MisterMike
Smash Champion
- Joined
- Jul 22, 2019
- Messages
- 2,252
What makes you say that?Most likely as a Mii costume.
Welcome to Smashboards, the world's largest Super Smash Brothers community! Over 250,000 Smash Bros. fans from around the world have come to discuss these great games in over 19 million posts!
You are currently viewing our boards as a visitor. Click here to sign up right now and start on your path in the Smash community!
What makes you say that?Most likely as a Mii costume.
But he's already in.Geno is getting in and that's a fact
Like not even joking there are still several Fire Emblem characters I'd want that aren't in. Edelgard, Caeda, if we're going for really out there picks then Merric...Aight all this Fire Emblem whining has got me thinking -- what series wouldn't you mind getting another rep via DLC?
I wouldn't mind another Pokemon rep, as long as they don't pick a humanoid starter.
Post combined with your avatar makes me think this could have been someone really confident in smash 4 speculation that hasn’t moved since smash 4 speculation, still waiting for their prophecy to be true.Geno is getting in and that's a fact
I'd love another FE rep (yes, really) around the time a potential Genealogy of the Holy War remake comes out if it's within the timeframe of DLC.Aight all this Fire Emblem whining has got me thinking -- what series wouldn't you mind getting another rep via DLC?
I wouldn't mind another Pokemon rep, as long as they don't pick a humanoid starter.
Posts like this usually don't tend to age well.Geno is getting in and that's a fact
Video games are entertainment, which is subjective, so I don't really think you can say one is objectively "superior" to another. Only way you could do that is to forego everything except how the games function and perform, which they both do equally well: Nothing is broken, and they both run decently on the hardware they are available on.I'm curious if there's anyone here who's beaten both The Legend of Zelda: Breath of the Wild and Fire Emblem: Three Houses. Could they weigh in on the subject of Byleth vs literally any new Zelda character?
As someone who's only beaten Breath of the Wild and only observed 3H from the feedback and most notable parts, my opinion is that BotW is an all-around superior game regardless of its franchise, and thus the two can't be equivocated. But since that's not a fair or wholly-informed opinion, I'd like to hear how others compare the two.
And that is your opinion.Geno is getting in and that's a fact
Caeda would be a very interesting heavyweight character. You could be fast and heavy, but with wonky/specialized hitboxes, and then dismount to become slow and light, but with more general hitboxes. I'd imagine it'd make being mounted better for capitalizing on your opponent's disadvantage state, but being dismounted being better for neutral.Like not even joking there are still several Fire Emblem characters I'd want that aren't in. Edelgard, Caeda, if we're going for really out there picks then Merric...
Same with Mario and Pokémon. My three favorite Nintendo franchises just happen to be the ones with the most characters, lol.
I haven't finished Fire Emblem: Three Houses, but I can already tell you you're comparing apples and oranges. As far as including a The Legend of Zelda: Breath of the Wild character is concerned, I don't really think any of the characters do much of anything to warrant their inclusion. I mean, characters like Midna, Girahim, and the Skull Kid are at least present throughout the game. Kass and the champions are completely optional and stuck in secluded areas.I'm curious if there's anyone here who's beaten both The Legend of Zelda: Breath of the Wild and Fire Emblem: Three Houses. Could they weigh in on the subject of Byleth vs literally any new Zelda character?
As someone who's only beaten Breath of the Wild and only observed 3H from the feedback and most notable parts, my opinion is that BotW is an all-around superior game regardless of its franchise, and thus the two can't be equivocated. But since that's not a fair or wholly-informed opinion, I'd like to hear how others compare the two.
Howdy. 400+ hours in BoTW and 160 hours in Three Houses here.I'm curious if there's anyone here who's beaten both The Legend of Zelda: Breath of the Wild and Fire Emblem: Three Houses. Could they weigh in on the subject of Byleth vs literally any new Zelda character?
As someone who's only beaten Breath of the Wild and only observed 3H from the feedback and most notable parts, my opinion is that BotW is an all-around superior game regardless of its franchise, and thus the two can't be equivocated. But since that's not a fair or wholly-informed opinion, I'd like to hear how others compare the two.
The only thing I remember about the Champions from BOTW was that Link was running circles around themI'm curious if there's anyone here who's beaten both The Legend of Zelda: Breath of the Wild and Fire Emblem: Three Houses. Could they weigh in on the subject of Byleth vs literally any new Zelda character?
As someone who's only beaten Breath of the Wild and only observed 3H from the feedback and most notable parts, my opinion is that BotW is an all-around superior game regardless of its franchise, and thus the two can't be equivocated. But since that's not a fair or wholly-informed opinion, I'd like to hear how others compare the two.
