it would make sense for this game to have a cop especially since there is no doc (unless xsyven comes out and claims doc). so im not going to say vyse is lying just cus he got his math wrong, im guessing he just forgot to count himself when coming up with the 5 vanilla town = 5 teams theory. but because of that we probably cant clear xsyven based on flavor.
Yeah, actually I thought about that earlier today and remembered that. Maybe Teran's got the 5th uniform? idk. It'll be clearer once we get another result.
vyse - do you basically just think that a jersey = townie and a non jersey item = power role and/or mafia?
That
was my theory, but I'm not sure now.
Here are a few reads:
Tom
I feel like I can instantly clear him from a post he made from the very beginning of the game:
http://www.smashboards.com/showpost.php?p=9295225&postcount=39
confirmed....
even though i am town aligned, i got a safe claim, but it was my real flavor name.
I don’t think any mafia aligned player would say that, and it’s funny because I don’t think anybody else really questioned it then. After reading ahead, I see you were the one to bring that up that fact yourself.
Moving past that and RVS, he dropped off for more than a little while, but since then he’s been active enough, so I’m not going to bring that up again.
Around about here Tom starts defending Kevin against Steel’s questioning, which CK picks up on and calls it distancing between Tom/Steel. It seems more like TomTown refuting an argument he doesn’t agree with.
Another good post from Tom I feel
is this one where he refutes the idea of his play being scummy since if he was being inactive + was scum he would have ridden the CK lynch wagon.
His play today gives me good vibes. He was the one to first strategise the idea of no-lynching to let me investigate, and I don’t think Scum would actively direct Town in that direction.
Kevin
I’ve already commented on what little I can glean from your early play when I mentioned Tom defending you. It’s no secret that you play the way you do and because of that you are unreadable at times. [/coolstorybro]
Point is, I feel he’s been trying to start wagons all game to really force this conception of him. But a few times he has backed off, when he decides his mind has changed/it seems like nobody is going to hop on. I didn’t like how he tried to wagon Teran again straight off on Day 2, and I don’t like much of his play toDay as well (particularly, how hard he was trying to push a lynch until finally giving in to Tom’s logic).
Xsyven
All or more of his posts piggy back on the ideas of others, probably because of his inactivity.
Xsyven’s attack on Teran’s play I felt was unfounded after all of Teran’s defences, and then moved to Air, a vote he coasted with til the end of the day.
Due to a lack of posts, it’s hard to construct a decent read on him. His day 2 play isn’t very interesting or revealing, and toDay he seems to think there’s something fishy about my claim (which I suppose I don’t blame). It’s this uninteresting, unrevealing play that led me to investigate him.
Steel
Day 1 there was the really quick unvote you made on air. The one post from that debacle that concerns me the most
is this one where he seems to be searching for a reason to unvote. When nobody commented, you unvoted, and cleared your name from the wagon. Still, it’s a WIFOM guessing game as to your intentions, but scum is definitely plausible.
HOWEVER, Day 2
I liked how you defended yourself from the repercussions of doing this. A bit like Tom did in post #340.
Your play is active and generally helpful but some things don’t sit well with me, particularly in the early game (airgemini debacle + You Vs. CK).
Vote: No Lynch
