Smash Bros. Mafia - OVER! Who lived happily ever after in the Subspace Emissary?

[Deleted member]

I think SwordsRbroken should do another vote count now. It would be interesting to see results as of now.

 

[DtJ Jungle]

My thoughts are that him claiming woudl only hurt town at this point. If he happens to be a PR and claims now, we scramble and no lynch, then tomorrow someone dies (maybe him maybe not) and we're either left with no information entirely because he dies, or we're left with little information and a townie (maybe) who has yet to be useful. It's all murky and I think that his claim could only create a more miserable situation Tomorrow.

 

[Nicholas1024]

My thoughts are that him claiming woudl only hurt town at this point. If he happens to be a PR and claims now, we scramble and no lynch, then tomorrow someone dies (maybe him maybe not) and we're either left with no information entirely because he dies, or we're left with little information and a townie (maybe) who has yet to be useful. It's all murky and I think that his claim could only create a more miserable situation Tomorrow.

Not following you. If he claims an important PR and isn't CC'd, we just lynch another suspect, like SSBF or Paprika Killer. How is that worse than having him not claim and lynching a PR? If he claims vanilla, the lynch would go through anyway (as vanilla is usually a scum fake-claim).

 

[DtJ Jungle]

Would you feel comfortable lynching either of them? I don't.

 

[DtJ Jungle]

Un-CC doesn't mean cleared. Vanilla is not always fake scum claim. You're assuming too much. I'd rather lynch unhelp/dumbtown then scramble for some weak, piss poor lynch.

 

[#HBC | Ryker]

No. Absolutely not. If he claims Doc or Cop, you lynch him anyway. If he claims masons and his buddy confirms him or he claims a day role, then you leave him alone. Always safest to let them claim in case you don't get a flip.

 

[Fatchu]

Im just a plain old vanilla townie, nothing more. I might not be special, but your not lyching scum which is the worst thing.

 

[Deleted member]

@Fatchu: I'm sorry but a claim is not enough for me to convince that you are innocent. If you are truly an townie, prove it. So far, most of your efforts have been poor.

 

[SwordsRbroken]

Vote Count

Fatchu(6): Bunglefever, Vrael, Chibicat, Clownbot, SSBF, Meta-Kirby
SSBF(2): Rockin, Fatchu,

With 12 alive it takes 7 to lynch!

Deadline is the last second of March 18.


​

​

​

 

[Deleted member]

@SwordsRbroken: I think you've made some mistakes there. First off, aren't we only allow to vote for one member at a time? Secondly, you need to make some corrections:

Vrael does not have any vote, since ChibiCat changed his vote to Fatchu.
Fatchu has five votes, Meta-Kirby has unvoted fo rnow.
I only have two votes, Clownbot unvoted me for Fatchu and Kirbyoshi has unvoted as well.

I could be wrong, thought.

 

[#HBC | Ryker]

So,...

=======[]
It appears I hold the Hammer of truth?


Nah, waiting for Tom before I throw the hammer unless Chibo gives me the go ahead.

 

[SwordsRbroken]

@SwordsRbroken: I think you've made some mistakes there. First off, aren't we only allow to vote for one member at a time? Secondly, you need to make some corrections:

Vrael does not have any vote, since ChibiCat changed his vote to Fatchu.
Fatchu has five votes, Meta-Kirby has unvoted fo rnow.
I only have two votes, Clownbot unvoted me for Fatchu and Kirbyoshi has unvoted as well.

I could be wrong, thought.

Thank you, i quoted myself previously and forgot to edit that.

 

[Deleted member]

So,...

=======[]
It appears I hold the Hammer of truth?


Nah, waiting for Tom before I throw the hammer unless Chibo gives me the go ahead.

awww, I wanted to have some hammer time.

 

[#HBC | Ryker]

Dibs on hammer.

 

[Deleted member]

@SwordsRbroken: You're very welcome.

BTW, you still have Meta-Kirby's vote in. Please remove it, since as of now, he has not voted for anyone. He unvoted Fatchu at post #497. I'm just saying, but nevetheless, I do apperatice the corrections you've made.