Jeez I just asked you a question, no need to get all pissy about it.To reiterate why bendy limbs for Steve would look off personally:
-He looks good with his regular limbs to me.
-The Mii limbs are sorta like regular human limbs, so the way they bend would look odd.
-If they bend like they do in the Minecraft Dungeons trailer, where it’s just at right-angles, it’d look fine. Maybe even if not just at right-angles, but only with one elbow joint and it’s still an edge instead of being rounded, and isn’t like the Mii limbs/they shouldn’t turn aside from the body-connecting joints.
-Official trailers already give them personality, they could even animate his eyes like the bees’ eyes in one trailer, if not how it’s done in Dungeons or in Bedrock Edition/Minecraft Earth.
I don’t expect anyone to agree, but this is why I think he’d look much better as his own fighter instead of as a model swap for a Mii, even ignoring my bias.
Heck, to be honest, I even think those animations some Minecraft fans make with very bendy limbs look okay on their own, although they are somewhat odd and stray from Minecraft’s style, so I personally don’t like them much...but anyway, I hope y’all understand instead of completely ignoring my view and going at me with “how would he even work as a fighter then?” as if straight, rectangular limbs are really oh-so objectively awful when no, they’re not.
In a mii costume...Geno is getting in and that's a fact
I've seen this idea passed around a bit, and I highly doubt it will happen, but I really like it. I'll do you one further. How about instead of just OoT Link, we also get Twilight Princess Link as an alt (I'm thinkin' 4 costumes are OoT Link, and 4 are TP Link), and name it Fighter 3ε: Classic Link? I like this idea more and more each time I hear it.
I'd picture him going over Adult Link, of course, because not much would be changed.
And that's really all that's necessary to make it work. Though I came up with some more personal changes anyways:
- Sword and shield animations horizontally mirrored to reflect him being left-handed
- Uses Melee voice clips when in OoT alt, and Brawl/Smash 4 voice clips in his Twilight Princess alt.
- Reuses old entrance animation from pre-Ultimate
- No sword beams (Forward smash is stronger/faster to compensate)
- Arrows don't last on the ground
- Hookshot grab/throws and tether recovery
- Bombs aren't remote controlled.
- Gets Young Link's multi-hit parry as an alternate neutral attack finisher.
- If he grabs a bomb, then he can fire a Bomb Arrow. This is his replacement for BotW Link's double arrow.
- Gets the fairy taunt back
Both are good games that appeal to different people, and trying to argue one is objectively better than the other will do nothing but start a pointless debate about what at the end of the day, is someone's subjective opinion.
Tsk TskWhat makes you say that?
If Mii Gunner continues to get the special costume... along with a music track... then...
— Brent (King of Skill) (@TrueKingOfSkill) January 20, 2020
...uh oh... pic.twitter.com/klv10EGHGc
I fit the criteria you have asked for and hereby claim my right to a response.I'm curious if there's anyone here who's beaten both The Legend of Zelda: Breath of the Wild and Fire Emblem: Three Houses. Could they weigh in on the subject of Byleth vs literally any new Zelda character?
As someone who's only beaten Breath of the Wild and only observed 3H from the feedback and most notable parts, my opinion is that BotW is an all-around superior game regardless of its franchise, and thus the two can't be equivocated. But since that's not a fair or wholly-informed opinion, I'd like to hear how others compare the two.
I have noticed so far that all the costumes that came with tracks were for the Gunner. No Swordfighter or Brawler costumes with music... yet...Tsk Tsk
If Mii Gunner continues to get the special costume... along with a music track... then...
— Brent (King of Skill) (@TrueKingOfSkill) January 20, 2020
...uh oh... pic.twitter.com/klv10EGHGc
Even though I'm not really much of a Zelda guy I would definitely say "The Legend of Zelda" as they haven't had a new fighter since Brawl with Toon Link. And that's if we're counting characters based on another fighter. If not then the last fully original fighter was both Zelda and Sheik in Melee. At this point 19 years ago. Even if I'm not that well knowledge in the games I'd suggest either Impa (main choice as long as it's the Hyrule Warriors version), Tingle, Linkle, Skull Kid, Lana, I'd even take the old who gives you your sword in the NES game as a retro fighter or even Epona as a joke fighter.Aight all this Fire Emblem whining has got me thinking -- what series wouldn't you mind getting another rep via DLC?
I wouldn't mind another Pokemon rep, as long as they don't pick a humanoid starter.
The Akira VF costume is so goodI have noticed so far that all the costumes that came with tracks were for the Gunner. No Swordfighter or Brawler costumes with music... yet...
