Well, funnily enough it was SotN... Okay, okay, don't sue me just yet.
The thing is though that he was complaining about you killing the wargs(AKA big wolves) in one shot.... Did he forget that in the intro you're purposely overpowered? Not to mention it's hard to take his complaints seriously when he really, really sucks at the game. Like look, I'm not a "pro gamer" or anything like that, I bet I'd suck at quite a few games. But hoooooly shoot, watching him play the game was so painful, especially after me playing through the game again recently. For instance, instead of going through the level design at a smooth pace, he's constantly fiddling around even when it's unnecessarily when really he could just be chopping through enemies and moving forward with ease.
It just seems like most of his complaints are at his own fault rather than the game's, and that's the worst kind of critic IMO. And don't get me wrong, SotN has it's issues, but he doesn't bring most of them up(Like how the game is really, really easy without handicapping yourself, yet he seems to have trouble with the difficulty of all things.) And I agree most items you do find are useless by the end of the game(Only because Alucard's equipment overpowers everything and you don't need anything else. But there's still fun weapons to mess around with, but not as much as later games.), but not immediately when you find them like he was saying. I remember him calling a good sword(at the time you get it) useless.
But maybe I'm misjudging him, after all AVGN had some weird complaints. Overpowered weapons being taken away, complaining that a useless weapon is useless.(Your fists are actually very powerful in the early game, yet I don't see any reviewers really use them.) etc. Also confusing Dawn of Sorrow's plot with Aria of Sorrow's and saying it takes place in Japan, none of the games take place in Japan, Aria of Sorrow takes place in an eclipse. The only difference being that I've seen almost every AVGN episode before so I guess I didn't mind when he screwed up.
And no, I'm not just talking about this game because it has an attractive bishonen, why would you think that?
But anyway, nevermind that. I could go on rants like that when it comes to a lot of critics, it's no big deal. What's potentially worse is that his voice reminds me of both Atheism Is Unstoppable and Black Pidgeon Speaks.(Maybe not exactly, but similar enough to make me bring me up the comparison I guess. So don't quote me on this as a certainty.
)