Welcome to Smashboards, the world's largest Super Smash Brothers community! Over 250,000 Smash Bros. fans from around the world have come to discuss these great games in over 19 million posts!
You are currently viewing our boards as a visitor. Click here to sign up right now and start on your path in the Smash community!
I don't see why
You CAN, but then there is less room if you want to keep veterans and new franchises
Needs??? No.
Harry is not an iconic or referenced part of Nintendo History. He represents a part of Nintendo's history that needs to be forgotten. And why is Hanafuda even a thing? It's probably the dumbest idea for character to ever exist, nor does it have anything to do with the company "Nintendo" currently is and it has NOTHING to do with video games.
It's suggested that, during that time, there were some complications regarding to using Donkey Kong characters redesigned/created by Rareware. I have absolutely nothing to legitimize this statement, but judging by some prototype stuff from the likes of Mario Party and Mario Kart 64, there is implications that even using the redesigned DK was a tad of a complication in itself.
We are talking about 4 Donkey Kong reps. And I don't consider those incredibly problematic characters as you're sarcasm implies.
As with Sheriff, I didn't see much going for him.
Sorry, I thought K. Rool and Dixie were interchangeable anyway.
There's not a limit of WTF characters. And Sheriff is retro in the same way that Mr. Game & Watch is. And what defines a WTF character? Just a non-requested character?
Why? He's a commonly referenced and important part of Nintendo History like Mr. Game & Watch.
WANT? uhhhh.........I GUESS Dixie?
There'd be less room to keep veterans and new franchises regardless if one added them both or not. I smell the usual Noah bias.
When? When do you ever see Sheriff, Noah? I've only seen him in the original WarioWare, Inc. Nowhere else.
I'd be content if this was the final roster. 4 FE characters could be a bit of a stretch, but it's plausible, being a franchise with countless amounts of characters.As with Sheriff, I didn't see much going for him.
My roster is a no-cut roster, I have a good amount of Miscellaneous characters and 4 DK characters so it's not that bad.
Here's my roster btw.
im not really sold on the idea of Shulk, Vaati or Robin. but overall id be pretty happy with this roster.As with Sheriff, I didn't see much going for him.
My roster is a no-cut roster, I have a good amount of Miscellaneous characters and 4 DK characters so it's not that bad.
Here's my roster btw.
I'd tap that.My roster is a no-cut roster, I have a good amount of Miscellaneous characters and 4 DK characters so it's not that bad.
Here's my roster btw.
-The Game & Watch was Nintendo's first gaming success and was a long, notable part of Nintendo's history.
I want K. Rool more, since he has practically no chance of being a clone (knock on wood), but I'd also like Dixie in the game as well.
Tap dat joystick.
I think this is a solid roster because it doesn't go out of its way to exclude popular characters just for the sake of standing out and getting attention, and yet still covers a sizable expanse of Nintendo history, new and old. I question whether Sakurai will add a second shock character beyond WFT, as well as potentially Mii or Pacman, but believe me, I'm more than happy seeing guys like Vaati in their stead.As with Sheriff, I didn't see much going for him.
My roster is a no-cut roster, I have a good amount of Miscellaneous characters and 4 DK characters so it's not that bad.
Here's my roster btw.
Here's the problem, BlazeMonkey. You can't say that a rule applies for one thing, but not the other and then claim there are rules that contradict other rules. You say that Olimar didn't get replaced by Alph because Olimar is a veteran. Then you turn around and say Ike & Lucario will get replaced regardless that they are veterans!?!? Where the living **** is the logic in that? You also go around saying that only the most recent Nintendo History matters to Sakurai (which is bull ****) UNLESS they are retro or unless they are veteran! Now you are declaring a rule and yet declaring your own exceptions to that rule which you are not qualified to do. That's like saying "Sakurai picks the most iconic Pokemon, Oh, but this one's a longer veteran so it doesn't matter" or "This ones a starter so it doesn't matter". You don't get to decide that.
- "Sakurai picks the most iconic Pokemon" if Pokemon does get a 5th rep it should be Zoroark or Genesect so they can represent the 5 generation Pokemon, their no reason bring back Lucario because we are not representing the 4 generation Pokemon.
