I personally care about both but it's not an either/or scenario in the slightest. Having them fight on foot rather than being in a tank lets the character be faithful to the series (purchasing units) while also taking creative liberties like Andy using his wrenches to fight and Sami using her machine gun. Andy was never shown using wrenches to fight but that's where Sakurai takes creative liberties. I mean hey, both
had nothing to work with for their movesets and Sakurai took a lot of liberties with them. Andy wouldn't even need that many creative liberties outside his wrench attacks.
The sprites would be fit to scale. As in, most would be bigger than Andy himself and not the toy-sized units you see in the Assist Trophy. Like, IDK if you know this but there's two different sprites for the units. One on the interface (i.e. the smaller sized units) and one in the in-game animations (the larger sized units). The units I had in mind would come from the sprites used in the animations. Here's a link to the gameplay of the series so I can show you what I mean.
It's usually the most prevailing thought when I go around seeing people make their pitches for Andy in Smash. It has some zanny moveset of him being stuck in a tank and having a pretty bland moveset all in all (I don't want to diss these people but I usually find these kinds of movesets uninspiring and basically Bowser Jr. 2.0). Andy fighting in a tank was an idea I had at one point but that was when I had the idea of Andy riding in different kind of units, something i'll admit is pretty unfeasible to do in Smash for various reasons. The Summoner/Resource Management route for him easily works the best in this regard.
No problem dude! If you want to talk more about Andy or Advance Wars in general, see the Andy support thread. We could always use more activity there lol.
I second this. Beggars truly can't be choosers, I would accept Andy in any given form at this point lol.
That being said of course, a summoner/resource management character like Andy is someone that could peak Sakurai's interest maybe. At least I hope so haha.