[collapse="Swampasaur's Grades"]Ascended
Importance: 8
Popularity: 9
Variety: 8
Fit: 9
Total: 34
Notes: In the Fields in a pretty catchy little jingle. I feel it may need to remixed though. Still a good choice! Your idea for Byrne's Theme is pretty cool! I like it. Regardless, the track is a good choice considering how popular and important he is. I do feel that Byrne Battle or Byrne Help would have been better choices though. Castle Town is a great choice as well. Popular, the main town of the game, and upbeat and catchy. It think it fits perfectly. The Phantom Hourglass Title Theme gives me chills... I won't lie. It's pretty darn good. This might be put on a Wind Waker stage in the Wii U version but hey! That won't affect your grade at all. Linebeck's theme is super popular as is the character himself. Fun Fact, his theme was remixed with Bellum's Theme for the Final Boss music of Phantom Hourglass. Nice choice. The Oracle medley is nice... Quick question, isn't the Overworld track exactly the same track as the Overworld from Link's Awakening? Tal Tal Heights is a good choice, though I feel that they will go with the Brawl version if they choose Tal Tal Heights.
Starphoenix
Importance: 8
Popularity: 8
Variety: 9
Fit: 7
Total: 32
Notes: Vs. Byrne is a good choice. As is the Great Sea. I always found it strange that the Title Theme and the Great Sea were one in the same for Phantom Hourglass. Vs Vaati is an interesting choice. Although I feel like other tracks from Minish Cap would have been a better choice. Not a bad choice in the slightest. I just feel like other tracks would be better suited. Your Oracle meldey is a pretty interesting one. The two songs can mesh together pretty well. Battle Quest is... wow! Never knew it was that catchy. Guess I only stayed on that street for small periods at a time. It certainly sounds like Zelda. But... I feel that since Zelda has so much to work with, priority should be given to it. Same goes for Overworld. Both are catchy as heck though.
God Robert's Cousin
Importance: 8
Popularity: 9
Variety: 8
Fit: 9
Total: 34
Notes: I've talked about the first couple of songs already. So... let's get to the more unique stuff. Cragma is a great choice. It's the most popular boss theme in the game by far (outside possible the Final Boss Theme). The Oracle medley is interesting. I can definitely see the transitions working. Thank you for posting the exact times to give me a better idea. The Brawl version of Tal Tal Heights is very nice. Minish Village is... the only thing I find questionable about your list. I feel like Hyrule Town would have been a better fit. Still, it's catchy.
Shinpichu
Importance: 9
Popularity: 9
Variety: 8
Fit:9
Total: 35
Notes: In the Fields and Fight against Byrne are great tracks from Spirit tracks. Both popular and important. The Great Sea and Linebeck's theme are also amazing, popular and important tracks from Phantom Hourglass. Hyrule Field is quite literally the main theme, but hey. It works well. Cloud Tops is among the most popular tracks from Minish Cap. Finish it off with Tal Tal Heights and I'd say you have a very fine list!
APC99
Importance: 8
Popularity: 9
Variety: 8
Fit:8
Total: 33
Notes:Starting off with Linebeck's theme isn't a bad choice at all. Minish Woods is a decent choice though I feel like there are better choices out there. Lost Woods really does feel like it should belong on the Gerudo Valley stage. Although it could work here as well. Dancing Dragon Dungeon is catchy and works very well. Among the most popular Oracle tracks. Ballad of the Windfish is a great choice for a song but... I honestly can't say I'd put it here. I'd put it in Skyloft or Gerudo Valley before I'd put it here. Still, it works. The Main Theme from Link Between Worlds was a risky choice... But I feel that it works. Vs Byrne (Not Byrne's Theme) is a solid choice. Overall, I feel like you took some risks. Let's see if they pay off!
BridgesWithTurtles
Importance: 9
Popularity: 10
Variety: 9
Fit: 8
Total: 36
Notes:In the Fields is a nice choice as always. Hyrule Field does feel like it would fit much better on Gerudo Valley, but it can also fit here. It's one of those tracks that could easily fit on both. I just feel like Gerudo Valley would be a better choice. The Dark World is another track that could easily fit on both. And A Link to The Past actually has been a handheld game. It was paired up with Four Swords on the GBA. Who knew huh? Battle with Byrne is a great choice. As is Linkbeck's Theme. Ah... Vs. Bellum. Frankly I'm surprised we didn't see more of this track. It's pretty popular and is a fight against the main villain of Phantom Hourglass. I'd say it's pretty important. Boss Battle is an interesting choice. I find it a pretty solid Minish Cap choice. Good job!
