Orboknown
Smash Hero
Mah bad gorf i could have sworn you called gheb town somewhere
-
Welcome to Smashboards, the world's largest Super Smash Brothers community! Over 250,000 Smash Bros. fans from around the world have come to discuss these great games in over 19 million posts!
You are currently viewing our boards as a visitor. Click here to sign up right now and start on your path in the Smash community!
Mini Mafia Game Thread | Newbies are welcome! | Town wins Gheb's game | Zen next to host!
- Thread starter ~ Gheb ~
- Start date
- Status
The Real Gamer
Smash Hero
I think I'm the only person left that would actually prefer Dietz over Gheb at this point... Gheb never even had a scum read on Dietz, Gorf doesn't know what's going on anymore, and Swords is on the fence.
#HBC | Gorf
toastin walrus since 4/20 maaaan
Oh and before a joke slips past you again no I don't actually think you think I should wagoned toDay and it's not scummy that I said that, cool?
And it's not scummy that I said that.
Or that.
That either.
You get where I'm going with this man?
And it's not scummy that I said that.
Or that.
That either.
You get where I'm going with this man?
#HBC | Kary
Fiend of Fire
Yes, but the point is that I can't see him reacting like this as scum.
Too ... many ... posts to read ;_;
I'm still not really convinced Dietz is scum and would rather not lynch him at the moment. In fact, I'd only sway from Orbo / Sword lynch if I have to vote for Dietz in order to not get lynched myself. I hope some of you people start to assume reason.
I'm still not really convinced Dietz is scum and would rather not lynch him at the moment. In fact, I'd only sway from Orbo / Sword lynch if I have to vote for Dietz in order to not get lynched myself. I hope some of you people start to assume reason.
#HBC | Gorf
toastin walrus since 4/20 maaaan
Oh don't worry TRG I know what's going on. There's just this awesome thing about mafia where secretly you don't have to read everything to have a strong opinion. You'll learn the power of skimming as time flies by man ! I'm still gung ho on the Dietz lynch if we're not going Kary. Gheb is null at best for me since (and he'll admit it too) his play is inherently anti town.
! I'm still gung ho on the Dietz lynch if we're not going Kary. Gheb is null at best for me since (and he'll admit it too) his play is inherently anti town.
The Real Gamer
Smash Hero
Meh I don't have the willpower to argue Dietz over Gheb anymore... Nor the experience to argue against meta reads.
We all CAN agree to at least Cop Dietz though, right?
We all CAN agree to at least Cop Dietz though, right?
Orboknown
Smash Hero
Cop dietz r gorf. Maybe kary.i would prefer gorf copped on a scumflip
The Real Gamer
Smash Hero
Wow and as soon as I post this I get ninja'd by Gheb and Gorf wanting to vote Dietz...
BACK TO SQUARE ONE
#HBC | Kary
Fiend of Fire
GBizzle my man, I totally think Kary's scum!
Everybody getting on Gheb's case for continuing the Gorf deserves to be lynched thing and the not explaining his town reads thing should totally halt. If it helps, trust me when I say that those are some of the nullest tells in the book man! He's called me town in enough posts to ensure that the whole lynching Gorf thing is either a joke (which I find radically HIGHLARIOUS!) or some form of a posting restriction. So don't look into it bros. Who cares that he doesn't explain his town reads? Ask all you want, sure, but if he tells you that he doesn't care to explain it, it's because he thinks there's no reason to explain it. At least he's telling you guys that he won't explain it rather than ignoring it completely. He's got more information out there than that, so stop just scratching at the surface of his posts and look at the content provided man! It's actually more groovy than what I can say for most of the content flowing in this game so far!
That being said, my read on him is null at the moment, but that's not a bad thing man! I've already decided my lynch pool toDay, and if you guys have lynch pools decided, at least have good reason for it man! Geez, the vibe's growing weaker and weaker man
Orboknown
Smash Hero
Back to Square Enix more like it
Make up your mind deadline is in 11 hrs
So I'm scummy because I'm not a tool and am actually able to think independently? My reads don't match yours and therefore you have an issue with me and think I'm scummy? Because I don't yield as easily to your attempts to manipulate me as you'd want me to?
Orboknown
Smash Hero
Welcome to gheb trg^
#HBC | Kary
Fiend of Fire
Do you really think he ended up as the swing vote and he's scum? If you're town he could have just hammered you, surely? Come on.
The Real Gamer
Smash Hero
So I'm scummy because I'm not a tool and am actually able to think independently? My reads don't match yours and therefore you have an issue with me and think I'm scummy? Because I don't yield as easily to your attempts to manipulate me as you'd want me to?
Keep reading... your... Determination to think independently is once of the main reasons I think we should keep you alive over Dietz which is in one of my posts back there... somewhere
Same goes to you, Sworddancer. Cherry-picking one of my post and slapping the generic null-tell of "armchair critic" into my face isn't scumhunting either. Not like you've done any such thing all game.
Good question. Why don't you answer it yourself Mr. "Gheb and Dietz are the only viable lynches toDay"?
The Real Gamer
Smash Hero
I'm quite enjoying watching Gheb slowly respond to everything.
BRB getting popcorn.
BRB getting popcorn.
Orboknown
Smash Hero
Because i had forgotten that gorf even existed up till then.
Dumb post. Of course he could end up in this position as scum. I mean you guys are virtually begging for it to happen with how you tunnel this Day phase down to me or Dietz being the play.
