Paper Mario Mafia: Day 4 finally ends! Luigi wins!

[#HBC | J]

No one has pointed out how a town-read of mine scummy....yeah that's totally not scumhunting. ;p

I already old you how he is protown in that very quote you quoted.

There is that evil side of me that wants to lynch Bardull and if he flips town, that'll just show me and marshy being right and Seph not deserving to lead lunches this game.

 

[Sephiroths Masamune]

Btw if they're both scum, Kary's cases on Bardull still stand


Rajam, you're wasting your vote on Adumb. Join Bardull tbh.

Ronike, seeing as you promised to semi-join the voting block, what is your current opinion on Bardull?

John, get back on Barbell. You joined him for the right reasons. We'll have him go.

cawm ooooon


and J, like OS said, your reasons were pretty bad. Go with that last plan and prove me wrong, it would be delicious, and you'd have a vig on your side. Sac a town read for the greater good woo?

 

[#HBC | J]

Kary I'll get back to you when I get the chance to sit down and deliberate more but a short note.

Do you understand FUD? it's fear, uncertainty, and doubt. you are trying to use fear to stop your lynch by saying it would be bad and also just not good or things like that. yes, it has wifom in it but it is also FUD.

 

[#HBC | J]

I will only lynch Bardull if marshy or Sang move to Bardull.

 

[Sephiroths Masamune]

Then don't say that you kinda want to lynch him, geez.

 

[#HBC | marshy]

@ john

were townbros right? vote kary

@ adumb

you said you didnt like bardull as scum. vote kary

@ sangfroid

read what i said to adumb. stick to your guns. vote kary

@ bardull

wanna live? vote kary

@ ronike

how the **** are you voting with OVERSWARM over me? are you serious dude? vote kary

@ rajam

you YOURSELF said kary was a better play than bardull. vote kary

@ chibo

lol

ronike remains the best play but we have seph to whiteknight his scummy ***. good job

 

[Sephiroths Masamune]

Stop refusing to read the ****ing thread Marshy. Read it and see what I see.

 

[#HBC | J]

Seph, that was a joke.

join Kary, Seph. It's the right path.

 

[Sephiroths Masamune]

If we DO lynch Kary (which isn't the end of the world but meh nonetheless) I'm shooting Bardull and spend the entire day seizing thread control if I get it right lol

 

[#HBC | J]

Grrrrr you should shoot Ronike/Rajam toNight regardless.

 

[#HBC | Kary]

lol @ kary wanting to be townbros with j but not just joining us on ronike by the way

pseudo bromanship right there brah

??? Pretty sure J said he wouldn't be townbros with me, so i'm not going to bro him after that; I think you're joking though so nevermind.

Bardull vs Kary is SvS. That's how it is. I can't compensate on reads. However, if you're gonna pull a quick one on me, pull it on Kary, not Ronike.

Oooh, dislike. Yeah, really not sold on me/Bardull being SvS, makes barely any sense at all (oh and I'm town, duh).

Marshy, I would go Ronike but we wot get it with the way Seph/OS are. we can get Kary though.

get the votes, and I'll join is pretty much what im saying at this point.

This sounds like crazy talk to me. You don't like the Bardull waggon not least because Seph etc. are on it, but you'll lynch me over Ronike because that's what Seph wants? You can get damn Ronike through if you need to, for crying out loud.
Apologies if I've misread this one but yeah.


Gotta dash now, anyhow.

Oh, P.S. @J, everyone?

HOW am I spreading FUD (fear, uncertainty, doubt) just by saying I'm a bad play.
Seriuosly, does that make you afraid, uncertain etc.?
I'm straight up telling you I'm a bad play; if that makes you doubt yourself then what are you playing at.
Now here's why I might be a bad play:
I'm actually posting content, which makes me easy to read.
I'm not going to slip out of anyone's attention when everyone wants me dead Day 2.
I'm actually helping town with my posts.
And so on, whatever, etc.
Disagree if you like, but if you lynch me now, regardless of how I flip, you're going to have a hella time figuring out who else is scum. Me plus Ronike or Bardull makes almost 0% sense.

Oh, and I have a sick claim as well. Where's that trollface smiley?

 

[#HBC | marshy]

**** your claim

 

[#HBC | Kary]

Oh, and someone, anyone, talk to me about Bardull being at L-1 but not being hammered. Does that tell us anything about his alignment/who he might be buddies with?

P.S. Can we just kill Bardull purely to answer this question?

Seriously, gotta go now.

(if you think this is deflecting, ask yourself, is it a pro-town question to ask? I'd say so! )

 

[#HBC | marshy]

1. Disagree if you like, but if you lynch me now, regardless of how I flip, you're going to have a hella time figuring out who else is scum. Me plus Ronike or Bardull makes almost 0% sense.

2. Oh, and I have a sick claim as well. Where's that trollface smiley?

1. lmao **** no. pretty sure i have 6 players outside myself that i dont wanna lynch anytime soon and a vig to narrow the others down

2. your claim means **** unless its mason. if im online ima just tell someone to hammer your *** before you post it. we JUST got done a game where town lost largely cuz of "lol claims are so important and integral to the game!!"

yo if you flip town kary dont *****. i gave you your chance with sangfroid and ronike earlier. your scare tactics dont mean **** either. can you vote yourself to make this go faster please?

 

[#HBC | marshy]

wait j you think sang is protown?

 

[#HBC | J]

Shhh marshy. I'm doing something. I'll give that answer later.

 

[#HBC | J]

Also there's the freaking word I was lookin for. Scare tactics = Kary.

 

[adumbrodeus]

*sigh*

Bardull isn't scum, and I'd prefer ronike, but...

unvote, Vote: Kary

I wanna finish up solidifying my reads before we end but currently:


Townbros:

Marshy
OS
Pierce

Probabably townbros:

Bardull

Null:

J
John2k
Chibo

Probably not townbros:

Sanfroid
Rajam

Definately not townbros:

Kary
Ronike


Special:

Sephi (townbro if doesn't have a nk, not townbro if he doesn)


I especially wanna get those nulls hammered down before we finish but if we do finish before I can, scythe through the nulls or worse.

And don't let sephi get away with controlling his nk if he has one.

 

[#HBC | Kary]

Yo, marshy, I asked you why Ronike and you just said because he's not Bardull.

You know I want at least some evidence/argument so seriously you saying you gave me a chance is just meaningless. You're just saying 'sheep me or die'.
And you're calling me on scare tactics, lol.

Scare tactics?
Give me some damn credit.
Or just think through why me + Ronike scum makes sense. As if I wouldn't have just made up some damn evidence and lynched him already. Oh look, WIFOM.

Speaking of which, where the duck is Ronike? His unvote on Bardull I did not like.

 

[John2k4]

My thoughts on a few of the recent posts here:

Alright I was able to skim through just about everything before I passed out from 3AM reading. I like marshy, J, and probably OS. I do not like Barbell, and I do not like Kary at this moment. Barbell I want dead first though.

Marshy we can be townbros. I still think Barbell is the better path, mang.


What's Barbell at vote-wise?

 

[John2k4]

Also where the hell did Chibo go?

 

[#HBC | marshy]

dude its simple process of elimination. i dont give a **** about interactions at this point when i have a bunch of townreads. i will lynch/vig everyone outside of them regardless of interactions. its not like scum cant bus/distance. remember erb where everyone was like "dude no way jerkus and jdietz are scum look at their interactions hurrdurr" despite town having a bunch of townreads? same **** here

i already said why ronike. here is my case

1. sense of smell
2. hes not in my pool of ggs

 

[#HBC | marshy]

john we are townbros fa sho buddy. chibo is lurking and will be shot before this game ends. you aint gotta worry about im

 

[#HBC | marshy]

scumteam is sangfroid/ronike/??? btw

 

[Overswarm]

@mod request replacement on chibo

 

[#HBC | Kary]

Ugh, if you've made up your mind who's gotta die, then it doesn't matter who dies first.
If you'd rather Ronike than me or you're 50/50, then why the hell don't you kill Ronike today.
I've not really got anyone defending me, and i'm not just lurking.
If you just push whichever waggon's easiest, you're pushing along with scum.
My interactions with Ronike tell you nothing, so don't lynch me on that,
but everyone wants me dead so my flip tells you ****.

I think that's what I'm getting at.
Plus, I'm town. And I don't see how this is scare tactics, really.

And yes, I am prepared to lynch Ronike today if it comes down to it. STILL don't know why Bardull's alive, but i'm not going to keep pushing his waggon to my grave.

On the other hand if you're all just going to lynch me tomorrow, I might as well try not to mislynch Ronike. So you see my predicament. Or not. Whatever.

Peace & ika:

 

[Sephiroths Masamune]

Looks like Bardull is dying tonight

Also, it's not weird to see your fight as SvS. The thing that threw me off most is your handling of Bardull, Kary. You made a case on him and didn't vote. Even afterwards, when you had your responses, you still hestiated to vote. He was your biggest scumread but instead of voting him, you were concerned with not following Seph. That's admitting you care more about looking town than pursuing scumreads, which is weird to say for smartscum, except if the scumread is a scumpartner.

Then there's the fact that Bardull avoids you as a lynch choice, which is wacko as hell.

I can see where Marshy comes from, and I agree on that being a possible scumteam. My top pick is Kary/Bardull/Adumb though.

 

[Sephiroths Masamune]

tonight = today whatevs

John you're safe to actually vote Barbell.

 

[BarDulL]

1. J
4. John2k4
5. Pierce7d
8. Sephiroths Masamune
12. Overswarm
13. marshy

Rajam/Ronike/Sang uhhhh
Would have to go Sang? here, then.

Marshy just read those games for ****s sake.
What are you even arguing about now? Who I trust? Not your business. I don't trust J, that's all.

Marshy don't be so dense and just read back on them.

John, Pierce, and OS haven't substantiated anything at all, they just jumped into a vote block with you. You think they're Town, but they haven't explained themselves at all. What makes you think they aren't scum sheeping you? Are you blind? What's your criteria for a town player, someone who is just willing to side with you and sheep? You're not going to get far in life as someone whose only criteria for friendship is when someone unquestioningly sides with you without offering something on the table.

And I LOL'd at me&Kary being SvS. I don't even begin to understand how you could come up with that considering Kary began pushing my slot at the start of the game, and I've been put at L-1 because of him + people sheeping you and his case on me. Between Kary and I, we should be 100% not the same alignment fypov, so you need to explain that when you get the chance, cause you're not making ANY sense at all.

 

[BarDulL]

Something else I noticed:

Sounds good, J.

Agrees with Kary dying first.

My thoughts on a few of the recent posts here:

Alright I was able to skim through just about everything before I passed out from 3AM reading. I like marshy, J, and probably OS. I do not like Barbell, and I do not like Kary at this moment. Barbell I want dead first though.

Marshy we can be townbros. I still think Barbell is the better path, mang.


What's Barbell at vote-wise?

Then disagrees with Kary dying and wants me dead again. Wut.

 

[BarDulL]

@Marshy - I'll vote for Kary upon a thorough reread and if I think he's the proper play.

 

[BarDulL]

Still really want Ronike though.

 

[#HBC | J]

Bardull, I hate to say this, but it's either you vote Kary or you die at this stage of the game. =/

 

[BarDulL]

Never count anything out, mon amie. Not until all the cards are dealt.

I actually do like the sound of Ronike/Rajam vig choices though.

 

[John2k4]

That first post a J was mostly sarcasm, mang.

 

[BarDulL]

That first post a J was mostly sarcasm, mang.

lol.

Not sure if that was the grossest attempt at back pedaling I've ever seen, or someone who genuinely isn't good at emphasizing sarcasm on the internet.

 

[#HBC | J]

I feel more of the latter w.r.t. John. ;P When I originally read that, I didn't feel he is agreeing with me but more just posting to post at that time.

 

[John2k4]

I was on that list myself. It was supposed to be a "You want me dead? Fine with me" kind of sarcasm. :/

--

The sarcasm












Bardull's head

 

[#HBC | J]

John, if you give me your vote toDay, I'll let you have my vote for a bit toMorrow to do whatever you want with it.

Deal? :3

 

[BarDulL]

I was on that list myself. It was supposed to be a "You want me dead? Fine with me" kind of sarcasm. :/

--

The sarcasm












Bardull's head