Violenceman
Importance:9
Popularity:9
Variety:8
Fit:8
Total: 34
Notes: Personally Byrne comes to the Rescue is my favorite Byrne track. It's a fine choice, but it does lack the impact and lasting impression the other versions have (This one is still better though, Rescue Master Race). Cloud Tops is a fine choice. As is the Brawl Version of Tal Tal Heights! Wifi Battle is an interesting choice. I didn't expect to see it on these lists and frankly, I feel stupid that I didn't see it coming. It's a fine choice. Especially considering how big the multiplayer of Phantom Hourglass was. HOLY CRAP!!! Four Swords had awesome music like that?!? Dang. It's good. I like it. Kinda obscure though. Your medley is among my favorite ones so far. It works REALLY well. The tracks all flow together very well and the choices for the transitions are nice ones. Good job! Cursed Overworld does seem a bit redundant when we already have the original version of the piece but hey! Sakurai did that with Zelda in the past. Why not? It's a good choice.
Ariand / AEM
Importance:8
Popularity:8
Variety:8
Fit:9
Total: 33
Notes: The Final Exam is another track I'm surprised we haven't heard more of. It's a good one! Your next track gave me flashbacks of phantoms... They are nice tracks... but I feel that the Tower of Spirits really pales in comparison to some of the other tracks from Spirit Tracks. Doesn't seem to be too popular either. I do agree with you that Phantoms need to be in the soundtrack of the game somewhere. In the Fields is nice as I've said several times. XD Still.... I don't see how it's a remix of the main theme of the main theme of the original Zelda. What do you mean? Byrne Boss Battle is a great choice as is Linebeck's Theme. Vaati Battle works pretty well. I do feel that the Ballad of the Windfish could work better on other stages though. Still nice list. Overall though... It's a bit Spirit Tracks heavy... That will hurt Variety a tad.
Watzup7856
Importance:8
Popularity:8
Variety:8
Fit:7
Total:31
Notes: Dragon Roost Island is... an interesting choice... That does feel like it should be a console track. Not on the handheld. Linebeck's theme is a nice choice. Tal Tal Heights and Village of the Blue Maiden are good past tracks... Overworld is an interesting choice but as I said before... Zelda doesn't have to rely on other series. It's got tons of great tracks on its own. I've already commented on Hyrule Field. It's a decent choice. I do wish you included more Spirit Tracks music though... Also, why only seven tracks?
KingofPhamtoms47
Importance: 8
Popularity: 8
Variety: 8
Fit:8
Total: 32
Notes: I wasn't aware that Spirit Tracks had a remix of The Great Sea in it.
Fraaz Battle is a good choice. It's among the more popular boss themes in the series. Song of Storms is a nice past track to have but... This easily fits Gerudo Valley better. The Collector's Edition is a cool choice for a track. It sounds almost like the multiplayer theme from Phantom Hourglass! Demon Train is a cool choice. Pretty popular and pretty important. Linebeck's Theme is Linkbeck's Theme. It's a must have. Nice choices... but why only seven tracks?
T-J Works
Importance:9
Popularity:9
Variety:9
Fit:10
Total:37
Notes: The Enemy Approaches is kinda cool. Won't affect your grade though. The Byrne redux idea is a novel one and frankly, I wish Sakurai would do something like this. Unfortunately, I don't think he will. He's not cool enough. Still, an interesting choice. Ah Malladus Phase 2! Favorite track from Spirit Tracks. Frankly I'm surprised it wasn't on more lists. This theme is actually a remix of the Title Theme (WHICH NO ONE HAS WHY?!!?!?!) and Realm Overworld. It's a great choice. The Phantom Hourglass Title Screen is a great choice as is Linebeck's Theme. Molgera.... I do see what you're saying with the chicka chicka... Hm... Molgera fits well enough I guess. Nice choice for a past track. (If this wasn't a past track, I would have marked down your score, keep that in mind). Still, good pick. HYRULE TOWN!!! I'm sorry, but I honestly feel that this is the best possible song from Minish Cap.
Plus I really like it... Tal Tal Heights is a good way to finish off your list. Overall, it's a great list!
