old 64 pikachu vs melee pikachu votes

[XIII ways to die]

so we all know pikachu wooped but in the first smash. i dont even have that game anymore.. wich pikachu do you think would woop who in wich move.

N-air=melee for sure
F-air=64
B-air=melee forgot if 64 even had a back air or not
U-air=64

U-smash=64
F-smash=64
D-smash=melee

D-b=64
U-b=melee

i left some stuff out purposly but if you want put it on here

 

[AXE 09]

kinda seems like 64 pikachu is better in every way lol.

except, i like that pika's up-b has a hitbox in melee =)

 

[MaxTheSlayer]

SSB64 pikachu is better then the SSBM Pika in every single way .. lol

 

[INSANE CARZY GUY]

what about up-throw and side-B and pikachu did get a better wavedash in melee. and melee's pummel>64's pummel to true

 

[XIII ways to die]

aw dude the up smash rocked in 64. so did the lighting. melees lighting sucks compared. i meen they should have left it as is fromt he begining

 

[Fortress | Sveet]

pikachu's bair in 64 was the ****. its like doc's in melee but with more knockback and priority. Yeah.

and his upb got invincibility when you used it. who needs a hitbox?

 

[sirchadakiss18]

Brawl's Pika > All Past Pika's

 

[INSANE CARZY GUY]

WHy? I would like too know why. If it's that up-B crap pichu can do that too but what is said about pichu? Also when you campare mechanics brawl pikachu should lose his chain throws and he becomes super chain throwable due to bad Di. But I do believe there was one thing broken about brawl pikachu.

 

[defsithe]

@ ICG
i dont think/remmber there being side Bs in 64.

but anyways 64 pikachu>> melee pika