Soooo, story time:
Me and my sister decided to eat a pizza in the restaurant who is like at two step from our house.
On the way, we talked about Goblin Slayer, I asked her if she heard about it, and to my surprise, she did. Curious, I asked what she thought of it, she said it was good in her opinion....that is, the light novel and the manga were good, she didn't know a anime adaption existed until I asked. Since I didn't watch the first episode too and the show had my curiosity since yesterday, we decided to watch the first episode together once we be back home.
A good pizza eated later, we came back home and watched the first episode as promised. We already know some stuff about the plot and whatnot, so we weren't 100% surprised by some of the more "shocking" stuff, not to mention we already some pretty gruesome show in the past, so when the "spoopy" things happened, we weren't as shocked as peoples not used to seinen were. Still, we were ready to give the show a chance on our own.
One viewage of Dark Goblin later, we were....mixed, on one hand, the show design looked good enough from what it was trying, the sound design was really great and the music was nice....but the clunky animation and weird pacing at time made us feel like there were something wrong, especially to my sister who readed the manga before some time ago.
So after watching the first episode, we decided to look the first two chapter of the manga to see if the anime was being loyal to it's source material (well, mostly for me, my sis' just wanted to be sure she wasn't remembering details wrong) or if the anime had sacrificed alot of element from the manga that caused the wonky moment we saw. To put in context, I thought the first episode was...alright, yeah, it got pretty shocking stuff in it, but again, I saw worst and the "surprise" was kinda ruined in advance for me. I was still expecting to be really gory from what I heard and all, but in the end, the weak pacing and animation made some of the more "shocking" moment not as, well, shocking to me. (Tho, again, the sound design was really good, probably the highlight of the episode)
Brief, we watched/rewatched the first two chapter of the manga and....
View attachment 169675
*ahem*
....We thought it was way, WAYYYYY better than the anime, and I ended up liking it way more that I expected.
Like, the manga pacing, framing, and general attention to detail smade the tone of loads of scenes wayyy better at conveying the tone and message of the story than the anime adaption did. Seriously, the anime adaption make some scenes that should have a slow build-up goes too fast to be taken seriously, while making scenes that should go fast goes too slow to be intense, which caused a weird dissonance with the tone of some scenes and what the character were actually doing. (not to mention that animation being really stiff at moment, no better exemple being random CGI Gobling Slayers who really look stiff and clunky, making him hard to take him seriously in moment where he should be.)
Really, I had a OK opinion of the first episode at first, but once I looked the manga, I just couldn't believe how many important details they removed or changed. Which make me understand the backslash the anime got way more than before. (that and Crunchyroll ****ing up like idiot, seriously, did anyone watched the show before putting it in the "13" rating?)
All to say that, what I came to conclusion is:
I'm actually interested in the story and it's characters, I'm going to read more chapters later on, but I probably avoid the anime, since outside of VA and the sound design, I feel like the "con" it have far outweight the "pro" it have, and just make it more "edgy" than it seem. (not to say the manga doesn't have edge, oh no, it's really edgy too, but more in a way I can dig)
Some of you may probably think I'm crazy or somethin', but the manga is really where the good **** is, for now atleast, my opinion might change, but now, Goblin Slayer is definitly winning me over.
Brief, I probably have trash taste for defending or just liking this show in any way, but at the very least, I got a nice pizza out of all this, so, I am OK with my current fate.
TL : DR: local man with his sister goes into trash can and find good pizza, would recommend local trash can for good ****.