Toxicroaker
Importance:8
Popularity:8
Variety:8
Fit: 8
Total: 32
Notes: Vs Byrne is a good way to start off. Hyrule Castle is a track I'm surprised we didn't get more of. It's a pretty popular track. Nice choice. Tal Tal Heights is a fine choice for a past track! Mercay Island is an interesting choice. Most choices from Phantom Hourglass are Linebeck's Theme and the Title/Great Sea theme. Mercay Island is certainly interesting... Props for originality, but it just isn't that popular methinks. It's important sure but.... I rarely see or hear people talk about it...Spirit Tower Medley...Hmm.... It is important but as I said before.... These tracks do compare in comparison to several other Spirit Tracks tracks (lol). Still, love that first theme in the medley. Always so chilling! I love it. Minish Village is a decent choice. The Dark World theme is fake. I checked it out... Because of that, I won't include it on your list. So that could both help and hinder you. About your comments on the bottom...
- Pirate Ship had a maximum of 3 songs from the same game. The most being Wind Waker with Dragon Roost Island, The Great Sea and Molgera. Still four tracks is just fine. No need to worry.
- Addressed above... Try to stick away from "leaked" stuff.
Jumpman84
Importance:8
Popularity:8
Variety:10
Fit: 8
Total:34
Notes: I glance at your list and I will say. I appreciate the dates and consoles. Thanks! You and Turtles like to make my life more easy! :D The Tal Tal Heights is a good choice to start off with...Sea of Trees is something I just didn't see coming. Um...Seems popular enough. Linebeck's theme is always nice. Fleeing by Demon Train seems a tad repetitive... and I don't feel it can be remixed enough on its own... Minish Village is cool. Your Fairy theme medley seems... redundant... Why not just use one of them? They are the same theme after all. Just with slightly different tempos... I mean the FSA version works perfectly on its own for example. It's not the best choice for a medley, but a great choice for a song. That Tingle song... DAYUM!!! Those are some catchy tunes right there! I like it. Still there are better choices. Also TacturnArtist is amazing and lol and Links.
Olekidsf
Importance:8
Popularity:8
Variety: 6
Fit: 7
Total: 29
Notes: Byrne Helps is a nice choice! As are the past Brawl tracks, Main Theme and Tal Tal Heights. Linebeck's theme is great! The Wind Waker version of the Great Sea doesn't fit here at all... Especially when there is a handheld song that does its job just as well. Hyrule Field and Lost Woods would fit much better on the Gerudo Valley stage too... There are a lot of past tracks here... I'm counting four... That's half your list... Variety is gonna have to take a plunge... [/collapse]
[collapse="Frostwraith's Grades"]
A bit of trivia before the results: In the European version of Spirit Tracks, Byrne is called Staven.
Ascended
Importance: 9/10
Popularity: 9/10
Variety: 7/10
Fit: 10/10
Total: 35/40
Good list overall, though I think you used Spirit Tracks music a bit too much. Byrne's theme is good, but I'd have preferred if you used the battle version of the theme.
In The Fields and Castle Town are good choices for the stage and are fairly important songs in Spirit Tracks.
Your two Phantom Hourglass themes are very good choices. The title theme is a rearrangement of the sailing theme from Wind Waker and also plays when you're sailing the seas (albeit with some very slight differences in instrumentation) and, of course, Linebeck's theme is a popular choice and is the theme of an important character too.
Your GB Zelda choices are very good. The Oracle Medley would flow perfectly in the same arrangement especially with the title theme and overworld theme (which is originally from Link's Awakening) being arrangements of the classic Zelda theme.
Tal Tal Heights is one of the most memorable songs from Link's Awakening and appeared in Brawl mixed with the Overworld theme from Link's Awakening that also appeared in both Oracle games.
You could have used Minish Cap music, but this is still a very good list that meets all criteria.
Starphoenix
Importance: 8/10
Popularity: 9/10
Variety: 10/10
Fit: 10/10
Total: 37/40
You have the overworld themes from both DS Zeldas, two important boss themes and a popular song from Link's Awakening. Those are all good choices. The Oracle medley you suggest is an interesting choice and would represent the oracles themselves in musical form.
On your other two songs, the Overworld theme from For the Frog the Bell Tolls is a good choice and also appeared in Link's Awakening in Richard's house. Given both Link's Awakening and that game share the same music composers, the musical style wouldn't look out of place in this stage at all. On the StreetPass Quest song, it fits the stage, it's known among most 3DS users and from a game similar to Zelda, but I feel it could have given place to another, more known, Zelda song. Still not a bad choice at all and this is one of the best lists here.
