Skies of Arcadia Mafia - Game Over! Indy (AM) Wins!

[Aggressive Mediation]

Orbo prior to Gheb. J prior to Gheb. We'll fry KevMo/Gheb after we lynch the much more solid choices of Orbo and J. I do not understand why you are so scared that town is going to be ****ed when there's about four players who are almost certainly town, there's a dead scumbag, and it's Day 3 with no night kill and only a recruit (who we've almost certainly caught already) to change our numbers.

Seriously. I'm town, Soup's town, MM's town, JTB's probably town, and Lego's probably town when J flips scum. That leaves Rockin, Gheb, KevMo, J, and Orbo and this is prior to anyone factoring in any night phase information in an all PR game.

@Gheb - Assuming one flips scum, will the other remain in your lynchpool?

 

[Marshmellowman]

@ soup

you can use your roleblock tonight aye?

 

[Marshmellowman]

btw if anyones online and not voting orbo post so we can get an alley oop goin

 

[#HBC | ѕoup]

@ soup

you can use your roleblock tonight aye?

ay e

 

[Marshmellowman]

@ gheb

a slot neither of usve given a **** about all game and even tried to kill d1 is -2. neither of us are voting him. if you want i can engage you in argument but lets be real here

1. this WILL turn into an obnoxious wall battle that no one wants to read and neither of us want to type (ok just me at least). i say this cuz the way youre setting up this argument is void to be a pain in the ***. look at your post on j. i feel bad for him. if i was in his shoes id just tell you to shut the **** up and for no one in town to listen to you regardless of my alignment

2. another typhoon might be on the way so i dunno if i can even do this this dayphase

3. i will probably want to kill you later in the game regardless of the outcome and i probably wont die since i seem to universally be considered town minus ****ty recruiting speculation

so do we really have to do this?

 

[#HBC | Red Ryu]

Gheb serious just shut the **** up.

All you have done is sit on your fat *** all day and scream from the top of a mountain, "LAK must go" just because I'm here. You haven't brought up **** about why this is a pro town idea or any sort of reference as to why this is a good idea.

The only even remotely seeable reference is ERB, which has my slot soing things I stopped doing, gambits, problems with acvivity, Joey got really sick and I was off in Hearts mafia trying to sort out the BS going on. I learned from that and moved on, you've been stuck to this thought without even a second thought.

"He's useless" Cool beans you've shown nothing just like Kevin has with my play or even what is that bad with it. Nothing, zip, nada, you've done **** with persuading anything this game and keep to a policy lynch in the face of a mason claim.

Your ****ing terrible status to lynches and pushes, you've done little to analyze play on multiple players only doing it when it is easy like Orbo.

~

On a side note.

Why are we considering lynching J over the mentor/recruiter when killing them would kill J/whoever was recruited? J can only be recruited if we lynch him they can recruit another person. So why would we lynch J if he can only be scum via recruit?

Kill the originals it kills the recruited member.

I'm gonna still wait on Orbo or a replacement for a claim.

Gheb, Lego, Rockin, is where we should go otherwise.

 

[Lovably Adorable Kanine]

Gheb serious just shut the **** up.

All you have done is sit on your fat *** all day and scream from the top of a mountain, "LAK must go" just because I'm here. You haven't brought up **** about why this is a pro town idea or any sort of reference as to why this is a good idea.

The only even remotely seeable reference is ERB, which has my slot soing things I stopped doing, gambits, problems with acvivity, Joey got really sick and I was off in Hearts mafia trying to sort out the BS going on. I learned from that and moved on, you've been stuck to this thought without even a second thought.

"He's useless" Cool beans you've shown nothing just like Kevin has with my play or even what is that bad with it. Nothing, zip, nada, you've done **** with persuading anything this game and keep to a policy lynch in the face of a mason claim.

Your ****ing terrible status to lynches and pushes, you've done little to analyze play on multiple players only doing it when it is easy like Orbo.

~

On a side note.

Why are we considering lynching J over the mentor/recruiter when killing them would kill J/whoever was recruited? J can only be recruited if we lynch him they can recruit another person. So why would we lynch J if he can only be scum via recruit?

Kill the originals it kills the recruited member.

I'm gonna still wait on Orbo or a replacement for a claim.

Gheb, Lego, Rockin, is where we should go otherwise.

Quoting and stuff, probs need to have that convo with J and John soon.

 

[Marshmellowman]

Gheb serious just shut the **** up.

All you have done is sit on your fat *** all day and scream from the top of a mountain, "LAK must go" just because I'm here. You haven't brought up **** about why this is a pro town idea or any sort of reference as to why this is a good idea.

The only even remotely seeable reference is ERB, which has my slot soing things I stopped doing, gambits, problems with acvivity, Joey got really sick and I was off in Hearts mafia trying to sort out the BS going on. I learned from that and moved on, you've been stuck to this thought without even a second thought.

"He's useless" Cool beans you've shown nothing just like Kevin has with my play or even what is that bad with it. Nothing, zip, nada, you've done **** with persuading anything this game and keep to a policy lynch in the face of a mason claim.

