Sorry if this is not relevant to the current conversation, being absent 2 days, but you two pretty much accurately describe the situation why I decided to join the site, to be more specific in the thread "What other Kid Icarus: Uprising character is most likely to join Pit in SSB4" I was reading this guy that claimed those exact same things, "Palutena is a goddess", "she gives Pit the power of flight so she can't fight", "she would be OP" that kind of flawed thinking annoyed me and couldn't stand that totally wrong perception.
The sad part is that he/she was promoting Dark Pit, over Palutena well it annoys me everytime people want shadow/dark variants.
So everytime someone comes with a flawed argument, it annoys me because, those are not even facts or evidence just biased perception, I might have a bias for Palutena but I try to stay objective when I have a counterargument, always staying as close as posible to facts.
About the last topic the evidence, I will go with Pit's final smash and the Pseudo Palutena trophy anything more is just a welcome bonus
It's an honor to have brought you over. *flattered Pit expression here*
I think I know that guy, who had the Dark Pit avy was it? To counter those claims or whatever:
-This wouldn't be the first time a God/Goddess would be playable in a battling game. And if iirc, Zelda is a mortal incarnate of a Goddess.
-The characters are not canonically tied to their games in the Smash Bros. Universe. Otherwise, we'd have Mario die in like 1 hit if he doesn't have a power up, or Pit would be able to brutally beat much of the cast using god-killing weapons. For the latter's case, the 3 Sacred Treasures (I gotta think that one through).
-By referring to my 2nd answer, characters wouldn't be canonically strong. For Palutena's case, she'd be weaker than she was in Uprising, just like Ganon and Bowser are.
I understand how you feel for sure though. We can always laugh in their face when she gets revealed. At the same time, I don't like shadow/dark variants either. You already had dark colored costumes for about half the characters in Brawl, and now ppl want them to take character slots? It sickens me as well.
Don't worry, I love Palutena, too. D: