Sure balancing and further advancing in a character's development takes time. But, for one of the largest teams in video game history, and development time which was far longer than what Melee received, it's a wonder how only 35 characters made it into the game, with 1-3 clones.
So, you would rather have three Foxes instead of three completely original characters? You yourself even said that you would give up all of the clones in Brawl for room of one more unique character.
Correct. Still, a huge disappointment.
Replacing one suck-ish move with a completely worthless move (so I hear), is hardly a significant change. In that, a lot of veterans were changed to a point, but nothing significant. In the end, their moves are almost completely the same.
As for Toon Link, he's just another Young Link. A clone with a minor change in attacks. Nothing more. Though, you can not say that Wolf and Toon Link's final smash being the exact same thing as their original is "cool." Really, that's where most of the complaining originated.
As for Ganondorf, you also can not say that you are glad he is back as he was before. Almost every single person in this forum wanted a moveset involving his sword, or at least something different. Most of his moves are the same as they were-- heck, even the up-tilt is back. That's just lazy.
Luigi, no one is complaining about.
Egruntz, I really dont think it matters anymore. Clones are not terrible. I also understand why it was best to keep Ganondorf a clone.
First, all of those who mained Ganon in melee possibly would not end up maining him again because his sword-based moveset would be quite different from his Melee one.
Also, his moveset varies greatly from C. Falcon's this time around, like I said in previous posts, his side B is different, his B is not a punch, and his FS is very, very different.
Clones add a different flavor to characters in the way that Falco mainers were not even close to good Fox mainers in Melee. Theyre so unbelievably different, and are not even close to the same when it comes to gameplay.
Now, there are even more differences. I.e. - Falco throws his reflector, he punches also.
Wolf is not even close to a clone minus the landmaster, dont bring up Wolf.
Toon Link..well, when it comes down to it, was there any other GOOD choice? THe Deku leaf would be nice, but that would be a clone of snake's cypher. The grappling hook? Oh noes, another teher recovery.
And those quotes only realy proved that those things were not said. Like Wiseguy said, proof that there should have been 40-50 characters would have been Sakurai saying "Ok guys, 40-50 characters and thats final!' But instead, he said he'd LIKE to have 40-50 characters, which, as it turns out in final development did not come to be. Complaining will really not do any good in this situation.
I'd say be happy with the roster, main Olimar, and knock the **** out of the characters you hate on Wifi. I'd do that, but I love this roster, noone on there I'd make a punching bag.