Roster Prediction Discussion Thread

[TheLastJinjo]

A leak (which has been accurate so far) mentioned that Mewtwo would have two new forms, the awakened one which we've seen and still resembles mewtwo, and another form, which will look more like Mew.

It's not in the Pokemon wiki and nobody mentions it, I think it's fake. But, even if it wasn't these are different forms NOT characters. So it's not a replacement for Pokemon Trainer.

You guys probably won't like the removal of Sonic and Snake, but I actually made it up with K. Rool along with Hades and Professor Layton. Realizing the third parties are likely to change.

I can't approve of this roster at all. You have Anna instead of Ike for NO reason and Zoroark over Lucario. and Tom Nook & Prince Sable over Toon Link would never happen.

Medusa would get in over Hades as a Palutena semi-clone.

You shouldn't have Young Link, we already have Young Toon Link.

And Bring back PT

PLEEEEEEEEASE! Just get rid of Tom Nook. Wait, do you have Prof. Layton again? Oh, no

No offense, but I think you base most your rosters on what you WANT to see. Or at least it influences you to add Tom Nook, Prince Sable, Anna for sure, and removing Pokemon Trainer.

 

[BluePikmin11]

It's not in the Pokemon wiki and nobody mentions it, I think it's fake. But, even if it wasn't these are different forms NOT characters. So it's not a replacement for Pokemon Trainer.



I can't approve of this roster at all. You have Anna instead of Ike for NO reason and Zoroark over Lucario. and Tom Nook & Prince Sable over Toon Link would never happen.

Medusa would get in over Hades as a Palutena semi-clone.

You shouldn't have Young Link, we already have Young Toon Link.

And Bring back PT

PLEEEEEEEEASE! Just get rid of Tom Nook. Wait, do you have Prof. Layton again? Oh, no

Again do you want lots of newcomers or what?
Also, Pokemon has so many choices for a character, it overwhelms PT's chances actually.

 

[the smash nerd]

Barbasol's Prediction Roster

Cut Veterans
Lucas (Mother)
Jigglypuff (Pokemon)

Newcomers
Paper Mario (Paper Mario)
King K. Rool (Donkey Kong Country)
Skull Kid (The Legend of Zelda)
Tingle (Tingle's Rupeeland)
Victini (Pokemon)
Mewtwo* (Pokemon)
Ridley (Metroid)
Zelgius/Black Knight (Fire Emblem)
Shulk (Xenosaga)
Ray (Custom Robo)
Andy (Advance Wars)
Isaac (Golden Sun)
Stafy (Legend of Stafy)
Duck Hunter (Duck Hunt)
Little Mac (Punch-Out)
Megaman (Megaman)

good one but *

 

[TheLastJinjo]

Again do you want lots of newcomers or what?
Also, Pokemon has so many choices for a character, it overwhelms PT's chances actually.

This isn't about what you want. And why do you single out Pokemon Trainer???? No really, why do you think the many Pokemon newcomers should replace this specific Pokemon character? And again people want newcomers, but they also want veterans, and nobody wants your newcomers over other newcomers OR veterans.

 

[Rebellious Treecko]

Hey, Guys! Nintendo is thinking about buying Atlus! I know who the next Smash rep is gonna be.........

A spiky-haired Rayman clone?

Seriously, who is that?

---

 

[BluePikmin11]

This isn't about what you want. And why do you single out Pokemon Trainer???? No really, why do you think the many Pokemon newcomers should replace this specific Pokemon character? And again people want newcomers, but they also want veterans, and nobody wants your newcomers over other newcomers OR veterans.

Because, I don't want to overrepresent Pokemon with 7 characters To the other side, that just leaves less opportunity for other characters.
You know that.

 

[FlareHabanero]

Just for the record, IF Atlus gets bought out by Nintendo, the roster for this game is not going to be influenced in the slightest. At least for this game, when a future Super Smash Bros. game is in development, then it will much more likely be influenced.

Again, these are "if" scenarios, so don't take this by heart.

 

[Sebz]

It's not in the Pokemon wiki and nobody mentions it, I think it's fake. But, even if it wasn't these are different forms NOT characters. So it's not a replacement for Pokemon Trainer.
.

Had to dig it up, but here's the leak I'm referring to:
http://pokebeach.com/2013/05/supposed-pokemon-x-and-y-insider-information
http://pokebeach.com/2013/05/last-of-the-pokemon-x-y-insider-information

These were posted in May, before many of the reveals took place, and so far have been accurate.

 

[Reznor]

gentlemen its obvious who we are getting next another Retro character and its going to be

 

[TheLastJinjo]

Just for the record, IF Atlus gets bought out by Nintendo, the roster for this game is not going to be influenced in the slightest. At least for this game, when a future Super Smash Bros. game is in development, then it will much more likely be influenced.

Again, these are "if" scenarios, so don't take this by heart.

It's a joke

Because, I don't want to overrepresent Pokemon with 7 characters To the other side, that just leaves less opportunity for other characters.
You know that.

You're giving oppurtunity to unnecessary and undeserving characters by removing necessary, important, popular and deserving characters.