 

[Nicholas1024]

Oh no you don't, Ryker. After Chibi cat makes his big long post, I'm going to hammer.

 

[#HBC | Ryker]

Oh no you don't, Ryker. After Chibi cat makes his big long post, I'm going to hammer.

Hey! I called it.

 

[Nicholas1024]

Hey! I called it.

First one on after Chibi cat's post gets it. I was behind this wagon too, you know.

 

[Deleted member]

First one on after Chibi cat's post gets it. I was behind this wagon too, you know.

*mashes F5*

I shall Hammer!!!

 

[Deleted member]

Nobody is going to hammer because Meta-Kirby already has unvoted for now.

Let's wait until ChibiCat arrives with his posts. Only then can we determind the final result. He will be crucial to the ending of Day 1 and we don't want his evidences wasted on an petty arguement on who should hammer Fatchu.

And even after ChibiCat does provide evidence, DON'T hammer right then. Investigate those posts yourself and then we all need to come to the conclusion who is an Mafia member and who is town.

 

[#HBC | Ryker]

If something of consequence comes up, no one's gonna vote, but we're two days from deadline so I think the hammer will be dropping.

 

[¯\_S.(ツ).L.I.D._/¯]

Kill him with flaming hammers of Thor!

 

[Kirbyoshi]

*Waiting for Chibicat*

Also, I'm gonna hammer

 

[ChibiCat]

Honeslty what I have wanted to say has been said, I dont like how ryker was going after one person, which has been said over and over again. I say it over and over again because I am being asked to, and I have not clamed that you all suck, why dont you try reading the statements. I am sorry for that comment earlier, it was only out of frustration.

How do you not have more to say than this?

-1 Fatchu

Nothing has really been contributed to this game nich, the entire post has mostly been ryker v. me/ vreal. I am trying to contibute, but other people have to do the same. I have said that other people need to post and say something about what is going on now. I have done my part, now everyone else must do theres.

Nothing in 300 posts? I've had plenty to comment on with reads on people besides the ones you mentioned.

DON'T CLAIM YET!!!!!!!!

FoS: Nich

Despite me not really posting yet, I don't feel that Nicholas' comment was out of line. You overacted a little quick there. Not a good or bad thing though really.

Needless FoS.

Good idea. Although Fatchu does seem to be cracking under the pressure, there isn't any harm in waiting for everyone to chime in.

Forcing someone to claim while under pressure is key. Hesitation shows thinking of a fake claim while standing by a firm ground is better imo. Good opportunity missed.

Ive said all I can say, we now just have to wait for rockin and chbi to weigh in.

I feel like you're using us just to delay the inevitable.

Heres a list of my thoughts:

We all now what we think about ryker.

I dont like how nich is asking for claims prematurly.

I wish rocket would elaborate on things more.

Clown is town, tehe I rhymed.

Mk is town, prolly the smartest person in the game right now.

I dont know what to think about chbi rockin right now, ill wait for them to post.

Your the slow one now kiroboshii.

Any questions????

Awful awful post. Full of parroting, lacking in description, very very small description of 20 pages. *sigh*

-2 Fatchu

Unvote
Vote: Ryker

The reason why I didn't vote for Vreal is because before coming to his final conclusion, he actually waited for some posts to come in. Ryker didn't and soon after, he started to argue with other members in this game. Thus this is the reason why I came to my conclusion.

Fatchu does not deserve to be lynched because like Vreal, he also took his time to study the situation. Bad people tend to rush to conclusion more then people who are good and even lie at it, which is another reason why I voted for Ryker.

@Rockin: I'm awake, see? I'm on this game, I just haven't posted much. And I finally got my computer back just today.

@Meta-Knight: I know you haven't seen me for awhile and I'm sorry about that. And as I promised, I have returned from a broken computer. My computer has finally gotten fixed and I promised that I would be back by today. See, problem solved, right?

