Roster Prediction Discussion Thread

[YoshiandToad]

So how about some more Happy Mask Salesman for the new year?

There's actually a Ravio thread and he's getting more support than the Salesman, it's a bit sad. I thought there were more Majora's Mask fans.

I get the feeling we're going to have a Zelda Shopkeep Smackdown.

Happy Mask Salesman Vs. Ravio Vs. Beedle. Of course my Rupees are on Tingle.

He sells maps, it counts...

 

[Kenith]

I see what you did there....
Changing the sig into something else other than Kenith's quote about Waluigi.

Oh no, he changed it! How disappointing. Promotion via signatures is how I learned about MorbidAltruism.

Edit: Also, someone said my name without addressing me! Mission Accomplished!

 

[Depressed Gengar]

I see what you did there....
Changing the sig into something else other than Kenith's quote about Waluigi.

I actually changed it BEFORE I read your comment. It was all mere coincidence.

 

[Deleted member]

Basically, people are arguing whether or not the fourth Kirby character should be Chef Kawasaki or Waddle Dee.

No, seriously.

But we already HAVE a chef...

 

[Swamp Castle]

I get the feeling we're going to have a Zelda Shopkeep Smackdown.

Happy Mask Salesman Vs. Ravio Vs. Beedle. Of course my Rupees are on Tingle.

He sells maps, it counts...

What, nobody wants to play as Rupin? XD

I think playing as a shopkeeper would be interesting. Hence my support for Anna (well, one of the reasons I support Anna).

 

[Kenith]

But we already HAVE a chef...

Ahem.

 

[Bowserlick]

DK could get Dixie and K. Rool.

Zelda series is fine (Sheik included).

Mario series is now done. Kirby series is done.

Starfox could swap out Wolf for Andross, but no more than three.

Samus should get Ridley, but I do not think it will.

Wario and Yoshi series are fine. Earthbound should lose Lucas.

Pokemon should gain Mewtwo.

Shulk, Mii, Pacman, Dillon, Mach Rider, and maybe Lip for newcomers. There is your roster. Enjoy it.

 

[Kenith]

DK could get Dixie and K. Rool.

Zelda series is fine (Sheik included).

Mario series is now done. Kirby series is done.

Starfox could swap out Wolf for Andross, but no more than three.

Samus should get Ridley, but I do not think it will.

Wario and Yoshi series are fine. Earthbound should lose Lucas.

Pokemon should gain Mewtwo.

Shulk, Mii, Pacman, Dillon, Mach Rider, and maybe Lip for newcomers. There is your roster. Enjoy it.

Andross? Playable? What? In place of Wolf nonetheless?

 

[LoneKonWolf]

Starfox could swap out Wolf for Andross, but no more than three.

 

[Sobreviviente]

I can't tell if he's supporting Linebeck or Ghirahim. If the former, Grrrr!

Linebeck of course.

 

[BlindFox]

Screw IGN. Rosalina is a really good Newcomer. From what I've seen on the trailer she looks really interesting, with a good player handing the controller she will be an awesome fighter, and I hope someone uses it to screw the spammy Meta Knight players

About Kirby, I think we definetely need a new rep. I'd say knuckle Joe, but I'm not quite sure if he could fit in..

And about Dr Mario... Keep in mind that 2014 is the Luigi Year for Nintendo, and we're going to have a Dr. Luigi for the Wii U. So.. Yeah, maybe we'll have a hilarious Dr. Luigi instead! I'd be awesome don't you think?

Spoiler

Starfox could swap out Wolf for Andross, but no more than three.

So... Andros... I mean, it's just impossible, and as much as He wants to destroy the Lylat System, Fox's arch enemy is and allways will be Wolf.

 

[Deleted member]

...no.
Dr. Mario over Dr. Luigi.

 

[BluePikmin11]

You guys talking about Kirby newcomers? For a more unique Kirby character, I prefer Yarn Kirby or Prince Fluff, the Yarn mechanic could bring about interesting potential.

 

[Kenith]

You guys talking about Kirby newcomers? For a more unique Kirby character, I prefer Yarn Kirby or Prince Fluff, the Yarn mechanic could bring about interesting potential.

