum people. If we lynch him and he does flip scum, then not only do we nail a scummy, we have info that there was 3 scum ppl (and now 2 remaining). Could be quite valuable to us tbh.

I'm hoping for that, as well as believing Nicholas is scum.

Kirbyyoshi, what do you make of D2 so far?

Yo, bunglefever, Post up whenever you can plz.

 

[Nicholas1024]

Is that all you can really say?

Well, since you're unwilling to listen to reasoned argument, there's nothing else to say.

Was I talking about SSBF in that post? I believe I was talking to EVERYONE ELSE THAT HAS BEEN FOSing. (Like The Paprika Killer, for one)

>_>

Well, considering that you started out talking to SSBF, and then went on to say "Ya wasn't too scared to throw around votes D1", it would be easy to see how someone might get confused.

I'm hoping for that, as well as believing Nicholas is scum.

Kirbyyoshi, what do you make of D2 so far?

Yo, bunglefever, Post up whenever you can plz.

Tunnel much, Rockin?

I don't think the "3 scum" thing was a slip on SSBF's part. As Chibi said, many people were throwing around "probably 3 scum" and the like earlier.

 

[ChibiCat]

Yea, I'm not seeing a better option at this point. Acting too scummy imo, and we learn something valuable if we lynch him. I'm open to going for other people if someone else convinces me.

Vote: Super Smash Bros. Fan

 

[Rockin]

Well, since you're unwilling to listen to reasoned argument, there's nothing else to say.

I'm not the only one, I believe. There are a few others who also share the dislike of you of that pre-claim.

Tunnel much, Rockin?

I don't think the "3 scum" thing was a slip on SSBF's part. As Chibi said, many people were throwing around "probably 3 scum" and the like earlier.

Nah, I'm pretty sure I'm not tunneling. I still have a issue with SSBF (as I mentioned before) and I'll gladly vote for him as well. Meta Kirby I'm still having issues with, as with Kirbyyoshi. Bunglefever seems fine in my book, but I'm keeping an eye on him cause I want him to post a bit more as to what's going on.

 

[Deleted member]

Well, considering that you started out talking to SSBF, and then went on to say "Ya wasn't too scared to throw around votes D1", it would be easy to see how someone might get confused.

"some of ya" was also in that sentence. if you actually cared not to just read it but actually understand what he was saying (I had to read it twice) then you wouldn't make this complaint.

I'm still awaiting SSBF's reaction on all this, is there actually anyone against voting him now?

 

[Deleted member]

Regarding the bandwagon, don't think that I did not see that coming. After my many susipicious posts in here, I knew this would be happening very soon.

@The Paprika Killer: I just got home from school and from #676 to #680, nothing really significant has happen. However, I have read all the posts and I will be re-reading them again and you'll be seeing some of my reactions.

@Rockin: Not really, but then again, between us, nobody knows who is Mafia and who is Town. That's why we're here, to gather information. Also, regarding the bold point, it is normal to assume that if there is twelve players in a Mafia game, there will be three scums.

@Nicholas1024: You do realize that we're not suppose to insult people in here? For someone who is relatively experienced at Mafia like you, that is low and dirty. Also, aside from the post you've made. Also, while you did give out your reason why you shouldn't be lynched because of one quick claim, that statement is somewhat hypocritical. You said that I need to back up my statement on why I should be susipicous of you, yet you cop-outed on Rockin on your excuses.

Right now, Nicholas1024 is rising up steadily and The Paprika Killer is going down, but he's still my vote.

Also people, keep in notice that Junglefever did say he would be busy this week, so don't be surprise if he only makes a couple of post during the rest of Day 2.

 

[M.K]

@SSBF
Oh my god, you can't even talk about being rude:
http://www.smashboards.com/showpost.php?p=9838617&postcount=580

Yeah, can we lynch him now people?

 

[M.K]

And you notice he didn't even mention the criticism against him regarding the slip of "three mafias".

>_> It's time.

 

[¯\_S.(ツ).L.I.D._/¯]

If SSBF flips town, I feel like we have to go after Nich and MK. Maybe Chibi too.

How many votes are there? I guess I might vote for him but I don't want to hammer by accident.

 

[ChibiCat]

Can you explain why exactly? Whats wrong with suspecting/voting based on what we have?
You yourself said you are willing to vote on him. Should we look after you as well?

 

[Clownbot]

ChibiCat, would you be absolutely fine with SSBF getting lynched right now despite us having almost a week left until the deadline?

 

[¯\_S.(ツ).L.I.D._/¯]

Can you explain why exactly? Whats wrong with suspecting/voting based on what we have?
You yourself said you are willing to vote on him. Should we look after you as well?

After I posted that I realized maybe you weren't really as suspicious. But MK and Nich are the ones really pulling for the lynch. I really don't care you look after me, go ahead. I'm more reluctant to vote for him than it seems like others are. That's not to say I'm not suspicious, but eh. I don't really know. I'll go read through all his posts, maybe he's said more sketchy stuff than I thought.

But yeah, can we get a vote count?

