Mini Mafia Game Thread | Newbies are welcome! | Town wins Gheb's game | Zen next to host!

[~ Gheb ~]

town uniformity

Ouch

 

[#HBC | Dancer]

Orbo > Kary > TRG from towniest to scummiest.

Uhhh, I worded this post terribly.

Like, I have all these players as town reads. IT should be like, towniest to least towniest, I guess.

 

[The Real Gamer]

Like people were all up in my grill for wanting to keep Gheb around despite his anti-town behavior but now that Gheb's back to scum hunting all the sudden nobody wants to lynch him anymore and now prefer Kary.

Lol this game.

 

[~ Gheb ~]

Like people were all up in my grill for wanting to keep Gheb around despite his anti-town behavior but now that Gheb's back to scum hunting all the sudden nobody wants to lynch him anymore and now prefer Kary.

What are you talking about? Nobody except Gorf wants to lynch Kary right now and everybody thinks I'm scum despite my consistent attempts to find out who the mafiosi are.

 

[#HBC | Dancer]

What are you talking about? Nobody except Gorf wants to lynch Kary right now and everybody thinks I'm scum despite my consistent attempts to find out who the mafiosi are.

OH! There we go! I think the reason people suspect you is because we find the lat sentence to be false.

 

[#HBC | Kary]

I'm try again.

TRG, would you lynch Gorf toDay?

 

[The Real Gamer]

What are you talking about? Nobody except Gorf wants to lynch Kary right now and everybody thinks I'm scum despite my consistent attempts to find out who the mafiosi are.

Swords, Gorf, and yourself seem fine with lynching Kary now. Orbo, Kary, Dietz voting for you. That's 3 v 3.

 

[~ Gheb ~]

Orb is the one who has explaining to do when it comes to the Gorf lynch. Stop giving him a free pass already.

 

[The Real Gamer]

I'm try again.

TRG, would you lynch Gorf toDay?

Nope.

 

[~ Gheb ~]

Swords, Gorf, and yourself seem fine with lynching Kary now. Orbo, Kary, Dietz voting for you. That's 3 v 3.

Sword would also lynch me and I'm not convinced that Kary is a good lynch yet.

 

[#HBC | Gorf]

I think almost all players are guilty of this to some extent though. Or most are, at least. I don't see any difference to Orbo or Dietz here - or you for that matter. Is his reaction to my shenanigans the only thing that sets him apart of these players?

The difference is he's scummy. He's showing no interest to get anything productive done. Orbo's cautious, and he's not afraid to make stances. Dietz I actually think has been making bad play. Me, well I'm scum so my play just sucks. Happy?

Don't tell me no he doesn't to any of the above because I'll answer with sorry Mr. Pessimist and move on. In fact from now on I'm gonna call you Mr. Pessimist if you really don't see how your play is anti town. It's really easy to call everyone's play bad or scummy cuz it leaves you no room for misreading to be your fault, huh? I should take a lesson from that, that way I'll never feel like I made a mistake again. Nobody gives enough of a shit about you as a mafia player to just play your game, sorry to break it to you. Nobody gives enough of a shit about me so I can't just play the game of listen to me. So yea, you refuse to cooperate with town. It's not that town refuses to cooperate with you. I really hope you're not that conceded.

Oh and that's not scummy or bad play so don't try to pass it off as one without any explanation. Sorry.

 

[#HBC | Dancer]

And I recently called Kary town. Like, 10 minutes ago.

 

[The Real Gamer]

Sword what's the stronger play for a D1 lynch: Gheb or Kary?

On anther note I hate how people are giving Jdietz a free pass for his frantic responses and AtE.

 

[The Real Gamer]

Nevermind.

 

[Orboknown]

I'm guessing this is the order you want people lynched? Or scum reads?

both

Why Gorf.

poe/he is less townier than dietz in my eye

Gheb's antagonizing play has been messing with town uniformity and it's bothering me but not enough to lynch him. I just want him cleared as town so we don't have to worry about him anymore.

What happens after Dietz flip is all gonna depend on the cop results actually.

If you want gheb cleared tomorrow that requires our cop who cannot be protected to claim. Thats not worth a gheb inno

 

[#HBC | Gorf]

Molly I hate Gorf's latest posts.

Gorf, me pushing Gheb wasn't scummy then and isn't scummy now. Throwing in some generic stuff that you can't back up ('sheeping' 'lurking') doesn't make for a convincing argument.

Would you actually lynch Gheb toDay or were you just saying that? I feel like you're pushing literally everything you can except Gheb.

I'll say it again.

I'm not willing to lynch outside of You, Dietz, or Gheb, and in that order. I swear that if I have to repeat this again I'm going to scream.

 

[#HBC | Dancer]

The difference is he's scummy. He's showing no interest to get anything productive done. Orbo's cautious, and he's not afraid to make stances. Dietz I actually think has been making bad play. Me, well I'm scum so my play just sucks. Happy?

Don't tell me no he doesn't to any of the above because I'll answer with sorry Mr. Pessimist and move on. In fact from now on I'm gonna call you Mr. Pessimist if you really don't see how your play is anti town. It's really easy to call everyone's play bad or scummy cuz it leaves you no room for misreading to be your fault, huh? I should take a lesson from that, that way I'll never feel like I made a mistake again. Nobody gives enough of a shit about you as a mafia player to just play your game, sorry to break it to you. Nobody gives enough of a shit about me so I can't just play the game of listen to me. So yea, you refuse to cooperate with town. It's not that town refuses to cooperate with you. I really hope you're not that conceded.

