North American ONLINE Player Tier List

[TANK64]

S tier:

SheerMadness- his Yoshi *****. Just sayin'.

I have to say, these listing make me want to play online. They really do.
I want to be acknowledged (in the most unselfish way). More of a community thing.
Also Darth should make a console list with me on top.

 

[Near²]

I have to say, these listing make me want to play online. They really do.

do it broski, there's a new server in chicago so us west coasters will get less ping

 

[SheerMadness]

Thanks Surri and ImNotPro.

Need more people to evaluate that A Tier list I posted.

 

[WOTG]

A$
Nintendude
SheerMadness
Fireblaster
Firo
Rawr/Marth
Hammerheart (I hear very good things about Hammer <3)
ECartman
Star King
MATTS (Stop the hating, matts is good)
Kabal
Peek
PD
MattNF (Not too sure, I hear really good things about Matt though now)
Near (Not too sure either, but I always thought Near was pretty good)

Who I think is definitely A Tier.
I still vote Sheer for S Tier :3

 

[rawrimamonster]

Who I think is definitely A Tier.
I still vote Sheer for S Tier :3

Kinda funny how these kids get so good, I remember when A$ was a impatient ness scrub who always got scared on his last stock and when I could 4 stock nintendude. XD

 

[#HBC | ѕoup]

I wish i could get more recognized by the new kids(i played back in 06-08 and just started playing again) matts! is the only one who actually put me in a teir list;maybe i should play some of you.

 

[rawrimamonster]

I remember you being a bit better than you are now soup, being honest you were nothing absolutely spectacular but better than now for sure.

 

[#HBC | ѕoup]

yeah i think i (need to) improve and there still is a patch of rusty but really overall i feel like i'm starting to play even better then before also i didnt know you were Marth. i remember playing some games with you.

hopefully i can play more if the chicago server ilkes michigan.

 

[thegreginator]

I'm not sure I like the idea of giving anyone outside of malva their own tier. S Tier is already ordered to denote that Boom is higher than the other 3 in S Tier. But if everyone feels strongly about Boom having his own tier then we will do that.

Nintendude, SheerMadness, A$ and Fireblaster have some votes for S Tier. We need your opinions on that also.

I've also made a list of everyone who was placed in A Tier throughout the thread. It's way too big and we really need to cut some people so everyone check it out and tell us who you think qualifies for A Tier:

A$
Nintendude
SheerMadness
Fireblaster
Firo
Ybombb
Rawr/Marth
Hammerheart
ECartman
Silent Slayers
Star King
MATTS
Kabal
Peek
PD
MattNF
Korobeniki
Near
Shade
MarioReincarnate
ZhinShin
Legendary
Saske
Surri
Zodiac
Denken
Uknown iXi
Thekuzinator
thegreginator


* I left some people out for inactivity like tigerbombz, s2j, zenyore and johnny

EDIT: That list is for A Tier not S Tier, my bad. I fixed it.

Here's who I would keep:

A$
Nintendude
SheerMadness
Fireblaster
ECartman

I think that list is still missing people tho.

Also I have no idea who StarKing is but maybe he should be in there?

 

[#HBC | ѕoup]

Here's who I would keep:

A$
Nintendude
SheerMadness
Fireblaster
ECartman

I think that list is still missing people tho.

Also I have no idea who StarKing is but maybe he should be in there?

his yoshi is pretty darn amazing.

