PM Arts and Alts Thread

[Shin F.]

ill do it i guess

I think someone else said they were going to. If you want to start it, be prepared to take the time to create and manage the OP and update the votes and stuff. Also, we might want to gather all the rules again from the last few pages.

 

[arcticfox8]

The Pokémon hats are fine, it's what makes Pika and Puff unique, they don't need to change their skin color for us. #Pokéracism

 

[splat]

The Pokémon hats are fine, it's what makes Pika and Puff unique, they don't need to change their skin color for us.

This, so much. I don't know why people want to get rid of something so unique. Changing hats to colors is one of the worse ideas I've read in this thread.

The circlejerk on it on the previous page doesn't make it any better.

 

[Zeallyx]

ill do it i guess

As Shin F. said, you'll have to put in quite some work: post the rules, keep track of mentioned alt. costumes, keep track of the votes per costume and make the OP easy (i. e organized) and nice to look at (i.e. visually appealing and grammatically correct). Also, you'll have to keep doing all this (minus posting the rules) for quite some time.

I think someone else said they were going to. If you want to start it, be prepared to take the time to create and manage the OP and update the votes and stuff. Also, we might want to gather all the rules again from the last few pages.

I said I was going to, but I don't think I will have the time to do it, at least not all on my own. I could make the OP and manage it, but people would have to help with keeping track of mentioned alt. costumes and their votes (for example) by counting and posting the results so I can copy/paste them into the OP. I'm not saying I'll never be able to manage the OP on my own, but I'd definitely need help to keep it up to date. So if there's someone who could do it all on his or her own, then I guess said person is better suited for the job than I am.

 

[kylexv]

My hopes for alts:

Mario: Full; replace brown color for yellow color from vBrawl
Luigi: Dr. Luigi
Peach: Needs no more
Bowser: Dark Bowser, Meowser
Donkey Kong: Needs no more
Diddy Kong: None needed
Yoshi: Full
Wario: Full
Link: White OoT Link recolor
Zelda: Melee Zelda w/ recolors
Sheik: Melee Sheik with recolors
Ganondorf: Melee Ganondorf w/ recolors
Toon Link: Conductor outfit
Samus: One of her other suits (Light, Dark, Fusion).
ZSS: A recolor to match the new Samus suit.
Pit: None needed
Ice Climbers: JP boxart (Look at Nana, create Popo that looks similar).
R.O.B.: Needs no more
Kirby: Purple, Brown, Meta Knight-colored Kirbies.
Meta Knight: Dark Meta Knight
King Dedede: Masked Dedede
Olimar: None needed
Fox: Full
Falco: Full
Wolf: Pirate Wolf recolors
Captain Falcon: Helmetless Falcon
Pikachu: Green Hat from Melee, Red Hat from Smash 64
Jigglypuff: No more needed
Squirtle: Squirtletwo
Ivysaur: "Ivysaurtwo" similar in design to Venusaurtwo
Charizard: Charizardtwo
Mewtwo: No more needed
Lucario: No more needed
Marth: SSB4-like design
Ike: Vanguard Ike
Roy: None needed
Ness: No more needed
Lucas: No more needed
Game and Watch: White color
Snake: None needed
Sonic: Sonic Boom design, SA2:B Battle mode alt outfit

 

[Kally Wally]

Roy: None needed

[collapse=u wot m8]

[/collapse]

 

[Generically Epic]

This, so much. I don't know why people want to get rid of something so unique. Changing hats to colors is one of the worse ideas I've read in this thread.

The circlejerk on it on the previous page doesn't make it any better.

I never said get rid of the hats, just put the hats on the recolors.

 

[Generically Epic]

The problem is Young Link is a different size compared to Link. Not even REMOTELY feasible. And neither is Young Link on top of Toon Link.

You could put a mask or something from his games on him then put toon link in young links clothes and carry his weapons and you're done.

 

[andalsoandy]

It's not impossible without bone edits, by the way

My hopes for alts:

Mario: Full; replace Fire Mario color for yellow color from vBrawl
Luigi: Dr. Luigi
Peach: Dark Queen Recolors, Wedding Peach.
Bowser: Dark Bowser, Meowser
Donkey Kong: Boxing DK Recolors
Diddy Kong: Another Kong's outfit (Funky, Chunky, etc.)
Yoshi: Full
Wario: Possibly in need or replacements for some colors.
Link: White OoT Link recolor
Zelda: Melee Zelda w/ recolors
Sheik: Melee Sheik with recolors
Ganondorf: Melee Ganondorf w/ recolors
Toon Link: Conductor outfit
Samus: One of her other suits (Light, Dark, Fusion).
ZSS: A recolor to match the new Samus suit, or Justin Bailey.
Pit: Whatever the **** armor from Uprising.
Ice Climbers: JP boxart (Look at Nana, create Popo that looks similar). (This is a really good idea.)
R.O.B.: Tocksknocks' Wii R.O.B.
Kirby: Purple, Brown, Meta Knight-colored and Carbon-colored Kirbies.
Meta Knight: Quickdraw Meta Knight and Super Star Ultra Hat (Name?)
King Dedede: Masked Dedede or Quickdraw Dedede
Olimar: Mr. President Outfit.
Fox: Full
Falco: Full
Wolf: Pirate Wolf recolors
Captain Falcon: Helmetless Falcon or SNES/90s Falcon
Pikachu: Green Hat from Melee, Red Hat from Smash 64
Jigglypuff: Green Focus Sash from Melee.
Squirtle: Squirtletwo
Ivysaur: "Ivysaurtwo" similar in design to Venusaurtwo
Charizard: Charizardtwo
Mewtwo: More Recolors for Armor Mewtwo
Lucario: Sir Aaron
Marth: SSB4-like design
Ike: Vanguard Ike
Roy: some popular FE design, idk
Ness: Robot Ness
Lucas: Commander Recolors
Game and Watch: White color or Mrs. G&W
Snake: MGS1 or MGS4 appearence
Sonic: Sonic Boom design, SA2:B Battle mode alt outfit

Fixed.

 

[LeeYawshee]

Guys, can we make it a priority to not request anything for characters that have costumes already? PMBR reads our posts so we should think up ideas for characters who haven't gotten a single costume.

 

[arcticfox8]

Mach Rider for Captain Falcon. Since Mach Rider has his face covered it could be written off as cosplay without changing Rider's design.

 

[Marthmario]

We need more console alts for R.O.B.....

 

[Motobug]

Here's my list for AC, only including characters that have no AC yet:

Diddy: Dixie if possible, maybe a fighting Diddy to go along with DK
Captain Falcon: Hearts Falcon like some have mentioned, a true blood falcon costume too.
Ice Climbers: I'd love to see Baby Mario+Luigi like some modders have done, but I have no idea otherwise
Zelda: SS zelda, most likely
Sheik: OoT Shiek to go along with Zelda, but otherwise idk
Ganon: OoT Ganon
Lucario: I kinda wanna see Riolu, his lvl 1 evolution
Squirtle: Full Koopa Costume
Ivysaur: Bulbasaur
Charizard: Dragonite, if possible
Samus: Light/Dark Samus, Fusion Suit
ZSS: No idea
Pit: Retro Pit color from the original game, that would be cool
Kirby: More colors
D3: Masked D3
All FE: Awakening costumes
Olimar: No idea
G&W: More colors
Snake: Liquid maybe? I don;t know much about MGS.
Sonic: Boom Sonic or Metal. Or if somehow they make classic work, then that too.

 

[Shin F.]

Here's my list for AC, only including characters that have no AC yet:
Diddy: Dixie if possible, maybe a fighting Diddy to go along with DK
Ice Climbers: I'd love to see Baby Mario+Luigi like some modders have done, but I have no idea otherwise
Squirtle: Full Koopa Costume
Charizard: Dragonite, if possible
Snake: Liquid maybe? I don;t know much about MGS.
Sonic: Boom Sonic or Metal. Or if somehow they make classic work, then that too.

PMBR said they'll only do alt costumes that are essentially the same character.

 

[Generically Epic]

Here's my list for AC, only including characters that have no AC yet:

Diddy: Dixie if possible, maybe a fighting Diddy to go along with DK
Captain Falcon: Hearts Falcon like some have mentioned, a true blood falcon costume too.
Ice Climbers: I'd love to see Baby Mario+Luigi like some modders have done, but I have no idea otherwise
Zelda: SS zelda, most likely
Sheik: OoT Shiek to go along with Zelda, but otherwise idk
Ganon: OoT Ganon
Lucario: I kinda wanna see Riolu, his lvl 1 evolution
Squirtle: Full Koopa Costume
Ivysaur: Bulbasaur
Charizard: Dragonite, if possible
Samus: Light/Dark Samus, Fusion Suit
Pit: Retro Pit color from the original game, that would be cool
Kirby: More colors
D3: Masked D3
All FE: Awakening costumes
G&W: More colors
Snake: Liquid maybe?
Sonic: Boom Sonic or Metal. Or if somehow they make classic work, then that too.

Crossed out all the ones that are completely impossible.

 

[Marthmario]

Crossed out all the ones that are completely impossible.

Why are Awakening Costumes impossible? ;~;

 

[Generically Epic]

Why are Awakening Costumes impossible? ;~;

too new

 

[Shin F.]

too new

Fire Peach.

 

[Marthmario]

Fire Peach.

This.

 

[Ginge]

Yeah, I'm in total support for the three lords in the game getting their Awakening costumes + recolors.

