Roster Prediction Discussion Thread

[Mega Bidoof]

I just wanted to let everyone here know, I will be leaving SmashBoards until my Heavy thread is unlocked.
I find it unfair that users are not allowed to show creativity and make a thread for a character that probably won't be in Smash.
If people don't want to support the character, that's his/her own choice.
So if anyone needs me, I'll be on GamFaqs.
Dunsparce, if the thread is unlocked, call me.

 

[Pacack]

I just wanted to let everyone here know, I will be leaving SmashBoards until my Heavy thread is unlocked.
I find it unfair that users are not allowed to show creativity and make a thread for a character that probably won't be in Smash.
If people don't want to support the character, that's his/her own choice.
So if anyone needs me, I'll be on GamFaqs.
Dunsparce, if the thread is unlocked, call me.

Nice knowing you! Bye!

 

[G0LD3N L0TUS]

I just wanted to let everyone here know, I will be leaving SmashBoards until my Heavy thread is unlocked.
I find it unfair that users are not allowed to show creativity and make a thread for a character that probably won't be in Smash.
If people don't want to support the character, that's his/her own choice.
So if anyone needs me, I'll be on GamFaqs.
Dunsparce, if the thread is unlocked, call me.

Good to know we mean less to you than a silly little thread.

 

[YeppersPeppers]

A Luigi's Mansion stage for the 3DS version on Halloween is very plausible.

I would love to see Wario revealed (he's terrifying enough, right?) alongside a stage based off of Ashley's Mansion, though that one seems a lot less likely... ~

 

[Zhadgon]

I just wanted to let everyone here know, I will be leaving SmashBoards until my Heavy thread is unlocked.
I find it unfair that users are not allowed to show creativity and make a thread for a character that probably won't be in Smash.
If people don't want to support the character, that's his/her own choice.
So if anyone needs me, I'll be on GamFaqs.
Dunsparce, if the thread is unlocked, call me.

Well if you come back you will have your sigs made, still maybe take a break and come back in few days.
.n_n.

 

[SuperBrawler]

I just wanted to let everyone here know, I will be leaving SmashBoards until my Heavy thread is unlocked.
I find it unfair that users are not allowed to show creativity and make a thread for a character that probably won't be in Smash.
If people don't want to support the character, that's his/her own choice.
So if anyone needs me, I'll be on GamFaqs.
Dunsparce, if the thread is unlocked, call me.

The character discussion Guidelines and Listings says they have to be in a Nintendo game or something along those lines. It's like making a Steve support thread.

 

[Oniric Spriter]

Something from Luigi's Mansion is what he expect us to expect to most likely happen the 31st.

Now is when he reveals one of the most lighthearted characters, Ness.

 

[Mega Bidoof]

The character discussion Guidelines and Listings says they have to be in a Nintendo game or something along those lines. It's like making a Steve support thread.

I don't give a Ratata's tail about the guidelines!
If the guidelines say I can't be creative, I'm done!
Goodbye everyone!

 

[Bowserlick]

Reading up on the internet, it seems that the Ice Climber's Summit stage was revealed Halloween on the Dojo for Brawl.

 

[YeppersPeppers]

Reading up on the internet, it seems that the Ice Climber's Summit stage was revealed Halloween on the Dojo for Brawl.

Makes sense. That fish is one of the most tense and frightening things ever.

 

[SuperBrawler]

So what the topic today guys?

 

[Chandeelure]

I just wanted to let everyone here know, I will be leaving SmashBoards until my Heavy thread is unlocked.
I find it unfair that users are not allowed to show creativity and make a thread for a character that probably won't be in Smash.
If people don't want to support the character, that's his/her own choice.
So if anyone needs me, I'll be on GamFaqs.
Dunsparce, if the thread is unlocked, call me.