The problem is that I can't see them putting another flat character in the game.

 

[AncientTobacco]

I'd prefer a villain for a 4th Kirby rep (No, Dedede is not a villain). Then again, it seems like all the true villains in the Kirby series are either giant monsters or irrelevant. Magolor maybe, but he redemeed himself so he wouldn't really be a villain either.

 

[Deleted member]

DK could get Dixie and K. Rool.

Zelda series is fine (Sheik included).

Mario series is now done. Kirby series is done.

Starfox could swap out Wolf for Andross, but no more than three.

Samus should get Ridley, but I do not think it will.

Wario and Yoshi series are fine. Earthbound should lose Lucas.

Pokemon should gain Mewtwo.

Shulk, Mii, Pacman, Dillon, Mach Rider, and maybe Lip for newcomers. There is your roster. Enjoy it.

Don't like some of these ideas, I also don't like how you think series need to be represented...

DK could upgrade Diddy into Diddy & Dixie duo character. And also get K.Rool to be the more feral heavyweight like old Bowser (since new Bowser is more like Zangeif).

Mario could still get P.Mario or Jr.

Zelda series splits the princess and loses Sheik gaining Impa as a dedicated ninja.

I agree on Kirby.

Starfox is fine, and every time people say Wolf should be cut I wanna punch a baby.

Ridley would be nice.

Wario needs Ashley, cause I like Ashley. EB, I like Claus too.

Pokemon should lose the useless PT, and just keep Charizard, make it a transforming character like in the DBZ games for both Megaforms. You choose either X or Y form pre-battle, and you build a "meter" by landing hits to transform into the selected Megazard for a bit. Oh, and agree on Mewtwo. Jiggs might go though.

Shulk yes, Mii no, PacMan HELL NO, Dillon meh, Machrider I doubt, Lip lulz, add Takamaru, Palutena, and some FE char I guess, or Isaac.

Screw IGN. Rosalina is a really good Newcomer. From what I've seen on the trailer she looks really interesting, with a good player handing the controller she will be an awesome fighter, and I hope someone uses it to screw the spammy Meta Knight players

About Kirby, I think we definetely need a new rep. I'd say knuckle Joe, but I'm not quite sure if he could fit in..

And about Dr Mario... Keep in mind that 2014 is the Luigi Year for Nintendo, and we're going to have a Dr. Luigi for the Wii U. So.. Yeah, maybe we'll have a hilarious Dr. Luigi instead! I'd be awesome don't you think?

Spoiler

​

So... Andros... I mean, it's just impossible, and as much as He wants to destroy the Lylat System, Fox's arch enemy is and allways will be Wolf.

I've come to accept Rosalina, but why do people want the Doc back? Why not make him an alt costume like in PM?

 

[BluePikmin11]

The problem is that I can't see them putting another flat character in the game.

Urgh? I don't think being flat will make Sakurai dismiss the idea of the character.

 

[TheLastJinjo]

Apparently if a character's entire move set is based off a theme that is already one part of another character's move set, it automatically makes them unoriginal.

 

[Kenith]

You guys talking about Kirby newcomers? For a more unique Kirby character, I prefer Yarn Kirby or Prince Fluff, the Yarn mechanic could bring about interesting potential.

What I mean to say, is neither of those characters really have any depth.

 

[TheLastJinjo]

Earthbound should lose Lucas.

 

[Deleted member]

Maybe we liked playing as him?
Hard concept to grasp, I know.

Project M, I will give props for making him actually feel like Dr. Mario (despite it just being that normal Mario was given some Dr. flair and mere aesthetic changes were given to the Dr. outfit), but it just isn't the same.
I'd rather see Doc come back in as a semi-clone with more taken from his home series rather than **** made up just to be like Mario (i.e. "Super Sheet").

 

[BlindFox]

I've come to accept Rosalina, but why do people want the Doc back? Why not make him an alt costume like in PM?

Why? Just imagine throwing pills to Ganondorf and saying: "Take your motha****in Pills Ganon!". It's so ridicolous that is awesome. That's why I love this game. But in terms of moveset and competitive, doesn't brings much, it's the same as Mario. An alt costume would be cool though.