 

[Clownbot]

SSBF: Kirbyo, MK, Chibi

Some other people: some other people

 

[Kirbyoshi]

Kirbyyoshi, what do you make of D2 so far?

SSBF has been acting very scummy toDay imo. Probably the only reason we didn't see his scumminess yesterDay is because we were so distracted by Fatchu.

PK seemed like he was lying low D1, and now he's starting to show a few scumtells. Second on my list.

I don't think Nick was scummy for the early request for a claim, but he seems to be using a fair amount of AtE defending himself from the accusations.

You do realize that we're not suppose to insult people in here?

Lawlz. This is really rich coming from you, Mr. "I don't want to see you in this forum ever again, understand?"

@Rockin: Got a case to go along with that soft-suspicion of me? I'd love to hear it, refute it, and get back to finding scum.

 

[M.K]

After I posted that I realized maybe you weren't really as suspicious. But MK and Nich are the ones really pulling for the lynch. I really don't care you look after me, go ahead. I'm more reluctant to vote for him than it seems like others are. That's not to say I'm not suspicious, but eh. I don't really know. I'll go read through all his posts, maybe he's said more sketchy stuff than I thought.

But yeah, can we get a vote count?

So, here you basically said:

"If SSBF flips town, we should look at Nich and MK because they voted for him. But not ChibiCat or me, because they wanted to lynch them more than I did"

That's a really dumb reason. Last time I checked, we each have just one vote, and basically, each of our "votes" is an equal "want" to lynch someone.

If you "so strongly" don't want to lynch SSBF, than thats perfectly okay; however, you really need to make a case against somebody ELSE. I mean, there is practically nothing besides petty things on anybody else. I would absolutely love (no sarcasm here) to hear any sort of case on anyone that isn't SSBF. But, for the time being, when the only case that has been established is SSBF, thats where my vote will stand until something new develops.

 

[Nicholas1024]

Regarding the bandwagon, don't think that I did not see that coming. After my many susipicious posts in here, I knew this would be happening very soon.

@The Paprika Killer: I just got home from school and from #676 to #680, nothing really significant has happen. However, I have read all the posts and I will be re-reading them again and you'll be seeing some of my reactions.

@Rockin: Not really, but then again, between us, nobody knows who is Mafia and who is Town. That's why we're here, to gather information. Also, regarding the bold point, it is normal to assume that if there is twelve players in a Mafia game, there will be three scums.

@Nicholas1024: You do realize that we're not suppose to insult people in here? For someone who is relatively experienced at Mafia like you, that is low and dirty. Also, aside from the post you've made. Also, while you did give out your reason why you shouldn't be lynched because of one quick claim, that statement is somewhat hypocritical. You said that I need to back up my statement on why I should be susipicous of you, yet you cop-outed on Rockin on your excuses.

Right now, Nicholas1024 is rising up steadily and The Paprika Killer is going down, but he's still my vote.

Also people, keep in notice that Junglefever did say he would be busy this week, so don't be surprise if he only makes a couple of post during the rest of Day 2.

@SSBF
Oh my god, you can't even talk about being rude:
http://www.smashboards.com/showpost.php?p=9838617&postcount=580

Yeah, can we lynch him now people?

Anyone else see the irony in that he accuses me of being hypocritical WHILE being hypocritical himself? Twice the hypocrisy. I have no problem with a SSBF lynch at this point.

Unvote if I had one
Vote: SSBF

 

[ChibiCat]

ChibiCat, would you be absolutely fine with SSBF getting lynched right now despite us having almost a week left until the deadline?

No, I would rather not do so yet.

 

[Rockin]

If SSBF flips town, I feel like we have to go after Nich and MK. Maybe Chibi too.

How many votes are there? I guess I might vote for him but I don't want to hammer by accident.

Why do you feel Chibicat is suspicious?

@Rockin: Got a case to go along with that soft-suspicion of me? I'd love to hear it, refute it, and get back to finding scum.

I'm not suspicious of you (yet. you havn't given me anything to be suspicious about). I said I only have an ISSUE with you. The said issue I have is that you've been fairly quiet in D1 (except with the issue with Fatchu). If you can be a bit more vocal and share more of your thoughts, that would no longer be an issue.

 

[Kirbyoshi]

Sweet, thanks Rockin, I just usually have in my head that "issue"=suspicion, but I guess that's not the case with you.

Btw, I think Vrael already retracted his mention of Chibi that you quoted.

 

[Deleted member]

I counted 4 votes on him, so that should put him on L-2, so I'd rather not vote yet in case I miscounted, but his sole reaction was just poor.

Fake Vote: SSBF

 

[SwordsRbroken]

Vote count

Paprikakiller(2): Clownbot, SSBF
SSBF(4): Kirbyoshi, Meta-kirby, Chibicat, Nicholas
Nicholas(1): Rockin

With 10 alive it takes 6 to lynch!

Rockin will be V/LA until March 29

Deadline is at March 29!​

 

[Deleted member]

Vote: SSBF

claim would be nice

also, clownbot what are the reasons you have voted me?

