Welcome to Smashboards, the world's largest Super Smash Brothers community! Over 250,000 Smash Bros. fans from around the world have come to discuss these great games in over 19 million posts!
You are currently viewing our boards as a visitor. Click here to sign up right now and start on your path in the Smash community!
Sakurai hates all the cool characters, He missed his chance to put Banjo in Smash 64, Megaman hasn't gotten in until just now, and then there's Rosalina. I think the Condor's fine, because Sakurai's a ***** and doesn't recognize a swaggin' ass mutha****a when he sees one.
All these plumbers and not one of them is doing their job right. This is why humans get replaced by machines.
In a perfect world, Shadow the Hedgehog would have a good game.
I'm still waiting on some Custom Robo representation yo.
All these plumbers and not one of them is doing their job right. This is why humans get replaced by machines.
Only Mario and Luigi are plumbers. Wario is a treasure hunter/indie video game designer and Waluigi is a certified player 2
Only if he comes with Roboigi.
Water types are not super effective against Steel types. They only deal normal damage.
That Robo-Waluigi is an imposter.OK, I am convinced of Ninten now. I love the Mother series and I could like him, even though like everyone else, Mother 1 is my least favorite (but I still like it a lot). Definitely deserves a 1/2 vote from me. He's not quite a character I REALLY want in, but it is one I don't mind seeing put in.
So from all the way from like page 8 I think, after a few changes, these are now my current votes:
+1
Waluigi
(Removing Mac due to Smash 4)
Isaac (TBH, if he gets conformed for Smash 4, I will also take him off the list.)
Also I will try to play Golden Sun again soon so I can double check my opinions on him and see if I REALLY want him.
+1/2
Ninten (congrats on being my first 1/2 vote)
And I still refuse to do negative votes. So there we go. Who knows where my votes will go now?
PS: I'm gonna post this again,
just because...![]()
Seriously.
Lol.
I believe it is still the same. You can have up to 5, and they have to have appeared in Brawl in some form, Anti Guy also recently shot down public domain characters.
I mean, I don't care about franchise over-representation either (I've never down-voted anyone with that argument). I'm also not saying people shouldn't/aren't allowed to care about it, but consistency across reasoning would be nice.See I didn't want to say anything (re:SmashBrosPM's list) because everyone should have their opinions welcome but then you guys went and did that...
I personally don't care about how many people from X franchise are in already if Y character brings something notably lacking in the roster at current to attention.
Public domain characters though? Who was desperate enough to try that? lol
The rules are that the votes have to be characters you wholeheartedly want. If you cast a vote, make absolutely sure you are not going to change it every time something new comes along. So if you make this change, stick with it.
You can vote on whoever you want up to 5 votes. The characters in the intro are just some of the frequently requested. After your top 5 votes, you have an infinite number of +1/2 votes.
Oh really? Then I put one forth for Medli too, but I'll probably be the only one. I have a thread in my signature on a thread for Medli if you'd like to see and maybe get a better idea on how she MIGHT work.
These just lead to Errors.
This is a discussion thread for characters for P:M.
I know ;-; my iPod's glitching, I had a really funny pic too
~Medli+Makar~
Two of my favourite characters, why can't they be playable? On their own or as a single slot
So, what makes them so special? Why them over T.Zelda?
It would clear off a potential clone, and be something unexpected and unique, what with Wind Waker HD they could easily represent both the game, and (Toon) Links companions who help him throughout the game.
They each have their own important role within the game, and both share something only 1 other Zelda character has achieved (Being playable besides Link)
Although of course this doesn't really mean they deserve being playable over TZelda in itself, but they pretty high up there if you ask me.
~Palettes~
Can you recognize who the 3 on the bottom reference?
Movesets
At the moment I've only created one for Medli on her own, but I assure you I have more in store in my head
Medli
B Moves
![]()
Flips her opponent around similar to Marios cape, 2%
![]()
Has a shine similar to Foxs, but only effects the front, can be angled to reflect projectiles
![]()
If the opponent is caught, she is launched towards them slamming into her opponent doing around 16% altogether (6% for latching on and 10% for slamming into. Doesn't act as a tether in the air. Her grab does though.