 

[Gune]

1. What are you talking about? When did I deny he had 2 forms? I just said there's no proof he can switch whenever he wants.
2. What did I say that isn't true because I said it?
3. You just said Sakurai would replace someone with 3 forms for another character with 3 forms. WHAT'S THE THIRD FORM???

Newtwo is shown switching threw its forms at will in the trailes sometiems at the blink of an eye its no doubt its has power over its transfermations. Thw fact you keep saying Pokemontrainer wont be cut just like you said with Ike and Toon link but thats your opinion on them you cant just spit that out as fact when they all have a real chance at being cut. Its speculative but the new form mewtwo has is Eclair form also called mewtwo X form on the official site most people beileve there will also be a Y form to complete the duo.


Ha spelled "through" like "threw"

 

[FlareHabanero]

It's a joke

Wasn't really pointing at you in particular, more like everyone in general.

You know, to avoid ***********.

 

[TheLastJinjo]

gentlemen its obvious who we are getting next another Retro character and its going to be

View attachment 1584

What could possibly go wrong?

 

[Gune]

A spiky-haired Rayman clone?

Seriously, who is that?

---

Slash from snowboard kids one of the best N64 games ever.

 

[Sebz]

Wasn't really pointing at you in particular, more like everyone in general.

You know, to avoid ***********.

Silly, silly Habanero.
*********** cannot be avoided, it can only be endured.

 

[BluePikmin11]

It's a joke



You're giving oppurtunity to unnecessary and undeserving characters by removing necessary, important, popular and deserving characters.

All Nintendo characters are deserving in some form, you're just not looking at the reasons for them.

 

[TheLastJinjo]

Newtwo is shown switching threw its forms at will in the trailes sometiems at the blink of an eye its no doubt its has power over its transfermations. Thw fact you keep saying Pokemontrainer wont be cut just like you said with Ike and Toon link but thats your opinion on them you cant just spit that out as fact when they all have a real chance at being cut. Its speculative but the new form mewtwo has is Eclair form also called mewtwo X form on the official site most people beileve there will also be a Y form to complete the duo.

This form is neither confirmed NOR are they their own characters like Squirtle, Ivysaur, and Charizard. So YOU stop stating that Sakurai WOULD remove PT. If these forms are confirmed I will however change my Pokemon on my roster to Mewtwo.

 

[Gune]

This form is neither confirmed NOR are they their own characters like Squirtle, Ivysaur, and Charizard. So YOU stop stating that Sakurai WOULD remove PT. If these forms are confirmed I will however change my Pokemon on my roster to Mewtwo.

Im not stateing im saying its a possibillity sakurai cut Mewtwo and people loved him whos to say that he wouldnt do the same to PT?

 

[TheLastJinjo]

All Nintendo characters are deserving in some form, you're just not looking at the reasons for them.

It doesn't matter who is deserving, it matters who is the MOST deserving. This is how it's decided who gets in over whom. Are you even trying to use simple logic?

whos to say that he wouldnt do the same to PT?

The fact that you'd be removing 3 Characters.

 

[BluePikmin11]

This form is neither confirmed NOR are they their own characters like Squirtle, Ivysaur, and Charizard. So YOU stop stating that Sakurai WOULD remove PT. If these forms are confirmed I will however change my Pokemon on my roster to Mewtwo.

So that totally means you're cutting Pokemon Trainer.

It doesn't matter who is deserving, it matters who is the MOST deserving. This is how it's decided who gets in over whom. Are you even trying to use simple logic?

Yeah but Sakurai can pick out of the blue choices like Wii Fit Trainer. So your argument is invalid.

 

[TheLastJinjo]

So that totally means you're cutting Pokemon Trainer.

Uh, no. If you look at my roster I have Pikachu, JigglyPuff, Pokemon Trainer, and Neomew.

 

[Gune]

The fact that you'd be removing 3 Characters.

For 3 new charecters equal exchange its the law noah

 

[TheLastJinjo]

Yeah but Sakurai can pick out of the blue choices like Wii Fit Trainer. So your argument is invalid.

• A: That's not an out of the blue choice, you just weren't expecting it. You have no clear understanding WHY she was added because you have no understanding why ANYBODY is added. That's how you come up with these rosters.
• B: She didn't replace more important characters.
• C: Oh, Wii Fit Trainer is in SSB. Now AAAAANYBODY CAN GET IN SUPER SMASH BROTHERS! So now any apposition to ANY character I have is invalid.

I'm being tempted to put you on ignore.

For 3 new charecters equal exchange its the law noah

Are you really being this ignorant, because you're kind of ignoring what I say. They are NOT their own characters, they are slightly different forms of the same character, supposedly all under the same name, Mewtwo. So that's NOT a reason to get rid of 3 DIFFERENT characters.

 

[Curious Villager]

Why do people always tend to threaten others of putting them on ignore? Just put them on ignore and shut your yap. Jeez.

Also, looks like its derp time in here again with silly arguments. Not that it surprises me much.