 

[¯\_S.(ツ).L.I.D._/¯]

Why do you feel Chibicat is suspicious?

I took back the Chibi statement like two posts below that one.

 

[Rockin]

Btw, I think Vrael already retracted his mention of Chibi that you quoted.

I know, but I still wanted to hear. Ahh well then.

I'm going out of state tomorrow to the PAX convention (Penny arcade. Think of it as a Small E3) and I won't be back till monday. Deadline for D2 is March 29th, so be sure not to forget that (since the mod hasn't put that in his update of vote counts).

Like I said before, I'm fine with either SSBF or Nicholas going. I'm keeping my vote on Nicholas in anycase

 

[Clownbot]

Stated them already, Paprika Killer. To sum up why it's that I think you've contributed least to the discussion and haven't made a lot of posts that do something.

Nevertheless, Unvote

SSBF looks like the lynch toDay but I'm not voting him now since we have plenty of time and I don't want to hammer yet.

@everyone, if somehow SSBF doesn't end up being the play who do you think we should go after?

 

[Deleted member]

@Clownbot: Actually, we're already out of time. Reason below:

Unvote, Vote: Super Smash Bros. Fan.

No seriously, I am officially lynching myself. The reason why is because I have absolutely no way to defend myself now, plus I know a sixth vote would be at reach very soon anyway. Also, claiming sounds like a useless idea that doesn't really work for me. Claiming certantly didn't save Fatchu from being lynched, so why should I even bother doing so? You people said never to lynch before a claim, well, what if someone wants to vote for himself and get himself lynched, knowing that any attempt at rebuttal is useless? That's when the exception comes in.

(You can ignore all this wish-mash below if you wish)

Since twlighted started by this post, I might as well add something acceptable before I die.

First off, I just want to say I am really sorry for my horrible gameplay here. I had computer problems that tooked up most of Day 1, I am an relatively naive player who doesn't really know much of the game, but most importantly, I made so many mistakes in the game that I outright knew this was going to happen sooner or later and nothing could prevent that.

I want to say that I really did enjoy the game and it was a lot of fun when I played it. Even thought, I am relatively new to the game, I have learned a few things that should help me in other games that I particapate in Smash World Forums. I will be remembering this game while I'm in Smash World Forums, because it introduced me to Mafia, which is an brillant concept that is very, very addicting.

For more of me on Mafia, check out Newbie Mafia 5, which is currently going on. That game is actually pretty good, although not as awesome as this.

As for the future of Mafia games I particapate in, I'll try to explain to the best of my ability. Depending if this counts as a "completed game" for me, I will be going to the Departed Mafia next, which will be my first true experience to Mafia, since I'm not marred by computer problems anymore. If that doesn't count, I will be heading over to Mafiascum.net to play future Mafia games for awhile and to brush up my skills and come back here when I feel ready. It may take months, possibly years to do depending on how well I do. But rest assure I will be back.

I would have choosen to replace in DBZ Mafia instead, but to tell the truth, I don't really feel like I'm ready for that type of game. I heard that it was recommended that you should be relatively experience before joining that game and given my relatively patethic effort in here, I feel like I need to stay clear out of the game of that magnitude for awhile, not to mention I'm worried it could end up like LoDScrew (A.K.A. game left unfinished).

However, even after I'm dead in this game, I will continue to document the events that goes on in the game. Once the game is over, I will be reveiling my whole document of the game for everyone to read, because there might be a favorite section of yours and wouldn't be nice to re-read it without having to search for possibly hours?

And to SwordsRbroken, before you lynch me, I have one more request.

I want all remaining players to give an opinion on me based on this game. I won't be responding to them since I don't want to start an argument, but I will be reading them, because they could help me in future Mafia games and possibly as a person in the future.

See you all later and I hope you guys continue to enjoy Smash Bros. Mafia!

 

[Clownbot]

What.

The.

****.

 

[Deleted member]

I like how he kept the honour to himself.

I general it were the mistakes and the activity thing you kept hammering on that were the most important reasons this happened.

 

[¯\_S.(ツ).L.I.D._/¯]

Well that was...iunno.

 

[M.K]

What a complete and total disrespect for the game and such a disrespect to other players. You view us as barbarians, sir; you think we are incompetent of reason? Wow, that is absolutely horrible playstyle. That's not even playstyle; that's quitstyle, and you sir, have MASTERED the art of quitstyle.
"There is no way of defending myself!! BOOHOO, oh well, looks like I'm gone, have FUNNN".
is BULL.
****.
What in the WORLD is this game coming to??

 

[M.K]

No, I really want to emphasize how much disrespect you've shown the moderator and towards the other players. This is really uncanny. For all the times that you've told Swords to step his game up with the more frequent vote counts and such, and for all the times you've criticized others for being inactive or not trying hard enough, and even telling Fatchu that you "don't ever want to see him in another Mafia game again", even though HE TRIED to defend himself, is absolutely horrendous.
YOU SIR.
Clear your mind of this bull**** and join another Mafia game when you have the COMMITMENT to dedicate to it.