God Robert's Cousin
Importance: 9/10
Popularity: 8/10
Variety: 9/10
Fit: 10/10
Total: 36/40
Good choices overall, though you could have replaced one of the songs from Spirit Tracks with something else, but it's me being nitpicky. All your songs fit the stage well too, which awards you with 10 points!
Your Oracle medley could flow nicely and it's a good way to represent the series in just one song. Minish Village is also a good choice and so is Title from Phantom Hourglass, which is also serves as its overworld theme (slight instrumentation differences aside).
shinpichu
Importance: 9/10
Popularity: 8/10
Variety: 8/10
Fit: 10/10
Total: 35/40
Your choices for Phantom Hourglass and Spirit Tracks songs are good, being important songs and fitting the stage nicely. Tal Tal Heights from Link's Awakening is also a good choice and yeah, you could have switched one of the Minish Cap songs with something else.
APC99
Importance: 8/10
Popularity: 8/10
Variety: 8/10
Fit: 10/10
Total: 34/40
Ballad of the Wind Fish! A good song that was meant to be in Brawl and could appear in this game. It's an important and popular song from Link's Awakening.
Choosing a song from A Link Between Worlds isn't a bad choice either, given it's a remix of the main Zelda theme. Linebeck and Byrne's themes are good popular choices too.
On the other hand, you have Dancing Dragon Dungeon and Minish Woods, which are fitting songs, but I don't feel that they have the degree of popularity that other songs have. Lost Woods is a good choice, being an important and iconic song, but I think that, being a song from Ocarina of Time, it would go better on the Ocarina of Time stage, Gerudo Valley.
BridgesWithTurtles
Importance: 9/10
Popularity: 9/10
Variety: 8/10
Fit: 10/10
Total: 36/40
You have very good choices for this stage. Vs. Bellum is a good choice and so is the boss theme from Minish Cap, though I think you could have just picked one of the two, given their similarities. I also think that Hyrule Field from Ocarina of Time would go better on the Gerudo Valley stage.
Violenceman
Importance: 8/10
Popularity: 8/10
Variety: 7/10
Fit: 10/10
Total: 33/40
You have some pretty odd choices out of more iconic songs. The version of Byrne's theme you've chosen is interesting and you have some popular themes too, such as Tal Tal Heights.
Your Linebeck medley isn't bad, but I'd prefer if you had the Gread Sea theme and Linebeck's theme separated to represent Phantom Hourglass.
Wi-Fi Battle isn't a bad choice being a remix of the main Zelda theme and Cursed Overworld feels a bit redundant with the already confirmed overworld song.
I feel you have too much songs from Spirit Tracks, when you could have used songs from the Oracle series.
Ariand/AEM
Importance: 9/10
Popularity: 9/10
Variety: 8/10
Fit: 10/10
Total: 36/40
You have good choices from Spirit Tracks with the Tower of Spirits song and The Final Exam, though I think you could have too much music from that game. You could have traded one of those music choices for Phantom Hourglass music. This made the difference in having an 8 instead of a 9 in the variety choice.
On your songs not from Spirit Tracks, you pretty much chose iconic songs from their respective games. Lastly, the songs you chose are very fitting for the stage.
watzup7856
Importance: 8/10
Popularity: 9/10
Variety: 8/10
Fit: 10/10
Total: 35/40
Good fitting choices and good variety of songs. I think Hyrule Field would fit better on Gerudo Valley. Dragon Roost Island is a nice choice.
My only nitpick is the Village of the Blue Maiden song that could easily be replaced by another Zelda theme, even though it's a remix of the classic Kakariko Village theme.
By the way, Village of the Blue Maiden is taken directly from Four Swords Adventures and isn't a Brawl arrangement.
KingofPhantoms47
Importance: 9/10
Popularity: 8/10
Variety: 7/10
Fit: 10/10
Total: 34/40
There's something that hurts your list: too much songs from Spirit Tracks. You could have given more love to the older games like Link's Awakening.
I do agree that Song of Storms from Brawl fits on this stage better, but considering it also contains Ganondorf's theme in the mix and is from Ocarina of Time, it wouldn't have been a bad choice for Gerudo Valley either.
