Roster Prediction Discussion Thread

[SuperBrawler]

Why can't we all be friends?

 

[BluePikmin11]

Unlike Wii Fit, there's characters in AC we actually want playable. Wii Fit Trainer doesn't really need a second character, because the majority of us are not demanding for another one. Sakurai knows that would piss off Smash fans.

 

[Arcadenik]

Careful now, Saturn... don't roll your eyes so much... you don't want your eyes to stare into your brain permanently.

 

[TheLastJinjo]

Unlike Wii Fit, there's characters in AC we actually want playable. Wii Fit Trainer doesn't really need a second character, because the majority of us are not demanding for another one. Sakurai knows that would piss off Smash fans.

Not a valid excuse.

 

[EddyBearr]

Unlike Wii Fit, there's characters in AC we actually want playable. Wii Fit Trainer doesn't really need a second character, because the majority of us are not demanding for another one. Sakurai knows that would piss off Smash fans.

There's just not enough characters that translate personally into smashers. It's got Yoshi/Metroid syndrome.

Above that, I'm seeing very few folks actually asking for more AC reps. There's more interest for the oh-so-hated Waluigi.

Man I love Waluigi.

 

[SuperBrawler]

Careful now, Saturn... don't roll your eyes so much... you don't want your eyes to stare into your brain permanently.

Brain?

 

[TumblrFamous]

I'm making a point how this excuse you guys use is invalid when used for other characters. Don't complain that I of all people am making sarcastic remarks about illogical points constantly being used by many to disregard major flaws in characters. It's not personally directed at you, it's directed at the invalid excuse itself.

I wasn't taking it offensively, but you're being a little unfair, as you have some odd choices too. I do understand agree that the argument for Tom Nook should not be applicable for characters, but come on.

 

[TheLastJinjo]

What people wanted was a character that was Animal Crossing. Just somebody to represent Animal Crossing and do Animal Crossing stuff. We got Villager. I honestly think people are just in denial about their Tom Nook requests just like Toad.

 

[BluePikmin11]

There's just not enough characters that translate personally into smashers. It's got Yoshi/Metroid syndrome.

Lemme ask ya a quick question, how would Ridley fit in personally?

 

[EddyBearr]

What people wanted was a character that was Animal Crossing. Just somebody to represent Animal Crossing and do Animal Crossing stuff. We got Villager. I honestly think people are just in denial about their Tom Nook requests just like Toad.

Not nearly as bad as Diskun fans.

Lemme ask ya a quick question, how would Ridley fit in personally?

Ridley has done things in games, things he could do in smash. He's even "snapped" with his mouth in the Melee trailer. He's got some unique things, especially those giant fireballs.

Ridley has massive moveset potential.

A better question would be questioning R.O.B.s personal moveset.

With that said, I have a strong feeling R.O.B. will not come back, and I have doubts for Ridley due to personality reasons. Ridley's personality just seems more like a boss role. I think demand has a strong chance of letting Ridley win out.

 

[Starcutter]

I think tom nook will get in smash. Remember the trailer?

 

[Arcadenik]

I am going to restrain myself and let that remark about Toad slide... Toad will always have my support no matter if he is confirmed or deconfirmed.

 

[Lasifer]

Lemme ask ya a quick question, how would Ridley fit in personally?

Ridley can't fit in anything. He is too big, dawg.

 

[TheLastJinjo]

Not nearly as bad as Diskun fans.

Diskun has fans?

Anyway, At least Diskun makes sense and isn't a pointless character that serves no purpose or defeats the purpose of an already existing character like Tom Nook does. Not to mention he has more potential than Tom Nook. There's nothing to be in denial about with Diskun.

 

[EddyBearr]

Ridley can't fit in anything. He is too big, dawg.

I've heard Pink Ridley would fit, though. Definitely not Purple Ridley.

Anyway, At least Diskun makes sense.

Not to mention he has more potential than Tom Nook.

A diskun reference makes tons of sense. A diskun character makes no sense. What's he gonna do? Spin?
At least Tom Nook has arms, legs, a head, and a tail. That's more potential to do things than Diskun could ever have. Tom Nook has, in the very least, the ability to turn enemies into green leaves (like he does furniture,) which is more than Diskun could ever do.

 

[Lasifer]

I think tom nook will get in smash. Remember the trailer?

DAYUUUM STRAIGHT, SON. HE FOLLOWIN' DAT ADDRESS AND KICKIN' THE VILLAGER'S ASS.

 

[TheLastJinjo]

I think tom nook will get in smash. Remember the trailer?

Sorry, but the invitation was for Villager. They won't allow Tom Nook in.

 

[Chandeelure]

Waddle dee is better than Tom Nook and Diskun combined.

 

[TheLastJinjo]

Comparing Diskun to Tom Nook is like comparing Wii Fit Trainer to Dark Pit.

Guess which one is Dark Pit...

 

[EddyBearr]

Waddle dee is better than Tom Nook and Diskun combined.

Waddle Dee's moveset potential consists of walking around mindlessly. At best, he has a spear and can poke someone if he happens to walk into them. At worst, he's just gonna waddle.

The spear gives him more potential than Tom Nook and Diskun combined, but a Koopa Troopa has more potential than all three combined.

 

[Louie G.]

