Roster Prediction Discussion Thread

[FalKoopa]

Why aren't you guys just ignoring him?

C'mon. There are better things to do.

 

[G0LD3N L0TUS]

Why aren't you guys just ignoring him?

C'mon. There are better things to do.

Just because they're better doesn't mean they're more fun

 

[Opossum]

...what did he say about Muddy Mole?

 

[AEMehr]

Muddy Mole does not need to be researched to claim he won't be available now move on to a different topic

My concern of Little Mac is he's a boxer. So wouldn't all his moves require is fists. What will nintendo decide for his downward arieal attack?

Maybe he would just
punch downward like some of the other characters do

 

[G0LD3N L0TUS]

Oww please...ZSS is as NEW...(-_-) of a rep as bloody Dr.Mario is...

Exactly: A poor excuse for a "newcomer". Zero Suit Samus made sense, but she's still the same person and even character slot.

I must have quoted the wrong post...sorry my bad
..someone said that if Starfox can get 3 Reps so should FE?
WA wa da Fuq?

I can somewhat understand that with Star Fox's inactivity recently. I agree that FE should get 3 reps, but I don't think comparing it to Star Fox is the smartest way to come to that conclusion.

Metroid doesnt havent any popular enough or suitable characters?

If Metroid were to get three reps, it would be Ridley, Samus, and Dark Samus hands down. I, personally, only have two reps because there isn't a need to have a third rep, amazingly. With what we have in Brawl and Ridley, we represent the Space Pirates, Samus herself, and the Metroids. What else is necessary to represent?

 

[Dark Phazon]

True. I agree

 

[8-peacock-8]

I see those pony and meme pictures and i lose all ability to take Noah seriously. Noah is just an idiot. (yeah i know he's probably a troll)

And after I came into this thread, I saw Noah throw a massive fit over Pac-Man. If Noah sticks around and Pac-Man gets confirmed at E3, I am staying far away from this forum until Noah's whining stops.

Really should have taken your word more seriously.

Oh well. Now you know.

Yup - Sony cuts ties with superbot

Im not sure if its been said what they are planning to do after the support for that game has ended, but as it stands they arent dealing with SCEA. And platinum games wasnt too happy about their blunder with the raiden leak either so im not even sure if konami would be willing to deal with them either at this point.

it wasn't because of the sales. Their contract expired. (I'm not lying) Besides that they haven't talked about any other reasons. I assume that Sony is treating this like they've been doing with other companies.

They're too lazy to re-new the contract and just give Sony Santa Monica a game because reasons.

I hate how half the people here assume stuff and yet they don't know what they're talking about when it comes to PSASBR.

 

[Scoliosis Jones]

I bought PSASBR myself, but it is nowhere near as good as Smash Bros. Like really.

I'm not laughing like I thought I would be last night. This makes me a sad panda .

However, while I sometimes disagree with him on things, I don't understand how Golden is a troll. At all. He does have some great points sometimes, and he uses logic to back up his points. So he gets heated sometimes. Doesn't mean he is trolling you.

*sigh...the ****storm has already begun

 

[Banjodorf]

I see those pony and meme pictures and i lose all ability to take Noah seriously.

It's people like Noah that help give a bad name to MLP fans, posting those things all over message boards where they don't belong and acting like they own the place.

Some of us just want to fandom in peace!

@Scoliosis: Golden's a G. A loud, somewhat lion-esque G. Word.

 

[Thirdkoopa]

I have PSASBR and it's not bad but it's not only that the features lack but the actual fighting pales when you realize they not only imbalanced some characters way off the chart but the game modes are limited. At least with Smash I feel it's a fighter and there's even more modes to feel that way like Stamina. Here I got... go for a super move.

 

[MagnesD3]

PSA is really good but for one nowhere as good as smash and doesnt really play like smash, it only looks like it and there are some similar space control elements.

 

[Swamp Sensei]

I
5. Sonic Snake are iconic characters that have a huge history Nintendo. They're appearance does not enable ANYBODY WHO APPEARS ON A NINTENDO CONSOLE, like Dillion and Pushmo.
.

You do realize that Dillon and Pushmo are 1st party characters right?

http://i1347.photobucket.com/albums/p701/Adam_Wade/MINEIRoster_zps5a609d67.png

Oh my.....

 

[FalKoopa]

I want to comment on this roster, but before that I would like to know whether this is meant to be a wishlist or a prediction.

 

[Banjodorf]

King Boo is one of those characters I think is underrated in the possible-rep department. If I were to pick another Mario villain, it'd be him fo sho.

And Tom Nook is still my G.

