Metroid Prime is a particularly influential and rarely matched first person adventure. Have you played that? Its part of a long line of successful and influential 3D transitions of Nintendo games (Mario 64, Ocarina of Time, Mario Kart 64, Star Fox 64, etc.) I don't think i've seen another first person game with as much variety in play control or as much structure as Metroid Prime.
I can see how the "find a weapon in a dungeon" structure could be unappealing to some, but its much more interesting and thoughtful than "shoot stuff, get to point B, shoot more stuff). There are puzzles, and side puzzles that provide upgrades and tangible rewards that allow you to have more freedom in combat situations to play as you would like as well as explore new areas and lore. The upgrades don't just making combat easier, as it might in say, Call of Duty where you simply get a bigger gun. Missile capacity upgrades don't just give you more missiles, they provide freedom to play the game as you wish. For instance if you like the plasma beam then you can use the super plasma beam more, or if you like freezing enemies and running through the room with navigational precision and speed you can do that too, or bait enemies into supermorphball bombs. I think the studio is talented, I think the DKC returns level design was pretty good, I would go so far as to say that Retro did a much better job with the property than Rare did back in 1995. I'm not saying that everyone has to like the game, what I am saying is the studio has given us quality titles and shown they have even versatility moving from Quake III development, to a new and innovative modern first person adventure, to classic platformer, more so than most popular studios these days.
What I really want to see is Nintendo to put Retro Studios on a new Zelda title, get it out of Nintendo EAD and Eiji Aonuma before it gets too stale. Skyward Sword is probably as far as they can carry the Windwaker inspiration line. Somewhere in a dream Nintendo gave Zelda to Platinum Games for an unofficial Okami 2 called Zelda
ALEX arent you coming to play with us tonight or something?