This post is:

Voting Ryker

Explaining why you're not voting other people, yet not focusing as much on why you're voting Ryker.

Your reasoning is weak imo. Not to mention I disagree with what you said about Fatchu.

-1 Smash Fan

Okay,... so you're voting me because I made the first move as opposed to people who sat on their heels and did nothing?

God how I love the people who are voting me!!!

Ease up.

I'm generally not a fan of pressure voting, but Fatchu has been horrible under pressure. I think we should lynch him toDay, then if he's town, go after Ryker toMorrow.

This.

We should only investigate Ryker further if it turn's out Fatchu is townie, but even then it's still stupid to assume things.

Isn't this your first post in a while? Kind of weak and trying to get people on Ryker's case acting like he's the only one pushing for Fatchu. 5 people are voting him atm iirc, not just Ryker.

-1 Rocket

Oy, really not liking Fatchu.

Seriously, you should look at the stuff you post Fatchu. It's really anti-town and unhelpful. All I did was told you that smash refs were bad to use, and you go on 'bah, lynch me, I'm town and ya will be sorry' as a defense. AtE are horrid defenses (in fact, they're hardly a defense). Instead of using those things, you should at least give a effort to why voting for you is bad instead of bad mouthing the players. It'll only make you sink faster. Townies don't give up. They keep fighting.

Now fatchu, I'm going to ask you two questions

1) Why should I take my vote off of you?

2) Besides ryker, who else do you find scummy?

try not to use any AtE



I'm waiting for your reason, good sir.



We're out of the RVS pages ago. You best read up and tell us what you feel about the whole situation in this day thus far. Who do you feel is scummy?



FoS: Nick

Why so quick on getting a claim, Nick?

I need to know from everyone else. Besides Rkyer, who do you find suspicious?

Good post, but I don't agree with the FoS.

+1 Rockin

Why wait to investigate ryker tommorrow? Investigate him now instead of just going after me, and what about nich and his quick claims?

You aren't reading, he said it's based on your flip.

-1 Fatchu

Now, this is the sort of post that makes me think "desperate scum". I mean, you haven't really said a word in your own defense, you're just quickly trying to shove suspicion onto someone else.

This.

+1 Nicholas

There shoudnt be any suspision on me, all I have done is say "hey lets investigate everybody instead of just grilling one person for awhile, then going to another" We have yet to investigate people other then my self and vreal.

There shoudnt be any suspision on me

There shoudnt be any suspision on me

There shoudnt be any suspision on me

-5 Fatchu

This brings his count to -29 LOL

@Fatchu: I actually agree with you. Unlike you, Ryker has defindently been showing behavior worth of suspicion. I would say you are currently at least neutral on the subject.

I'm seeing what seems to be a lot of buddying with you on Fatchu. Duly noted.

I'm really not too suspicious of Ryker any more, but outside of Fatchu I'd say... well, Chibi has said extremely little and until they make a post of substance I'd say them. SSBF as well for buddying Fatchu and using almost the exact same logic as him, seems kind of parroty.

Picked up the same thoughts as me. Good stuff.

+1 Clownbot

@rockin:

1. All I have done is say stop grilling one person and investigate others, since that I have been attacked like vreal was. True what I have done might be viewed as odd and some post might be seen as anti town, which I have appogized for i might add. They were not in anyway scummy.

2. I dont like how nich is trying to push a claim, I also dont like the fact that the minute vreal was off the hot seat he began to parrot public opnion, also notice that as soon as that happened he hasnt said anything except to vote for me and give a parroted reason.

At this time I do think that all ryker was trying to do was get people to talk and converese, which he has done, I am still suspisious but I dont think that they are in anyway scummy, as odd as this my seem I am going to do this.....


unvote

This contradicts everything you have done up to this point.

-1 Fatchu

You can't say bad things and then apologise for them multiple times, just like you can't curse at people and then say sorry to them all the time, since you're stilling cursing at poeple, or in this case, saying anti-town stuff.
I also haven't seen you actually say sorry anywhere. I only say so put the "I hope you all die" thing of as a misinterpretation.