Who cares? XD

 

[Mega Bidoof]

I think I forgot to mention something about my predicament.
FALLKOOPA GAVE ME PERMISSION TO MAKE THE THREAD BEFORE I EVEN MADE IT!
So I have permission to make the thread, and then another moderator just locks it.

Who cares? XD

I do you peice of Goomba meat.

 

[SuperBrawler]

I think I forgot to mention something about my predicament.
FALLKOOPA GAVE ME PERMISSION TO MAKE THE THREAD BEFORE I EVEN MADE IT!
So I have permission to make the thread, and then another moderator just locks it.

Proof please.

 

[Gune]

I think I forgot to mention something about my predicament.
FALLKOOPA GAVE ME PERMISSION TO MAKE THE THREAD BEFORE I EVEN MADE IT!
So I have permission to make the thread, and then another moderator just locks it.

Have you told Fal? If not tell Fall and see if it can't be unlocked.

 

[SuperBrawler]

Have you told Fal? If not tell Fall and see if it can't be unlocked.

Well it's actually against th Guidelines :/.

 

[Mega Bidoof]

Proof please.

 

[SuperBrawler]

View attachment 3592

Thank you.

 

[YeppersPeppers]

So what the topic today guys?

Here's a question: How do you think the locked characters will work in terms of roster organization? Will it be like Melee where the character would show up without affecting the roster layout (except for Luigi pushing Pikachu away), or will it be like Brawl where every character unlocked would push the boxes around and disorganize everything?

I hope there's a bit more organization to it. It felt a little lazy in Brawl.

 

[SuperBrawler]

Here's a question: How do you think the locked characters will work in terms of roster organization? Will it be like Melee where the character would show up without affecting the roster layout (except for Luigi pushing Pikachu away), or will it be like Brawl where every character unlocked would push the boxes around and disorganize everything?

I hope there's a bit more organization to it. It felt a little lazy in Brawl.

I already created a Roster Organization thread about the roster design and stuff.

I'll put it in my sig.

 

[Jaedrik]

I just wanted to let everyone here know, I will be leaving SmashBoards until my Heavy thread is unlocked.
I find it unfair that users are not allowed to show creativity and make a thread for a character that probably won't be in Smash.
If people don't want to support the character, that's his/her own choice.
So if anyone needs me, I'll be on GamFaqs.
Dunsparce, if the thread is unlocked, call me.

I feel your pain.
Muh Gaston thread.

 

[YeppersPeppers]

Oh, did you? I guess I probably should have checked around before hand. Well, there goes that topic.

 

[SuperBrawler]

I feel your pain.
Muh Gaston thread.

Super Meat Boy thread.

 

[GmanSir]

Are we to the point where I can not have Ridley in my roster, and people will not be anal about it?

 

[SuperBrawler]

Are we to the point where I can not have Ridley in my roster, and people will not be anal about it?

Yes.

Oops read it wrong.

No.

 

[FlareHabanero]

Are we to the point where I can not have Ridley in my roster, and people will not be anal about it?

Heh, no, you'd still get some anal annihilation.

 

[G0LD3N L0TUS]

Are we to the point where I can not have Ridley in my roster, and people will not be anal about it?

I think he deserves to get it. Very much so, in fact. However, I wouldn't attack someone who doesn't put him in their roster. Granted, I will if their reasoning is "He's too big".

 

[SuperBrawler]

I think he deserves to get it. Very much so, in fact. However, I wouldn't attack someone who doesn't put him in their roster. Granted, I will if their reasoning is "He's too big".

I think you speak for more than yourself sir.

 

[BluePikmin11]

Looks like not much activity here since I was gone for awhile.

 

[Chandeelure]

The only one that can determine if Ridley will be playable or not is Sakurai,so you can stop with "the Ridley's inclusion is obvious". If Sakurai thinks that Ridley is boss material,he will be a boss again,so,deserving or not,there are not safe characters.

 

[SuperBrawler]

Looks like not much activity here since I was gone for awhile.

No good topics today.

 

[FlareHabanero]

No good topics today.