![]()
Medli isn't a very strong flier, shown in Windwaker, fly too long and you'll fall down helplessly
A Moves
(WIP)
![]()
2% , 6%, 10%
18% altogether
![]()
5%
![]()
6%
![]()
5%
Dash (Wip)
Smashes
(No progress yet)
Told you, nothing
Grabs
(No progress yet)
Told you, nothing
Final Smash
(No progress yet)
Told you, nothing
Taunts, this will be used to switch between Makar and Medli
(No progress yet)
Told you, nothing
Makar
(wip)
Feel free to post your thoughts and/or movesets here, I may even work them into my ones. (ooOOooh Animaty goodness)
Other peoples movesets
Still gonna post it here in a spoiler incase some of you don't want to leave the comfort of this thread.
Oh sorry about that. I assumed everything in the moveset posted has been up to date. I do like the idea of a Medli + Makar duo character though. That is actually an interesting idea. I'd back that all day long.Still gonna post it here in a spoiler incase some of you don't want to leave the comfort of this thread.
EDIT: Oh, solbliminal already posted it, but the one in this post has some of the missing moves like smashes and grabs.
vv Medlis Moveset vv
Here is Medli
![]()
She could sit in and represent a second side to the Toon games and Windwaker, as well as not be another version of the same character so to speak.
In this image I have her the size of Toon Link, She wouldn't be that fast on ground compared to Toon Link however, she'd be better off in the Air.
Here I have some moves, if they are impossible to recreate within Project M due to limitations, I am perfectly capable with coming up with alternatives that still fit with Medlis character.
First, her B moves, sat in this spoiler within a spoiler
Her are some of her A moves and tilts, I haven't animated them all yet, but I will write out the ones I haven't done.![]()
Her Neutral B, acts like Marios Cape, possibly dealing damage, I wont use any damage percents because I have no idea how much damage is too much or too little
![]()
Her down B, it's a hold reflect like Foxes, because it reflects light in the game she's from I thought it could act like a shine similar to Fox or PM Ness, only from the front however, and on the first frame or so.
![]()
Here's one that might be a little tricky for PM, but I don't know how well you are so I'll write it out anyway.
As it says on the animation, you can tilt it up or down (down if your over a ledge or in the air) if you hit someone with this, it pulls you towards your opponent slamming into them and potentially leading into a combo or a spike if your aim is good enough.
![]()
Up B, probably the same as Brawl Pits up B.
Shown in Windwaker, Medli isn't a strong flyer and she normally needs a current or wind under her wings to be able to fly.
![]()
On the second hit we could maybe have her hair do some damage, but that might just be a little bit tricky, simple A combo is simple.
Tilts
![]()
Down tilt, sweepy kick, hits low, obviously.
![]()
Forward tilt, she's a bird sorta, so using them wings could hurt.
![]()
Up tilt, reasonable reach.
This is were I ran out of animations, but that doesn't stop me from talking!
Her dash attack would be her sticking out both her arms like a shove while skidding to a stop.
Her Forward smash would be her slamming her Harp down over the top of her head.
Her Up Smash would be her throwing both her arms up forming into wings both sides.
Her Down smash would be sorta the reverse to her up Smash.
Aerials
Down aerial would be her kicking two of her feet downwards with her arms extended as wings
Her up aerial would be her swinging her wings down while poking her Beak up, sorta like links up Air
FAir would be her slamming her harp forward, similar to her forward smash
Back air would be her kicking her two legs behind her
NAir would just be her twirling.
Grabs
Tether grab, pummel is headbutting with her beak.
Forward throw would just be a kick forward
Back throw would be a swinging throw like marios
Down throw she slams her opponent to the ground and butt slams them
Up throw would be swinging the opponent around and then twirling it so they fly up.
Final smash, now I don't know if this matters, but possibly something like PK starstorm, but with Fire and valoo in the background (like Palutena appears)
There are no initial requirements. We just discuss what we wish to see of the characters here and if something catches people's attention, they usually vote on it. It is more of a case of showing how a character would be fun to play in the Project M format. But with that also comes the difficulty of mod programming.
It is not a matter of just popularity. A lot of people take into consideration things like amount of appearances, impact on the series, seniority, worth, and as I stated above, programming difficulty. Though I think the way you describe Medli is somewhat possible, but may take longer to develop than other choices. That shouldn't stop you from supporting her though.Medli is more popular than you think actually, it's just people in the smash community just shrug her off as "unimportant side character". At least, from everyone in the Smash community I'VE spoken to.