TJ-Works
Importance: 9/10
Popularity: 9/10
Variety: 9/10
Fit: 10/10
Total: 37/40
A very good list with popular and important songs. Molgera is a good addition for this stage, as is much of Wind Waker's music, actually. You also have important songs from Phantom Hourglass and Spirit Tracks. Tal Tal Heights is one of the most popular songs from Link's Awakening and fits this stage as well.
Toxicroaker
Importance: 8/10
Popularity: 8/10
Variety: 9/10
Fit: 8/10
Total: 33/40
A good list, but not without its faults. From Phantom Hourglass, I think you should have chosen a different song, such as the more iconic Great Sea theme or the more popular Linebeck's theme, anyway it's still a fitting song for the stage.
Your Spirit Tower Medley is a nice idea too and Minish Village is a good choice for this stage as well.
On your A Link Between Worlds song, the fact that it's possibly fake made me lower your importance and popularity scorings. You took a high risk on this choice and hurt you badly.
Jumpman84
Importance: 8/10
Popularity: 8/10
Variety: 9/10
Fit: 10/10
Total: 35/40
First of all, nice choice on the Great Fairy Medley! Even though it's not exactly a medley since you chose several versions of the iconic songs. A new arrangement of the song that would take elements from its many versions would be very interesting.
The Sea of Trees song is an interesting choice, being an iconic song from the somewhat obscure Four Swords game, although it's relatively unknown compared to other, more popular songs.
You could have replaced the song from Tingle's game and favor a more known Zelda game, such as Link's Awakening.
Olekidsf
Importance: 9/10
Popularity: 9/10
Variety: 9/10
Fit: 9/10
Total: 36/40
My only nitpicks with this list is that the Ocarina of Time songs would be better on Gerudo Valley, especially Hyrule Field. I also think that you should have chosen another version of Byrne's theme or perhaps making a medley out of the several versions, but it's still a good choice. [/collapse]
[collapse="TumblrFamous's Grades"]
Ascended
Importance: 9
Popularity: 9
Variety: 8
Fit: 9
Total: 35/40
Notes: Pretty good selection. I felt like the songs you picked fit the stage very well. I like the Castle Town music, and while I never liked the Oracle music, I think it worked. Nicely done.
Starphoenix
Importance: 8
Popularity: 8
Variety: 9
Fit: 9
Total: 34/40
Notes: Nice songs. There were a few songs that I liked, but ultimately felt as if they weren't all that important to the franchise/stage/game. But overall, a solid list of songs. They all seem very fitting and different from each other.
God Robert's Cousin
Importance: 8
Popularity: 10
Variety: 9
Fit: 9
Total: 36/10
Notes: I loved loved loved the Oracle medley! And the rest of your songs worked perfectly! And plus, you have the SSBB version of Tal Tal Heights, so good job! I just have to say there were some songs that didn't make that much sense, that while still fit, it didn't feel all that memorable. But still, great job! Like always...
shinpichu
Importance: 10
Popularity: 9
Variety: 8
Fit: 9
Total: 36/40
Notes: You had everything there that needed to be there. That's what's important. No pros I can say, because it's pretty straightforward. They're all popular, fitting songs. However, I took off points for variety with the Minish Cap songs. They fit, but they would've worked best together instead of separate pieces.
APC99
Importance: 8
Popularity: 8
Variety: 10
Fit: 9
Total: 35/40
Notes: Very nice! While we have an OoT stage for the 3DS already, I feel there are some songs that could work well on this stage (like the Lost Woods). The Minish Woods was an odd choice, but it worked. There were some songs that weren't as iconic as others, though. You missed Tal Tal Height, which is kind of a big one. But still, great nonetheless!
BridgesWithTurtles
Importance: 9
Popularity: 8
Variety: 8
Fit: 10
Total: 35/40
Notes: Nice job! I liked all of your songs, and they all fit perfectly! However, I feel like the Hyrule Field theme would go better with a different stage. And it would be better if the two Minish Cap stages were together instead of their own separate songs. Great job, though!
Violenceman
Importance: 8
Popularity: 8
Variety: 8
Fit: 10
Total: 34/40
Notes: Way too much Spirit Tracks. That's the main issue. But it's pretty good, there was just one more nitpick: a lot of the songs don't seem too important to Zelda, or at least the handheld, cel-shaded Zelda games. I feel like you could've had better choices. Although, you do have that Byrne-Lullaby remix. SO MUCH BROWNIE POINTS.
