Scott Pilgrim vs. The Mafia | GAME OVER: Infinite Sadness/Finest Hour

[soupamarioyoshiluigiwario]

i hate doing something without marshy's input but sure

vote: FML

 

[#HBC | J]

What does Bard flipping town tell you exactly ? What about me ?

Bard's flip isn't the point of the plan. His role is the point. If Bard flips town, it starts a good paper trail and will give us insight on players like Nabe-babe/Kary. You flipping town would also be good in the fact of being able to dissemble your wagon. Regardless of your flip, find scum from your wagon/interactions can be done. I can only speak for myself, but during the night phase of the game I'll be re-reading the game after the lynch to debate where I want to go next.

 

[FullMetalLynch]

J.

Why did you vote Marshy when you clearly laid out how much better I was over and over ?

 

[FullMetalLynch]

Alright, I'll save you the trouble.

I'm going to flip town.

Who's scum on my wagon ? Who's town ?

 

[BarDulL]

unvote

 

[#HBC | J]

J.

Why did you vote Marshy when you clearly laid out how much better I was over and over ?

Uh, where have I said that you were better over and over? I even said in the post I voted S&M that they were my strongest scum-read. You have a lot of more coonnections then S&M which I believe I have said which in the end does make for a better D1 lynch, but I was perfectly comfortable with my S&M vote.

 

[BarDulL]

Rake, let's say J's plan goes through and I get lynched. Who should I shoot?

 

[FullMetalLynch]

Gova all day.

All.

Day.

 

[#HBC | J]

Also FML, if you are truly town, why are you not fighting more adamantly against your lynch and trying to give an alternative for us to lynch. Yes, you've suggested BW but you have more or less sat on the fact that his reaction/replacement was scummy and what you have said earlier on in the day. If you are town, your play at this point can just be described as apathetic to dying or not. I also cannot answer your question honestly without reading more in-depth but off your wagon at the moment I would say this:

Kanty - Towny(bit absent now but his posts in the beginning were good)
KevinM - Null-lean town
Ruy - Town
PBJ - Dummy or Scummy after his debate with Gova. Debating which side. I liked his post towards Bardull but that's more because it was common sense.
S&M - My opinion's kind of clear on this one

Bardull was on your wagon and I literally have no read on him since all he is and what he has chosen to make himself completely about is his role and his role to me is a liability regardless of alignment that needs to be dealt with sooner rather than later.

 

[BarDulL]

I'd rather shoot J though.

That cool with you, J?

Rake, is it because Gova is null?

 

[FullMetalLynch]

J. for the longest time, and even in your post where you called em a strong scum read you kept repeating that you agreed / were sorta kinda behind me an I was going to be the play.

So what made marshy your priority.

From your pov your letting "the best lynch " an your feel as my lynch being a scum one to boot, run around for reason. When you could have ended me long ago.

 

[FullMetalLynch]

If i'm not fighting my lynch, Bardull is a ham sandwhich.

 

[#HBC | J]

J. for the longest time, and even in your post where you called em a strong scum read you kept repeating that you agreed / were sorta kinda behind me an I was going to be the play.

So what made marshy your priority.

From your pov your letting "the best lynch " an your feel as my lynch being a scum one to boot, run around for reason. When you could have ended me long ago.

Because I would rather scum-hunt and investigate a slot I felt more preeminent then your slot which had a butt load of intention in the world. Marshy's slot came in with something I deemed more worthy of myself looking into then the sheer fact of just joining you and twiddling my thumbs. I agreed to your lynch and still do while still being behind it.

@Bardull: If you did shoot me, you'd be god-tier awful. You are literally only saying that you want to shoot me because you are going to be butthurt that I pointed out a logical plan and it simply involves you dying.

 

[BarDulL]

I was playfully teasing J. I was serious about your Gova read though.

 

[#HBC | J]

Alright Bardull, then offer me an alternative for you to stop the scum-team from alpha-striking you when they have an opportunity? If you can do that and garuntee that it is fool proof, you can live in my book.

 

[#HBC | Joker]

Lol, how do I go from "townbro" to "dummy or scummy" just based on Gova coming in and talking nonsense?

 

[#HBC | J]

I was playfully teasing J. I was serious about your Gova read though.

Lord, I am way to serious after debating with Soup. I'm going to go play some league and stay away from this game now that I've laid out all I want to for now and let other people post/respond. My gova read or FML's though?

 

[FullMetalLynch]

J, the only alternative I have, is a scum lean on Marshtomp because him calling my reaction to Zen was calculated from mypov. Especially considering he still hasn't addressed how it could be knee-jerk , when Zen had already passed the interaction off.

My only other feel is your null-scumish here because you've essentially sat on me for the better part of the day and your intent to remain non-commital until just the point where my lynch seems likeliest doesn't read as town to me right now. Not to mention you've flat out avoided going into any real depth on your read in me, especially when it's me asking you to do so. If your not purposely dodging my questions, your doing a terrible job of reading my posts.

 

[#HBC | J]

Lol, how do I go from "townbro" to "dummy or scummy" just based on Gova coming in and talking nonsense?