 

[Scoliosis Jones]

I think with that roster, there are just too many 3rd parties, and too many characters in general.

 

[Swamp Sensei]

King Boo is one of those characters I think is underrated in the possible-rep department. If I were to pick another Mario villain, it'd be him fo sho.

And Tom Nook is still my G.

Are Sora, Demise and Silver your G's?

 

[8-peacock-8]

King Boo is a beast.

 

[Banjodorf]

Are Sora, Demise and Silver your G's?

Man, if Demise *somehow* (note, impossibly) replaces Ganon, I'm just gonna be mad. My name is Banjodorf, not Banjomise. (Eww...)

Not that I don't like demise, but man...

Sora's coo, but naw man, naw. And Silver? Whatever! Ruins PT's uniqueness in the gimmick front.

TL;DR: Errbody's my G. Long as they not terrible.

 

[MagnesD3]

I want to comment on this roster, but before that I would like to know whether this is meant to be a wishlist or a prediction.

Its more of a wishlist, I doubt Id get all of them, Ill be happy if I get ridley, krystal or K. rool.

King Boo is one of those characters I think is underrated in the possible-rep department. If I were to pick another Mario villain, it'd be him fo sho.

And Tom Nook is still my G.

I was thinking King Boo would be Luigis villian rep actually.

 

[Banjodorf]

I was thinking King Boo would be Luigis villian rep actually.

Not a bad idea, especially if they decide to further seperate Luigi from Mario this game. Poltergust move finally please? Please?

 

[MagnesD3]

Are Sora, Demise and Silver your G's?

I think sora would be the optimal square choice (im considering him as a bundle package with geno and mallow), Demise would be awesome as I think he Is the next most important zelda character, and silver would be a pokemon trainer type, I dont know what types of pokemon I would choice for him to hold but It would be 3 that arent currently represented, currently we have normal, electric, fighting, steel, psychic, fire, water and grass (maybe poison cant remember if ivysaur is poison or not). I would want the 3 pokemon silver holds to be different pokemon type's.

Not a bad idea, especially if they decide to further seperate Luigi from Mario this game. Poltergust move finally please? Please?

Most certainly I expect luigi to get his vacuum.

I think with that roster, there are just too many 3rd parties, and too many characters in general.

Its more of what I want the smash roster to eventually be than an accurate prediction for the next game, I expect 2-3 new third parties and probably 10 less characters than I have up their.

Man, if Demise *somehow* (note, impossibly) replaces Ganon, I'm just gonna be mad. My name is Banjodorf, not Banjomise. (Eww...)

Not that I don't like demise, but man...

Sora's coo, but naw man, naw. And Silver? Whatever! Ruins PT's uniqueness in the gimmick front.

TL;DR: Errbody's my G. Long as they not terrible.

Demise replacing Ganondorf would piss me off as well, I would expect them to rework ganons moveset to be like an evil zelda (so dark magic user with some sword moves) and I expect demise would be alot more combat oriented, not as slow use his sword alot, use his dark lightning
, I think it would be sick.

 

[Banjodorf]

Demise replacing Ganondorf would piss me off as well, I would expect them to rework ganons moveset to be like an evil zelda (so dark magic user with some sword moves) and I expect demise would be alot more combat oriented, not as slow use his sword alot, use his dark lightning
, I think it would be sick.

Honestly, I really like that idea. It sounds badass. I think I'd want Wizardorf to be a little less like "Evil Zelda" but it's definitely the right direction. Woo!

 

[~ Valkyrie ~]

Noah J.

You remind me of a very Young Horsetail.

Good times.

 

[HylianHeroBigBoss]

I think with that roster, there are just too many 3rd parties, and too many characters in general.

Yeah sora and rayman stick out a bit. I actually dont think we would ever see any third party characters that didnt originate in japan.

 

[Frostwraith]

Question about this roster: is this supposed to be dream roster or a prediction roster?

EDIT: Never mind.

 

[Scoliosis Jones]

Its more of what I want the smash roster to eventually be than an accurate prediction for the next game, I expect 2-3 new third parties and probably 10 less characters than I have up their.

Ah alright. It looked like more of a wishlist roster. I agree with a lot of your characters on there.

 

[Noler_Mass]

Do you mean it's true that you are:
?

You probably have about a respectably average understanding of the criteria they use to select characters. But your knowledge of games, characters, popularity levels and inner workings is atrocious which is why you have made so many terrible predictions.

Moved to the correct thread before those get deleted:


Do you mean it's true that you are:
?

You probably have about a respectably average understanding of the criteria they use to select characters. But your knowledge of games, characters, popularity levels and inner workings is atrocious which is why you have made so many terrible predictions.

