Roster Discussion Thread (Closed)

[MagnesD3]

Not any more forced than pulling made-up moves out of Sakurai's butt for certain characters who are already in.

Im feel jr/shadow mario has earned the spot alot more though, he has been turned into a main villian.

 

[FlareHabanero]

Only Bowser Jr. earned that spot, while Shadow Mario has been dormant for years now. But just because he got promoted to a prominent villain, it doesn't guarantee anything.

 

[MagnesD3]

Only Bowser Jr. earned that spot, while Shadow Mario has been dormant for years now. But just because he got promoted to a prominent villain, it doesn't guarantee anything.

shadow mario is mostly just a great addition to jr's moveset, i mean he is shadow mario. And of course it doesnt guarantee an entry im just saying he deserves it. I mean hell ridley deserved it along time ago

 

[lobotheduck21]

Anyways, if k. rool gets in, then dixie and diddy become a tag team character, do you think we could could get a 3rd DK character (making up 4 slots)

I'm tired of this generic argument, and I want people's opinion on this

 

[3Bismyname]

after K Rool, and Dixie who else would you add to make up 4 slots?

 

[Ember Reaper]

Im feel jr/shadow mario has earned the spot alot more though, he has been turned into a main villian.

Bowser Jr. has been one of my most wanted for so very long. So I totally agree with you, but I see it happening less and less. I don't see a mario character happening because there are 4 possibilities and all 4 are split evenly. None are really high enough as others. If one character had the combined want of all 4 (Jr, Toad, Paper Mario, and Waluigi) it would be a no brainer on par with K. Rool, Mewtwo and Megaman. That's the only issue. It saddens me because I want Bowser Jr. so bad. Paper Mario would be cool too

 

[MagnesD3]

I'm tired of this generic argument, and I want people's opinion on this

Dk series only deserves 3 reps id say, dk, diddy and k. rool. Dixie just seems way to cloney to me, and i dont want a team up with diddy/dixie since diddy is such a good character by himself.

 

[Robert of Normandy]

Anyways, if k. rool gets in, then dixie and diddy become a tag team character, do you think we could could get a 3rd DK character (making up 4 slots)

Not sure what you're asking. If K. Rool got in, and Dixie became a partner to Diddy, then yes, there WOULD be 4 DK characters. Are you asking how likely the situation is?

 

[lobotheduck21]

after K Rool, and Dixie who else would you add to make up 4 slots?

Only one I can see is cranky (I feel he even deserves a spot)

@shinpichu yes then we get a 3rd DK character

 

[MagnesD3]

Bowser Jr. has been one of my most wanted for so very long. So I totally agree with you, but I see it happening less and less. I don't see a mario character happening because there are 4 possibilities and all 4 are split evenly. None are really high enough as others. If one character had the combined want of all 4 (Jr, Toad, Paper Mario, and Waluigi) it would be a no brainer on par with K. Rool, Mewtwo and Megaman. That's the only issue. It saddens me because I want Bowser Jr. so bad. Paper Mario would be cool too

Id love to see what sakerai would do with shadow mario and his various types of paint, the combo of jr./shadow mario is something ive wanted since sunshine.

 

[Arcadenik]

Toad, the species, are Kino in Japan. The individual is Kinopio. What more do you need?

And for being Peach's special, he can be replaced with Toadsworth so Toad can be playable. Problem solved.

This! I also posted this on the Peach thread the other night...

What I want to see regarding Peach's palette swaps in SSB4... I'd like her palette swaps to be based on the other damsels in distress of the Marioverse and her history. This includes eye color and hair color and even skin color, the style of the dress and the crown, the style of the earrings and the brooch, and even the Toads she pulls out swap palettes depend on her current palette swap.

[COLLAPSE="Peach's Palette Swaps"]Default - Peach

Red Team - Pauline from Mario vs. Donkey Kong

Blue Team - Rosalina from Super Mario Galaxy

Green Team - Queen Merelda from Wario Land: Shake It!

Other Color #1 - Daisy from Super Mario Land

Other Color #2 - Shadow Queen from Paper Mario: The Thousand-Year Door

Other Color #3 - Princess Toadstool from Super Mario Bros.

[/COLLAPSE]

[COLLAPSE="Peach's Toad's Palette Swaps"]Default (Peach) - Toadsworth

Red Team (Pauline) - Super Mushroom

Blue Team (Rosalina) - Mini Mushroom

Green Team (Queen Merelda) - 1-UP Mushroom

Other Color #1 (Daisy) - Toadette

Other Color #2 (Shadow Queen) - Poison Mushroom

Other Color #3 (Princess Toadstool) - Mushroom Retainer

[/COLLAPSE]

While Peach's Toad gets palette swaps based on mushrooms and obscure Toads, the playable Toad gets palette swaps based on the well-known Toad Brigade. It's to emphasize that Peach's Toad is a generic Toad and the playable Toad is THE Toad.

[COLLAPSE="Playable Toad's Palette Swaps"]Default - Kinopio

Red Team - Red Toad
Blue Team - Blue Toad
Green Team - Green Toad
Other Color #1 - Yellow Toad
Other Color #2 - Purple Toad

[/COLLAPSE]

 

[3Bismyname]

Only one I can see is cranky (I feel he even deserves the spot)

@shinpichu yes then we get a 3rd DK character

if Cranky is the best option than no i dont see that as likely

 

[Robert of Normandy]

@shinpichu yes then we get a 3rd DK character

You mean newcomer? No. I think Dixie getting is stretching it a bit. IMO, if Dixie gets in, she will likely be the last.