A Tom Nook discussion?
Well that's kind of new.
Anyway, his chances aren't zero, but I don't believe that he will make it in the end.
Too many other potential candidates that are more requested and overall deserving than Tom Nook, an obvious Villager clone.

 

[shrooby]

I honestly think people are just in denial about their Tom Nook requests just like Toad.

You're just jealous because we got this whole river to ourselves

 

[Arcadenik]

A diskun reference makes tons of sense. A diskun character makes no sense. What's he gonna do? Spin?
At least Tom Nook has arms, legs, a head, and a tail. That's more potential to do things than Diskun could ever have. Tom Nook has, in the very least, the ability to turn enemies into green leaves (like he does furniture,) which is more than Diskun could ever do.

Good luck debating with Noah about Diskun... I've given up on the Diskun argument for the sake of my sanity.

 

[EddyBearr]

Good luck debating with Noah about Diskun... I've given up on the Diskun argument for the sake of my sanity.

Duck Hunt Dog > Diskun.

 

[Louie G.]

Duck Hunt Dog > Diskun.

 

[TheLastJinjo]

what's he gonna do? Spin?

Anything you can do in a Famicom game and anything related to the disk system. But, yeah that's not nearly as impressive as trying to get people to pay their house bills.
And yeah, the mascot for the popular peripheral of the revolutionary Famicom makes a little more sense than Villager 2, mind you.

Good luck debating with Noah about Diskun... I've given up on the Diskun argument for the sake of my sanity.

This is implying you debated at all or that sanity was present with you when you attempted to do so.

All you did was rant on Diskun and say he doesn't do anything. You intentionally ignored every point made that proved Diskun works which is your own stupid bias and sheer lack of knowledge.

Every single point you made WAS in fact proven false or invalid so give some credit to the people who really lost their insanity having to argue with someone who didn't even bring up a single true or valid point.

 

[Arcadenik]

Uh.... nope... I am not taking the bait.

 

[BluePikmin11]

The only reason Diskun or a Hanafuda character would be added is because of its importance to Nintendo's history.

 

[TheLastJinjo]

Uh.... nope... I am not taking the bait.

Then prove Diskun doesn't work instead of making up pure lies and go parading around acting like you contributed **** to the debate. You are a pure bull **** liar.

You are know better than Divine Deity, going around spewing Grade A Bull **** and then after claiming victory with no merits besides your narcissism you complain that the people proving you wrong are trolling.

You were prove wrong in your argument. Admit it and stop acting like DD.

 

[SchAlternate]

So... kinda late, but I've read the Ice Climber discussion a few pages ago. While Ice Climber itself was pretty lame, I think it'd be great to see the duo appear in a non-Smash game again.

 

[BluePikmin11]

I think tom nook will get in smash. Remember the trailer?

Ah I love the letter theory.

 

[Chandeelure]

Waddle Dee's moveset potential consists of walking around mindlessly. At best, he has a spear and can poke someone if he happens to walk into them. At worst, he's just gonna waddle.

The spear gives him more potential than Tom Nook and Diskun combined, but a Koopa Troopa has more potential than all three combined.

Koopa Troopa eh?
You've made a powerful enemy today...

 

[Arcadenik]

Duck Hunt Dog is a dog. Diskun is a floppy disk. Dogs use floppy disks as chewing toys.

 

[TheLastJinjo]

Duck Hunt Dog is a dog. Diskun is a floppy disk. Dogs use floppy disks as chewing toys.

At least attempt to use a valid excuse. Don't go acting like you won a debate which was actually just you ranting when you fully acknowledge in this comment you are being bias.

 

[Lasifer]

The only reason Diskun or a Hanafuda character would be added is because of its importance to Nintendo's history.

Hanafuda topkek.

 

[EddyBearr]

Anything you can do in a Famicom game and anything related to the disk system. But, yeah that's not nearly as impressive as trying to get people to pay their house bills.
And yeah, the mascot for the popular peripheral of the revolutionary Famicom makes a little more sense than Villager 2, mind you.

That's like saying we can have an N64 logo throw Golden bananas, swing a master sword, or fly with the wing-cap.

So because it happens to be a logo, without a history of ever actually doing anything, of a platform by which certain games could be played in which certain characters could do certain things, Diskun automatically is personally attached to all the moves in all the games?

This is absurd. This is like saying that because Duck Hunt existed on the NES, then Duck Hunt Dog can take in enemies like cartridges.

At least Duck Hunt Dog has one thing going for him, for sure: a taunt. Nothing you suggest about Diskun has anything to do with Diskun.

 

[TheLastJinjo]

Everything you said about Diskun is a lie and you know it Arcadenik. You are complete hypocrite and are the last person who has the right to compare people to DD, when you are acting JUST like him

 

[Richard 89]

Duck Hunt Dog is a dog. Diskun is a floppy disk. Dogs use floppy disks as chewing toys.

*imagines a St. Bernard holding a computer floppy disk* .....EW

 

[Louie G.]

Are we going to go over this again?
I'm gonna say this one more time:
The Dog can laugh, Diskun can not.
The Dog can not use all NES Peripherals or represent Famicom games other than Duck Hunt.
They would be quite different, and can both work.

 

[KingofPhantoms]

Arcadenik is trolling Saturn about Diskun. What else is new?