Orboknown
Smash Hero
It shouldnt be. Gheb goes on this tirade at least once a game regardless of alignment
The Real Gamer
Smash Hero
Dumb post. Of course he could end up in this position as scum. I mean you guys are virtually begging for it to happen with how you tunnel this Day phase down to me or Dietz being the play.
You still haven't convinced us why Swords is scum.
#HBC | Gorf
toastin walrus since 4/20 maaaan
#HBC | Gorf
toastin walrus since 4/20 maaaan
Not going for fake compromise =/= how you'd like me to play =/= inherently anti town
Oh I don't care that you don't fake compromise or anything. Your words not mine man! Your play IS inherently anti town seeing how you refuse to cooperate with the six other players in this game. If you're town, that means you know four of the players you refuse to cooperate with are town. Therefore, you're being anti town. Was that too hard to follow or should I make a tye dye shirt with a diagram of it?
Aight I'm back and fed and feeling better and here's how I'm seeing things atm:
IMO Gheb's potential asset is his reads which if I'm not mistaken right now is Swords/Orbo scum. I frankly think his labeling Orbo scum is him whistling dixie through a straw because he just doesn't like how Orbo plays as he's said before, but I do take stock in his Swords read if he's being truthful.
I have no idea how to read Swords, and if TownGheb thinks he's scum I'd be inclined to give that weight on the assumption that Gheb has played with him and knows how to read him more than I can. If Gheb is right it's something that needs to be known.
Thing is of course we can't trust he's not bull****ting it if we don't know his alignment, and I doubt he'll do much more if he's alive over alignment being shown. Here's the rub: If we kill me and cop Gheb, cop HAS to out in order for Gheb's opinions to be fully useful. In reverse, the cop doesn't have to out an inno on me because no one gives a **** about my terrible reads so far as long as I'm not one of the scum team. They probably would anyways, but they don't have to, and options are always good.
If we kill Gheb we all get to see his alignment, if we don't the cop has to tell us what it is and that's worse. That's my take on it. #obviouslybiased
IMO Gheb's potential asset is his reads which if I'm not mistaken right now is Swords/Orbo scum. I frankly think his labeling Orbo scum is him whistling dixie through a straw because he just doesn't like how Orbo plays as he's said before, but I do take stock in his Swords read if he's being truthful.
I have no idea how to read Swords, and if TownGheb thinks he's scum I'd be inclined to give that weight on the assumption that Gheb has played with him and knows how to read him more than I can. If Gheb is right it's something that needs to be known.
Thing is of course we can't trust he's not bull****ting it if we don't know his alignment, and I doubt he'll do much more if he's alive over alignment being shown. Here's the rub: If we kill me and cop Gheb, cop HAS to out in order for Gheb's opinions to be fully useful. In reverse, the cop doesn't have to out an inno on me because no one gives a **** about my terrible reads so far as long as I'm not one of the scum team. They probably would anyways, but they don't have to, and options are always good.
If we kill Gheb we all get to see his alignment, if we don't the cop has to tell us what it is and that's worse. That's my take on it. #obviouslybiased
The Real Gamer
Smash Hero
Gheb forget everything else and please focus on why we shouldn't be tunneling you/Dietz and vote Swords/Orbo instead.
It's kinda important to your survival here...
It's kinda important to your survival here...
What does it take to convince people anyway? It takes the mere caprice of people to lynch me but I am expected to magically "convince" you of all people. I can try to convince you but I don't expect it to work and I don't know what it takes to convince you.
There's some assumptions there like assuming that Gheb can read Swords, but it makes sense to me. If I flip inno no one really gains anything from it, and if Gheb is actually scum we all get to know without outing a cop.
Now I have to read all the posts that I missed though... :U
Now I have to read all the posts that I missed though... :U
The Real Gamer
Smash Hero
What does it take to convince people anyway? It takes the mere caprice of people to lynch me but I am expected to magically "convince" you of all people. I can try to convince you but I don't expect it to work and I don't know what it takes to convince you.
You're not even gonna attempt to make a case?
...OK?
Why should we keep you alive instead of Dietz, then?
I don't refuse to cooperate with them, they refuse to cooperate with me.
And for the very same reason the majority of people is down my throat right now. Funny how easy it is to nudge people and ask and demand me to do things when the majority is with you, isn't it?
Terrible line of thinking. My win condition isn't surviving - it's to eliminate mafia. My survival is of secondary importance.
(lul, that wasn't a complement. It means you dragged Gheb into a situation he wasn't comfortable with by doing things in thread without thinking about them)LOL you hear that Gheb?
Looks like I hold the pants in our theoretical scum team.
On what? A case requires content to refer to, something that Sword has simply not put forth. All he did was complain about my call-outs on his lack of input. It's still scummy though.
Idk man, if the choice is between me who I know is inno and another slot that I have no idea about: I'm going to pick me living every time because I know it's right and the other slot very well could be scumTerrible line of thinking. My win condition isn't surviving - it's to eliminate mafia. My survival is of secondary importance.
The Real Gamer
Smash Hero
You're really bad at telling when I'm not being serious. >.>
That question was bait to see if you'd value attempting to save yourself over scum hunter, so nice answer I guess.Terrible line of thinking. My win condition isn't surviving - it's to eliminate mafia. My survival is of secondary importance.
The Real Gamer
Smash Hero
Scum hunting*
Orboknown
Smash Hero
How many of those can realistically get four votes though gheb?
- Status