- You also go around saying that only the most recent Nintendo History matters to Sakurai (which is bull ****) UNLESS they are retro or unless they are veteran! why are you cussing..... but anyways Sakurai said himself that SSB4 going be base off Wii/Wiiu/3DS/DS, unless it's a retro character's
- You say that Olimar didn't get replaced by Alph because Olimar is a veteran. it's true Olimar it a veteran, but Alph fell like a one time character, (Isaac maybe was the starred of two big Golden Sun games on the GBA, but his son Matthew is the future of Golden Sun Series)
- Then you turn around and say Ike & Lucario will get replaced regardless that they are veterans their is a possible that Ike will return if Sakurai give "Fire Emblem 3 reps" but it should be Lucina or Chrom to represent the recent fire emblem awaking game. (plus 3ds also got a fire emblem awaking stage)
- You don't get to decide that. Occurs i don't im not sakurai!!!!! xDis my roster that bad for you get so mad....
I think it's more in-line with WTF characters, which we already have Wii Fit Trainer. Of course, I'd personally prefer Sukapon.
Ah, that's understandable.
That really depends on how he is done in Smash... if he does have an interesting moveset like Villager and Wii Fit Trainer do, I would be more accepting of him, you know?
I have a 2nd shock character? Well, you know more about my roster than I do.
hellz ya 1000I think it's more in-line with WTF characters, which we already have Wii Fit Trainer. Of course, I'd personally prefer Sukapon.
By the way, congratulations on 1000 posts!
>People in charge of caring about DK Jr.
No, I meant that your roster doesn't have another one, and I'm unsure whether there will be another one in the actual roster. I figure it's a crapshoot if you're making a roster prediction anyway, given that you're not supposed to be able to guess them, and when people try predicting them, they mainly choose unimportant guys like that 3DS Shop NPC Golden refused to add to his speculation thread a while back.
Oh. That's why I never had a WTF character before the SSB4 E3 trailer, because then it's no longer a WTF character and it's rather pointless to think of one.No, I meant that your roster doesn't have another one, and I'm unsure whether there will be another one in the actual roster. I figure it's a crapshoot if you're making a roster prediction anyway, given that you're not supposed to be able to guess them, and when people try predicting them, they mainly choose unimportant guys like that 3DS Shop NPC Golden refused to add to his speculation thread a while back.
I really like Donkey Kong Jr.... I loved to play as him in Super Mario Kart and Mario Tennis... and I liked playing the arcade game on the NES... I had Donkey Kong Classics when I was a kid. I would have liked Donkey Kong Jr. in Melee too... hell, I wouldn't even mind if he got replaced with Diddy Kong in Brawl... because at least Donkey Kong Jr. was already playable in Melee and I could always go back to play Melee when Brawl and SSB4 are out. But too little too late now...
Like the Duck Hunt Dog?
Thank you for being the one to say that...you saved us all the trouble. Sorry xXBlazeMonkeyXx, we don't hate you or anything, we just wanted to let you know.
I'm sorry to say this but...I feel like Duck Hunt Dog is like the Tingle of retro characters...sure he's a good choice, but he's one of the most hated characters in videogame history. To be honest, if anything, people would want him in to beat the crap out of him.Like the Duck Hunt Dog?
Yes, complete lack of notability. That must be why he's always revived in some way. Whether it's a Wario Ware Mini Game (or actual part of the game) or the credits in the Gameboy Camera he seems to always be referenced. He's also an arcade title which is quite a merit in the way Sakurai wanted an NES character for Melee. This is an important part of their history however you want to look at it and it's certainly not an obscure one. You seem to be saying that because Game & Watch had a little more that anything less couldn't ever be added alongside him. Sheriff still fits the similar historical merits even if it wasn't AS remembered by the players. It' still remembered, acknowledged, and referenced by Nintendo.
He's not really a retro character in the sense that I think you are implying.
Just like Tom Nook.
This is literally how I feel about hand full of retros.
Yeah, that's really the only problem with it. I still find Balloon Fighter redundant and unlikely due to the Villager, and way too many retros. I like it nonetheless. 8/10New roster I guess:
Lots of retros!
I dunno...that laugh is pretty haunting...that and I shot him every chance I got for payback...
New roster I guess:
Lots of retros!
,but if this is your prediction roster,sorry,but is pretty bad... ._.
I don't understand what you mean by this