A$ (havent played yet.)
Nintendude (played him in a clan tourney. beat me by a couple of stocks.)
SheerMadness (I THINK I PLAYED YOU. I JUST DONT REMEMBER.)
Fireblaster (played him all the time in the past, he usually beat me.)
Firo (havent played yet)
Ybombb (play dubs with him or against him, can get some wins off him.)
Rawr/Marth (Played p2p with him not too long ago, got ***** but my rust is wearing off.)
Hammerheart (havent played yet)
ECartman (havent played yet)
Silent Slayers (havent played yet)
Star King (played dubs with him. game DSed but he was good.)
MATTS (play him alot, can beat his kirby.)
Kabal (Ex-NBK member. has an amazing samus; played him a couple of times in the past.)
Peek (played a couple of matches with him in the past, fun player. can beat him..maybe.)
PD (played a ton of matches with him, awesome guy, awesomer smasher. w/l is fair.)
MattNF (havent played yet)
Korobeniki (played a couple of matches with koro, he's a cool guy. w/l is fair.)
Near (are you yoshiking? if so, i played him alot and won most of the time.)
Shade (good friend, havent played him in forever, w/l is fair.)
MarioReincarnate (havent played yet)
ZhinShin (havent played yet)
Legendary (havent played yet)
Saske (played alot of matches with saske in the past, he probably has improved.)
Surri (same goes for surri; although i know he's rusty.)
Zodiac (A.K.A Arcane can beat him.)
Denken (Got destroyed first time i played him, want to have a rematch.)
Uknown iXi (played him alot, he's pretty good. w/l is fair.)
Thekuzinator (play dubs with him, good player, cool guy; w/l is fair.)
thegreginator (i think i played you..)

Anyone remember Q! ? he was pretty good..actually...


Old people who if they still played today would be A teir:
Q!
('.')
Xelph
Vex Kazarani (probably spelled that wrong)
Parallax (his ness was amazing.)
Beans
Asylum Smash
Rich (dat yoshi man.)
and some other old people that i miss.

ALPHAKIT TEIR:
Alphakit ixi
(******************************)

anyways, i really need to play some of you people, get at me sometime

here's who i think qualifies for A Teir:

PD
Fireblaster
Zen Yore (miss playing with him. great guy. )
Sheermadness
Nintendude
Denken
Kabal

 

[Surri-Sama]

Asylum

Thats probably the only name i could agree with from what you just said


Xelph? LOL? are you kissing me xD

 

[#HBC | ѕoup]

I put xelph because he was the best rage quitter ever. <3

 

[Surri-Sama]

yeah four stocking him and him still trash talking about how much you suck and acting as if he "DS" 90% of the time... was pretty great

 

[Battlecow]

Anyone remember Q! ? he was pretty good..actually...

He still plays, I used to friendly with him every other day and this was only like a couple months ago. He's all right; nothing special.

 

[SheerMadness]

Need more votes on the A Tier list I posted.

I also need to play Star King. I don't think I've ever played him knowing it was him.

 

[Tech_EDGE]

JAMES FRANCO SaYS THAT SHEER SHOULD PUT HIMSELF ABOVE NINTENDUDE ON HIS OWN TIER, AND THAT HE DOESN'T KNOW ABOUT ANYONE ELSE BECAUSE HE DOESN'T REMEMBER PLAYING ANY OF THEM

 

[SheerMadness]

So I did some recon on this Tech_EDGE/Frames Janco character. Frog apparently foreshadowed his re-appearance on his tier list:

A Tier:
Cart
Sheer
Zack
Jin iXi

Zack = Frames Janco = Tech_EDGE

I think I remember Zack from back in the day. While he apparently hasn't been playing with the general online ssb64 community, he has been secretly been playing frog for like the last 3 years. Which explains his skills.

Zack/Frames Janco/Tech_EDGE is A Tier indeed.

 

[SuPeRbOoM]

oh zack, I remember him sort of

 

[Tech_EDGE]

We SHOULD PLAY AGAIN SOMETIME SUPERBOOM, YOU STILL HAVE MY AIM?

 

[rawrimamonster]

We SHOULD PLAY AGAIN SOMETIME SUPERBOOM, YOU STILL HAVE MY AIM?

Zack from Socal?

 

[SuPeRbOoM]

idk zack, ADD ME, IT'S IN MY PROFILE.

 

[Tech_EDGE]

Zack from Socal?

MaYBE, WHY?

 

[P D]

just a quick question, how many tiers are we thinking here lol?

only 4 for a in a lot of tier lists??? so is that like all the way to I tier?

