Name any dumb character request for smash

[LIQUID12A]

Desperate(or clueless) people will turn to whatever material there is to make a point regardless of how illogical it ends up being.

In this case, that Geno appearing in manga somehow means something.

 

[oZzIIgk]

Can we nullify any statements about Deviantart fanbases(,as I'm pretty sure that there's a Deviantart fanbase for pregnant Aziz Ansari)?
Or, for that matter, can we nullify any statements about Tumblr fanbases while we're at it? They seem to flock to the worst of whatever is offered by something (I'm looking at you, Fire Emblem).
i want all of my favorite touhou girls in smash because they were all in a painfully large collection of manga

 

[Burb]

Can we nullify any statements about Deviantart fanbases(,as I'm pretty sure that there's a Deviantart fanbase for pregnant Aziz Ansari)?
Or, for that matter, can we nullify any statements about Tumblr fanbases while we're at it? They seem to flock to the worst of whatever is offered by something (I'm looking at you, Fire Emblem).
i want all of my favorite touhou girls in smash because they were all in a painfully large collection of manga

Last I heard, they hate Fire Emblem over on Tumblr now due to the Soleil controversy.

from what I could tell he used them as a means of the 'Character X had multiple appearances' argument, and that games weren't the only thing he was in. Kinda fails as friggin Ridley's been on TV

I get that, but in the more recent posts he's made after that, he lumps comics with things that are less important than SMRPG.

Which, granted, is true, but it's just sorta confusing that he'd use Super Mario Kun as another Geno appearance (even though I'm pretty sure it was just a comic based on SMRPG), but then go on to call them unimportant in later posts.

 

[Schnee117]

I get that, but in the more recent posts he's made after that, he lumps comics with things that are less important than SMRPG.

Which, granted, is true, but it's just sorta confusing that he'd use Super Mario Kun as another Geno appearance (even though I'm pretty sure it was just a comic based on SMRPG), but then go on to call them unimportant in later posts.

Just more contradictions and lack of logic really.

 

[oZzIIgk]

Last I heard, they hate Fire Emblem over on Tumblr now due to the Soleil controversy.

I just meant they were all over Awakening.
shivers

 

[Cutie Gwen]

I just meant they were all over Awakening.
shivers

Awakening WAS a success

 

[oZzIIgk]

Awakening WAS a success

success =/= good game
In all seriousness, FEA was a good game but a poor game by Fire Emblem standards, imo.
i thought for sure someone would laugh about m-preg aziz ansari

 

[Geno Boost]

Except this whole argument was sparked by Geno Boost taking offense to people naming Geno as a dumb character request.

You can't label us as being mad that he likes Geno when we're not even the ones who started it. There would be no Geno argument if he hadn't gotten so worked up over people saying Geno is a stupid idea.

Nope it's because you called him impossible and has no chance when you clearly don't work at Nintendo and didn't come from the future and Geno is already character that has both negative and positive just like every character, you can call him unlucky but calling him impossible is not a fact if there is 0 proof from Nintendo or sakurai that will make him impossible

I am not going to reply to your reasons because some people here already wants us to stop from this disscusion

 

[oZzIIgk]

Nope it's because you called him impossible and has no chance when you clearly don't work at Nintendo and didn't come from the future and Geno is already character that has both negative and positive just like every character, you can call him unlucky but calling him impossible is not a fact

wow burb get gainfully employed while simultaneously getting cooked like a nice glass of ice water you nerd
my dad works at geno btw guys

 

[Burb]

Nope it's because you called him impossible and has no chance when you clearly don't work at Nintendo and didn't come from the future and Geno is already character that has both negative and positive just like every character, you can call him unlucky but calling him impossible is not a fact if there is 0 proof from Nintendo or sakurai that will make him impossible

http://smashboards.com/threads/name-any-dumb-character-request-for-smash.390926/page-4#post-19667885

That was the first reply you made directed towards in this topic.

I didn't say in any of my posts prior to yours that Geno was impossible. All I did was explain why he's a dumb character choice (Because he's unimportant to the Mario series and would require more effort than he's worth to put in, given that he's third party and all the other third party characters are major gaming icons). The closest thing I said to "he has no chance/he is impossible" is that Cranky Kong is likelier to get in than he is, which isn't really a bad comment (Cranky Kong just came off being a playable character in DKC: Tropical Freeze).

The argument was going on before I even arrived in this topic, by the way, with you taking part in it. So, please, cut with the "IT'S CUZ U SAID HE'S IMPOSSIBLE" bull. You were angry before I ever typed the word.

 

[Geno Boost]

http://smashboards.com/threads/name-any-dumb-character-request-for-smash.390926/page-4#post-19667885

That was the first reply you made directed towards in this topic.

I didn't say in any of my posts prior to yours that Geno had no chance. All I did was explain why he's a dumb character choice (Because he's unimportant to the Mario series and would require more effort than he's worth to put in, given that he's third party and all the other third party characters are major gaming icons). The closest thing I said to "he has no chance" is that Cranky Kong is likelier to get in than he is, which isn't really a bad comment (Cranky Kong just came off being a playable character in DKC: Tropical Freeze).

The argument was going on before I even arrived in this topic, by the way, with you taking part in it. So, please, cut with the "IT'S CUZ U SAID HE'S IMPOSSIBLE" bull. You were angry before I ever typed the word.

