Cpt.
Smash Lord
(+) are good, (-) are bad, (0) are neutralIn regards to Fire Emblem I would want to see Robin (Female) or Micaiah one of the mains from Radiant Dawn.
Here is my roster right now and I know I will be blasted for it:
Guys on the right are Alternates.
Characers:
Paper Mario, highly requested and had a recent new game, pretty good pick (+)
King K. Rool, requested and a villan which smash needs more of. DK and Falcon are the only two original 8 that still do not have a villan. Him and Dixie are pretty close, but I'd say he's got a better shot (+)
Shulk is likely based on his games response (+)
Micaiah, I think only the die-hard players are going to know who she is. A pretty good choice since it's a girl character which smash needs more of, but it is highly unlikey that FE will get two new reps and even more unlikely that it isn't a more popular character (-)
Chrom is a good choice based off of the FE Awakening stage reveal and a new FE rep (+)
Mewtwo is VERY likely to come back, I can't think of another gen 6 besides megalucario (+)
Lucario's cut could very well happen, but is more like a 50/50 with Mewtwo (0)
Hoenn Trainer, sorry you're a few gens short and the original 3 are the most iconic. (-)
0/No Ridley again, but its fair to exclude him I guess (0)
Lucas's cut could happen, but based on Mother 3's popularity in japan and Ness being one of the orignal 8 it is unlikely that Lucas will be cut reducing earthbound to 1. (-)
Takamaru is the most likely retro IMO, unless you count little Mac as a retro (+)
Palutena is obviously a good choice (+)
Layton is interesting. I can see him happening, but It's not all that likely that he would get in over Little Mac or Isaac (-)
R.O.B. as an alternative is ok, but I don't think they would cut any retros especially since his play-style is so original (-)
Snake's cut (0)
The Decision:
King K. Rool, requested and a villan which smash needs more of. DK and Falcon are the only two original 8 that still do not have a villan. Him and Dixie are pretty close, but I'd say he's got a better shot (+)
Shulk is likely based on his games response (+)
Micaiah, I think only the die-hard players are going to know who she is. A pretty good choice since it's a girl character which smash needs more of, but it is highly unlikey that FE will get two new reps and even more unlikely that it isn't a more popular character (-)
Chrom is a good choice based off of the FE Awakening stage reveal and a new FE rep (+)
Mewtwo is VERY likely to come back, I can't think of another gen 6 besides megalucario (+)
Lucario's cut could very well happen, but is more like a 50/50 with Mewtwo (0)
Hoenn Trainer, sorry you're a few gens short and the original 3 are the most iconic. (-)
0/No Ridley again, but its fair to exclude him I guess (0)
Lucas's cut could happen, but based on Mother 3's popularity in japan and Ness being one of the orignal 8 it is unlikely that Lucas will be cut reducing earthbound to 1. (-)
Takamaru is the most likely retro IMO, unless you count little Mac as a retro (+)
Palutena is obviously a good choice (+)
Layton is interesting. I can see him happening, but It's not all that likely that he would get in over Little Mac or Isaac (-)
R.O.B. as an alternative is ok, but I don't think they would cut any retros especially since his play-style is so original (-)
Snake's cut (0)
The Decision:
All together you scored a solid +2 congrats! Generally you're characters are very likely to get in minus a few odd balls, but hey everyone has hopes right?
Format:
5 by 9 block is is too bulky to happen. They have been horizontal ever since 64. (-)
Paper Mario before Mario in the row is odd and probably wouldn't happen (-), same with young link (-), but they are in the same Column and are technically both major characters (0)
Putting all Retros together (+)
Putting all 3rd Parties Together (+)
Shulk with FE (+)
Putting Olimar with SF (+), Captain Falcon with SF (-), not putting Samus with SF, but next to megaman (0), she looks cramped there (0)
The DK row looks like it should be moved down to the 2nd to last row. Ness would look better near villager and Pokemon/Kirby/Metroid has much more priority than DK/FE (-)
Wii Fit and Villager have good spots but Shulk and Olimar should have been rearrenged to be near them since they are Nintendo solo reps. (-)
The Decision:
Paper Mario before Mario in the row is odd and probably wouldn't happen (-), same with young link (-), but they are in the same Column and are technically both major characters (0)
Putting all Retros together (+)
Putting all 3rd Parties Together (+)
Shulk with FE (+)
Putting Olimar with SF (+), Captain Falcon with SF (-), not putting Samus with SF, but next to megaman (0), she looks cramped there (0)
The DK row looks like it should be moved down to the 2nd to last row. Ness would look better near villager and Pokemon/Kirby/Metroid has much more priority than DK/FE (-)
Wii Fit and Villager have good spots but Shulk and Olimar should have been rearrenged to be near them since they are Nintendo solo reps. (-)
The Decision:
All together you scored a solid 0. Although it is not on a horizontal basis you have clearly put some effort into the formatting of who goes into each row and the smart placement of most misc. characters.
The Result: Not a bad list, but some of it is too hopeful. The formatting needs just a little bit of work
You scored a +2 congrats it's positive!