Ariand/AEM
Importance: 9
Popularity: 9
Variety: 8
Fit: 10
Total: 36/40
Notes: There was quite a lot of Spirit Tracks on here, so I had to dock some points. Although, all of the songs fit perfectly! And they're pretty popular and iconic to boot. You took a risk with that and succeeded, but the major flaw was too much Spirit Tracks. If you replaced one of them with Tal Tal Heights or the PH Overworld, it'd be near perfection.
watzup7856
Importance: 9
Popularity: 9
Variety: 8
Fit: 10
Total: 36/40
Notes: Where are all the other handheld Zelda pieces? I mean, I love your selection, but it felt like it was missing some tracks. Like from the Minish Cap, or the Oracle games. Still, fine job, but could've used a bit of variety.
KingofPhantoms47
Importance: 9
Popularity: 9
Variety: 7
Fit: 10
Total: 34/40
Notes: My good friend, you have faced the same problem nearly everyone else has faced: way too much Spirit Tracks. All of them work out perfectly, it just felt very bland when you have so much potential with the other handheld Zeldas. Good list, but missing those other older games.
TJ-Works
Importance: 9
Popularity: 9
Variety: 9
Fit: 9
Total: 36/40
Notes: One of my favorites! You seem to represent all of it perfectly. I love the Molgera theme, it's actually my third favorite Zelda track (next to Sheik's theme and Zelda's Lullaby), but I feel it'd be better off on the probable WW stage we will get for the Wii U.
Toxicroaker
Importance: 8
Popularity: 9
Variety: 9
Fit: 8
Total: 34/40
Notes: What got me was the Dark World theme. It did not seem to fit at all. I think it'd be better if you had the ALttP Dark World instead. But everything else seemed to work. The Mercay Island was a little weird though. Those two pieces just seemed to throw me off...
Jumpman84
Importance: 8
Popularity: 8
Variety: 9
Fit: 10
Total: 35/40
Notes: Wow... I see my scoring is identical to Frost's. Anyway, Tingle's "theme" isn't all popular or iconic, Tingle himself isn't even all that popular. And a lot of the songs you have aren't very important to those handheld Zelda cel-shaded games. Fitting? Definitely, but I didn't find it important enough to be on the stage.
Olekidsf
Importance: 9
Popularity: 9
Variety: 9
Fit: 10
Total: 37/40
Notes: Nicely done! That Byrne theme was sublime, putting a twist on my favorite Zelda piece. (I haven't played ST in a while, so forgive me) All the rest was amazing and fitting, just I felt that the OoT and WW overworld themes would have been best on other stages, not this one. They still fit, but they'd be better off on a different Zelda stage. [/collapse]
[collapse="Luco's Grades"]
Ascended:
Rawr!
Importance: 10/10
Popularity: 9/10
Variety: 8/10
Fit: 9/10
Total: 36
A very solid list. My only real thing was that the overworld theme would need some remixing to have that moving feel - even for a GB pick, it feels very walky-slashy world rather than open wide expanses movement... um, if that makes sense XD.That said, your general picks were a REALLY solid bunch and in fact I think pretty much all of them are REALLY important to the series so congrats on my first 10 of scoring! (But i'm nice so you mightn't be the only one!) 
I didn't mark you down really on the overworld thing in the end. It could be easily remixed to fit the stage fine haha. Very nice high score!
Star:
Like usual, a strong lineup. Can't believe i'm scoring you and not the other way around. Something about this kinda feels wrong...
Importance: 7/10
Popularity: 9/10
Variety: 9/10
Fit: 10/10
Total: 35
One of the most fitting (heh) soundtracks for a stage i've heard in ages. Even the Vaati song, which although felt a tad repetitive, did feel to me like it represented the stage really skillfully. In fact, on that point, I debated on whether to give it a 9 or a 10 due to the fact that the song wasn't one i'd particularly listen to if I didn't play the game. But I gave the 10 based on its merits to the stage rather than my personal perceptions of it. You pulled up some really unknown stuff but it resulted in an awesome playlist. I wouldn't mind seeing that one with a few more tossed in. =D
Also loved the variety with Nayru's and Din's. I don't know why but I didn't find it hard at all to imagine a remix for the stage that would make it fit - Nayru's especially has an airy feel to it that kinda makes me feel like i'm floating....
Shinpichu:
Hey man!