 

[lobotheduck21]

if Cranky is the best option than no i dont see that as likely

A why out of curiosity

 

[MagnesD3]

A why out of curiosity

Cranky fights your self esteem lol.

 

[3Bismyname]

i just dont see it. no real reason really. Cranky feels very assist trophy at best to me.

 

[Ember Reaper]

i just dont see it. no real reason really. Cranky feels very assist trophy at best to me.

I could see him being a hilarious assist trophy. Especially if he had rockets on his chair and would hit people. Why? That's what I envisioned. Why? Cuz it would be hilarious. That is all.
He deserves AT status

 

[lobotheduck21]

i just dont see it. no real reason really. Cranky feels very assist trophy at best to me.

Alright, thanks for the opinion

I think he won't be in for ssb4, but with an appearance in a mario sports game I think it might help, I think he has the most appearance through out the platforming series

But I do think he would make a good assist trophy

 

[3Bismyname]

does donkey kong have an assist trophy in Brawl? if not than that's a damn shame

 

[Arcadenik]

Cranky Kong, Rambi, Donkey Kong Jr., and Stanley the Bugman are good choices for Assist Trophies.

 

[Opossum]

This! I also posted this on the Peach thread the other night...

I went to the Peach thread to see if anyone responded to this post...what the hell was going on in that thread...?

 

[Arcadenik]

I went to the Peach thread to see if anyone responded to this post...what the hell was going on in that thread...?

I dunno what they were talking about... I only skimmed as I scrolled down... something about sex appeal... and high heels... and furries. Granted, it was only on the last page, the same page where I posted my post.

 

[lobotheduck21]

does donkey kong have an assist trophy in Brawl? if not than that's a damn shame

No, he doesn't, DK didn't get a lot of content

 

[Opossum]

That being said, Arcadenik, I did like the idea with the Peach/Toad Pallete Swaps.

 

[3Bismyname]

No, he doesn't, DK didn't get a lot of content

than they definately deserve one in smash 4. Cranky or Rambi are the best choices imo

 

[lobotheduck21]

One cool thing if cranky was in smash would be the cranky mario fights

 

[3Bismyname]

that would make a good event match

 

[lobotheduck21]

It's to bad cranky can't get out of the DK series (curse you super mario sluggers developers)

 

[Arcadenik]

That being said, Arcadenik, I did like the idea with the Peach/Toad Pallete Swaps.

Thanks! That "Super Mushroom" palette swap for Peach's Toad really appeals to me the most, mainly because it really reminds me of Fire Toad from the old Mario cartoon. I would love to see that Fire Toad in other colors based on the other mushrooms. They are like the reverse-colored Toad Brigade.

I would love to see someone edit palette swaps for those Peach/Toad suggestions. I know it's superficial and doesn't affect gameplay but the idea of it really excites me as a fan of the Mario universe to see so many mushrooms and damsels in distress referred through Toad and Peach.

 

[SmashChu]

An aside: it's funny to go on 4Chan and see Manly talk crap about Chrono.

 

[3Bismyname]

An aside: it's funny to go on 4Chan and see Manly talk crap about Chrono.

doesn't surprise me in the slightest.

 

[lobotheduck21]

An aside: it's funny to go on 4Chan and see Manly talk crap about Chrono.

We should have made bets on how long their peace would last

 

[Arcadenik]

I think the peace would have lasted a bit longer if Smashchu didn't bring it up here instead of leaving it behind at 4chan. Oh well!

 

[FlareHabanero]

I told all of you tranquility never lasts long.

 

[Arcadenik]

To restore some peace to this thread, let's just change the subjects back to Toad. Yeah, Toad for SSB4! How about those palette swaps?

 

[Deleted member]

Yeah, but that's what palette swaps are for. What's the big deal?

Default = Kinopio
Palette swaps = Kinos

Oh, and THE Yoshi isn't the only green Yoshi in existence. Generic Yoshis come in green, too.

OMG. Why are we having this generic argument again?

No, I was correcting your statement that the red spot/blue vest made Kinopio stand out like how the Bandana Dee's bandana makes him stand out.
It really doesn't since most of the time, the Kinos share the color.
You do realize I'm a Toad supporter too, right? There's no rule that a Waluigi supporter can't be a Toad supporter.

 

[Diddy Kong]

How can you even recognise that it´s Manly, talking about Chrono? Then again, I KNOW all of you are 4chan dwellers anyway so... Do what ya´ll feel like you need to do.

Leave me out of it though. Am innocent as ****.

 

[lobotheduck21]

I would actually be happy with any Mario character except for daisy
Wa, toad, and Bj would be good for cutscenes, rosa and paper could have cool gameplay (not that rosa or daisy are likely)

It's the GOLDEN rule wa supporters must troll all other mario options

 

[Arcadenik]

No, I was correcting your statement that the red spot/blue vest made Kinopio stand out like how the Bandana Dee's bandana makes him stand out.
It really doesn't since most of the time, the Kinos share the color.
You do realize I'm a Toad supporter too, right? There's no rule that a Waluigi supporter can't be a Toad supporter.

Well, no, there's no rule saying that... but I didn't know you were a Toad supporter. I didn't see you voting for Toad on that SSB4 poll thread. That's one of the few ways I use to determine who's supporting who.

 

[Big-Cat]

I told all of you tranquility never lasts long.

SmashBoards Tag Tournament! KumaOso and Manly Spirit vs. Chronobound and SmashChu!