Before I talk about your roster, since it seems you haven't been to this thread before you posted the roster. (which was very recent right?) it's a rather good thing you haven't been here before, you came at just the right time.
Did something happen? :O
My only problem with the roster is that you made ZSS a seperate character from Samus, and Sheik seperate from Zelda.
MonK4, that's actually a really good roster. The only immediate issues I can see with it are that Zero Suit shouldn't be a separate character on the roster list, and that Bayonette and Yoshimitsu have pretty much 0% chance. Apart from that, 8/10 could be better but mostly solid.
Hah, thanks, but just so it's clear, I wasn't trying to separate the two, or Zelda and Sheik for that matter, I simply wished to show them as distinct, and I think they will be combined in the actual game as well, plus, it makes the number of characters fit solidly into the rectangle. I was thinking about making a distinction in PKMN trainer, but the only thing I feel is certain or good is that he will return in some yet unknown capacity, for Mewtwo I was simply conflicted and left it at two forms to cover the bases.
Yes, I was thinking that Yoshimitsu was out of the question, but he is a placeholder for a Namco rep as well as himself, I feel if any Namco characters get in, it should be him, due to his appearance in pretty much everything Namco does cross games with, but yes, Bayonetta and Yoshimitsu are in my tentative cutting boat, but if ANY other 3rd parties get in, it should be those two, I have a strong dislike of Pac-man, part of my bias unfortunately
Well, you have Bayonetta which I doubt will happen and a character I don't even recognize. Who is Yoshimitsu, I've never even heard of it. Anna over Chrom isn't happening, I don't even know if Anna will even be considered. You need to bring back Toon Link and not make Sheik & ZS Samus separate characters. You should have a 5th Pokemon, you have 6 Third-Parties THAT'S not gonna happen, I don't see why we should have an Advance Wars character and I doubt we will. That's really all I can think of at the moment, maybe replace Black Shadow with Toad or Paper Mario.
Yes, I also doubt that many 3rd parties, but there was only 5 in the roster
, here, I removed two for you.
Bayonetta and Yoshimitsu. Yoshimitsu is an original fighting game character (I know about the interview where Sakurai says fighter characters don't get priority/won't be in) that's been in Street Fighter, Soul Calibur, and principally Tekken. But do not discount Anna, and please add to your assertion the exact reason why she would not be considered, I can give just as many if not more potent reasons she
should and
would be considered. This is my prediction and emulation of if Sakurai was in a sound, intelligent, and reasoning state of mind at all times while still keeping his principal design philosophies, at least this is what I am attempting.
I'm gonna go ahead and say that F-Zero deserves a second rep before the Mario series deserves another, I think this because of historical significance. far more weighty than sales significance, Black Shadow is the man, and Sakurai's reluctance to add too many characters would prioritize these series over more heavily represented ones, that is Sakurai will prioritize unrepresented series before heavily represented ones, regardless of their weighty Nintendo expanse. If other minor series which are hard to distinguish historical importance from are getting reps in my roster (such as Layton or Custom Robo or Starfy series), you can darn tootin' bet I'm gonna give Advanced Wars a rep, though I do not think any character in particular.
Considering also Sakurai's pain to cut characters from one game to the next, he would opt out of removing Ike, a 'popular' lord (that's what they tell me!) with an already unique moveset. If there is any next Fire Emblem rep most deserving, then it is Anna. Come at me. Wooh, maybe 4 reps for Intelligent Systems is a lot, but hey, y'know?
In light of this, I wish to know why exactly why you think I should have a 5th Pokemon. (And there already is, look, Awakening Mewtwo! Not to mention PKMN Trainer and his possible 3 Pokemans.)
If I would consider adding ANYONE from the Mario series (which I do not believe will get another rep this time around), it will be Paper Mario OR Toad before Bowser Jr. If anyone from Zelda series, then Toon Link or Tingle, but I will not add any more than the four.