Importance: 9/10
Popularity: 8/10
Variety: 9/10
Fit: 9/10
Total: 35
Congratulations on finding like the first Minish Cap song that I really, really liked (it's overworld theme) haha. A fine overworld and quite fitting! Your other picks were pretty stock standard so you didn't really have to worry about a loss of marks from me, just that a tune from OoA or OoS as a retro experience other than just tal Tal heights would have really made this one beautiful. Not bad though, very good!
(I notice as I do more and more of these, it becomes harder to give low scores - yay! - because people are often choosing the same ones! Hahaha )
APC99:
Ditties I see! Well then! :-)
Importance: 8/10
Popularity: 9/10
Variety: 8/10
Fit: 8/10
Total: 33
I loved dancing dragon dungeon (maybe i'm just a sucker for OoA and OoS! ) in your playlist haha. For the most part it was fairly stock standard, though I felt like the lost woods was a bit weird when considering the movement of a train through open fields. Perhaps a forest area? Hm...
The other issue I had was most of your picks went away from Spirit Tracks. Where's the Spirit Tracks lovin', my good sir? So many awesome tracks to pick in addition to Byrne's and the Overworld! Fractured overworld, town theme, castle theme.... all picks i've seen that I really enjoyed. :-D
For the most part though, decent picks, decent score. Good work, sir. :-)
Watzup7856:
NESSAMATRON! Um, I mean, hello there fellow PSI kid user! :3
Importance: 9/10
Popularity: 9/10
Variety: 8/10
Fit: 10/10
Total: 36
Another REALLY fitting playlist. I could easily imagine every one of those songs on the stage in some form or another. WHY DID NO-ONE ELSE PICK VILLAGE OF THE BLUE MAIDEN UNTIL NOW?? ;_;
In any case, importance was substituted for fit in the Overworld theme of 'Kaeru No Tame Ni Kane Wa Naru' and although the game isn't the most well known I thought it was a good choice and didn't really try to take much away for it.
Good work man, very good score from me!
ONTO THE NEXT!
KingofPhantoms:
I'll always love your charmander gifs! <3
Importance: 8/10
Popularity: 9/10
Variety: 8/10
Fit: 9/10
Total: 34
Fun playlist with some curious picks. DARN YOU FOR PUTTING IN THE FINAL BOSS THEME FOR SPIRIT TRACKS SEEING AS I ONLY JUST GOT PAST A PART I WAS STUCK IN!!!! Judge gotta do what a judge gotta do, though. @.@
Anywho, A decent remix of Song of Storms might be able to do the track theme some justice, though in its current form I think its more suited for the ship theme (thus why the brawl version was made that way). Not bad, though.
My main concern with this list was you didn't put as much retro stuff in. (;_ I really would've loved a Link's Awakening theme or an Oracle theme or a Link between worlds/Link to the past song. :-D I count LttP as viable because of LbW, you see.
But still, very nice!
TJ works:
Dem Spoilers.
Importance: 9/10
Popularity: 8/10
Variety: 9/10
Fit: 9/10
Total: 35
ANOTHER SPOILER FOR ME TO CRY ABOUT!!! ;_;
A very different but valid and refreshing list. I really enjoyed listening to your picks and thought they were well thought out and placed. Though this surprised me a bit, your tracks are all quite heavily important too for such variety. I was really pleased with this list and so should you! I do see your point on the Oracle games but I feel they'd be better for this stage. Aw well.
Toxicroaker:
Red text is... definitely noticeable! :3
Importance: 8/10
Popularity: 8/10
Variety: 9/10
Fit: 7/10
Total: 32
Decent playlist, though I feel you skipped out some really important tracks in some cases (Linebeck, for instance, or the dystopic overworld). Quite a few of the ones there felt a bit too calm and relaxing for the stage too, although I really liked your decision to use the tower and make it a medley to suit the track theme.
Unfortunately the Dark World theme there appears to be fake, however since LttP is like my favourite zelda game of all time, it's pretty easy for me to see it being used, which I liked.