It depends on the Zelda character. From most of my experience with the series, including BOTW as you said, characters that aren't Link only have a few minutes of screentime and don't actually do much. Meanwhile, Byleth is the protagonist of a game with 3 (4 if you're technical) routes worth of content and does a lot more that can be transferred into Smash. I think there can be some really fun Zelda characters added like some villains, but they've already been passed over with Spirits and ATs. Maybe BOTW2 will have someone other than Link with a unique moveset and story relevance.I'm curious if there's anyone here who's beaten both The Legend of Zelda: Breath of the Wild and Fire Emblem: Three Houses. Could they weigh in on the subject of Byleth vs literally any new Zelda character?
As someone who's only beaten Breath of the Wild and only observed 3H from the feedback and most notable parts, my opinion is that BotW is an all-around superior game regardless of its franchise, and thus the two can't be equivocated. But since that's not a fair or wholly-informed opinion, I'd like to hear how others compare the two.
Throwing a few more:Even though I'm not really much of a Zelda guy I would definitely say "The Legend of Zelda" as they haven't had a new fighter since Brawl with Toon Link. And that's if we're counting characters based on another fighter. If not then the last fully original fighter was both Zelda and Sheik in Melee. At this point 19 years ago. Even if I'm not that well knowledge in the games I'd suggest either Impa (main choice as long as it's the Hyrule Warriors version), Tingle, Linkle, Skull Kid, Lana, I'd even take the old who gives you your sword in the NES game as a retro fighter or even Epona as a joke fighter.
others include
-Kirby could use Bandanna Dee, Adeleine, Magalor, Gooey or Dark Matter
-Yoshi with Kamek
-Sonic could use Shadow, Knuckles, Tails, Eggman, Classic Sonic or Metal Sonic
-Punch-Out with either King Hippo or Glass Joe
-Earthbound with Ninten
-Starfox with either Krystal, Panther or Slippy
-Kid Icarus with Viridian or Ignus
-Final Fantasy with either Leon, Lightning, Warrior of Light or Noctus
-R.O.B. with Professor Hector from Gyromite
-Metal Gear with the Rising Revengeance version of Raiden
-F-Zero with either Samurai Goroh or Black Shadow
Yes, I know a lot of these suggestions are assist trophies but I'm more referring to not just Ultimate but possible later titles
Only issue I have with Byleth is that as an FE character their move-sets seem rather limited. Despite holding an axe, a sword, or a lance, from a game development perspective all those weapons are basically the same.Aight all this Fire Emblem whining has got me thinking -- what series wouldn't you mind getting another rep via DLC?
I wouldn't mind another Pokemon rep, as long as they don't pick a humanoid starter.
I’m sorry, it’s just you sounded a bit condescending with how you worded it. I know you don’t like Steve, showing a lot of hatred to the idea in the past even if you’re calmer about it now, so when you asked if he’d be animated in a way you don’t like and “Wait, so Steve can't be a Mii Fighter because bendy limbs don't suit him... Doesn't that mean he's even less of a fit to be a full-blown fighter?” it sounded kinda condescending like you ignored some of what I was explaining about how I thought he looked fine otherwise + the mii’s limbs are nothing like his regular limbs or Dungeons.Jeez I just asked you a question, no need to get all pissy about it.
Even among Fire Emblem I still want Lyn or Anna.Aight all this Fire Emblem whining has got me thinking -- what series wouldn't you mind getting another rep via DLC?
I wouldn't mind another Pokemon rep, as long as they don't pick a humanoid starter.
They wouldn't have a music track anyways because SNK had 50. Even if you didn't buy the DLC, they already added enough songs to where they didn't wanna bother adding more. At least that's what I think.The Akira VF costume is so good
Should have gotten his theme
Breath of the Wild and Three Houses are both excellent games that are truly up there with the best in their series, but it's apples and oranges. It's really tough to call one better than the other because they're going for separate things. It's kind of like saying "What's the better game, Breath of the Wild or Mario Odyssey?", both are extremely well polished and enjoyable, so the only real criterion that serves as a tie-breaker is personal preference. Even then, I don't think critical success is a major impact in what games get representation in Smash. Otherwise, we wouldn't have gotten a large quantity of Sonic 06 content in Brawl.I'm curious if there's anyone here who's beaten both The Legend of Zelda: Breath of the Wild and Fire Emblem: Three Houses. Could they weigh in on the subject of Byleth vs literally any new Zelda character?
As someone who's only beaten Breath of the Wild and only observed 3H from the feedback and most notable parts, my opinion is that BotW is an all-around superior game regardless of its franchise, and thus the two can't be equivocated. But since that's not a fair or wholly-informed opinion, I'd like to hear how others compare the two.
