Roster Prediction Discussion Thread

[LoneKonWolf]

I think Shulk is, sadly, in the same spot as Isaac or Saki. Maybe a little stronger.

So glad I can post again, here's my roster if this is the right place for one...
View attachment 5544

first of all, why is there no DK newcomer? there's bound to be one in this game, but what bothers me is that you added a fire emblem and a Zelda newcomer before adding a DK one? and even the Zelda newcomer is a bit of a bad choice, while ghirahim is a character that has great smash feel, he'll probably get the shaft this game (sadly) and what's the purpose of cutting Lucas again? he's not a likely choice, and defiantly won't be cut over ghirahim or Anna,
and for the love of okami, why is wolf replaced by Krystal? your replacing star fox's teams eternal revival, just for an love interest, its backwards logic dammit -_-#

> Sees Krystal, but no Wolf
@ LoneKonWolf won't like this.

your dam right I don't like this

 

[FalKoopa]

Why is everyone stealing Diddy's avatars now?

 

[Louie G.]

Here's my roster.

Nothing special except Lyn I suppose. She's the placeholder FE rep at the moment.
Also no cuts to avoid conflict.

 

[FalKoopa]

Posting my roster again.

Changes from last time:
- Bowser Jr. was replaced by Rosalina.
- Tingle replaced Toon Zelda/Tetra.

Mewtwo, Pikachu and Sonic have new icons.

 

[Autumn ♫]

Here's my roster.
View attachment 5546
Nothing special except Lyn I suppose. She's the placeholder FE rep at the moment.
Also no cuts to avoid conflict.

Needs more Impa, and just add Roy to your Fire Emblem and that should be good.
(I'm doing this Diddy thing right, right?)

 

[SuperBrawler]

So, anybody else think that Impa should replace Sheik? Anybody? *cricket chirping*

I agree.

Here's my roster.
View attachment 5546
Nothing special except Lyn I suppose. She's the placeholder FE rep at the moment.
Also no cuts to avoid conflict.

Posting my roster again.

Changes from last time:
- Bowser Jr. was replaced by Rosalina.
- Tingle replaced Toon Zelda/Tetra.

Mewtwo, Pikachu and Sonic have new icons.

Both of you have no Impa. 0/10.

 

[Knight Dude]

I update my Paint roster in light of Rosalina's confirmation.

MS Paint Mega Man looks chill as f**k, not gonna lie.

So, anybody else think that Impa should replace Sheik? Anybody? *cricket chirping*

Nope. No need to replace an already unique character.

Also, people, please go back to your own avatars. It's a little confusing.

 

[TopTierPichu]

isnt Shulk 3rd party?

 

[LoneKonWolf]

everybody is becoming diddy kong, and i'm just sitting here with my normal toon linkifed avatar . . . . . . . .

isnt Shulk 3rd party?

nope, monolith is now first party

 

[Depressed Gengar]

Sweet Lord! WHEN WILL IT END?!?!

 

[SuperBrawler]

everybody is becoming diddy kong, and i'm just sitting here with my normal toon linkifed avatar . . . . . . . .

Nah, I'm done. I can't stand hating Dr. Mario.

 

[Louie G.]

I decided that my old roster was terrible, so I made a new one.

It has everything a roster needs to be amazing.

 

[TopTierPichu]

I decided that my old roster was terrible, so I made a new one.
View attachment 5549
It has everything a roster needs to be amazing.

no Pichu
0/10

 

[Depressed Gengar]

-_-
Sigh...

 

[Louie G.]

-_-
Sigh...

Hey, you started it.
A while ago, but you started it.

 

[Mega Bidoof]

isnt Shulk 3rd party?

No, Monolith Soft is owned by Nintendo, so they are a 2nd party developer, which means Shulk is technically a Nintendo character, and Sakurai doesn't need special permission to put him in.

On the subject of Wonder-Red, it all depends on how he works.
He could be very unique, or he could be just be very bland and have a move set like this.

