TheAJJohnson
Smash Journeyman
- Joined
- Aug 29, 2018
- Messages
- 220
This comment may be late to the party, but I was at work and I typed this on my breaks...so get off my back!
Why is this topic even being debated? The ESRB/CERO don't care about what other games are like when rating Smash. Bayonetta's source material is a bloody, sexual mess. However, they translated her character over just fine. How? They toned stuff down (e.g., no blood, no spanking, hair doesn't fully come off thereby revealing the more private and sexual aspects of her body). The ESRB/CERO isn't going to say, "Yeah, but she's naked and violent in this other game!" when they're trying to rate Smash Bros content.
Additionally, assuming the Smash team couldn't do the same (remove the violent aspect) with any other character is asinine. It's silly to say that "who the character is" or "what the franchise represents" would be lost by taking out the violence. Again, their respective franchises might be about the violence, but Smash is not. The character's core can be maintained without having buckets of blood and gore. (Side note: the buckets of blood and gore aren't even the character's, they belong to everyone else the character is killing. If the enemies were robots in the core game, would it make the character any less like himself/herself?)
However, when it comes to Mai, you can't really un-sexify her. (Yes, I just made up a word.) Her attire is pretty consistent from game to game, from what I've seen, so in this case, changing her drastically just to shoehorn her in would be a disservice to her original design. (And let's be honest, there are two really big reasons why she's popular.) Bayonetta is generally fully clothed, only becoming nude when she attacks. Again, this was toned down and the game is so fast paced that it's hardly noticeable.
Why is this topic even being debated? The ESRB/CERO don't care about what other games are like when rating Smash. Bayonetta's source material is a bloody, sexual mess. However, they translated her character over just fine. How? They toned stuff down (e.g., no blood, no spanking, hair doesn't fully come off thereby revealing the more private and sexual aspects of her body). The ESRB/CERO isn't going to say, "Yeah, but she's naked and violent in this other game!" when they're trying to rate Smash Bros content.
Additionally, assuming the Smash team couldn't do the same (remove the violent aspect) with any other character is asinine. It's silly to say that "who the character is" or "what the franchise represents" would be lost by taking out the violence. Again, their respective franchises might be about the violence, but Smash is not. The character's core can be maintained without having buckets of blood and gore. (Side note: the buckets of blood and gore aren't even the character's, they belong to everyone else the character is killing. If the enemies were robots in the core game, would it make the character any less like himself/herself?)
However, when it comes to Mai, you can't really un-sexify her. (Yes, I just made up a word.) Her attire is pretty consistent from game to game, from what I've seen, so in this case, changing her drastically just to shoehorn her in would be a disservice to her original design. (And let's be honest, there are two really big reasons why she's popular.) Bayonetta is generally fully clothed, only becoming nude when she attacks. Again, this was toned down and the game is so fast paced that it's hardly noticeable.