Oh and that's not scummy or bad play so don't try to pass it off as one without any explanation. Sorry.

Okay this is the last youtube video I'll use this game I swear but

 

[The Real Gamer]

The difference is he's scummy. He's showing no interest to get anything productive done. Orbo's cautious, and he's not afraid to make stances. Dietz I actually think has been making bad play. Me, well I'm scum so my play just sucks. Happy?

Don't tell me no he doesn't to any of the above because I'll answer with sorry Mr. Pessimist and move on. In fact from now on I'm gonna call you Mr. Pessimist if you really don't see how your play is anti town. It's really easy to call everyone's play bad or scummy cuz it leaves you no room for misreading to be your fault, huh? I should take a lesson from that, that way I'll never feel like I made a mistake again. Nobody gives enough of a shit about you as a mafia player to just play your game, sorry to break it to you. Nobody gives enough of a shit about me so I can't just play the game of listen to me. So yea, you refuse to cooperate with town. It's not that town refuses to cooperate with you. I really hope you're not that conceded.

Oh and that's not scummy or bad play so don't try to pass it off as one without any explanation. Sorry.

Damn Gorf didn't even use any hippie lingo...

 

[Orboknown]

Its not so much i scumread gorf as much as i townread him the least out of the not gheb people

 

[~ Gheb ~]

poe/he is less townier than dietz in my eye

How long are you guys going to let Orbo get away with this wishy-washy bullcrap?

 

[Orboknown]

How is that wishywashy?

 

[#HBC | Dancer]

I THINK that I want to read over some posts.

 

[~ Gheb ~]

It doesn't actually require you to form an opinion and take a stance on Gorf.

Or anybody except me for that matter.

Why am I expected to bring unrealistically accurate information, reads and explanations to the table while people throw around the whackest stances left and right? People can keep saying I'm being antagonistic but none of you realize how antagonistic *you* are towards me. You're not even interested in my arguments. This is like the 239712391280th that I called out Orbo's bullcrap in a very concrete manner and yet people ask me for cases just cause they disagree. And that's what makes me scum to you...

 

[Orboknown]

...I THINK i want to just ignore gheb till he starts making sense

 

[The Real Gamer]

It doesn't actually require you to form an opinion and take a stance on Gorf.

Or anybody except me for that matter.

Why am I expected to bring unrealistically accurate information, reads and explanations to the table while people throw around the whackest stances left and right? People can keep saying I'm being antagonistic but none of you realize how antagonistic *you* are towards me. You're not even interested in my arguments. This is like the 239712391280th that I called out Orbo's bullcrap in a very concrete manner and yet people ask me for cases just cause they disagree. And that's what makes me scum to you...

NEWSFLASH I've been asking for the reasoning behind your reads all day to try to get on the same page PLUS defending the idea of lynching. Your response was "I'm not changing anyone's mind so why bother?" You then went on to call us "tools" and misreped me by claiming I'm not thinking for myself.

You're not really giving anyone anything to work with here.

 

[The Real Gamer]

lynching you*

 

[The Real Gamer]

Oh for ****s sake **defending AGAINST the idea of lynching you

 

[Orboknown]

NEWSFLASH I've been asking for the reasoning behind your reads all day to try to get on the same page PLUS defending the idea of lynching. Your response was "I'm not changing anyone's mind so why bother?" You then went on to call us "tools" and misreped me by claiming I'm not thinking for myself.

You're not really giving anyone anything to work with here.

Trg welcome to gheb^

 

[~ Gheb ~]

NEWSFLASH I've been asking for the reasoning behind your reads all day to try to get on the same page PLUS defending the idea of lynching. Your response was "I'm not changing anyone's mind so why bother?" You then went on to call us "tools" and misreped me by claiming I'm not thinking for myself.

You're not really giving anyone anything to work with here.

I asked you what it takes to convince you.

 

[The Real Gamer]

We aren't even playing mafia anymore everyone's just pissed off at Gheb and want him gone because of his behavior.

 

[The Real Gamer]

I asked you what it takes to convince you.

Make. A. Case.

 

[~ Gheb ~]

Make. A. Case.

What do you think of 1499 and 1501?

 

[Orboknown]

Dietz is this back and forth between gheb and trg indicative of scummates fypov?

 

[The Real Gamer]

What do you think of 1499 and 1501?

I don't get what Orbo was even trying to say in the first place.

IDK what Sword is re-reading.

 

[~ Gheb ~]

I don't get what Orbo was even trying to say in the first place.

He says his reasoning for having Gorf as his 2nd most favorite lynch is a mix of process of elimination and him thinking Dietz is townies than Gorf.

I think that's extremely weak and wishy-washy.

What do you think?

 

[Orboknown]

Via process of.elimination gorf if the least towny of my reads that isnt gheb

 

[The Real Gamer]

Dietz is this back and forth between gheb and trg indicative of scummates fypov?

This again. >.>

If I were scum and knew for a fact Gheb is town I'd keep Gheb alive as long as possible since he's pissing everyone off. lol

 

[The Real Gamer]

Gheb is scum*

I hate not being able to edit posts.

 

[Orboknown]

You've never had scum mates before so i don't know what you would do. Plus it extracts a stance from dietz to help read him

 

[The Real Gamer]

He says his reasoning for having Gorf as his 2nd most favorite lynch is a mix of process of elimination and him thinking Dietz is townies than Gorf.

I think that's extremely weak and wishy-washy.

What do you think?

I don't think it's a good case but I'm failing to see any scummy intention behind it.