Neutral Special - Chargable Unite Fist
Side Special - Unite Sword
Up Special -Unite Whip
Down Special - Unite Gun

 

[LoneKonWolf]

whelp there is only one way to end this diddy kong madness. . .

good bye everyone, i'll see ya in the afterlife

 

[Fire Emblemier]

Here's my roster.
View attachment 5546
Nothing special except Lyn I suppose. She's the placeholder FE rep at the moment.
Also no cuts to avoid conflict.

Was looking at this roster surprised that Diddy forgot Impa, but realized it's Louie G/

 

[FalKoopa]

I decided that my old roster was terrible, so I made a new one.
View attachment 5549
It has everything a roster needs to be amazing.

Needs more females.

Zelda/10

 

[Mega Bidoof]

I decided that my old roster was terrible, so I made a new one.
View attachment 5549
It has everything a roster needs to be amazing.

 

[APC99]

Here's my roster.

Nothing special except Lyn I suppose. She's the placeholder FE rep at the moment.
Also no cuts to avoid conflict.

+No cuts
+Little Pac-Mii
+ Brawl Pokemon & Mewtwo
+Elite Four
Lyn (neutral to this idea)
Shulk (neutral)
-No WTF character

I give it an 8/10.

Posting my roster again.

Changes from last time:
- Bowser Jr. was replaced by Rosalina.
- Tingle replaced Toon Zelda/Tetra.

Mewtwo, Pikachu and Sonic have new icons.

+Elite Four
+Pac-Man, Tingle & Isaac
-No WTF character

I give it an 8/10 as well.

 

[Autumn ♫]

I decided that my old roster was terrible, so I made a new one.
View attachment 5549
It has everything a roster needs to be amazing.

Hold up! Where's the perfect Fire Emblem representation? Where's Marth, Ike, Roy, and Lyn?

 

[Fire Emblemier]

whelp there is only one way to end this diddy kong madness. . .
View attachment 5551
good bye everyone, i'll see ya in the afterlife

No don't!! I can't be all alone in this madness!

 

[Louie G.]

+No cuts
+Little Pac-Mii
+ Brawl Pokemon & Mewtwo
+Elite Four
Lyn (neutral to this idea)
Shulk (neutral)
-No WTF character

I give it an 8/10.

WFT is the WTF character.
At least I think so.

 

[Depressed Gengar]

Hey, you started it.
A while ago, but you started it.

Exactly. I came up with the joke, so now I feel like everyone is copying ME.

 

[Kenith]

first of all, why is there no DK newcomer? there's bound to be one in this game, but what bothers me is that you added a fire emblem and a Zelda newcomer? and even the Zelda newcomer is a bit of a bad choice, while ghirahim is a character that has great smash feel, he'll probably get the shaft this game (sadly) and what's the purpose of cutting Lucas again? he's not a likely choice, and defiantly won't be cut over ghirahim or Anna,
and for the love of okami, why is wolf replaced by Krystal? your replacing star fox's teams eternal revival, just for an love interest, its backwards logic dammit -_-#

I'm sorry. It's terrible, I know. But I'm working to improve it. To Summarize: I have no idea which DK newcomer to include, Dixie is most likely, but least unique (by herself) King K Rool reps DK's villains, but has not been around for years, and Cranky Kong is my personal favorite, but a little unlikely.

My original FE team was Marth and Chrom, but I decided to add another rep since it's bigger now. I switched Chrom for Ike since Ike is in multiple games, and we like him.
I chose Anna to represent the whole series, but the artwork reflects upon Awakening only. It's a personal choice, really. Better than three Lords.

I cut Lucas because, and I know I'll get flamed for this, why not?

Krystal took Wolf's spot due to space constraints. Lastly, Ghirahim's there because...well, come on. Look at my everything.

 

[OcarinaOfDoom]

much diddy kong
much impa.

I cut Lucas because, and I know I'll get flamed for this, why not?.

because he has a pretty unique moveset and he's a popular character?

 

[Louie G.]

