Welcome to Smashboards, the world's largest Super Smash Brothers community! Over 250,000 Smash Bros. fans from around the world have come to discuss these great games in over 19 million posts!
You are currently viewing our boards as a visitor. Click here to sign up right now and start on your path in the Smash community!
The thing is that Pokemon Amie on Nintendogs IS NOT SLAPPING IT IN! I can literally go for hours listing all of the reasons of why the track has to be on Nintendogs and not on a Pokemon stage.
There's a waiting period around 1-2 days for us to reflect on the results while they prepare the next stage. I'm thinking that the next round will begin tomorrow night.
Thanks, Ascended! I hope you win a round, too. At the very least, this thread has made me a popular Smashboardian thanks to my endless supply of Pac-Man pics. So it'll still be worth it.
Probably going to want to talk to Sakurai about that.
Pretty soon I think.
Hopefully, right next to my Golden Sun stage.
Better include this song. In my opinion, it;s the only song that needs to be on any Pokemon stage.
Completely this.
Now can you actually do anything with it?F***ING CALLED IT!
I'll always think that Fit being judged entirely on franchise-representation is ridiculous, sorry. I can't change your opinion on the epicness of cross-franchise songs and you can't change mine...my objective's to win, as this is a contest. I think we can all get along even though we have different opinions.
You can hold an opinion and not be a jacka** about it.
It's not entirely judged on that. But franchise representation is a big part of it. Part of "fitting the stage."
Bull****.
Then act like it.
That's going to be difficult. I even do it IRL, and this is the Internet we're talking about. And the judges do act a little jackassy when they shrug off the cross-franchise songs as 'slapping them in' instead of actually thinking of the reasons that make them fitting choices. And no, a franchise having a stage doesn't mean that all of the songs from that franchise should go on the stage, especially if said songs are completely unfitting on their home stages.
The problem is that, in Smash Bros, never have we seen a franchise with stages put music in unrelated stages. For instance, Fire Emblem in Melee appeared in Temple because there was no Fire Emblem stage, and it's now a staple of it. But, if they were to put Ike's Theme on Bridge of Eldin solely because the two series have something in common, and there's still a viable Fire Emblem stage to put it on instead, it'll go there. So, fit basically means it has some connections to the series and, if it's from another franchise, it doesn't fit anywhere else but there, and belongs to a series which isn't already represented as a stage. Even if, let's say, Snake Man's stage from Mega Man 3 fits PERFECTLY with Garden of Hope, why would Mega Man tracks appear in a Pikmin stage when there's a Mega Man stage they can go on? I'm not saying you make bad choices, the Moon theme on Mario Galaxy would be nerdgasmic... but if it has it's own stage with other great tracks, let it be alongside them.
Because there's a good chance those tracks don't fit on a Megaman stage. But seriously, I wanna stop talking about this and go to sleep, I just submitted my entry.
That's not an excuse and you know it.
We all got what you were trying to do.
Midna's Lament didn't fit with the atmosphere of Bridge of Eldin.
I think it could use a remix, though.
Don't bother. It's been explained to D-idara why judges docked points for cross platform songs. He(?) just doesn't care.
Wow, you're an a**hole IRL too. What a shock.
And there you go again missing the point of my post. Sure, you can hold the opinion that tracklists with cross-franchise songs shouldn't be docked points because of those cross platform songs, but again, that's your OPINION. The judges might not(and obviously don't) share that opinion, but that's no reason to get all high-and-mighty about the fact that not everybody in the world agrees with you on this.
Tell me about it!
Implying that the last statement was a smart move from Sakurai...let's just go the fanservice theory and MAYBE you'll understand, Brinstar - OGWV has NO CHANCE of appearing on Pyrosphere or the Metroid Prime stage because it simply doesn't fit (MP stage's probably going to be Skyworld or Phaaze), but that song is ridiculously good and should be on the game no matter what, so why should Sakurai refrain from putting it where it fits just because it's from another franchise? That'd just make the game's music collection better and richer, much more varied and interesting, especially if the cross-franchise songs are rearranged to fit the stage even more.