Dammit man Noah actually stopped posting here for a little while because nobody responded to him. He will shut up if you don't respond to him and then peace will be gained, so please no one respond to Noah again unless he can be peaceful like everyone else on this goddamn forum. PLEASE.

 

[TheLastJinjo]

You do realize that Dillon and Pushmo are 1st party characters right?


Oh my.....

They aren't.

 

[FalKoopa]

Dammit man Noah actually stopped posting here for a little while because nobody responded to him. He will shut up if you don't respond to him and then peace will be gained, so please no one respond to Noah again unless he can be peaceful like everyone else on this goddamn forum. PLEASE.

Psst. He's back.

 

[TheLastJinjo]

Do you mean it's true that you are:
?

You probably have about a respectably average understanding of the criteria they use to select characters. But your knowledge of games, characters, popularity levels and inner workings is atrocious which is why you have made so many terrible predictions.

Moved to the correct thread before those get deleted:


Do you mean it's true that you are:
?

You probably have about a respectably average understanding of the criteria they use to select characters. But your knowledge of games, characters, popularity levels and inner workings is atrocious which is why you have made so many terrible predictions.

Actually my predictions are much better. And I am COMPLETELY aware of the popularity and inner workings. Just because I say they can't be in doesn't mean I don't. You don't get into SSB for being a good selling game. You can disagree, but that's how it is. Shulk won't be in SSB4. That's all I have to say about that.

 

[Frostwraith]

They aren't.

First of all, Pushmo is not a character, but a game (known in Europe as Pullblox). Mallo is the protagonist of that game.

That game was developed by Intelligent Systems and published by Nintendo, much like the Paper Mario, Fire Emblem and Wars series as well as majority of the WarioWare games.

Intelligent Systems is a first-party studio to Nintendo, therefore, Mallo is a first-party character.

 

[Scoliosis Jones]

They aren't.

Dillon's Rolling Western and Pushmo in Published by Nintendo. They are both First Party games.

Dillon's Rolling Western and Pushmo in Published by Nintendo. They are both First Party games.

EDIT: Frostwraith Ninja'd me

EDIT 2: ****! QUOTED MYSELF WHEN I MEANT TO EDIT

 

[TheLastJinjo]

Dammit man Noah actually stopped posting here for a little while because nobody responded to him. He will shut up if you don't respond to him and then peace will be gained, so please no one respond to Noah again unless he can be peaceful like everyone else on this goddamn forum. PLEASE.

I am the only one who is being peaceful. You don't see me cussing and getting mad because you don't like my roster. I am reporting.

 

[Frostwraith]

Actually my predictions are much better. And I am COMPLETELY aware of the popularity and inner workings. Just because I say they can't be in doesn't mean I don't. You don't get into SSB for being a good selling game. You can disagree, but that's how it is. Shulk won't be in SSB4. That's all I have to say about that.

If you are so sure about it, why don't you back your points with irrefutable evidence?

 

[FalKoopa]

Shulk won't be in SSB4. That's all I have to say about that.

Are you a Nintendo/Sora employee? Or are you a relative of Sakurai?

Spoiler

Or are you a troll?

 

[Scoliosis Jones]

Actually my predictions are much better. And I am COMPLETELY aware of the popularity and inner workings. Just because I say they can't be in doesn't mean I don't. You don't get into SSB for being a good selling game. You can disagree, but that's how it is. Shulk won't be in SSB4. That's all I have to say about that.

What exactly does Shulk have going against him? I'm not quite sure.

Also, these "inner workings" you know of are oddly not being brought up. Care to share what those might be?

 

[TheLastJinjo]

First of all, Pushmo is not a character, but a game (known in Europe as Pullblox). Mallo is the protagonist of that game.

That game was developed by Intelligent Systems and published by Nintendo, much like the Paper Mario, Fire Emblem and Wars series as well as majority of the WarioWare games.

Intelligent Systems is a first-party studio to Nintendo, therefore, Mallo is a first-party character.

I don't know where you got that idea, but I'm not responding to your flaming anymore. This is a discussion thread.

 

[3Bismyname]

@ Falkoopa
he's either the later or just ignorant

 

[TheLastJinjo]

Are you a Nintendo/Sora employee? Or are you a relative of Sakurai?

Spoiler

Or are you a troll?

if you don't agree, then don't agree. I'm not gonna flame with you

 

[3Bismyname]

I don't know where you got that idea, but I'm not responding to your flaming anymore. This is a discussion thread.

technically this is a display thread. u shouldnt be posting comments here. and what he said is 100% true. Google is a powerful tool u know