I will throw thisSakurai: "I play literally thousands of games of many different genres, companies, etc and as a game dev I tend to appreciate at least 1 thing in the game a lot"
Smash fans: "Clearly this means Smash will feature every game ever made"
I honestly think this is a pretty realistic prediction lmaoNext Fighters Pass:
4 picks that are from Sakurai's favorite games. All worthy of Smash but people will initially complain then get over it.
1 8th Generation Pokemon that everyone will complain about and claiming Pokemon over-representation and waste of Challenger Pack slot over.
1 fan favorite like Geno, Lloyd, Isaac, Waluigi.
There. That's it. Go home folks.
OH ****Which obviously means we're getting Knack as DLC
There's no franchise that I would be mad about getting more rep, as long as the moveset is original I won't mind. That being said the franchises that I want more to see more rep are Zelda, Kirby, Sonic and Earthbound.Aight all this Fire Emblem whining has got me thinking -- what series wouldn't you mind getting another rep via DLC?
I wouldn't mind another Pokemon rep, as long as they don't pick a humanoid starter.
I dunno, I think we've kind of passed that a long time ago, like if he was going to come back as a Mii Costume it would've already happened with Hero. I've heard people counter this with the idea that they were shilling Dragon Quest XI S: Echoes of an Elusive Age: Definitive Edition, and as such they didn't want to associate Dragon Quest or Hero in Smash with the mass disappointment of Geno being a Mii Costume, but I honestly have a hard time buying that.Tsk Tsk
If Mii Gunner continues to get the special costume... along with a music track... then...
— Brent (King of Skill) (@TrueKingOfSkill) January 20, 2020
...uh oh... pic.twitter.com/klv10EGHGc
YOU'D BETTER BE READY, 'COS HERE COMES FREDDY!I have noticed so far that all the costumes that came with tracks were for the Gunner. No Swordfighter or Brawler costumes with music... yet...
Gotta take this from the Lloyd thread, now we know that Bamco's newly trademarked tales of save icon is used in a certain Tales of event, but we have the Scott NDA thing left and this depends whenever he is voicing a playable Lloyd or not.テイルズオブ新“周年ロゴ”とシリーズロゴが公開 pic.twitter.com/Vs4hvNOsKz
— ゲームのはなし (@gamenohanashi) January 20, 2020
New 25th Anniversary logo and new Tales series logo.
The latter we've seen before, via trademarks.
Bandai Namco might be doing something this year for the series (besides Tales of Arise, obviously).
Edit: found this:
【テイルズオブ25周年】新たな周年ロゴとシリーズロゴが発表。また、タイトルのカテゴライズが一新され、従来のマザーシップ/エスコート/モバイルの3つから、オリジナル/クロスオーバーの2つに。恒例「テイルズオブフェスティバル」開催も発表されました。 pic.twitter.com/mbIF0KPNnI
— ゲームのはなし (@gamenohanashi) January 20, 2020
I made this a long time agoI dunno, I think we've kind of passed that a long time ago, like if he was going to come back as a Mii Costume it would've already happened with Hero. I've heard people counter this with the idea that they were shilling Dragon Quest XI S: Echoes of an Elusive Age: Definitive Edition, and as such they didn't want to associate Dragon Quest or Hero in Smash with the mass disappointment of Geno being a Mii Costume, but I honestly have a hard time buying that.
On Nintendo's end, they created and released Byleth as a DLC fighter, so I don't think they'd really care too much about occasionally doing things that would upset the fans. And on Square's side, I have no reason to think that they'd really care all that much in the first place. I mean, most people expected Geno's costume to come back alongside Hero anyway, so anyone who would've been upset about it would've already been upset. And would people have really boycotted Dragon Quest XI S: Echoes of an Elusive Age: Definitive Edition because Geno was a costume in Smash? "I was interested in buying your swordy boy game, but you put in the puppet as a costume, so no monies for you!" The two seem almost entirely unrelated. If anything, people would be more mad at Sakurai than anything.
That's also putting aside the fact that we've gotten two potential leaks regarding these Mii Costumes, but neither of them have mentioned the Geno costume. The Mii Fighter List, which has gotten everything else it listed correct, has a Mallow, Smithy, and Chocobo costume/hat on the list, but no Geno. The CacoMallow Post has a Mallow Hat, but no Geno.
YOU'D BETTER BE READY, 'COS HERE COMES FREDDY!
View attachment 258933
'Cuz you can't spell hype without mass Mii genocide!YOU'D BETTER BE READY, 'COS HERE COMES FREDDY!
Now that would be a MAJOR disservice to SpyroUnless he just became a hat