 

[BluePikmin11]

• A: That's not an out of the blue choice, you just weren't expecting it. You have no clear understanding WHY she was added because you have no understanding why ANYBODY is added. That's how you come up with these rosters.
• B: She didn't replace more important characters.
• C: Oh, Wii Fit Trainer is in SSB. Now AAAAANYBODY CAN GET IN SUPER SMASH BROTHERS! So now any apposition to ANY character I have is invalid.

I'm being tempted to put you on ignore.

A. Out of the blue and not expecting it mean the same thing, right? She was added because Sakurai said this character would be the surprise character.
B. Oh ya right. You'd probably disagree about Wii Fit Trainer before E3 began.
C. Yeah, but they gotta be smart choices, otherwise we'll get a very bad roster.

You don't have to ignore me really there's no point to it, you're gonna block anyone who disagrees with your ideas of most deserving characters is the logical way Sakurai thinks.

 

[TheCreator]

I came for the discussion. I'm staying for Mirror B.'s theme.

 

[Hotfeet444]

Why do people always tend to threaten others of putting them on ignore? Just put them on ignore and shut your yap. Jeez.

Also, looks like its derp time in here again with silly arguments. Not that it surprises me much.

It's always a party of awkward statements, threats of ignoring people because of a superiority complex, and just all-round hilarious times when Noah's around.

I came for the discussion. I'm staying for Mirror B.'s theme.

Which one? By the way, did you see your request of Tingle got drawn as well? :3

 

[BluePikmin11]

Wheres the Anna drawing D:

 

[Hotfeet444]

Wheres the Anna drawing D:

It's done, just not scanned yet. The Tingle drawing was done with the last batch of requests and I was just curious as to whether or not Creator saw it since I only got a chance to show him the Dillon request.

 

[Curious Villager]

It's always a party of awkward statements, threats of ignoring people because of a superiority complex, and just all-round hilarious times when Noah's around.

Ah well, I suppose so I guess. If all else fails, threaten the other side by telling them that you are putting them on ignore only by generating more lulz for them. It's a classic.

 

[TheCreator]

Both, I always loved the XD one and hadn't heard it in FOREVER, and i never even heard the coliseum one. It's amazing as well. lol
And no I did not! Post pls.
See in the rules if this is against them, but I think you should make a thread advertising your drawings and taking requests and stuff.

 

[Deleted member]

Why do people always tend to threaten others of putting them on ignore? Just put them on ignore and shut your yap. Jeez.

Also, looks like its derp time in here again with silly arguments. Not that it surprises me much.

Dude, it's the school playground all over again.

"I-if you don't let me play as Captain Planet, I-I'll tell my mom on you."

It's kinda like people using "sage" as an insult on 4chan.

We really are scraping at the bottom of the dignity barrel here now...

 

[Gune]

• A: That's not an out of the blue choice, you just weren't expecting it. You have no clear understanding WHY she was added because you have no understanding why ANYBODY is added. That's how you come up with these rosters.
• B: She didn't replace more important characters.
• C: Oh, Wii Fit Trainer is in SSB. Now AAAAANYBODY CAN GET IN SUPER SMASH BROTHERS! So now any apposition to ANY character I have is invalid.

I'm being tempted to put you on ignore.




Are you really being this ignorant, because you're kind of ignoring what I say. They are NOT their own characters, they are slightly different forms of the same character, supposedly all under the same name, Mewtwo. So that's NOT a reason to get rid of 3 DIFFERENT characters.

Theres no telling if all 3 forms will fight the same or not, Not in the slightest am I ignoring that there are 3 different charecters im just saying if each form fights differently then we have 9 pokemon reps which seems like overkill to the latter of replacing PT with Mewtwo with his forms we would still have 6 like before.

 

[FlareHabanero]

We really are scraping at the bottom of the dignity barrel here now...

There is dignity to begin with?

 

[Deleted member]

There is dignity to begin with?

You're right, what was I thinking.

With that I take my leave.

 

[Hotfeet444]

Both, I always loved the XD one and hadn't heard it in FOREVER, and i never even heard the coliseum one. It's amazing as well. lol
And no I did not! Post pls.
See in the rules if this is against them, but I think you should make a thread advertising your drawings and taking requests and stuff.

Knowing my luck it's probably against the rules to some extent,

As for the Tingle picture...

Spoiler

Hope ya like it. :D

Ah well, I suppose so I guess. If all else fails, threaten the other side by telling them that you are putting them on ignore only by generating more lulz for them. It's a classic.

So true, So true.

There is dignity to begin with?

We have ignorance and blatant superiority complexes, is that a form of dignity? :3

 

[Gune]

We have ignorance and blatant superiority complexes, is that a form of dignity? :3

In some peoples books yes. Yes it is.

 

[Hotfeet444]

In some peoples books yes. Yes it is.

That's a really subtle way to explain dignity...

 

[Gune]

That's a really subtle way to explain dignity...especially if you spelt "subtly " like this...

Funny im watching GG's right now

 

[shinhed-echi]

There is dignity to begin with?

Dignity?

Hit it Dudley!