This.

+1 Paprika

Kirbyoshi: Nothing really worth mentioning.
ChibiCat: A very silent person. He's probably taking his time and deciding on who is the real criminal.
Bunglefever: Nothing really worth mentioning
Meta-Kirby: He has not said very much in this forum, so I won't bother mentioning him.
Clownbot: Can't really say anything bad about him.
Nicholas1024: He's a fine person, nothing wrong with him.
The Paprika Killer: The name alone can make a person a little suspicies, but he hasn't said anything that is worth voting for.
Rockin: Rockin is fine with me for now.

I'll investigate Ryker, Vreal, and Fatchu posts to see who really deserve to be hanged.

Close analysis matching mine, however at the comment for me - stop the buddying, I don't appreciate it. If I were anyone besides myself I would have certainly voted me by now. I'll admit that being absent for that long was awful, and thankfully I'm back in the game, but for real, it was faaar too long not being in the game.

I don't see the reason to buddy someone who isn't here, nor do I really understand buddying in general.

-1 Smash Fan

I went through the thread and I can finally answer your question.

Vreal is not worth of suspicon or a vote since he was pratically being attacked by Ryker. He wanted to get some information before he could vote and he did, so he's fine with me.

Ryker, on the other hand, still has my vote. Ryker voted for Vreal eight times because he wanted to get him hanged, not because he knows he is a scum. He also called Vreal names. Look at page 9 through 13 of this thread for why I vote for him.

However, I will say this FOS: Fatchu. Because he said "I hope you all lose." once in this thread, he is worthy of suspicon.

Not liking this post.

-1 Smash Fan

this is the single most generic, non-saying list I've seen in a while. the few "not worth mentioning" okay, but the comment on chibicat and meta-kirby are just awful.
FoS: SSB Fan

First person to really point on the things I didn't find good about it. Though I'm not liking the ultra conservative view on voting over FoS, though that might not be a bad thing always.

+1 Paprika

Fatchu probably said that because he would rather get lynched as soon as possible then actually say something meaniful. This could be due to his frustration at this game.

He also denided for awhile that he actually did something wrong and he has yet to answer the two question you gave him. Which were:



Taken from comment 322 in this thread.

What Clownbot says right below this post,

-1 Smash Fan

Hasn't been over 48 hours yet.

But if Chibi doesn't make any good posts soon I'm gonna be pretty exhausted. He's my top lynch candidate right now after Fatchu and it stays that way until he can make at least just a couple of posts that express his thoughts on the game and/or contribute something productive to it.

Taking initiative against me wanting to keep everyone active.

+1 Clownbot

@Clownbot: These are two post the where I have expressed what has been going on in the game, how can you still say I have yet to contribute?

These are not very good summaries of the game.

This list, plain and simple, sucks.
Also, your hypocrisy is DULY noted. I love how you mention all of this about players "not saying anything" or "hasn't really said much" when you yourself have been horridly useless so far. HUGE FoS: SSBF because this list is such a terrible way to come back into the game.
At last, you've re-entered the game, and now you're giving us this? Almost as bad as Fatchu; equally as unhelpful as town. Now you say that you've gotta take a step out of this game? No way, this definitely sounds like some "coasting" bull**** and that's one of my Mafia pet peeves. If you don't have the kindness or respect towards other players to stay in the game and HELP (if you're town, that is), than you need to replace out. I'm tired of this "well, I'll just step out for a little while...doo doo dooooo....ohh, whoops? Day 7? Oh yeah, I'm scum lawlz" crap that plagues Mafia games.
You need to contribute to the game as if it were a daily responsibility, and the fact that you treat this game as something that you can waiver so easily is quite deceptive and truly annoying.

It's not as bad as Fatchu, but this post otherwise is correct.

+1 Meta-Kirby

Guess I might as well come back. The last thing I need is for Meta-Kirby to start another rant against me.

And yes, I actually promise to contribute to this thread until the game is over.

