Really wish these so called "silent supporters" voted for a character that I really liked. That would be a nice surprise.
Sounds like
would fit it with the Mr. Blue category. IDK what his support base was like but he got in mainly because he was a video game icon more so than the people that wanted him in the game (though to be fair his popularity is what got him chosen over other Final Fantasy characters).
And I do think there's some limitations to Mr. Red's chances if say Mr. Red was a character like Captain Rainbow. His support base would more or less be limited to the 30K (maybe some extra people interested in the character) that bought his game and I honestly don't believe that even if all those 30K voted for him because that number wouldn't be enough theoretically speaking to get him in the game.
That sounds like your just undermining everyone and your own opinion dude. We've never had DLC before in a Smash Bros game so it was a completely new ball game in terms of what to expect character wise.
It's not even like we were completely wrong either. Lots of people speculated that
would return and here they are. We didn't know going in that the focus of DLC would be third party heavy hitters.
Of course that's not to say fan rules weren't a thing back then. Even I overestimated/underestimated a lot of things in that Smash speculation period. I just think you should give yourself and others some credit.
Hardly. I see a bunch of people who believe SK outranked K. Rool and with Bayo i'm almost of the belief that it'll probably happen even though i'm not the biggest fan of the character (mind you i'm talking the character being in Smash Bros and not Shovel Knight the game which IMO is a good game). And in SK's defense he would have a bigger chance than Bayo did given that his series sold a million+ copies. Shantae as well maybe if her series/game did well in Japan.