Roster Prediction Discussion Thread

[Pazzo.]

It's okay, he already started trolling the Pokemon fanbase now that he got his fill from the Ridley fans anyway.

UP NEXT: The Kid Icarus fanbase! Show a TON of Pit and the new stage... But where's Palutena??

 

[FalKoopa]

I Double post. Sorry.
Dakota.

Do not blame yourself for the crappy server. Just report the post and I'll take care of it.

 

[Pazzo.]

Do not blame yourself for the crappy server. Just report the post and I'll take care of it.

Kay-O. I forgot that you got Mod... Congrads! Now, back to topic.

 

[Tepig2000]

I suggest getting rid of either Toad or Bowser Jr. and Meowth. Replace those slots with the Mii like you wanted, and Palutena. May I also suggest to only keep either Dixie or K. Rool. I don't see getting both of them. Maybe get rid of one in favor of Takamaru?

I don't see why I should remove Meowth. It's popularity is really high because of the anime. This is the same reason Jigglypuff joined. I don't like the idea of chossing between Dixe or K. Rool and Toad or Bowser Jr.. The Mario series got 3 newcomers in Melee. The Pokémon series also got 2 newcomers, and Zelda gained 4. In Brawl, Pokémon did lose 2 but gained 4, so that's 2 more characters than in Melee. It's not impossible for Sakurai to add 2 newcomers for the Mario and DK series. But I like the idea of Mii, Palutena and Takamaru. I will get rid of some different characters than you suggested and add them.

 

[BluePikmin11]

Jigglypuff was chosen (I think) instead of Meowth because she had easier development after Kirby.

 

[SchAlternate]

I secretly hope Sakurai realizes the potential of Zoroark.

And Genesect's

 

[BluePikmin11]

And Genesect's

We need more aliens.

 

[SchAlternate]

We need more aliens.

ridley.jpg

 

[Arcadenik]

View attachment 3430

My roster.

I like it because it has Toad, Meowth, and Dixie Kong. Most people usually include a Mario newcomer that is not Toad, a Pokemon newcomer that is not Meowth, and King K. Rool on their rosters over them.

 

[Tepig2000]

I like it because it has Toad, Meowth, and Dixie Kong. Most people usually include a Mario newcomer that is not Toad, a Pokemon newcomer that is not Meowth, and King K. Rool on their rosters over them.

I tried to make it different than the usual rosters in the internet but still possible to happen.

My updated roster! Includes some of the suggestions made here:

 

[Gune]

Pssh... Zoroark...we don't need that thing we need mew she does everything zoroark does but a hell of a lot better.

 

[Tepig2000]

Pssh... Zoroark...we don't need that thing we need mew she does everything zoroark does but a hell of a lot better.

Looks like I'm not the only one that thinks Zoroark is not the best choice for Pokémon newcomer.

 

[Arcadenik]

I tried to make it different than the usual rosters in the internet but still possible to happen.

My updated roster! Includes some of the suggestions made here:

View attachment 3447

This is even better!!! Toad, Meowth, Dixie Kong, Tingle, and Pac-Man together in one roster? I love it!! I would love it to be real... if the Duck Hunt Dog and Simon Belmont were included on the roster too...

 

[Tepig2000]

This is even better!!! Toad, Meowth, Dixie Kong, Tingle, and Pac-Man together in one roster? I love it!! I would love it to be real... if the Duck Hunt Dog and Simon Belmont were included on the roster too...

Duck Hunt Dog would be a cool retro, but the next best one after Takamaru, in my opnion, is Ballon Fighter. As for Simon Belmont, I don't think he qualifies well in the "Third Parties need to be legendary" thing.

 

[BluePikmin11]

I tried to make it different than the usual rosters in the internet but still possible to happen.

My updated roster! Includes some of the suggestions made here:

View attachment 3447

IMO, you should remove Bowser Jr., Meowth, and Toon Zelda.
6 characters for the big 3 is too much.

 

[Tepig2000]

IMO, you should remove Bowser Jr., Meowth, and Toon Zelda.
6 characters for the big 3 is too much.

Well, since they are the BIG three they should have a BIG number of characters right?

 

[BluePikmin11]

Just recommending because I don't the we'll get 53 characters, so I think you remove those 3 so it can least be a possible 50 characters.

 

[FalKoopa]

Well, since they are the BIG three they should have a BIG number of characters right?

But it's not just BIG, it's TOO BIG.

Jokes aside, I believe the big 3 should not get more than 5 slots each.

 

[Chandeelure]

Pssh... Zoroark...we don't need that thing we need mew she does everything zoroark does but a hell of a lot better.

Mew is not female...

 

[Deleted member]

If it's just what you want to see, 6 is fine.
If it's a prediction, then 5 should be the limit. Sakurai has already expressed distaste for overcrowding the line-up with Mario and Pokémon characters.

 

[Curious Villager]

Well yeah, their called the Big Three by fans, not the Too Big Three.........................


But I honestly wouldn't mind 6 characters for at least Mario and Pokemon though. (At least it would shut up the Toad vs Bowser jr wars and the people who want the Brawl vets and Mewtwo back but also a brand new Pokemon character............:x )

 

[Arcadenik]

Mew is not female...

Well, Mega Mewtwo Y is female. We need more females.

 

[Curious Villager]

Pssh... Zoroark...we don't need that thing we need mew she does everything zoroark does but a hell of a lot better.

Well Mew is a legendary Pokemon, what do you expect?

 

[BluePikmin11]

We don't have enough unknown gender characters in the game.

 

[Chandeelure]

Well Mew is a legendary, what do you expect?

We don't need Pikachu or Jigglypuff,we only need Arceus,it does everything other Pokemon does,but better.