You look a little paranoid there...



---



Ok, up through page 25. This is getting very tiring, I need to take a break lol.

Current count:

Clownbot: 1
Vrael: -1
Ryker: 3
Rockin: 3
Paprika: -1
kirbyoshi: -1
Nicholas: 2
Fatchu: -30
Smash Fan: -5
Rocket: -2
Meta-Kirby: 1

Don't wait for Tom, I'm still playing the hydra which is fine. He's having comp troubles and said before he might be back today, but he isn't yet so w/e.

Don't worry about ending the day before I'm done my analysis. I've gone through 25 pages so far and at least to me it's still glaringly obvious at who needs to go. Besides the first 25 I've been keeping up and reading on all new posts since my first catch up post which is like 5 or so pages, so I hardly have anything left in the game.

 

[#HBC | Ryker]

Alright then. Let's see what happens if I hammer.

Vote: Fatchu

===========[]

 

[Kirbyoshi]

I would have liked Fatchu to nameclaim, but I don't think it would have saved him.

 

[¯\_S.(ツ).L.I.D._/¯]

I think he claimed vanilla townie.

 

[Clownbot]

Nah, what Kirbyo meant was that he would have liked Fatchu to claim what character he got.

 

[Kirbyoshi]

^^^That.
10Char

 

[¯\_S.(ツ).L.I.D._/¯]

Oh, I gotcha. Makes sense.

 

[Fatchu]

fools..........

 

[DtJ Jungle]

You know while we are in twilight you can at least like say soemthing useful before you die.

 

[Kirbyoshi]

Fatchu doesn't have anything useful to say. He hasn't said anything useful so far, so why should he start now?

 

[Deleted member]

@Ryker: You haven't thrown the hammer at Fatchu just quite yet. As a matter of fact, look at Meta-Kirby's post here:

It's not the final vote, I know.
I'm pretty sure that everyone in this game has enough awareness to realize that Fatchu is now at L-1, but for now, I'll Unvote so that we can hear more from Chibi.

Fatchu is now at L-2

This was taken direction from post #497. You did not lynch Fatchu just yet, all you did was put him at L-1 again. However, since ChibiCat told us not to worry about lynching him before he completes his investigation, I won't stop anyone from lynching him. Beside, he needs to go as soon as possible.

 

[Fatchu]

I did exactly what you wanted I was usuful, but you lot refused to see what I was saying and dismissed it.

 

[¯\_S.(ツ).L.I.D._/¯]

How about a nameclaim.

 

[Fatchu]

I already gave my nameclaim, Ive had enugh repeating myself in this game.

 

[Deleted member]

@Fatchu: Be glad that those people don't realize that SwordsRbroken had made a mistake he has yet to correct. Look at the last post I made. I basically brought out a fact that Meta-Kirby has not voted for you, so therefore, we have not enter Twlight Phase yet. We are still in the Day phase, but you are indeed dangerously close to being lynched. This might be the time for you to give out your last arguements and hopes of saving yourself, so you better use it well because I am not unvoting you again.

Give us reasons why you are not a scum.

 

[DtJ Jungle]

What you don't understand is what you're doing ISN'T GOOD ENOUGH. What YOU consider enough isn't cutting it with us because you aren't giving us enough information on your thoughts. you haven't brought anything to the table at all. Don't make it out as our fault when you fail to answer questions thoroughly and beat around the bush. You're use of AtE is frustrating and completely anti-town. When you're under suspicion, as town, you should have no reason to be afraid since you're town! yet you get defensive and startin throwing out 'lol you're ********' and bull**** liekt hat which is completely unproductive. You never properly defended acusuations against you, just whined about them. Learn the difference and form a proper defense as to why you are town and why someone else is scum. YOu're letting other people form cases for you but it looks like you don't understand how they do it, meaning your suspicions look completely unfounded.

 

[¯\_S.(ツ).L.I.D._/¯]

I already gave my nameclaim, Ive had enugh repeating myself in this game.

Where was this? Sorry if I didn't see it.