Except, Other M established beforehand that clones were present on the ship, so really, she should've at least considered the matter that Ridley could be one of them.
That won't make her be unable to have a panic attack, you know. They're something that doesn't logically come up, they just happen. Welcome to how they work, they're random and irrational.
Ironically, you ignored my point completely. The argument is there's an inconsistency in how it's portrayed. You say it's established, but the manga established it completely differently then how it's done in Other M. In the manga, it's supposed to be used in a method of character growth (yes I know that's not how it works in real life, but that's how the manga did it), but Other M tries to do it differently. So really, Other M is the only instance that tries to establish it in the way it's portrayed in that game.
Big deal. Tons of games are inconsistent. Shadow the Hedgehog has inconsistencies with Sonic Adventure 2's story. Still part of the actual main storyline regardless. Mistakes happen.
Also, nothing suggested that she feared multiple Ridleys, at least not in the context of the story nor her freakout. She was just scared of the one in front of her and that's the best we get from it.
Then they should've make it more obvious what the case was. I didn't say it was written perfectly. Cause that's unreasonable to say. I never thought that. I agree that it has problems. I'm more concerned with other stuff anyway.
If we're going for realism, I'll just point to this
I, notably, was not. I am saying that these things are fairly irrational anyway. I know panic attacks happen, and you can't control them. That's just how it is. However, in the context of the story? It can be different from real life, and that's okay too. Whether you like how it was portrayed or not, it can be portrayed that way.
Anyway, I'm honestly done with this conversation. Had a somewhat rough dinner due to my false teeth, so I need a break right now. Sorry. Please don't make me try to continue.