I guess I need to clean my glasses

 

[Cutie Gwen]

success =/= good game
In all seriousness, FEA was a good game but a poor game by Fire Emblem standards, imo.
i thought for sure someone would laugh about m-preg aziz ansari

It was a great game. I recently played my second FE game, FE7. Miles better

Nope it's because you called him impossible and has no chance when you clearly don't work at Nintendo and didn't come from the future and Geno is already character that has both negative and positive just like every character, you can call him unlucky but calling him impossible is not a fact if there is 0 proof from Nintendo or sakurai that will make him impossible

I am not going to reply to your reasons because some people here already wants us to stop from this disscusion

Ridley's the first Ballot character. Geno's impossible. I sent a letter to Nintendo once so I'm a reliable source. The thing is, this only started because you got a hissyfit about people thinking your precious favourite is impossible. Do what I do when that happens to me! Ignore it

 

[Spak]

Mr. Rodgers for Smash.

Make it happen, Nintendo. You can have one of his sons try to voice act him.

 

[Deleted member]

Frosty the Snowman
.... He was a very happy soul.

 

[Sir Gengar de Èctoplasma]

- Geno (one-time character, not counting the cameo, owned by Square-Enix, and there are far better choices for both Mario series and Square-Enix)
- Young Link (I know he's a veteran, but he is pointless to bring back when we have Toon Link)
- Ninten (Would work way better as Ness' alt than a separate character)
- Shrek (self-explanatory)
- Every anime character (self-explanatory)
- Reckless Safety Man (self-explanatory)
- Any Sonic character that isn't Tails, Knuckles or Eggman (They won't and shouldn't be in Smash before those three)

These are my opinions and I won't be arguing about them (I'm only saying this because someone mentioning one of these characters caused a massive argument in this thread).

 

[Yellowood Lovely]

DQ Slime
Is no dumb character

Post-brawl lucario
Is a dumb character

Lovable dumb characters I've seen and hope for secretly:
- Yoshi's island stork
- Seedot
- Abraham Lincoln
- The evil of gator of DK Fame
- Chrom still
- Single Ice Climber

@mostcontrovertialpicks

 

[Cutie Gwen]

- The evil of gator of DK Fame

@mostcontrovertialpicks

If you mean K.Rool, then it's certainly not controversial

 

[Yellowood Lovely]

If you mean K.Rool, then it's certainly not controversial

Super controversial

 

[Cutie Gwen]

Super controversial

How? K.Rool's the most requested character

 

[Yellowood Lovely]

How? K.Rool's the most requested character

And a natural pick for DLC

 

[GhostlyLure]

How is this thread not locked...I thought these were against the rules

 

[oZzIIgk]

How is this thread not locked...I thought these were against the rules

Well, the "is Geno a legitimate suggestion?" thread might not be against the rules, per se.

 

[SphericalCrusher]

Goku. I'm a huge DBZ fan, but no.

 

[ProjectBrawl7]

- Geno (one-time character, not counting the cameo, owned by Square-Enix, and there are far better choices for both Mario series and Square-Enix)
- Young Link (I know he's a veteran, but he is pointless to bring back when we have Toon Link)
- Ninten (Would work way better as Ness' alt than a separate character)
- Shrek (self-explanatory)
- Every anime character (self-explanatory)
- Reckless Safety Man (self-explanatory)
- Any Sonic character that isn't Tails, Knuckles or Eggman (They won't and shouldn't be in Smash before those three)

These are my opinions and I won't be arguing about them (I'm only saying this because someone mentioning one of these characters caused a massive argument in this thread).

Dont forget, other third parties that never get along with nintendo or whatever,

 

[villaqer]

tbh i voted for the red square from the world's hardest game

 

[MOI-ARI]

Guys, guys...

TOON YOUNG LINK
or better
YOUNG TOON LINK!
hmmm!






make it happen SoccerRye

 

[oZzIIgk]

Kurt Cobain
upspecial shoots him into the air by blasting his body up with a shotgun shot to the mouth

 

[Mamboo07]

That was probably a troll request, like shrek, barney and other troll requests. Now, i will tell you one of the MOST ANNOYING STUPID requests thats popular. Tip: That stupid emo sonic recolor.

Let me guess... Shadow?

 

[lordofwood98]

Sans









Thanks for 100 posts

 

[Nowheretogo859]

This thread reminds me a a fan fiction I came across years ago...the writer put in characters like Eric cartman l, spongebob, captain underpants... and even wwe wrestlers

Just thought I put that in... the fan fiction was on the older version of these boards

 

[Michael the Spikester]

Goku.

Just Goku.

Also Shrek. Why the **** is that also a thing!?

 

[Deleted member]

Barnacle Boy

 

[ChiLé]

Who we really need in smash is Tingle

 

[Spongeboob]

Hector LeMans

 

[Doctor Big O]

Sora was a pretty dumb one.

 

[Kold Pizza]

I want Buzz Lightyear, Freddy Fazbear, Goku, Shrek, and Tony Hawk all in.

i CaN’t BeLiEvE tHeY hAvEn’T mAdE yEt! I wAnT tHeM iN oR I RiOt!

XD

 

[Mamboo07]

Here are my wanted non-video game characters:
1. Lincoln Loud (The Loud House)
2. Scooby-Doo (Scooby Doo series)
3. Godzilla (Godzilla series)
4. Meme Man (Surreal Memes)

 

[Sebas22]

Dumb request, huh? Hmmm.... Ok, got it.

Spoiler

Fire Emblem character who uses a sword

 

[Vincey_Boi]

I want The Terminator From Terminator, Abraham Lincoln from the $5 bill, Starling Marte from the Pittsburgh Pirates, Patrick Mahomes from Madden 20 & Frank West From Dead rising.

 

[Gorilli09]

A lot of people have requested the following:
Rocket League Car
Cooking Mama
Tetrominos
Geno
Waluigi
Shantae
Isaac
Freddy Fazbear
Goku
You