 

[MLGF]

Yeah, I'm in total support for the three lords in the game getting their Awakening costumes + recolors.

...Do you really want this?

When Ike has 3 other legitimately cool outfits not shown in Smash yet?
Really? Heck, I'd take Priam before I took FE13 Ike, this abomination needs to die.

Marth deserves his Pantless alt and a few more recolors and Roy... yeah his FE13 art is pretty sweet.

 

[Shin F.]

...Do you really want this?

When Ike has 3 other legitimately cool outfits not shown in Smash yet?
Really? Heck, I'd take Priam before I took FE13 Ike, this abomination needs to die.

Marth deserves his Pantless alt and a few more recolors and Roy... yeah his FE13 art is pretty sweet.

Oh... so that's why I've never seen Ike's Awakening artwork. Excuse me while I bleach my eyes.

I do like Roy's quite a bit, though.

 

[Ginge]

I seem to remember a different costume on Ike when I came across him.

Edit:

Spoiler: Around 17:00

Granted, it's not as good as his other costumes like Hero Ike. But at the same time, it isn't as bad as that.

 

[MLGF]

Well for that chapter the ingame outfit is based on the generic merc class, what all the enemy units of that game look like with a different pallet, while the artwork itself is directly ripped off of his official art for Fire Emblem Path of Radiance. In fact, his DLC outfit is literally Ike poorly drawn in the generic hero outfit. I dunno, having Ike get an outfit based off of a generic model feels underwhelming even if he didn't have a sword arm.

 

[Marthmario]

Hey what about Wedding Dress Peach and A Peach with a Plumber esque costume? Also, would Awakening Marth have the new Falchion or no?

 

[Marthmario]

*actually likes the redesign of Ike* ._. *would prefer Vanguard Ike tho*

 

[Shin F.]

Hey what about Wedding Dress Peach and A Peach with a Plumber esque costume? Also, would Awakening Marth have the new Falchion or no?

Any Peach costume has to have her dress because some of her attacks use it, so the Plumber Peach probably wouldn't work.

 

[Marthmario]

Any Peach costume has to have her dress because some of her attacks use it, so the Plumber Peach probably wouldn't work.

I realize, but what if we give her a plumber inspired dress?2

 

[Shin F.]

I realize, but what if we give her a plumber inspired dress?2

If it had a dress, I don't think it would look very plumber-like. I suppose you could make it hang on her shoulders like a pair of overalls. That might work.

 

[Marthmario]

If it had a dress, I don't think it would look very plumber-like. I suppose you could make it hang on her like a pair of overalls. That might work.

Perhaps a Denim dress? I think it'd be cool to have a cap for her as well.

 

[Shin F.]

Perhaps a Denim dress? I think it'd be cool to have a cap for her as well.

It can't interfere with her crown. She also uses it in an attack, I believe. You could have it replace her crown, but it would have to match it in size.

 

[arcticfox8]

Best Peach alt, would main.

 

[Ginge]

*actually likes the redesign of Ike* ._. *would prefer Vanguard Ike tho*

The problem what that outfit is that it seems more like something from Odin Sphere or Dragon's Crown than from a Fire Emblem game.

 

[PhantasyStar]

I posted this in the Zelda Thread, but can my baby get a little makeover

 

[Generically Epic]

THEN I DEMAND MARTH WEARING LUCINA'S MASK!

 

[shairn]

In response to helmetless CF: if you take the anime as canon, it wouldn't be very coherent to show his face because of the pretty big plot point near the end surrounding it.

Spoiler

There are at least two Captains, and might have been more before but I can't remember if it's said that there was.

 

[SmashBroski]

All my want.

Spoiler: Masked Dedede

Spoiler: Charizardtwo

Spoiler: Marth (Fire Emblem: Awakening)

Spoiler: Ike (Lord: Path of Radiance)

Spoiler: Snake (MGS3: Snake Eate)r

 

[Banjodorf]

<-- Still thinks Tuxedo Snake is a must.

 

[Generically Epic]

All my want.

Spoiler: Masked Dedede

Spoiler: Charizardtwo

Spoiler: Marth (Fire Emblem: Awakening)

Spoiler: Ike (Lord: Path of Radiance)

Spoiler: Snake (MGS3: Snake Eate)r

that marth needs a mask, bro.

 

[SmashBroski]

that marth needs a mask, bro.

"Since these costumes are either the same character or wearing a costume inspired by another, the criteria we use for deciding on Clone Engine characters (that is, already appearing in the game in some way) does not necessarily apply to Alternate Costumes. This all being said, you shouldn't expect things like Daisy over Peach, or Shadow over Sonic as these would break our rules and are just not possible to do at the level of quality and professionalism we strive to maintain."

If it meets the criteria the PMBR strives for, I'm all for it.