Your ****ing terrible status to lynches and pushes, you've done little to analyze play on multiple players only doing it when it is easy like Orbo.

~

On a side note.

Why are we considering lynching J over the mentor/recruiter when killing them would kill J/whoever was recruited? J can only be recruited if we lynch him they can recruit another person. So why would we lynch J if he can only be scum via recruit?

Kill the originals it kills the recruited member.

I'm gonna still wait on Orbo or a replacement for a claim.

Gheb, Lego, Rockin, is where we should go otherwise.

yeah gheb this guy is really a great play and should be in a lynchpool

 

[Marshmellowman]

something im learning from this game and others:

me/j/macman/dancer think and reach conclusions very differently from ryker/laundry/kevin/xonar regardless of our alignments. ghebs kind of in the middle

 

[#HBC | J]

Can we just kill my slot already? Like, I really don't want to respond to Gheb's last big post at me because it's just so....bad...and wrong. I also really don't wanna turn this into a wall battle where Gheb is getting really upset at every little thing I do when the fact is I wasn't recruited, but no one seems to believe that fact. If I am to die toDay, people will get my flip (which will be normal Mason) and you will be able to lynch Gheb/Lego/KevinM.

As a side-note: Gheb, quit being so disrespectful to RR. He isn't that bad as you say he is and it's just rude to try and lynch people off that prejudice you have and also to just throw their name through the ground all game long and act like it's alright, when it's not.

I may end up responding when I get the time to.

 

[Marshmellowman]

who gives a **** of gheb gets upset?

one good thing about j dying: gheb gets to be ****ed outta hear

 

[Lovably Adorable Kanine]

We're not lynching J.

If J was recruited, lynching the mentor will net him dead anyways.

 

[KevinM]

I can't believe you're defending that bolded statement MM..

 

[Marshmellowman]

what am i defending?

am i scum or not kevin?

 

[Marshmellowman]

btw ruy

vote orbo? why slow the inevitable?

 

[Marshmellowman]

oh you mean the thing that lak said

yeah. no issue with that at the moment. do you think lak is likelier tove been recruited or something?

 

[Marshmellowman]

itt

> kevin/gheb share voting history with me all game

itt

> kevin/gheb waste energy calling masons dumb/useless d1 and d2

itt

> kevin/gheb say its suspicious for me to argue recruiting shenanigans while a wagon happens

itt

> kevin/gheb act like im dumb d3 after 2 days of harmony

 

[Aggressive Mediation]

I feel it imperative to point out that a recruiter flip where no death occurs is a possibility, but it's something we can react to.

I also want to point out how J regurgitated Marshy's line about not wanting to respond to Gheb which would be a lot more okay if he would respond to the little things from me and not have just volunteered to be lynched when the only thing anyone is really accusing him of is being recruited (meaning he's NOT the one who should go first in any case).



@Marshy - About the getting reads differently, it's interesting and I want to post about it in mafia theory discussion or social after the game. Gheb isn't in the middle, he's on another planet.

 

[#HBC | J]

Volunteering for lynch = Joke

;P

 

[~ Gheb ~]

@ gheb

a slot neither of usve given a **** about all game and even tried to kill d1 is -2. neither of us are voting him. if you want i can engage you in argument but lets be real here

1. this WILL turn into an obnoxious wall battle that no one wants to read and neither of us want to type (ok just me at least). i say this cuz the way youre setting up this argument is void to be a pain in the ***. look at your post on j. i feel bad for him. if i was in his shoes id just tell you to shut the **** up and for no one in town to listen to you regardless of my alignment

2. another typhoon might be on the way so i dunno if i can even do this this dayphase

3. i will probably want to kill you later in the game regardless of the outcome and i probably wont die since i seem to universally be considered town minus ****ty recruiting speculation

so do we really have to do this?

What / Who are you even talking about?

yeah gheb this guy is really a great play and should be in a lynchpool

Yes, he should. Destroy him before he destroys us.

 

[Marshmellowman]

and we were going to be such good friends this game too j

 

[Marshmellowman]

gheb im saying you/me have beef but if we argued it would just be annoying and a pain in the *** and since youre here we can kill orbo and everyones happy

so whats good?

 

[Marshmellowman]

man

lets just lynch orbo and be done with this

 

[~ Gheb ~]

Can we just kill my slot already? Like, I really don't want to respond to Gheb's last big post at me because it's just so....bad...and wrong.

Then point out why. "It's so bad" is not a legitimate counter-argument and just confirms to me that you're incapeable of actually responding to it. I mean, I don't expect you to suddenly to see the light unless you start crying to me post-game like you did when you almost blew up in MK's revenge. Same scenario - you just don't wanna see things if they don't go the way you want them to go and that's what happens right now. Rather than looking for a constructive solution to things you're looking for somebody you can blame. That's not how you hunt scum.

As a side-note: Gheb, quit being so disrespectful to RR. He isn't that bad as you say he is and it's just rude to try and lynch people off that prejudice you have and also to just throw their name through the ground all game long and act like it's alright, when it's not.