It's been rumored that character would have different outfits instead of skins right? I don't fancy that quite much, but it'd be a cool feature nonetheless.

 

[Kenith]

View attachment 5733

Lucas is actually better than Ness, combat wise.

 

[SuperBrawler]

Maybe we liked playing as him?
Hard concept to grasp, I know.

Project M, I will give props for making him actually feel like Dr. Mario (despite it just being that normal Mario was given some Dr. flair and mere aesthetic changes were given to the Dr. outfit), but it just isn't the same.
I'd rather see Doc come back in as a semi-clone with more taken from his home series rather than **** made up just to be like Mario (i.e. "Super Sheet").

I thought I was the only person who would rather see that.

Well I'm sure everybody else would if they had to choose anyway.

 

[TheLastJinjo]

The problem is that I can't see them putting another flat character in the game.

We have 2 Pink Puffballs and we can't have another character because of it's dimension?

 

[SuperBrawler]

We have 2 Pink Puffballs and we can't have another character because of it's dimension?

The Mario spot is for dr. Mario .

 

[BluePikmin11]

I thought I was the only person who would rather see that.

Well I'm sure everybody else would if they had to choose anyway.

I too want Dr. Mario back, but do you think he'll count as a Mario character or a "Dr. Mario" one?

 

[AncientTobacco]

None of the Melee-only characters (bar Mewtwo) should or will come back.

 

[TheLastJinjo]

I've come to accept Rosalina, but why do people want the Doc back? Why not make him an alt costume like in PM?

Because people love Dr. Mario and would rather play as him than pretend to play as him. A character being similar is no reason to hate somebody. If you hate Dr. Mario you might as well hate Luigi too. Dr. Mario would have had almost just as much difference in moves from Mario in Brawl as Luigi did.

I don't know about you, but people liked that game, and since then Dr. Mario has become the most popular persona of Mario. If you don't have pills and your name isn't Dr. Mario, then you're not Dr. Mario.

Plain and simple. We don't give a **** if he's technically Mario.

 

[SuperBrawler]

None of the Melee-only characters (bar Mewtwo) should or will come back.

And why do you think that?

 

[TumblrFamous]

None of the Melee-only characters (bar Mewtwo) should or will come back.

Roy and Mewtwo have good chances of coming back. Dr. Mario had a chance, being planned for Brawl and all means he was considered, but in all I think Rosalina will be it for Mario.

 

[TheLastJinjo]

Roy will come back if Fire Emblem gets another character that isn't Lyn.

 

[SuperBrawler]

I think I'm the one who actually wants all the Melee characters back.

 

[TheLastJinjo]

I think I'm the one who actually wants all the Melee characters back.

No you're not. Except I don't want Young Link, just Toon Link.

 

[Kenith]

Because people love Dr. Mario and would rather play as him than pretend to play as him. A character being similar is no reason to hate somebody. If you hate Dr. Mario you might as well hate Luigi too.

I don't know about you, but people liked that game, and since then Dr. Mario has become the most popular persona of Mario. If you don't have pills and your name isn't Dr. Mario, then you're not Dr. Mario.

Plain and simple. We don't give a **** if he's technically Mario.

I can't tell if the point is you want Dr. Mario or don't.

Maybe we liked playing as him?
Hard concept to grasp, I know.

I think they should make Mario have Dr. Mario's physics. Mario played under-average in Melee; Dr. Mario was almost top-tier.

 

[TheLastJinjo]

I can't tell if the point is you want Dr. Mario or don't.

Considering I'm defending him in every way, I DO want Dr. Mario back.

 

[BluePikmin11]

I think I'm the one who actually wants all the Melee characters back.

I would gladly have Young Link back if he's given the masks from LoZ:MM.

 

[Starcutter]

I think I'm the one who actually wants all the Melee characters back.

Young link included?

 

[Rebellious Treecko]

Roy will come back if Fire Emblem gets another character that isn't Lyn.

That's a bold statement, mate. ♫

----

 

[Depressed Gengar]

I wonder what they could do to declone Dr. Mario. Not that I'm against the Doc being a clone again.