Knight Dude
Keeping it going.
I would agree that the way the rating system is used is pretty terrible. Where many good games are given overblown scores to terribly low ones that mismatches the actual content. However that's strictly the case, those games are "good", but not exactly great. I mean, I would personally say that The Last of Us is probably one of the most overrated games in recent years, as the actual video game part of it is fairly dull, and that people focus too much on the flashy graphics and narrative people got emotional over. But the mechanics aren't particularly stand out and enemy AI can have it's hiccups. Though that's my personal taste.@Swampasaur
In 100% honesty the fact that Skyward Sword and Xenoblade X are considered bad games just goes to show how spoiled the gamer base really is. Like someone else said a 70 on Metacritic in games is considered 'bad'. To put that into perspective, if a movie gets a 70% or above rating on Rotten Tomatoes it's considered 'guaranteed fresh' which means that a lot of people thought it was good and it's almost guaranteed you'll enjoy it as well.
And as a game, and not for what it did to the franchise, Sonic Adventure 2 is a FAR, FAR better game than 1. It's controls are tighter, it's levels are faster (or have better level design in general depending per character), and it's overall polish is much more noticable.
So you liking games like that isn't a problem with you. It's the fact that gamers are spoiled and jump to conclusions that anything below a 9 is garbage. None of the games you mentioned are bad. This is coming from someone who loves DK 64 the top tier of controversial games.
But that's not an issue with the gaming audience entirely. Those expectations of only wanting 9 and 10 rated games due to the reviewers only using those for both solid and great titles alike. This leads to everything bleeding into each other. It establishes a status quo for the audience. And when a game is given something lower than that, despite the score more than likely fitting it's number (take Twilight Princess getting 8's on some sites) people freak out. As it messes with the established standard rankings were used to.
Had reviewers and the companies who buy them off stuck to honest numbers, then you wouldn't get jokes like "7.8/10 too much water."