Talk of EarthBound's bad marketing back in the day leaves a bitter taste in my mouth now, since I'm seeing people using that as a "reason" why MOTHER doesn't deserve any more representation.
Pointing out how well it's selling on virtual console just gets you a lot of ear-plugging and doubling-down --- you can't win arguments with people who keep saying stuff like "Sure, it might be popular NOW, but it sold like crap when it was released, so it's not actually that popular and shouldn't be represented that much".
Sorry if it seems like I'm ranting but unfortunately it's something that I'm surrounded by because this is the kind of stuff I'm hearing from people who are supposed to be good friends.
Sad thing is that we can sit and debunk every argument against why Ninten is still a possibility, all these arguments can be compiled into a PowerPoint --- but in the end, people don't want evidence for characters from franchises they don't like. And I don't mean people who just happen to not be interested, I mean this small group of people that, for some reason, just have this burning, seething hatred for this series.
Maybe it's gotten worse lately because they feel threatened by MOTHER getting more attention from Nintendo? It was always pretty quiet until now.
Wait are people seriously using an ad campaign from two decades ago as evidence on how it's not popular now...? Jeez dude I thought the people I dealt with were stupid. That is purposely ignoring facts just because they don't like em. What a bunch of children...
Wonder if these people think F-Zero deserves another shot when that franchise sold even worse than Mother.
Also do they forget Japan exists? They ****ing love the games over there and even Mother 1 is still considered a classic and is a best seller on their E-Shop. Hell all three games are. They're more popular than
most Zelda games.
It sounds like they're just making crap up because the thought of a franchise they think sucks having another character before their franchise just cannot be.
"Nintendo must cater to our wishes and their wishes alone." I'm honestly kinda curious of what characters these guys want.
Also I can relate to the good friends part. I had a friend get so annoyed with me back in Laxcord that he blew up on me telling me to chill the hell out with the Ninten stuff because it's annoying as well as pointless since
"He isn't as popular as Masked Man and all the digging you've done made you delusional."
Trust me, as one that has actually compiled said powerpoint, I've been outright ignored simply because
"Mother won't get another character because Nintendo hates the franchise" and
"Porky would get in because I think he's cooler." without reading a damn thing which makes me ask myself:"
Why did I make a 258 page slideshow when no one that really should read it is going to." You are right though. It's ultimately pointless arguing with these people. The only thing that would maybe get them to back off would Ninten being revealed because there is literally nothing they can do about it if it happens.
Honestly, it MUST be because they feel threatened. Not sure why. I guess a very dedicated fandom that's been clamoring for a game's release for 12 years finally getting what they've asked for might distract Nintendo from Metroid Prime 4 for a few minutes or something. People are strange and selfish I guess.