I cut Lucas because, and I know I'll get flamed for this, why not?

Because Lucas is important to the Mother franchise and is the most recent protagonist.
Other than that I see no reason why he should stay. But he will.

 

[APC99]

Exactly. I came up with the joke, so now I feel like everyone is copying ME.

I have no idea what you're talking about.

Also, I'm not doing this to spite Diddy, I'm doing it to spite the copiers.

 

[Diddy Kong]

Why is everyone stealing Diddy's avatars now?

It's becoming a running gag here I feel... Guess am getting popular.

 

[Deleted member]

In what sense does doing exactly what the copiers are doing mean you're being spiteful?

Wouldn't copying the copiers mean you're one of them?

 

[TopTierPichu]

why would Lucas be cut and not Ness, if I remember correctly Ness was not even supposed to be in Melee

 

[Louie G.]

RIGHT when I forgot about this...
Boom, here it is again.

why would Lucas be cut and not Ness, if I remember correctly Ness was not even supposed to be in Melee

If I remember correctly Ness has been in Super Smash Bros since the original.
If one of them gets cut it will no question be Lucas.

 

[Mega Bidoof]

Look what you've started Shadow!
Look at all this Diddy madness!

I have an idea!
Let's do something fun!
Lets all make a roster on who we would WANT in a smash game, and not who we would PREDICT!
6 characters for the 3 major series, 4 for DK, Kirby, StarFox, Mother, and FE, and at least 2 for F-Zero and Metroid.
And at least 5 new series characters (Villager and WFT count).
NOW GO!!!

 

[APC99]

In what sense does doing exactly what the copiers are doing mean you're being spiteful?

Wouldn't copying the copiers mean you're one of them?

...once again, foiled by my flawed teenage mind.

I need a new avatar anyway.

 

[Diddy Kong]

Recruirement for becoming one of the Diddy, rap this fully:

 

[Autumn ♫]

In what sense does doing exactly what the copiers are doing mean you're being spiteful?

Wouldn't copying the copiers mean you're one of them?

If K.Rool makes it into Smash 4, I really hope he has that voice.

 

[Kenith]

Because Lucas is important to the Mother franchise and is the most recent protagonist.
Other than that I see no reason why he should stay. But he will.

Fire Emblem and Mother are like cousins. From what I've read about Lucas, it just seems like:

Ness = Marth
Lucas = Roy, Ephiraim, Chrom
Porky = Black Knight
Claus = Micaiah

 

[Depressed Gengar]

I have no idea what you're talking about.

Also, I'm not doing this to spite Diddy, I'm doing it to spite the copiers.

I came up with the "Copy Diddy" joke a while back.

 

[LoneKonWolf]

I'm sorry. It's terrible, I know. But I'm working to improve it. To Summarize: I have no idea which DK newcomer to include, Dixie is most likely, but least unique (by herself) King K Rool reps DK's villains, but has not been around for years, and Cranky Kong is my personal favorite, but a little unlikely.

well, that's probably because no one knows which dk newcomer will be in, most just chose one or the other, and now that cranky is back, some says he'll get the Rosalina treatment, I guess when it comes down to it, it comes to personal opinion, I guess

My original FE team was Marth and Chrom, but I decided to add another rep since it's bigger now. I switched Chrom for Ike since Ike is in multiple games, and we like him.
I chose Anna to represent the whole series, but the artwork reflects upon Awakening only. It's a personal choice, really. Better than three Lords.

that's good, all fire emblem needs is marth and ike, everyone else is just a bonus,

I cut Lucas because, and I know I'll get flamed for this, why not?

he's a fan favorite of the so called master piece of mother 3, so everybody loves him, other than that I don't know why

Krystal took Wolf's spot due to space constraints. Lastly, Ghirahim's there because...well, come on. Look at my everything.

so? if space constraints were a problem then get rid of an unlikely newcomer or just get rid of Krystal, wolf is not getting cut no matter what, not even for Krystal
and ghirahim is understandable, I mean even I can agree I wish he had a better chance,