Eh, it's more I feel you are dummy with your debate with Gova. I could see the argument being SvT and in the case I have a stronger read on Gova's slot over yours which would result in you being the scummer in it. Otherwise you are not a priority of mine at all. Just in the debate, you lost a few townbro points from me. Also it wasn't really nonsense and I explained that because I was pretty much there during the entire debacle.

 

[ranmaru]

J I actually commented on your reasoning for your opinion on Gova:

Did I say Ryu town? Well if not, Ryu can totally be town. Also I am totally infatuated with Gova lately especially with his more recent conversation with PBJ. He is coming off very calm and trying to explain things clearly but in a logical tone that makes sense so I am pretty fine with Gova's slot and definitely would not like to see it lynched toDay when combining Gova's posts with BW's posts.

I don't really see how the underlined is indicative of alignment. (It's null to me) Unless you have seen otherwise from GovaSCUM.

Can you please elaborate further?

 

[FullMetalLynch]

Also, your entire basis for GovaTown is crap.

No offence

 

[#HBC | Joker]

which was the part he said that made sense? The part where he said I was out of line for voting for my scumreads? Or the part where he said me mentioning that they were strongly connected, and likely a team, was not a point worth bringing up? Like, his whole spiel was saying that my reads completely depended on his slot being scum, which isn't true at all. They are individually, and their scummy connection to each other only strengthens that.

 

[FullMetalLynch]

And by crap, I mean it doesn't add up and feels made up.

Gova is still far and away my choice for today.

 

[BarDulL]

Lord, I am way to serious after debating with Soup. I'm going to go play some league and stay away from this game now that I've laid out all I want to for now and let other people post/respond. My gova read or FML's though?

FML's. Gova is kinda nullish to me ever since I played.

Really, there's no escaping my hated role, but policy lynching me is bad for Town unless it's out of necessity.

If I absolutely HAVE to die to avoid silliness from occurring, like 100%, then that's fine, but it doesn't necessarily have to be toDay. Thinking it over, D3 might not be a terrible idea if we're not ahead on scum lynches. If it's toDay, then town can vote on who my vengeful will hit.

 

[BarDulL]

EDWOP: ever since I played with him in...I forget, uTrick'd 3 I think it's called? He kinda reminded me of his play there but I see valid points against him.

And by crap, I mean it doesn't add up and feels made up.

Gova is still far and away my choice for today.

Substantiate this please. Also, what do you think of Nabe/Marsh/J?

 

[FullMetalLynch]

My play reads of indy ?

MFW that would have been a dream come true for me after the endless town roles I keep getting.

Nabe hasn't moved since the last read I stated on him. I have issues with Nabe as a solo slot, as does Orbo an I haven't talked to em lately.

Marshy i just said is a scum lean because of his callimg me scum made me n orbo feel like it was calculated over him legitly calling us scum.

J i just mentioned.

 

[FullMetalLynch]

Ugh Bardul your actually going to make me sift j's posts and do that.

I guess after seeing your mug in avvy form I can give it a go.

Most I can do off the top of my head is that J's read on Gova doesn't add up to me with how he's arguing the idea of me being scum and his town read just reads of smoke and mirrors coming from J. I'd almost call it a chainsaw, especially with how I've seen J act towards my slot.

 

[FullMetalLynch]

Also no wrt shooting J, if it were up to me I would have you shoot Gova , if you were the lynch.

That is how 100% confident I am in BW's scumminess here. An if I'm wrong well then I guess I'm just bad this time around as town

 

[FullMetalLynch]

^ and by extension, Gova's slot

 

[soupamarioyoshiluigiwario]

cant we all just get along and lynch gova and ****ing call it a day?

 

[#HBC | Red Ryu]

Kevin can you put your vote on Bardull so I can do the same?

 

[FullMetalLynch]

^ give that man a prize.

Will work on sifting J's posts.

Good day turning blegh because of mafia.

The things I do for you all

 

[FullMetalLynch]

dammit Ryu you ninja.

712 was @ Marshy

 

[#HBC | Nabe]

Nabe has been tunneling my slot

You don't think this.

 

[#HBC | Nabe]

I can't remember which game it was but the scum-team had a safe-claim of the protagonist of whatever series it is.

vanderzant

 

[KevinM]

I'm town with lynching Bardull and having his shot be voted on.

FML or Gova for the shot?

Unvote

Vote Bardull

 

[#HBC | Nabe]

Wow.

Okay, so no offense to ****ing everyone, but Bardull is well-in-****ing-hand. Identical responses to the key of "Bardull is Baddull and needs to be put down because as town he's a liability" are a) useless sentiments because as town he's town, and b) if town he's accounted for by setup.

But c), the actual problem, is that these identical responses are muddying up the thread, and killing player readability by giving every player a common cause, and diverting posting away from the quality targets they had before Bardull became a "Situation". J, Kev, S&M, and somehow PJB of all people: step off.

News: Bardull is not a situation, this **** is handled. It's my ball in the air, and I thought I had made it decently clear that I've made it as such. Kindly get back to the good work that was going on around this isolated argument, because that other posting is necessary to stuff actually happening and town not being mired in a swampy mess.

 

[#HBC | Nabe]

Vote: FullMetalLynch

 

[#HBC | J]

*scratches head in confusion*

 

[soupamarioyoshiluigiwario]

i think hes sayin him and bard are going to ****