 

[SheerMadness]

I was thinking like 5 minimum and 10 maximum for A Tier. There's no set limits though. Whatever everyone agrees upon.

 

[Near²]

(in order if i weren't included)

Ecartman
A$
Nintendude
SheerMadness
Starking
Fireblaster
Peek
Hammerheart
Firo
thegreginator

 

[Peek~]

Ecartman
A$
Nintendude
SheerMadness
Starking
Fireblaster
Peek
Hammerheart
Firo
thegreginator

Ecartman (most likely better than me)
A$ (never played/dont remember)
Nintendude (most likely better than me)
SheerMadness (better than me)
Starking (never played)
Fireblaster (most likely better than me)
Peek (piiiiiii)
Hammerheart (better than me. Play alot lately, only beat him 2-3 times)
Firo (never played/dont remember)
thegreginator (better than him in the old days, but he says hes much better now)

I wouldnt put me in any in A list unless I was at the bottom of a longer list. I'd put myself at a high B position atm.

Actually I like the spot im in on Booms list

 

[MarioReincarnate]

either 5 or 15...

Ecartman
A$
Nintendude
SheerMadness
Fireblaster
Hammerheart
star king
peek
kabal
near
Firo
thegreginator
denken
me
koro/pd/MATTS!

-ish... my feelings won't be hurt in b tier since I sandbag a lot and haven't played that much lately (wedding is tomorrow!), but I think 10 is a wrong number for A tier... 5 or so are def worthy, then it gets muddled the next 10 or so, imo.

 

[NovaSmash]

I sandbag too, I should be in A tier

 

[#HBC | ѕoup]

yo for people putting fireblaster in A teir you guys should know he is extremely rusty.

 

[Near²]

I don't know about putting Kabal in A tier. I mean, his Samus is good but that's the ONLY character he plays.

 

[WOTG]

I don't know about putting Kabal in A tier. I mean, his Samus is good but that's the ONLY character he plays.

...So?

(post too short)

 

[Peek~]

yo for people putting fireblaster in A teir you guys should know he is extremely rusty.

It's not hard forgetting how to play this game

I don't know about putting Kabal in A tier. I mean, his Samus is good but that's the ONLY character he plays.

What about me? I'm the same and you put me in A-Tier

And we all know Samus > Ness

 

[NovaSmash]

I don't know about putting Kabal in A tier. I mean, his Samus is good but that's the ONLY character he plays.

Sheer only plays yoshi and MATTS! only plays kirby

 

[Near²]

...So?

(post too short)

:|

What about me? I'm the same and you put me in A-Tier

And we all know Samus > Ness

No. There's a difference. You actually choose other characters and are good with them. Kabal uses samus only.

 

[NixxxoN]

Sheer only plays yoshi and MATTS! only plays kirby

Its not about not giving enough credit to those who only play 1 char well, its about giving even more credit to those who can play a lot of chars well. I think thats fair enough

 

[WOTG]

Your arguments about single character players have to ensure on what exactly makes you "good" on this online tier list.

Win/lose ratio?
How many characters you're good with?
Who you can beat?

Which of those factors are deciding more? (So far it seems to be Who you can beat followed by the win/lose ratio of the players you can beat or do good against)

 

[Surri-Sama]

It's like Ballin said, the criteria for "being good" is winning games...thats it :o

 

[The Star King]

If that's the case, then Kabal should be pretty low.

 

[Surri-Sama]

that maybe...as Rawr has said before he might just be "my counter style" as i really cant deal with samus xD

Kuzis Jiggly is seeming to get under my Uairs pretty good too...ima have to fix dis

 

[Battlecow]

Here's how I see it: If your something can beat someone else's everything, you're probably better than them. If in the standard best-of-whatever w/ slob picks etc. etc. you can beat them, you're probably better than them. Range of characters shouldn't matter at all; the results that you're capable of getting should be the only thing that matters.