They never find themselves below RU because of good movepools and stats. Pokémon like Druddigon and Altaria may not be powerful, but their stats aren't exactly terrible either
Drud has a BST of 485, a speed of 40 and no bulk or priority to justify that either. There's quite simply no way anyone who is compotent at this game could possibly argue that is anything near decent unless you have massive conformation bias.
Every single pokemon with his BST total is NU with the exception of Spirtomb and Cryonogal is NU, and Cry is only picked because of his use for rapid spin.
Yet this pokemon not only overcomes his BST to particpate in the tier, he DEFINES the tier. He is the dominate threat despite being below the tier's average BST. He has no move like Spore to justify it, he has no obscene stat to justify it. All he has is the undisputed most powerful STAB in the game.
Even outside of our own metagame, if you simply run the numbers on what types are objectively strong beitof themselves, dragon comes out on top both offensively AND defensively. If you then weight those numbers by what is strong on the other end, dragon again comes out on top. (And as a note, if you make a type that hits everything neutral, it comes out on top.)
I've spent the last summer with Ulti looking into stuff like this (given he's done all the hard work and math and graphs) and I can easily provide those, but for something as blatently obvious as this, it shouldn't be needed.
Physical/Special split was the best thing to ever happen to this game
Physical Special was horrible handled and destroyed as many pokemon as it saved. It was nothing more than a redistribution of power, not the creation of.
EVs force you to walk a tightrop, and up until the upcoming gen, they were so poorly implemented it's unreal. They were hidden specific values that needed absolute precision control on the part of the trainer, thus causing an incredibly bizarre type of grind that did absolutely nothing to improve the overall experience over just letting you assign the EVs. Looks like they're fixing that at least. Still, EVs are far too limited to really allow players to take advantage of say, more evenly distributed stats, thus driving the metagame to extremes, Hyper speed, hyper offence, hyper this hyper that, there's always going to be a lean towards a certain tactic, but the fact that you're so pigeonholed is frustrating.
Again, none of what you say here is true.
What setbacks EV training may have on the players is greatly outweighed by the flexibility it offers to the player. When you compare the number of viable sets then to now you see the benefit this has brought competitive
play.
http://www.smogon.com/gs/pokemon/gengarhttp://www.smogon.com/rs/pokemon/gengar
Third and Fourth gen were some of the most balanced in reguards to playstyle despite being the dawns of EVs. The only reason for our hyper offense game right now is simply too much power creep in offense. There was a deliberate effort here to make the game more offensive and unfortunately for singles it was unneeded.
Oh I'm sorry I don't keep up to date with the metagame of glorious Nippon (banzai), and that I also expect them to only cater to one facet of their own ****ing game. Yes it's called whining and moaning when I expect them to make sure ALL aspects of the design are sound. What a ******** argument that is, were you born in Snap City? "Oh they're not trying to design the game properly so you shouldn't complain!"
That's piss poor.
You can design for them.
You can make them function.
However you can NEVER balance two games internally with shared resources at once.
Have you ever even worked on a game before? Balancing one is a near impossibility. Balancing two simultaneously is impossible.
Guild Wars 1 collapsed because of this.
From Magic to League, every community that has to work with these institutes banlilst balance changes for these different environments to make them adjust.
"Debate Hall rhetoric"
You can report me to whomever you want, and they aren't gonna do ****.
Maybe its changed since I was permabanned from Smashboards but it was always told that you must uphold debate hall standards to all sections of the site.