 

[Tepig2000]

Well yeah, their called the Big Three by fans, not the Too Big Three.........................


But I honestly wouldn't mind 6 characters for at least Mario and Pokemon though. (At least it would shut up the Toad vs Bowser jr wars and the people who want the Brawl vets and Mewtwo back but also a brand new Pokemon character............:x )

About the small letters part:

That was my goal when putting these characters in. But the war is somewhat a Toad vs Bowser Jr. vs Paper Mario war. But then Paper Mario would be the obvious new Mario character for SSB5.

 

[FalKoopa]

We don't have enough unknown gender characters in the game.

Birdo for Smash.

 

[BluePikmin11]

Zoroark looks more like fighting material than Mew.

 

[Deleted member]

We don't need any Pokémon but Missingno.

 

[Tepig2000]

Birdo for Smash.

Yeah. Birdo should be playable. Birdo is 1000000 times better than Ridley, King K. Rool, Mewtwo, Palutena and any other character.

Jokes aside, I would like Birdo if it gets in after Toad, Bowser Jr., Paper Mario, Waluigi, Daisy, Fawful and Rosalina.

 

[FalKoopa]

Jokes aside, I would like Birdo if it gets in after Toad, Bowser Jr., Paper Mario, Waluigi, Daisy, Fawful and Rosalina.

So, in other words, Birdo should not be playable until Smash 8 or 9.

 

[Arcadenik]

We don't have enough unknown gender characters in the game.

R.O.B. is not enough?

 

[Knight Dude]

I tried to make it different than the usual rosters in the internet but still possible to happen.

My updated roster! Includes some of the suggestions made here:

View attachment 3447

Meowth isn't that bad of a choice actually. It's probably the one legit Pokemon that could be added that isn't a Starter or a Legendary. Props for adding Tingle too I guess. Though as Golden said earlier, if this a preference then its fine. But for a prediction, you might want to swap one character for Mario, Pokemon, and Zelda respectively. Still a good roster nonetheless.

We don't have enough unknown gender characters in the game.

Well we could always throw Mewtwo back in.

EDIT: Double post, sorry.

 

[Hotfeet444]

Good afternoon all, glad to see that you're all keeping your sanity intact...and by that I mean, from the last few pages I read, that it's clearly leaking and sinking faster than the Titanic. Then again, I shouldn't exactly be surprised.

 

[Johnknight1]

.....I have been usurped?

Damn.

By someone other than ManlySpirit, HyperFalcon, or a long time member no less!!!!

Jesus, is that how people use R.O.B. competitively? That doesn't even sound like fun for the R.O.B. player either.

Oh man, Meta Knight can be just as bad. The match after that the guy went to Meta Knight and did all kinds of things so I couldn't approach without getting whacked, and yet, he refused to approach despite Meta Knight's great approach.

Really though, it's a problem with quite a few characters. It would probably be a problem with Snake too if he didn't have Snaking.

You lost to a campy character with using Toon Link, who can be just as campy? I mean toon link has more projectiles to spam at him and you have the hook shot, so if you space him out while using your specials and zair the match up shouldn't be so bad for your character. I think all of toon links specials and his zair can stop ROB's gyro, even just simply blocking it and the laser.


In short, just out camp campy characters until they're mad. They will come eventually.

I won the first match by using solely projectiles. After I got bored to death of just camping and spamming projectiles, I wanted to get in and have an actual fight, instead of a boring "throw stuff" competition that I would clearly win.

Ultimately, that match showed me what's wrong with Brawl: it's not fun when you play to win. Smash 64 and Melee competitively at the highest level and play to win is very fun. But with Brawl, eh, not so much.

I mean, in that second match when he switched to Meta Knight and ran away, I could have gone to Meta Knight and won by similarly camping (because I knew I was more technical and precise than my opponent with any character, despite me not knowing Meta Knight), but truth be told, I hate playing Meta Knight, and Toon Link was the only character in Brawl that gave me an ounce of joy to play.

And when I realized that I had to camp to win with him, I just quit. I'm not going to play that way. I want to have fun, too, and nothing is funner than getting in an intense, in your face, everywhere at once fight where both players KNOW they will win such an epic war., which I then found out is just not possible in Brawl due to Brawl discouraging fighting close or really that brand of smart yet hyper aggressive play.

And that's why I dumped Brawl, and continued playing Smash 64 and Melee.

Anyways, to bring that all back, I would love to see a character like Miis, K. Rool, or Dixie Kong have that floatiness that is kinda Brawlsy, but has that sense of just Melee aggression. Truth be told, I think the Villager will be a lot like that.

Agree with this sentiment, so I'll just nod my head.

Yeah, I just love the prospect of a playable character like that.

 

[Mega Bidoof]

I tried to make it different than the usual rosters in the internet but still possible to happen.

My updated roster! Includes some of the suggestions made here:

View attachment 3447

WOW!!
This roster has a reasonable number of character, (I stretch the word reasonable)
If you replace the random space with N64, this would be one of my favorite roster ever!!

 

[TheLastJinjo]

Meowth as the 6th Pokemon? Lolno!

BTW What was EddyBearr even arguing about with Starman?

 

[TumblrFamous]

Meowth as the 6th Pokemon? Lolno!

BTW What was EddyBearr even arguing about with Starman?

In reality, if we did get a newcomer, it would be between him, Zoroark, or Genesect.

 

[Ridley_Prime]

Zoroark looks more like fighting material than Mew.

Even though Mew probably has a much bigger movepool than Zoroark due to all the TMs and stuff it can learn?

 

[3Bismyname]

I like to think Meowth has always been a highly considered Pokémon rep.