Overall, decent. I liked the variety, I just felt it lacked some tracks that would've done the stage so much justice. But not bad! :-)
Jumpman84:
MOAR SPOILERS! No I mean really, third time's the charm and by the end of this i'll have heard every Spirit tracks ending-ish area theme. :3
Importance: 8/10
Popularity: 8/10
Variety: 9/10
Fit: 8/10
Total: 33
Not a bad list, although tingle's theme was ummm.... unexpected! Nothing too nitpicky here, I enjoyed the file screen/fairy medley, thought it'd be great if it could build up, though at the same time imagining it on a train stage took some creativity. Not bad though, decent picks. And indeed, the tribute to retro... I was happy. ^_^
Olekidsf:
Hope you enjoy your time on the boards! :-D
Importance:10/10
Popularity: 9/10
Variety: 8/10
Fit: 9/10
Total: 36
Hmm, be careful with songs not from 3DS stages, I think that was part of the special ruleset. :o
Aside from this, one of the most solid tracks i've seen. Very well chosen in that you took really important tracks from everywhere. I liked Link's Awakening Tal Tal Heights but I feel like i'd like a tiny bit more retro in there at some point. Still, really nice, definitely a list to be happy about. :-D
Agreed btw that the stages will probably have more to them. Although we're grading you on what you've chosen, it's realised that the stage will probably have more. Heck, thats the reason why we can like so many different types of lists!
Ariand/AEM:
Hey I missed this! Why'd I miss this! Oh well, found it now. :D
Importance: 8/10
Popularity: 9/10
Variety: 9/10
Fit: 9/10
Total: 35
Solid song list. LOVE THE USE OF FINAL EXAM, dunno why nobody else used it.
Not too much to say on it, as i've said before I feel like Vaati's theme needs a bit of re-working but I won't mark you down on it because it does fit.
Uhm, hooray? :D
Now GRC, the first one I noticed:
Importance: 8/10
Popularity: 8/10
Variety: 9/10
Fit: 9/10
Total: 34
Notes: First of all, the Oracle medley sent me back to way back when I was playing those games as a young pre-adolescent. Good stuff! And the Dancing Dragon dungeon at the end of that medley sounds really solid (not to mention it's one of my absolute favourite songs from that game so ya might've caught me there, just a bit. XD). Minish Village had both really fitting and kinda non-fitting moments and I feel like that was mainly what stopped your fit from being a 10, however I think a remix of the song could quite possibly eliminate that problem and most of your other songs were just spot on, so a 9. Your other songs were solid, though sometimes zelda has that issue where the boss battle themes are fit for stationary battles and not moving ones. That said, I don't count it against you. Finally, the Tal tal heights return I feel was the PERFECT song to finish off. Not only is it a really loved remix but it fits the moving, open feel of the stage to like, the most awesome degree I can think of.
So yeah, good stuff!
Bridges with Turtles!
Importance: 8/10
Popularity: 8/10
Variety: 8/10
Fit: 9/10
Total: 33
Okay, so, I really liked the town theme. Actually, this carried across pretty much all of your tunes and you kinda picked up on it - but the thing that really gave it the fit to the stage was the use of the beat in your tunes. The beat is like the chug of a train and helps keep the feel of a moving stage. This was why I loved your town pick so much. Listening to it and imagining a fight on board the train just went really well together, even more so than I originally thought and what you would think when not listening to it.
You went a little in to the unknown in terms of your choices but they were weird and wacky and I kinda liked it. Nice work. :-)
Next one, for Violenceman. ^_^
Okay so
Importance: 9/10
Popularity: 7/10
Variety: 9/10
Fit: 8/10
Total: 33
I liked the overall theme of your medley. There were a few songs where, at moments I felt a bit underwhelmed (a couple of the songs from the Medley seemed like they had to be at particular times of the stage to fit well, for instance), however for the most part I liked your picks. What really made me go "YES!" was your 'cursed overworld'. My third review and I hadn't seen that yet and I was so sad that no-one had picked it, so you getting that in there to me was a really big 'awesomeness' moment and I loved listening to it even though I knew exactly what I was gonna hear.
A few odd picks that came from surprising sources. However, other choices really picked the list up and carried it along, so i'm pretty happy. ^_^
(I think i'm done!) [/collapse]
[collapse="Final Grades"]Ascended: 140
StarPhoenix: 138
God Robet's Cousin: Pyrosphere (140)
shinpichu (Dad): 141
APC99: 135
BridgesWithTurtles: 140
Violenceman: 134
Ariand / AEM: 140
watzup7856: 138
KingofPhantoms47: 134
T-J Works: 145
Toxicroaker: 131
Jumpman84: 137
Olekidsf: 138[/collapse]
This rounds winner is....
T-J Works!
Congratulations. I'll update the youtube channel and the wall of honor with your list. As usual, you have half a day to mull over results. Also I'm mean now. 