More like no more new topics.

 

[G0LD3N L0TUS]

The only one that can determine if Ridley will be playable or not is Sakurai,so you can stop with "the Ridley's inclusion is obvious". If Sakurai thinks that Ridley is boss material,he will be a boss again,so,deserving or not,there are not safe characters.

I'm sorry, but are you putting words in my mouth? That's how I read this.

 

[BluePikmin11]

More like no more new topics.

We covered every topic imaginable, don't be surprised.

 

[Chandeelure]

I'm sorry, but are you putting words in my mouth? That's how I read this.

No...XD
It's for all the people here.

 

[SuperBrawler]

Scizor?

I wanted him since Melee.

 

[G0LD3N L0TUS]

No...XD
It's for all the people here.

Good. I get enough of that from Saturn.

 

[Chandeelure]

Good. I get enough of that from Saturn.

Don't worry, I don't like fights XD (except when someone says something bad about Bandana Dee).

 

[TumblrFamous]

I think he deserves to get it. Very much so, in fact. However, I wouldn't attack someone who doesn't put him in their roster. Granted, I will if their reasoning is "He's too big".

On that note:

Here's my Roster. I took a big risk not putting in Ridley, but my defense is threefold:

• While iconic and certainly deserving to be in as a playable character, I feel as if Sakurai has decided where Ridley's place in the game should be, as a boss. It's possible he may be promoted to playability, but I'm still doubtful.
• While the Pyrosphere stage certainly does not deconfirm him, I do think that it may lower his chances. Sakurai could either be playing mindgames, or just telling us Ridley's role in the game, and I am guessing the latter.
• In all, Ridley, to me, would be difficult to work on and a bit awkward. This is 100% bias, so you don't have to consider it. It's just my opinion, and I'd like it if you respect it.

The two big issues with my roster, in my opinion, is its size, which 54 total characters (alts included) is quite a hefty amount (I'd be surprised if we break 50), and the thought from some people that it is a bit "vanilla" and safe. Well, I think a good predictable roster doesn't have to be bursting with unlikely retros to be predictable. I fully believe Brawl wasn't that shocking as a final roster. Apart from some cuts, the shockers, IMO, were Pit, ROB, and to an extent the Pokemon Trainer. We've already gotten two shocking characters, so I expect maybe one or two more, but nothing to completely throw it off.

Thoughts?

 

[NickerBocker]

On that note:
View attachment 3593
Here's my Roster. I took a big risk not putting in Ridley, but my defense is threefold:

• While iconic and certainly deserving to be in as a playable character, I feel as if Sakurai has decided where Ridley's place in the game should be, as a boss. It's possible he may be promoted to playability, but I'm still doubtful.
• While the Pyrosphere stage certainly does not deconfirm him, I do think that it may lower his chances. Sakurai could either be playing mindgames, or just telling us Ridley's role in the game, and I am guessing the latter.
• In all, Ridley, to me, would be difficult to work on and a bit awkward. This is 100% bias, so you don't have to consider it. It's just my opinion, and I'd like it if you respect it.

The two big issues with my roster, in my opinion, is its size, which 54 characters is quite a hefty amount (I'd be surprised if we break 50), and the thought from some people that it is a bit "vanilla" and safe. Well, I think a good predictable roster doesn't have to be bursting with unlikely retros to be predictable. I fully believe Brawl wasn't that shocking as a final roster. Apart from some cuts, the shockers, IMO, were Pit, ROB, and to an extent the Pokemon Trainer. We've already gotten two shocking characters, so I expect maybe one or two more, but nothing to completely throw it off.

Thoughts?

Thats 49 not 54, so its quite good. Not hefty at all (unless you were talking about alt forms then my apologies ) the only problems I have are preferential which could realistically go either way. Characters like K Roolover Dixie, PM over bowser junior, etc.

Ridley is so up in the air I dont really care about that one (although I do put him in my rosters)