I may end up responding when I get the time to.

There's no prejudice included. I'm sticking to the facts and the facts are that he single-handedly destroyed town in ERB and that he didn't do **** all game so far other than push bad plays. It's not even a question of me respecting him or not [I have no issues with him as a person] it's a matter of town being likely incapeable of winning as long as his slot has any sort of influence over the town.
Speaking about disrespect, who was the one between him and me that insulted the other *personally* first? Right, it was him who started to call me a moron so don't look at me first when it comes to disrespect. I'm drawing the consequences of his bad play and try to minimize our losses - he just insults me.

 

[Lovably Adorable Kanine]

Marsh, I know you are all about saying, "**** claims" but on the chance he flips town wouldn't just waiting to see what info he might have to be useful?

 

[~ Gheb ~]

gheb im saying you/me have beef but if we argued it would just be annoying and a pain in the *** and since youre here we can kill orbo and everyones happy

so whats good?

I don't know what argument you're talking about still.

Also, why are you complaining about my case on J being unfair? Not only did he start the whole thing but he also made an even longer case yet failing to point out how any of it adds up to me being supposedly scum. He just cherry picked a few minor points and made it look like a huge case. But when I'm working my *** off to debunk that **** you're saying I'm asking too much off J?

 

[Marshmellowman]

i was going to be an *** and respond with just "**** claims" but

i really dont give a **** about any of orbos results

lol. what if he was tracker and bingod scum. meh. dont care

 

[Lovably Adorable Kanine]

There's no prejudice included. I'm sticking to the facts and the facts are that he single-handedly destroyed town in ERB and that he didn't do **** all game so far other than push bad plays. It's not even a question of me respecting him or not [I have no issues with him as a person] it's a matter of town being likely incapeable of winning as long as his slot has any sort of influence over the town.
Speaking about disrespect, who was the one between him and me that insulted the other *personally* first? Right, it was him who started to call me a moron so don't look at me first when it comes to disrespect. I'm drawing the consequences of his bad play and try to minimize our losses - he just insults me.

I find calling me a policy lynch without a care of a current play and situation to be very disrespectful and insulting.

But seeing how you said I was the solo reason in ERB at to why town lost, I know how far I can value your input.

Laughable at best.

 

[~ Gheb ~]

So why are people still acting like I'm anywhere close at pushing a LAK lynch again?

Laughable at best.

 

[Marshmellowman]

so can you guys get back to THIS game and vote orbo?

 

[#HBC | J]

I'm going to respond to both Gheb and AM.

Then I'll contemplate hammering Orbo.

I also chuckled at Gheb telling me I don't know how to hunt scum. =P

 

[~ Gheb ~]

You have yet to prove yourself to be good at it so yeah

 

[Aggressive Mediation]

i was going to be an *** and respond with just "**** claims" but

i really dont give a **** about any of orbos results

lol. what if he was tracker and bingod scum. meh. dont care

If he had a bingo and didn't manage to find SOME time with internet to get on long enough to spill it, then there would have to be some SEVERE problems.

I'm not particularly worried about Orbo's claim, especially with masons already on the board. If he gets on, he should claim and we should be careful about an unnecessary CC. If he doesn't I lose no sleep at all.

The only thing I can see as a reason to wait is to let JTB catch up seeing as he was supposed to be here today. He can give you the alley.

 

[Aggressive Mediation]

So why are people still acting like I'm anywhere close at pushing a LAK lynch again?

Laughable at best.

That's the thing. Put him on blast for keeping the LAK and MM options open, but where he's pushed to lynch today has been right calls.

 

[~ Gheb ~]

I think we should stop getting sidetracked now.

J please don't drop hammer if you make another longass post about me. Do either one or the other but not both at the same time.

That's the thing. Put him on blast for keeping the LAK and MM options open, but where he's pushed to lynch today has been right calls.

Why the mention of MM?

Are you guys all terrible at reading or are my post *that* hard to understand? ;_;

 

[Aggressive Mediation]

Why the mention of MM?

Because while, yes, you are pushing J/Orbo, you are certainly treating MM like a secondary lynch.

If I had to say your lynch order right now, it would be:

Orbo
J
LAK
MM

Meanwhile you aren't willing to lynch:

Rockin
Yourself

I have no clue what your stance on myself, KevMo, Legolas, JTB, or Soup is.

 

[~ Gheb ~]

MM isn't even suspicious in my book. I also never mentioned him as such so I have no idea why you get that idea. If I thought he were scum I'd tell you so and would try to get him lynched rather than trying to convince him that J is scum -.-

 

[Marshmellowman]

gheb if you had the chance right now would you lynch lak

 

[#HBC | J]

Gheb, what are you planning on doing when I flip town then? AM is at least considering other options yet you are just being stubborn and have it "narrowed down" to me or MM being the recruited scum.

 

[~ Gheb ~]

Only if Orbo, J and AM aren't lynch options. Otherwise I'd lynch any of those first.